1
00:01:57,600 --> 00:01:58,870
It is recognisable.

2
00:02:02,970 --> 00:02:06,430
I repeat my question: do you recognize yourself in these images?

3
00:02:06,750 --> 00:02:07,750
Yes.

4
00:02:08,160 --> 00:02:10,500
Can you describe what he's doing?

5
00:02:11,190 --> 00:02:13,320
I pick up a stone from the
road and shooting.

6
00:02:13,620 --> 00:02:15,220
Towards the protesters?

7
00:02:15,360 --> 00:02:15,660
Yes.

8
00:02:16,290 --> 00:02:18,960
I actually don't have it
thrown at you, no.

9
00:02:19,170 --> 00:02:19,990
but in their direction, yes.

10
00:02:20,190 --> 00:02:20,850
We'll come back to it later.

11
00:02:21,360 --> 00:02:22,080
Did I get anyone?

12
00:02:22,440 --> 00:02:24,370
Excuse me, I'm the one
I ask the questions.

13
00:02:25,800 --> 00:02:27,919
In these images, you see...

14
00:02:28,121 --> 00:02:30,100
objects thrown by protesters?

15
00:02:31,320 --> 00:02:32,590
Not at that moment.

16
00:02:33,240 --> 00:02:35,290
But before then, yes, ne
they pulled many.

17
00:02:36,270 --> 00:02:39,190
We were pelted with objects
and insults all day.

18
00:02:39,480 --> 00:02:42,610
And two minutes earlier, my commander was
was hit in the face by a stone.

19
00:02:43,500 --> 00:02:46,690
He had raised his visor to be heard,
and they hit him full in the face.

20
00:02:46,850 --> 00:02:48,610
The demonstrators applauded.

21
00:02:49,620 --> 00:02:50,620
All right.

22
00:02:51,210 --> 00:02:53,320
Let's go back to the moment he has
threw the stone.

23
00:02:56,640 --> 00:02:58,660
How does he justify his action?

24
00:02:59,220 --> 00:03:00,490
I do not know.

25
00:03:02,510 --> 00:03:03,858
I've been doing it for fifteen years
public order...

26
00:03:03,859 --> 00:03:06,700
I've always done my job
in an impeccable way.

27
00:03:06,930 --> 00:03:08,040
Something like this has never happened to me.
This is the first time.

28
00:03:08,070 --> 00:03:10,360
I have been several times
heard by IGPN.

29
00:03:10,410 --> 00:03:12,330
But not this time
I resisted.

30
00:03:12,360 --> 00:03:13,750
I couldn't take it anymore.

31
00:03:15,810 --> 00:03:16,810
Okay.

32
00:03:22,320 --> 00:03:24,130
Do you know if I risk being suspended?

33
00:03:24,780 --> 00:03:26,080
I do not know.

34
00:03:26,670 --> 00:03:28,900
The suspension depends on the outcome
of the administrative investigation.

35
00:03:30,120 --> 00:03:32,200
You will be questioned by a
other official.

36
00:03:35,730 --> 00:03:37,870
I don't know how to do anything else
the policeman.

37
00:03:41,250 --> 00:03:43,110
He too agrees that not
it was an appropriate gesture.

38
00:03:43,249 --> 00:03:46,440
He did it out of anger and anger
shock at seeing his superior injured.

39
00:03:46,830 --> 00:03:49,110
Given the resonance of the video,
it's hard to let go.

40
00:03:49,500 --> 00:03:52,990
A riot policeman throwing a cobblestone
it damages the image of the police.

41
00:03:53,130 --> 00:03:54,520
This is an act of retaliation.

42
00:03:54,660 --> 00:03:57,650
with a non-regulation weapon… it's serious

43
00:03:57,870 --> 00:03:58,970
Very serious.

44
00:03:59,040 --> 00:04:00,917
Sure, but he admits his own
mistake and is regretted.

45
00:04:00,918 --> 00:04:03,930
Then he didn't hurt anyone.

46
00:04:03,936 --> 00:04:06,730
They must be taken into consideration
context and stress

47
00:04:06,731 --> 00:04:06,732


48
00:04:06,800 --> 00:04:11,010
Your lawyer will raise all these objections
during the trial… send me the report

49
00:04:11,020 --> 00:04:12,620
Sure, okay

50
00:04:12,780 --> 00:04:14,700
His office is that of
availability on weekends.

51
00:04:15,150 --> 00:04:17,020
No, it's office two

52
00:04:17,520 --> 00:04:18,240
let's hope it is

53
00:04:18,390 --> 00:04:20,500
quieter than the past.

54
00:04:20,670 --> 00:04:21,690
Goodbye, Mrs Bertrand.

55
00:04:22,230 --> 00:04:23,680
Goodbye, Mr. Deputy Prosecutor.

56
00:05:33,900 --> 00:05:36,130
We had another pretty chaotic Saturday.

57
00:05:36,420 --> 00:05:38,230
Several complaints have already been filed.

58
00:05:38,760 --> 00:05:43,379
The news is that the prosecutor's office has decided
that it's up to us to manage everything.

59
00:05:43,380 --> 00:05:46,870
complaints relating to the yellow vests,
regardless of the degree of severity.

60
00:05:47,040 --> 00:05:49,670
Even with prognosis
less than 8 days?

61
00:05:49,680 --> 00:05:50,890
That's how it is.

62
00:05:51,330 --> 00:05:53,830
Since Christelle and her office are already saturated

63
00:05:53,940 --> 00:05:56,820
I will distribute the next cases between offices one and three.

64
00:05:57,420 --> 00:05:58,590
We are already managing forty cases.

65
00:05:58,920 --> 00:05:59,370
I know.

66
00:05:59,670 --> 00:06:01,120
Stephanie too.

67
00:06:01,590 --> 00:06:03,130
Christelle is fifty.

68
00:06:03,607 --> 00:06:09,229
<i>Translation: ennelle65</i>

69
00:06:11,340 --> 00:06:14,630
It was a nurse at the hospital who told me
to come here to file a complaint.

70
00:06:14,670 --> 00:06:16,420
It's for my son Guillaume.

71
00:06:16,500 --> 00:06:17,100
Is he a minor?

72
00:06:17,370 --> 00:06:18,480
No, he's twenty.

73
00:06:19,200 --> 00:06:20,200
All right.

74
00:06:20,310 --> 00:06:22,340
If he is an adult, he cannot do it
report in his place

75
00:06:22,341 --> 00:06:24,490
he is the one who should file a complaint.

76
00:06:24,540 --> 00:06:27,090
But he can't, he's in hospital
and it's in very bad shape.

77
00:06:27,720 --> 00:06:30,719
In that case I will take your statement
and then we'll see later when

78
00:06:30,720 --> 00:06:32,580
The doctors will give us permission
to listen to his son.

79
00:06:33,150 --> 00:06:35,350
What should I do?
I've never done this before.

80
00:06:35,580 --> 00:06:37,980
Simply describe what happened.

81
00:06:38,460 --> 00:06:40,410
We were at the demonstration on Saturday.

82
00:06:40,530 --> 00:06:43,060
a police officer who has them
shot with a flash ball.

83
00:06:43,680 --> 00:06:45,760
A shot fired from a weapon
non-lethal defense (LBD).

84
00:06:45,810 --> 00:06:46,810
All right.

85
00:06:47,280 --> 00:06:48,480
Did you witness the scene?

86
00:06:48,720 --> 00:06:49,020
No.

87
00:06:49,440 --> 00:06:51,250
I wasn't with Guillaume

88
00:06:51,510 --> 00:06:52,960
when it happened

89
00:06:53,160 --> 00:06:54,848
We were together shortly before on the Champs-Élysées.

90
00:06:54,849 --> 00:06:57,670
But there was a scuffle
that separated us.

91
00:06:57,930 --> 00:06:59,580
He came to demonstrate with his son.

92
00:07:00,120 --> 00:07:01,120
Yes.

93
00:07:01,440 --> 00:07:02,870
We came as a whole family.

94
00:07:02,880 --> 00:07:04,480
My three children were there.

95
00:07:04,650 --> 00:07:06,400
Antonin, the eldest.

96
00:07:06,450 --> 00:07:08,424
And then Sonia, and finally Guillaume.

97
00:07:08,640 --> 00:07:09,330
And also.

98
00:07:09,540 --> 00:07:11,250
Rémy is Sonia's boyfriend.

99
00:07:11,850 --> 00:07:13,710
He was the one who was with Guillaume when it happened.

100
00:07:14,310 --> 00:07:18,510
So you were separated and it was Rémi who did
was with Guillaume at the time of the events.

101
00:07:18,870 --> 00:07:19,140
YES.

102
00:07:19,320 --> 00:07:22,330
He was the one who told you how things went.

103
00:07:22,620 --> 00:07:22,950
YES.

104
00:07:23,490 --> 00:07:27,070
and found us again after the firefighters
they had taken Guillaume to hospital.

105
00:07:28,230 --> 00:07:29,760
In which hospital is your son hospitalized?

106
00:07:30,300 --> 00:07:31,840
at Bichat Hospital.

107
00:07:33,090 --> 00:07:35,260
It was the firefighters who brought him there.

108
00:07:35,580 --> 00:07:36,900
Yes, that's exactly what Rémi told us.

109
00:07:37,440 --> 00:07:38,440
All right.

110
00:07:39,510 --> 00:07:41,410
I need to hear from Rémi.

111
00:07:41,700 --> 00:07:42,720
Do you know his last name?

112
00:07:43,170 --> 00:07:44,170
Cordier.

113
00:07:45,000 --> 00:07:46,420
Where is he now?

114
00:07:46,650 --> 00:07:49,500
He is in police custody.

115
00:07:49,680 --> 00:07:52,020
He was arrested by officers
police who shot?

116
00:07:52,230 --> 00:07:54,790
No, no, he was arrested later.

117
00:07:54,840 --> 00:07:56,560
He appeared before a judge.

118
00:07:56,640 --> 00:07:57,510
Directly?

119
00:07:57,660 --> 00:07:58,660
YES.

120
00:07:59,040 --> 00:08:00,340
Was he convicted?

121
00:08:00,840 --> 00:08:02,730
I do not know.

122
00:08:02,700 --> 00:08:02,940


123
00:08:03,150 --> 00:08:05,650
I didn't sleep much, I was
in hospital for two nights.

124
00:08:09,600 --> 00:08:12,670
I don't understand why they shot
to my son like that.

125
00:08:12,840 --> 00:08:14,320
Right in the head.

126
00:08:14,880 --> 00:08:16,170
My son is not a hooligan.

127
00:08:16,410 --> 00:08:19,000
On the contrary, he has a job.

128
00:08:19,500 --> 00:08:21,250
He is an apprentice electrician.

129
00:08:22,980 --> 00:08:25,540
We came to demonstrate for public services.

130
00:08:26,610 --> 00:08:28,630
In Saint-Dizier everything is closing.

131
00:08:29,400 --> 00:08:30,760
Are you from Saint-Dizier?

132
00:08:31,650 --> 00:08:32,650
YES.

133
00:08:33,210 --> 00:08:34,120
You know him.

134
00:08:34,140 --> 00:08:34,440
YES.

135
00:08:35,100 --> 00:08:36,100


136
00:08:35,270 --> 00:08:37,420
It doesn't matter.

137
00:08:37,570 --> 00:08:38,987
Saint-Dizier or elsewhere

138
00:08:39,090 --> 00:08:40,780
It's the same everywhere.

139
00:08:41,100 --> 00:08:42,400
The same thing?.

140
00:08:42,480 --> 00:08:44,470
It's like he doesn't care about us.

141
00:08:46,920 --> 00:08:48,790
We'll put everything in writing.

142
00:08:51,390 --> 00:08:51,780
HI.

143
00:08:52,320 --> 00:08:53,825
Mom, I'm Stephanie.

144
00:08:54,000 --> 00:08:55,470
Hi dear, how are you?

145
00:08:55,710 --> 00:08:56,130
YES.

146
00:08:56,550 --> 00:08:57,840
With everything that's going on.

147
00:08:58,170 --> 00:08:58,740
How is it going?

148
00:08:59,370 --> 00:08:59,580


149
00:08:59,700 --> 00:09:03,130
Mom, it tells you something: la
Girard family of Saint-Dizier.

150
00:09:03,420 --> 00:09:03,990
Girard?

151
00:09:04,110 --> 00:09:08,460
Yes, Joëlle Girard, forty-eight years old.
He has three children in their twenties

152
00:09:09,120 --> 00:09:10,020
Hmm, nothing at all.

153
00:09:10,560 --> 00:09:12,990
Girard is a common surname in these parts.

154
00:09:13,260 --> 00:09:14,309
I can ask your father.

155
00:09:14,310 --> 00:09:17,880
No... it was just a curiosity
to find out if you know her

156
00:09:17,940 --> 00:09:18,420
Why?

157
00:09:18,690 --> 00:09:20,950
Nothing, it's a matter of work.

158
00:09:21,150 --> 00:09:21,960
Are you investigating them?

159
00:09:22,530 --> 00:09:25,330
No mom, IGPN investigates
on police officers.

160
00:09:25,470 --> 00:09:27,250
Could they be police officers?

161
00:09:27,960 --> 00:09:29,530
Don't worry.

162
00:09:29,670 --> 00:09:30,600
Who are his parents?

163
00:09:30,810 --> 00:09:32,770
I don't know, forget it.

164
00:10:01,650 --> 00:10:03,100
Who are you?

165
00:10:03,180 --> 00:10:04,990
How did you get in there?

166
00:10:20,210 --> 00:10:21,210
.

167
00:10:26,164 --> 00:10:27,684
Come here.

168
00:10:31,024 --> 00:10:32,594
What should I do with you?

169
00:10:48,244 --> 00:10:49,358
In recent days the neighborhood
it's barricading itself

170
00:10:50,446 --> 00:10:54,346
While the police deploy
on the Champs Elysées

170

171
00:10:54,394 --> 00:10:55,574
In the capital.

172
00:10:55,744 --> 00:10:57,981
With double the police officers
compared to last week.

173
00:10:57,982 --> 00:11:01,034
and even the armored vehicles of the gendarmerie
they went out on patrol.

174
00:11:00,544 --> 00:11:00,844


175
00:11:01,054 --> 00:11:02,824
No, it's not July 14th

176
00:11:02,914 --> 00:11:06,213
In an extremely tense context,
political power closes ranks and...

177
00:11:06,214 --> 00:11:08,587
traders try to
protect their activities.

178
00:11:08,718 --> 00:11:09,064


179
00:11:09,664 --> 00:11:11,824
As for the question of whether the panels
of wood will be sufficient.

180
00:11:11,949 --> 00:11:13,114
to prevent looting.

181
00:11:13,534 --> 00:11:17,404
Paris police headquarters confirms
that police resources were deployed.

182
00:11:17,405 --> 00:11:18,934
exceptional measures that have been put in place.

183
00:11:19,474 --> 00:11:20,614
It's true that on the roads.

184
00:11:20,854 --> 00:11:22,724
The protest is impressive.

185
00:11:25,414 --> 00:11:26,714
Yes, my darling.

186
00:11:27,484 --> 00:11:28,174
I'm bothering you.

187
00:11:28,774 --> 00:11:31,124
No, I'm fine, and where are you?

188
00:11:31,954 --> 00:11:33,124
I'm in dad's car.

189
00:11:33,334 --> 00:11:34,264
and people fighting.

190
00:11:34,864 --> 00:11:36,104
How come ?

191
00:11:36,244 --> 00:11:36,334
AND.

192
00:11:36,635 --> 00:11:39,374
They were arguing and suddenly
they started fighting.

193
00:11:39,454 --> 00:11:40,454
Look.

194
00:11:43,174 --> 00:11:43,564
You see.

195
00:11:43,864 --> 00:11:44,864
Yes.

196
00:11:45,274 --> 00:11:46,484
Oh shit.

197
00:11:48,304 --> 00:11:48,514
Not.

198
00:11:48,844 --> 00:11:51,404
Don't move from the car, where is your father?

199
00:11:51,454 --> 00:11:52,454
Wait.

200
00:11:53,254 --> 00:11:55,994
You didn't answer me, you're everything
alone, where is your father?

201
00:11:57,454 --> 00:11:57,844
He's running away.

202
00:11:58,414 --> 00:12:00,314
He's running away, but where are you?

203
00:12:00,964 --> 00:12:01,964
At Lake Choisy.

204
00:12:02,824 --> 00:12:04,864
Dad wanted me to run
the marathon with them.

205
00:12:05,284 --> 00:12:05,944
But I had enough.

206
00:12:06,154 --> 00:12:07,504
and I'm waiting for him in the car.

207
00:12:07,594 --> 00:12:09,074
Who is he with?

208
00:12:09,514 --> 00:12:10,624
Noélie, his new girlfriend.

209
00:12:11,194 --> 00:12:12,194
Oh.

210
00:12:12,364 --> 00:12:13,724
She is also in the police.

211
00:12:13,864 --> 00:12:15,294
Were you with him at the drug detention center?

212
00:12:15,334 --> 00:12:17,774
No, I don't think so, but she's definitely a policewoman,
he talks about it all the time.

213
00:12:17,854 --> 00:12:19,264
I took some photos of her, do you want to see them?

214
00:12:19,984 --> 00:12:20,984
Ninth.

215
00:12:21,424 --> 00:12:23,594
What do you want me to do with these photos?

216
00:12:24,004 --> 00:12:25,504
To see what it looks like.

217
00:12:25,954 --> 00:12:26,584
I won't tell dad.

218
00:12:27,070 --> 00:12:28,070
Ninth.

219
00:12:28,714 --> 00:12:29,614
This is not done.

220
00:12:30,034 --> 00:12:31,754
And then I don't care.

221
00:12:31,864 --> 00:12:33,314
Wait, don't go.

222
00:12:37,234 --> 00:12:39,194
I have a new boyfriend too.

223
00:12:41,314 --> 00:12:42,764
It's so cute.

224
00:12:44,524 --> 00:12:45,184
You bought it.

225
00:12:45,634 --> 00:12:46,024
No.

226
00:12:46,294 --> 00:12:47,794
I found it in the garage.

227
00:12:48,124 --> 00:12:49,804
- Will you keep it?
- I do not believe

228
00:12:50,104 --> 00:12:52,754
Taking care of an animal is a responsibility.

229
00:12:53,254 --> 00:12:54,214
But I'd take care of it.

230
00:12:54,574 --> 00:12:55,754
If you say so.

231
00:12:56,284 --> 00:12:57,424
Let's talk again on Monday.

232
00:12:57,994 --> 00:13:00,374
You stay in the car, I'll call your father.

233
00:13:04,174 --> 00:13:05,349
It's me.

234
00:13:06,694 --> 00:13:10,424
Tell me, did you leave Victor waiting in a parking lot?
Frankly, it's a horrible thing.

235
00:13:11,044 --> 00:13:13,664
Not a problem, he ran with
us and then it stopped.

236
00:13:13,834 --> 00:13:14,934
he was tired.

237
00:13:15,094 --> 00:13:18,104
Meanwhile, two boys have
started a fight near the car.

238
00:13:18,484 --> 00:13:19,364
What?

239
00:13:19,374 --> 00:13:22,534
I told him to call me if he was there
need, why did he call you?

240
00:13:22,624 --> 00:13:24,404
Maybe he didn't want to disturb you.

241
00:13:24,534 --> 00:13:26,394
OK. I understand

242
00:13:26,524 --> 00:13:28,684
You don't understand anything.

243
00:13:28,924 --> 00:13:30,394
I don't care who you're running with.

244
00:13:30,574 --> 00:13:33,974
But, don't leave Victor alone
in a parking lot in the middle of nowhere.

245
00:13:34,744 --> 00:13:34,894


246
00:13:35,136 --> 00:13:37,394
I go back to the car to see
what's happening.

247
00:13:37,584 --> 00:13:37,868
HI.

248
00:13:38,284 --> 00:13:39,284
HI.

249
00:13:45,634 --> 00:13:46,924
I Stéphanie Bertrand.

250
00:13:47,134 --> 00:13:48,784
police commander at the IGPN.

251
00:13:48,964 --> 00:13:51,544
I pray and, if necessary, I dispose
the collaboration of the Bichat hospital.

252
00:13:51,664 --> 00:13:55,654
to provide us with status information
of health of Mr. Girard Guillaume.

253
00:13:56,164 --> 00:13:59,034
admitted to the facility
on December 8, 2018.

254
00:13:59,044 --> 00:14:02,464
in particular to inform us of your condition
of health will allow him to be questioned.

255
00:14:02,494 --> 00:14:06,693
Service communication, please and if necessary
I order that the commander

256
00:14:06,694 --> 00:14:10,134
of the fire brigade
Paris could provide all the elements

257
00:14:10,234 --> 00:14:13,213
in his possession relating to
a rescue operation.

258
00:14:13,214 --> 00:14:16,174
carried out on 8.12.2018.

259
00:14:16,264 --> 00:14:20,074
concerning a male subject of
twenty years old named Gérard Guillaume.

260
00:14:20,344 --> 00:14:23,164
on Triomphe sector 75-0-0-8.

261
00:14:23,434 --> 00:14:27,303
I pray and, if necessary, I am available at the office
of execution of sentences to communicate.

262
00:14:27,304 --> 00:14:30,724
Which penitentiary institution was he in?
Mr. Rémy Cordier transferred

263
00:14:31,054 --> 00:14:35,194
following his conviction at the hearing
urgently on 10 December 2018.

264
00:14:35,464 --> 00:14:37,594
before the criminal court of
Paris on the aforementioned date.

265
00:14:37,595 --> 00:14:39,652
I report that I have received a response

266
00:14:39,653 --> 00:14:41,964
to the request sent
to the Paris fire brigade.

267
00:14:42,304 --> 00:14:45,303
This letter contains an intervention
on the public road which took place on the 8th

268
00:14:45,304 --> 00:14:47,494
December 2018 at 6.43pm.

269
00:14:47,734 --> 00:14:50,084
On Via Magellano in the eighth arrondissement.

270
00:14:50,794 --> 00:14:52,741
I report that I have received a response
from the service.

271
00:14:52,742 --> 00:14:54,904
trauma medicine department
of Bichat hospital.

272
00:14:55,234 --> 00:14:58,084
to request N° 2018-0023.

273
00:14:58,684 --> 00:15:00,496
This email contains a medical certificate.

274
00:15:00,497 --> 00:15:03,704
Description of injuries reported
by Mr. Guillaume Girard.

275
00:15:03,754 --> 00:15:05,744
The results are as follows:

276
00:15:05,873 --> 00:15:10,124
Multiple left craniofacial fractures
with hematoma extending to the temporal bone.

277
00:15:10,234 --> 00:15:14,115
Cranioencephalic trauma with
severe subarachnoid hemorrhage.

278
00:15:14,224 --> 00:15:16,429
Hematoma and lesions are compatible with

279
00:15:16,430 --> 00:15:19,364
an impact of LBD 40 type ammunition.

280
00:15:19,534 --> 00:15:23,164
Mr. Girard suffers from aphasia and
acute post-traumatic stress disorder.

281
00:15:23,584 --> 00:15:26,454
and will not be able to testify for a
indefinite period of time.

282
00:15:26,464 --> 00:15:28,632
Attached you will find the authorization form

283
00:15:28,633 --> 00:15:30,874
of the prosecutor's office to be heard
as a witness

284
00:15:31,294 --> 00:15:35,913
the prisoner Rémy Cordier therefore please
to indicate a date and time when

285
00:15:35,914 --> 00:15:39,274
you deem it appropriate for him to be questioned
at your institution.

286
00:15:39,544 --> 00:15:41,324
in the Fleury-Mérogis prison.

287
00:16:05,434 --> 00:16:08,014
Good morning Mr. Cordier, I'm the
Commander Bertrand of the IGPN.

288
00:16:08,194 --> 00:16:10,174
the General Inspectorate of the National Police.

289
00:16:10,504 --> 00:16:12,314
my colleague, Major Guérini.

290
00:16:12,874 --> 00:16:14,391
We are investigating the circumstances
that they brought

291
00:16:14,392 --> 00:16:17,144
to the wounding of Guillaume Girard last Saturday.

292
00:16:17,404 --> 00:16:19,384
His mother told us that she was with him at the time of the events.

293
00:16:19,984 --> 00:16:21,224
Is this correct?

294
00:16:23,224 --> 00:16:25,544
We would love to hear your testimony.

295
00:16:25,744 --> 00:16:28,034
I don't even know how he is, I haven't heard anything.

296
00:16:28,384 --> 00:16:29,972
His life is no longer in danger, but...

297
00:16:29,973 --> 00:16:32,714
doctors don't think it's in
able to be questioned.

298
00:16:32,824 --> 00:16:34,544
What does "not capable" mean?

299
00:16:35,040 --> 00:16:36,254
Will there be permanent consequences?

300
00:16:37,084 --> 00:16:37,653
We don't know.

301
00:16:37,654 --> 00:16:39,919
Holy shit, he didn't do anything!
Those sons of bitches

302
00:16:39,920 --> 00:16:41,614
they beat him though
he hadn't done anything.

303
00:16:41,794 --> 00:16:43,454
Keep your tone down.

304
00:16:44,344 --> 00:16:46,364
Please speak correctly.

305
00:16:46,654 --> 00:16:48,354
You found the policemen
who did this?

306
00:16:48,064 --> 00:16:48,514


307
00:16:48,355 --> 00:16:49,860
It's me, Cordier, who asks the questions

308
00:16:48,634 --> 00:16:48,754


309
00:16:49,864 --> 00:16:52,934
Why will you believe me?

310
00:16:54,304 --> 00:16:55,534
They didn't even listen to me in court.

311
00:16:56,134 --> 00:16:59,114
It lasted five minutes, stopwatch in hand,
that's all that mattered.

312
00:16:59,164 --> 00:17:01,264
An arrest report drawn up by the police.

313
00:17:01,834 --> 00:17:03,464
where it is written that I hit the policemen.

314
00:17:03,484 --> 00:17:05,054
This is completely false.

315
00:17:05,164 --> 00:17:08,313
Mr. Cordier, we are not here to
investigate his arrest, but...

316
00:17:08,314 --> 00:17:10,244
for what happened to Mr. Girard.

317
00:17:10,444 --> 00:17:13,244
Your testimony can help us
to understand what happened.

318
00:17:14,014 --> 00:17:17,764
But if it comes to my word against
theirs will be worth nothing.

319
00:17:18,094 --> 00:17:20,384
Who did you come to demonstrate with in Paris?

320
00:17:21,814 --> 00:17:23,224
Sonia, her two brothers and her mother.

321
00:17:23,494 --> 00:17:26,354
- Sonia, Antonin, Guillaume and Joëlle Girard, correct?
- Yes

322
00:17:27,424 --> 00:17:29,264
We arrived from Saint-Dizier in the morning.

323
00:17:29,794 --> 00:17:32,654
The idea came to me and Antonin

324
00:17:30,754 --> 00:17:32,684


325
00:17:32,734 --> 00:17:34,384
We are not really "yellow vests".

326
00:17:34,414 --> 00:17:36,694
But my mother and Remy are
health assistants

327
00:17:36,754 --> 00:17:37,754
I am a stretcher bearer.

328
00:17:38,734 --> 00:17:40,844
And we are tired of being
paid a pittance.

329
00:17:41,404 --> 00:17:42,824
so we wanted to participate.

330
00:17:43,864 --> 00:17:45,824
Then the opportunity arose to come to Paris.

331
00:17:48,724 --> 00:17:50,744


332
00:17:52,564 --> 00:17:54,494


333
00:17:55,534 --> 00:17:56,534


334
00:17:56,699 --> 00:17:56,914
.

335
00:17:57,634 --> 00:17:58,634


336
00:18:01,624 --> 00:18:02,079


337
00:18:02,944 --> 00:18:03,944


338
00:18:04,541 --> 00:18:05,541


339
00:18:06,544 --> 00:18:07,414


340
00:18:07,564 --> 00:18:07,714


341
00:18:07,834 --> 00:18:08,834


342
00:18:09,094 --> 00:18:10,094


343
00:18:15,094 --> 00:18:16,094


344
00:18:22,774 --> 00:18:24,574
Do you often participate in events?

345
00:18:24,784 --> 00:18:25,784
No

346
00:18:26,434 --> 00:18:28,394
This was the first time
that I was coming to Paris.

347
00:18:29,614 --> 00:18:31,764
We parked nearby
at a city gate.

348
00:18:31,834 --> 00:18:34,484
We're a little disoriented, it wasn't about it
properly of a demonstration.

349
00:18:35,614 --> 00:18:37,124
We walked along the Seine.

350
00:18:38,164 --> 00:18:40,034
We were checked several times.

351
00:18:41,674 --> 00:18:43,124
Yes, that's fine.

352
00:18:42,274 --> 00:18:43,274


353
00:18:46,654 --> 00:18:47,654


354
00:18:48,484 --> 00:18:50,389
Sir, stop filming

355
00:18:54,544 --> 00:18:54,784


356
00:18:55,204 --> 00:18:57,584
We walked a lot and
My feet hurt.

357
00:18:58,534 --> 00:19:00,644
We took the opportunity to
do a bit of tourism.

358
00:19:01,624 --> 00:19:02,832
This was the opportunity.

359
00:19:19,990 --> 00:19:22,644
It was definitely new
compared to Saint-Dizier.

360
00:19:20,914 --> 00:19:22,514


361
00:19:22,834 --> 00:19:25,294
We ended up joining some yellow vests
who wanted to go to the Champs-Élysées.

362
00:19:25,297 --> 00:19:26,374
They told us to
pass that way.

363
00:19:26,974 --> 00:19:29,774
But when we got to the
Champs-Élysées, there were a lot of people.

364
00:19:44,854 --> 00:19:45,784
Where you could smell it
of tear gas.

365
00:19:46,024 --> 00:19:48,364
It seemed like things were heating up
near the Arc de Triomphe, there was even...

366
00:19:48,934 --> 00:19:51,794
a helicopter flying over the area,
we didn't feel very calm.

367
00:19:51,909 --> 00:19:53,953
So we wanted to leave.

368
00:19:54,454 --> 00:19:56,354
And we found ourselves stuck
by police officers.

369
00:20:08,360 --> 00:20:09,770
They didn't allow us to pass.

370
00:20:09,890 --> 00:20:11,820
In the end they threw tear gas at us.

371
00:20:23,540 --> 00:20:24,740
We took refuge in a laundromat.

372
00:20:24,950 --> 00:20:27,330
It was all very chaotic.

373
00:20:27,680 --> 00:20:29,970
A protester was arrested…
we got scared.

374
00:20:44,390 --> 00:20:46,170
It was starting to get dark.

375
00:20:46,850 --> 00:20:48,750
We tried to go back
passing through the Champs-Élysées.

376
00:20:48,860 --> 00:20:50,220
so we can start again.

377
00:20:50,930 --> 00:20:52,710
It wasn't possible.

378
00:20:53,889 --> 00:20:55,530
Tear gas was falling everywhere.

379
00:20:56,390 --> 00:20:59,220
Panic broke out, people
ran in all directions.

380
00:21:46,730 --> 00:21:49,920
At a certain point we realized that
Guillaume and Rémi were no longer with us.

381
00:21:50,810 --> 00:21:52,470
We didn't know where they ended up.

382
00:21:52,760 --> 00:21:54,574
And Guillaume and I found each other again
in some streets.

383
00:21:54,575 --> 00:21:57,640
and we realized we had lost the others.

384
00:21:58,130 --> 00:21:59,570
Well, continue

385
00:21:58,550 --> 00:21:59,550


386
00:22:00,050 --> 00:22:02,930
Afterwards we tried to go back towards
the Champs-Élysées to find the others.

387
00:22:03,590 --> 00:22:06,970
Then the policemen arrived who took us
fired their guns at Flash ball, that's it.

388
00:22:07,400 --> 00:22:10,070
They suddenly appeared and shot you for no reason.

389
00:22:10,490 --> 00:22:11,490
Yes

390
00:22:12,440 --> 00:22:15,690
We were walking down a road when I
arrived at a crossroads on the right.

391
00:22:17,660 --> 00:22:19,548
I was about to run away, I thought, Guillaume.

392
00:22:19,580 --> 00:22:21,530
he was following me.

393
00:22:22,160 --> 00:22:25,900
And when I realized it was no longer
with me, I went back.

394
00:22:27,500 --> 00:22:29,220
And he was no longer there.

395
00:22:31,220 --> 00:22:32,940
Guillaume was on the ground.

396
00:22:36,680 --> 00:22:38,310
His head was covered in blood.

397
00:22:40,190 --> 00:22:41,640
I was in a panic.

398
00:22:41,750 --> 00:22:43,200
I called the fire department.

399
00:22:44,210 --> 00:22:46,017
The police officers were uniformed
or in civilian clothes?

400
00:22:45,290 --> 00:22:45,650


401
00:22:46,160 --> 00:22:47,670
In civilian clothes, yes.

402
00:22:48,290 --> 00:22:50,100
They wore police armbands.

403
00:22:53,120 --> 00:22:54,810
I do not know. I didn't see it

404
00:22:53,660 --> 00:22:54,660


405
00:22:54,890 --> 00:22:57,110
What makes you think they were police officers?

406
00:22:57,350 --> 00:22:58,950
But what kind of question is that?

407
00:22:59,120 --> 00:23:00,320
Of course they were policemen.

408
00:23:00,702 --> 00:23:01,893
They had Flash balls.

409
00:23:01,100 --> 00:23:01,670


410
00:23:02,120 --> 00:23:05,660
Mr. Girard, have you ever had an attitude
hostile towards the police?

411
00:23:05,810 --> 00:23:06,140
No.

412
00:23:06,680 --> 00:23:08,090
When you saw them, you didn't say anything.

413
00:23:08,240 --> 00:23:09,950
- Made gestures?
- No.

414
00:23:10,010 --> 00:23:12,140
I ran away screaming at Guillaume
to come away with me.

415
00:23:12,620 --> 00:23:13,620
Why?

416
00:23:13,760 --> 00:23:15,990
But how why? I was scared

417
00:23:16,100 --> 00:23:17,030
They pointed their guns at us.

418
00:23:17,180 --> 00:23:20,839
Mr. Girard, have you ever committed any acts
of damage to property,

419
00:23:20,840 --> 00:23:24,000
theft, looting and acts of violence
against the police?

420
00:23:24,320 --> 00:23:25,320
No.

421
00:23:25,850 --> 00:23:27,060
Are you sure?

422
00:23:28,220 --> 00:23:29,220
YES.

423
00:23:30,410 --> 00:23:33,570
We found some car videos
on fire on your phone.

424
00:23:34,520 --> 00:23:37,170
Have you participated in this type of vandalism?

425
00:23:37,400 --> 00:23:38,400
No

426
00:23:38,900 --> 00:23:41,490
Are you attracted or fascinated by violence?

427
00:23:41,990 --> 00:23:42,320
No.

428
00:23:42,680 --> 00:23:45,970
Why film burning cars, then?

429
00:23:46,300 --> 00:23:48,300
I don't know.

430
00:23:46,940 --> 00:23:47,142


431
00:23:48,350 --> 00:23:49,350
Era.

432
00:23:51,710 --> 00:23:52,920
What was it?

433
00:23:53,930 --> 00:23:54,440
I do not know.

434
00:23:55,040 --> 00:23:56,490
Are you politically involved?

435
00:23:57,440 --> 00:23:59,690
That is to say, it is part of
a political movement.

436
00:23:59,870 --> 00:24:01,860
far right, far left.

437
00:24:03,170 --> 00:24:04,280
I'm not interested in politics.

438
00:24:04,430 --> 00:24:06,360
This is the first time I have protested.

439
00:24:07,250 --> 00:24:09,108
Mr. Cordier, you were stopped around ten o'clock.

440
00:24:09,109 --> 00:24:10,790
7.40pm, that is, one hour after the events.

441
00:24:11,420 --> 00:24:13,530
For outrage, rebellion and violence.

442
00:24:14,150 --> 00:24:16,950
Could you explain to us the circumstances of this arrest?

443
00:24:19,190 --> 00:24:20,140
I stayed on the street to try

444
00:24:20,141 --> 00:24:22,650
to find the policemen who shot.

445
00:24:23,150 --> 00:24:24,150
Why?

446
00:24:24,200 --> 00:24:25,500
I was angry.

447
00:24:25,850 --> 00:24:27,866
I wanted to find them.

448
00:24:28,190 --> 00:24:30,240
To photograph and film them.

449
00:24:30,860 --> 00:24:32,280
To have a proof.

450
00:24:32,390 --> 00:24:33,940
Evidence of what?

451
00:24:33,890 --> 00:24:34,190


452
00:24:33,998 --> 00:24:36,450
Who had been, who was there.

453
00:24:37,550 --> 00:24:38,940
Then.

454
00:24:39,950 --> 00:24:41,143
At a certain point I found myself faced with it

455
00:24:41,144 --> 00:24:43,260
at CRS with other demonstrators.

456
00:24:44,450 --> 00:24:47,910
They blocked the passage again
and they threw tear gas at us.

457
00:24:48,140 --> 00:24:50,640
I was so angry that I started insulting them.

458
00:24:52,040 --> 00:24:53,340
And in that moment.

459
00:24:53,451 --> 00:24:56,190
The policemen rushed towards
of me and tackled me to the ground.

460
00:24:56,840 --> 00:24:58,343
From the minutes it appears that she...

461
00:24:58,373 --> 00:25:01,520
- He attacked and hit the officers.
- Absolutely not.

462
00:25:01,580 --> 00:25:03,290
They were the ones who hit me.

463
00:25:04,400 --> 00:25:05,450
Among the videos.

464
00:25:05,660 --> 00:25:07,850
Among the videos found in his
telephone there is one that

465
00:25:06,080 --> 00:25:07,808


466
00:25:07,809 --> 00:25:10,950
shows firefighters taking
care of Mr. Girard.

467
00:25:11,210 --> 00:25:12,290
Why did you film that scene?

468
00:25:12,950 --> 00:25:15,720
I wanted to show how the cops
they had massacred Guillaume.

469
00:25:16,580 --> 00:25:18,060
- Do you know what happened?

470
00:25:18,080 --> 00:25:19,520
They hit him with a Flash Ball.

471
00:25:19,850 --> 00:25:20,810
- In the head?
- In the head.

472
00:25:21,127 --> 00:25:22,127
THANK YOU.

473
00:25:22,954 --> 00:25:24,080
It's a Flash ball shot

474
00:25:24,244 --> 00:25:26,210
Let's load him into the ambulance.

475
00:25:26,660 --> 00:25:28,286
Let's turn it up!
Up!

476
00:25:27,110 --> 00:25:28,230


477
00:25:38,570 --> 00:25:40,470
Please sir, let us work.

478
00:25:44,660 --> 00:25:46,082
Was he there?

479
00:25:46,340 --> 00:25:48,760
The fire truck was there.

480
00:25:49,310 --> 00:25:51,090
We can see further traces of blood.

481
00:25:52,670 --> 00:25:55,080
The cleaning service had to come
the next day.

482
00:25:55,760 --> 00:25:57,390
They cleaned up the whole neighborhood.

483
00:25:57,440 --> 00:25:59,880
In this neighborhood they do it right away.

484
00:26:07,760 --> 00:26:09,510
It's the back of which hotel?

485
00:26:08,360 --> 00:26:09,360


486
00:26:09,680 --> 00:26:10,980
Prince of Wales.

487
00:26:12,080 --> 00:26:15,769
We pray and, if necessary, we are available to
operational management of technical services

488
00:26:15,770 --> 00:26:18,352
and logistics of sending the recording to us.

489
00:26:18,353 --> 00:26:20,510
Videos from the following
Hatvp paid cameras.

490
00:26:20,720 --> 00:26:24,230
on December 8, 2018,
from 4pm to 8pm.

491
00:26:24,860 --> 00:26:28,250
Room 08021 Avenue George V
corner of via de la Tremoille.

492
00:26:28,730 --> 00:26:32,300
Room 08371 Champs-Élysées
corner via Bassano.

493
00:26:32,720 --> 00:26:35,570
Room 08115 Avenue Pierre 1er de Serbie.

494
00:26:36,110 --> 00:26:39,530
camera 73532 Champs-Élysées a
corner of via Giorgio V.

495
00:26:40,010 --> 00:26:43,800
cameras 08118 via Marboeuf
corner Avenue Georges Cinq.

496
00:26:44,390 --> 00:26:47,180
This is camera number 0815,
Avenue Pierre 1er de Serbie.

497
00:26:47,840 --> 00:26:50,580
At the end of the fight, down there at the bottom.

498
00:26:50,720 --> 00:26:54,540
See a small group of five people
which enters via Georges Bizet.

499
00:26:54,950 --> 00:26:57,769
Obviously you can't see much,
but we recover them…

500
00:26:57,770 --> 00:26:59,600
In the camera of a clinic
private in Georges Bizet street.

501
00:27:00,320 --> 00:27:02,450
The date and time match
at 6.17pm for the premiere

502
00:27:02,480 --> 00:27:04,543
at 6.18pm for Georges Bizet.

503
00:27:03,646 --> 00:27:04,490


504
00:27:05,150 --> 00:27:07,110
As you can see, they are wearing civilian clothes and helmets.

505
00:27:07,490 --> 00:27:08,750
The first two seem to have…

506
00:27:08,800 --> 00:27:09,900
Flash ball rifles.

507
00:27:09,950 --> 00:27:11,280
At least the first one.

508
00:27:11,750 --> 00:27:14,480
The second probably has shin guards.

509
00:27:14,600 --> 00:27:15,600
You see?

510
00:27:15,800 --> 00:27:18,060
Finally, at 6.22pm.

511
00:27:18,110 --> 00:27:20,090
Retrieving images from an ATM camera.

512
00:27:20,270 --> 00:27:21,860
on the corner of Avenue Marceau and rue de Chaillot.

513
00:27:22,040 --> 00:27:23,379
I can't see their faces,
but it's the same group.

514
00:27:23,380 --> 00:27:25,800
if you compare sneakers and pants.

515
00:27:26,030 --> 00:27:27,260
The shin guards are clearly visible.

516
00:27:27,920 --> 00:27:30,110
There are three of them with rifles.

517
00:27:30,620 --> 00:27:32,420
and the other two have truncheons
telescopic, look.

518
00:27:33,020 --> 00:27:33,560


519
00:27:33,040 --> 00:27:34,280
Rifle, rifle…

520
00:27:34,880 --> 00:27:36,240
truncheon truncheon…

521
00:27:37,100 --> 00:27:38,370
rifle.

522
00:27:38,960 --> 00:27:43,410
If we follow their path on a map, we see
which depart from Avenue Pierre 1er de Serbie.

523
00:27:43,550 --> 00:27:45,030
Then Georges Bizet.

524
00:27:45,530 --> 00:27:47,450
Then they had to turn onto rue de Chaillot.

525
00:27:47,570 --> 00:27:49,710
up to Avenue Marceau to the ATM.

526
00:27:49,970 --> 00:27:52,650
and to be in front of via Quentin Bauchart.

527
00:27:52,850 --> 00:27:55,490
It is therefore entirely possible that they are
entered via Quentin Bouchard.

528
00:27:55,790 --> 00:27:58,980
which leads to via Magellan, where
Guillaume Gérard was injured.

529
00:27:59,900 --> 00:28:01,860
You can go back to Georges Bizet.

530
00:28:05,390 --> 00:28:08,780
We know which personnel in civilian clothes
was operating in that area at that time?

531
00:28:08,870 --> 00:28:10,590
This is where things get complicated.

532
00:28:10,970 --> 00:28:14,569
With Mark, we carefully examined the le
operational provisions and the Pegaso report

533
00:28:14,570 --> 00:28:17,839
radio communications for the units
in uniform they are clear.

534
00:28:17,840 --> 00:28:19,310


535
00:28:17,900 --> 00:28:21,470
But the various units in civilian clothes.

536
00:28:21,550 --> 00:28:24,960
they eventually move and position themselves
on its own initiative.

537
00:28:25,280 --> 00:28:28,830
The prefecture and the government were in such a panic
who asked for help from anyone who could intervene.

538
00:28:28,835 --> 00:28:30,540
but everything was clearly lacking
of coordination.

539
00:28:30,600 --> 00:28:33,690
I'm using a euphemism...
in reality it was total brothel.

540
00:28:34,300 --> 00:28:36,750
What was his rank and position
the day of the event?

541
00:28:36,751 --> 00:28:40,050
I am a police captain and I participated
at the demonstration on December 8th

542
00:28:40,160 --> 00:28:43,160
and I ran the units
BAC 11, 12, 19 and 20.

543
00:28:43,970 --> 00:28:45,020
I'm a police major.

544
00:28:45,410 --> 00:28:47,720
and I had under my command
the nine civil sections.

545
00:28:48,140 --> 00:28:50,430
by the security and intervention company.

546
00:28:50,570 --> 00:28:52,420
under the orders of Commander Baron.

547
00:28:52,430 --> 00:28:53,850
Division Commissioner.

548
00:28:54,440 --> 00:28:57,210
I was in charge of the officers
of the BRI in the field.

549
00:28:57,650 --> 00:28:59,657
The General Management has us
asked exceptionally.

550
00:28:59,808 --> 00:29:01,844
to lend a hand to the patrols
furniture that was disoriented.

551
00:29:00,200 --> 00:29:01,820


552
00:29:02,090 --> 00:29:03,780
and they were no longer in control
of the situation.

553
00:29:04,100 --> 00:29:06,380
I was the head of a detachment
of rapid intervention.

554
00:29:07,070 --> 00:29:11,450
The DAR 5 composed of twenty-five officials
coming from BAC 93 and 92

555
00:29:08,600 --> 00:29:10,490


556
00:29:10,700 --> 00:29:11,994


557
00:29:11,540 --> 00:29:13,470
and from various police stations.

558
00:29:13,700 --> 00:29:14,404
Police major.

559
00:29:14,570 --> 00:29:17,820
I had my responsibility
the crews of BAC 92

560
00:29:18,290 --> 00:29:20,850
Can you specify what your duties were?

561
00:29:21,110 --> 00:29:22,190
Prevent looting

562
00:29:22,730 --> 00:29:24,140
and block violent individuals.

563
00:29:24,380 --> 00:29:27,428
stop the thugs and protect
colleagues in uniform.

564
00:29:27,470 --> 00:29:29,510
They told us that the Republic was in danger.

565
00:29:30,080 --> 00:29:31,910
and that we had to stop the insurrection

566
00:29:32,450 --> 00:29:33,610
and asked to

567
00:29:33,680 --> 00:29:34,970
participate in the war effort.

568
00:29:35,660 --> 00:29:37,720
Were those the instructions?
Save the Republic

569
00:29:37,721 --> 00:29:41,040
and participate in the war effort? In these terms?
- Right.

570
00:29:41,540 --> 00:29:44,100
Maintaining public order does
part of his usual duties.

571
00:29:44,210 --> 00:29:45,210
No.

572
00:29:46,130 --> 00:29:46,400
No.

573
00:29:47,150 --> 00:29:48,900
What are your usual duties?

574
00:29:49,730 --> 00:29:51,870
He is not familiar with the BAC's missions.

575
00:29:52,700 --> 00:29:54,780
Please answer my question.

576
00:29:55,400 --> 00:29:59,790
Interventions against organized crime,
kidnappings and terrorism.

577
00:29:59,900 --> 00:30:01,610
fight against urban violence.

578
00:30:01,790 --> 00:30:03,780
flagrant crimes in a public place.

579
00:30:05,870 --> 00:30:09,300
You have received specific training on
maintenance of public order?

580
00:30:10,258 --> 00:30:13,308
No. Everything was done with
a certain rush.

581
00:30:12,328 --> 00:30:13,328


582
00:30:14,668 --> 00:30:16,388
The government was in a panic.

583
00:30:17,541 --> 00:30:19,708
We have been asked to intervene

584
00:30:19,728 --> 00:30:21,418
completely improvised.

585
00:30:21,628 --> 00:30:23,058
Some of my men had to procure
the necessary equipment

586
00:30:23,068 --> 00:30:24,218
from Decathlon.

587
00:30:25,528 --> 00:30:28,908
- What weapons do you have? C
- LBD 40 (Flash Ball)

588
00:30:28,918 --> 00:30:30,208
GM2L grenades.

589
00:30:30,748 --> 00:30:31,528
Our service weapons.

590
00:30:31,948 --> 00:30:35,348
Crowd control grenades
and tear gas grenades in the backpack.

591
00:30:35,518 --> 00:30:36,388
Have you ever used…

592
00:30:36,508 --> 00:30:37,808
the LBD 40?

593
00:30:38,338 --> 00:30:41,198
Yes. Having often had to face
very determined thugs.

594
00:30:41,389 --> 00:30:42,518
Obviously.

595
00:30:42,838 --> 00:30:44,258
On numerous occasions.

596
00:30:44,668 --> 00:30:45,468
I?

597
00:30:45,568 --> 00:30:47,528
Yes. I authorized about sixty shots.

598
00:30:47,638 --> 00:30:50,128
You've filled out some reports
about shootings?

599
00:30:50,548 --> 00:30:51,958
I exempted my men from doing so

600
00:30:52,078 --> 00:30:53,398
given the complicated situation.

601
00:30:53,848 --> 00:30:54,088
No.

602
00:30:54,508 --> 00:30:55,971
In such a context the modules
TSUA are compiled

603
00:30:55,972 --> 00:30:58,688
at the end of the shift or even the following day.

604
00:30:58,768 --> 00:31:01,558
By specifying a time slot
over a large geographical area.

605
00:31:02,128 --> 00:31:02,788
we filled it the next day.

606
00:31:03,178 --> 00:31:04,348
but not for all our shots

607
00:31:04,828 --> 00:31:06,698
But is he obligated to do so?

608
00:31:06,748 --> 00:31:07,648
We are obliged to do it.

609
00:31:08,098 --> 00:31:09,698
Except it's impossible.

610
00:31:10,018 --> 00:31:11,440
I tell you it's impossible.

611
00:31:12,148 --> 00:31:14,408
The situation was almost insurrectional.

612
00:31:15,307 --> 00:31:17,498
it wasn't simple maintenance
of public order.

613
00:31:17,638 --> 00:31:20,607
There were shots fired by your people
men who caused injuries or

614
00:31:20,608 --> 00:31:22,328
the intervention of the firefighters?

615
00:31:23,518 --> 00:31:24,788
As far as I know, no.

616
00:31:25,408 --> 00:31:27,404
From memory, no.

617
00:31:27,958 --> 00:31:30,338
The affected people run away.

618
00:31:30,808 --> 00:31:32,197
I didn't see any injuries.

619
00:31:33,688 --> 00:31:36,518
I show a photo taken during
a routine activity.

620
00:31:41,488 --> 00:31:43,898
This could be a drive
internal to your staff?

621
00:31:46,318 --> 00:31:47,798
I can't make out much.

622
00:31:48,208 --> 00:31:49,838
No, I don't think so.

623
00:31:51,958 --> 00:31:53,283
Have you met any units that might

624
00:31:53,284 --> 00:31:56,378
match the group that
you can see it in these images.

625
00:31:57,418 --> 00:31:59,748
No, I don't recognize anyone.

626
00:32:01,048 --> 00:32:02,741
As far as I remember, no.

627
00:32:03,148 --> 00:32:04,148
No.

628
00:32:08,398 --> 00:32:10,918
Eric found some images that
correspond to our kids.

629
00:32:11,548 --> 00:32:13,778
We're working on another case
starting December 8th.

630
00:32:13,888 --> 00:32:16,518
He found a video of a journalist
of the intervention of the firefighters.

631
00:32:16,588 --> 00:32:18,538
On the corner of Rue de Vernet and Rue Bassano.

632
00:32:18,568 --> 00:32:20,318
It's 6.29pm.

633
00:32:20,398 --> 00:32:24,248
So, seven minutes after the switch
from the ATM on Avenue Marceau.

634
00:32:24,718 --> 00:32:26,318
You will see them appear there.

635
00:32:26,788 --> 00:32:27,508
It's the same group.

636
00:32:27,628 --> 00:32:30,008
Same number, same weapons,
same details.

637
00:32:32,368 --> 00:32:34,538
The video is much clearer than the others.

638
00:32:38,158 --> 00:32:39,518
then they are no longer seen.

639
00:32:39,842 --> 00:32:41,468
I approach him

640
00:32:45,328 --> 00:32:48,838
The first two have LBD 40 rifles.

641
00:32:49,048 --> 00:32:50,858
The third lowers his balaclava.

642
00:32:52,978 --> 00:32:55,187
The last one has the LBD 40 rifle.

643
00:32:53,698 --> 00:32:54,878


644
00:32:55,978 --> 00:32:56,978


645
00:32:57,028 --> 00:32:59,108
The third when you lower your balaclava.

646
00:33:00,748 --> 00:33:01,748
Here you are.

647
00:33:04,618 --> 00:33:08,308
You can see it pretty well on your face.

648
00:33:10,443 --> 00:33:10,858
Here it is.

649
00:33:11,368 --> 00:33:13,168
if they were on Avenue Marceau at 6.22pm.

650
00:33:13,378 --> 00:33:14,989
They can be passed from the corner
Magellan/Bauchart

651
00:33:14,990 --> 00:33:16,678
where Guillaume Gérard was wounded.

652
00:33:16,828 --> 00:33:18,261
Just enter Avenue George V and you find yourself

653
00:33:18,262 --> 00:33:21,098
On rue Vernet-Bassano at 6.29pm.

654
00:33:22,498 --> 00:33:25,148
I take the screenshot at the points
where they are most visible.

655
00:33:30,658 --> 00:33:31,988
Have you seen their helmets?

656
00:33:34,228 --> 00:33:35,708
Right.

657
00:34:03,598 --> 00:34:04,598
Yessss.

658
00:34:14,848 --> 00:34:14,998
Oh.

659
00:34:15,148 --> 00:34:16,908
She has really shitty style.

660
00:34:15,808 --> 00:34:16,808


661
00:34:17,488 --> 00:34:18,848
- Who?
- I'm not talking about you

662
00:34:18,253 --> 00:34:18,718


663
00:34:19,017 --> 00:34:20,318
I wouldn't dare.

664
00:34:20,728 --> 00:34:22,968
And go play, play...

665
00:34:21,568 --> 00:34:22,928


666
00:34:23,008 --> 00:34:24,008
YES.

667
00:34:24,448 --> 00:34:25,448
This.

668
00:34:27,178 --> 00:34:28,718
Wait, wait… concentration.

669
00:34:32,968 --> 00:34:35,088
Look, it has a bit of an effect.

670
00:34:36,838 --> 00:34:37,838
Come on.

671
00:34:38,128 --> 00:34:38,848


672
00:34:39,148 --> 00:34:40,822


673
00:34:42,448 --> 00:34:46,448
- Anyone want anything? I'm going to the bar
- I'm coming with you

674
00:34:46,768 --> 00:34:47,978
Oh… Oh

675
00:34:47,908 --> 00:34:48,998
What is it?

676
00:34:49,018 --> 00:34:50,198
My ex

677
00:34:55,558 --> 00:34:57,788
Four more, please.

678
00:34:59,494 --> 00:35:00,238
He how are you?

679
00:35:00,508 --> 00:35:01,078
Super.

680
00:35:01,468 --> 00:35:01,918
And you?

681
00:35:02,428 --> 00:35:03,388
Finally.

682
00:35:03,628 --> 00:35:04,628
Good morning.

683
00:35:04,738 --> 00:35:05,218
- Noelie
-Stephanie.

684
00:35:05,728 --> 00:35:06,938
His ex.

685
00:35:07,348 --> 00:35:08,638
Victor's mother.

686
00:35:09,238 --> 00:35:10,238
Already.

687
00:35:13,048 --> 00:35:15,094
- Can I ask you a question?
- Yes

688
00:35:15,178 --> 00:35:16,778
Do you work at IGPN?

689
00:35:17,668 --> 00:35:18,508
And did you work in narcotics before?

690
00:35:18,868 --> 00:35:20,858
Yes, that's right, with Jeremy.

691
00:35:22,318 --> 00:35:24,058
I wonder how we can pass
from one to the other.

692
00:35:24,688 --> 00:35:26,748
How can you investigate colleagues

693
00:35:26,749 --> 00:35:28,858
- instead of criminals?
- Noelie…

694
00:35:29,278 --> 00:35:30,478
I'm interested in this

695
00:35:30,598 --> 00:35:32,248
It shouldn't exactly be put in these terms.

696
00:35:32,548 --> 00:35:32,908
Oh no?.

697
00:35:33,298 --> 00:35:33,538
No.

698
00:35:34,018 --> 00:35:36,068
But I don't want to talk about it here.

699
00:35:36,659 --> 00:35:39,498
- We're here to have fun
- Well have fun

700
00:35:38,188 --> 00:35:40,118


701
00:35:41,668 --> 00:35:42,778
We, together with the union,

702
00:35:42,988 --> 00:35:45,038
we are here to support each other.

703
00:35:45,568 --> 00:35:46,568
Certain.

704
00:35:47,092 --> 00:35:50,598
- Does it bother you that I'm a member of the union?
- At all.

705
00:35:48,328 --> 00:35:49,538


706
00:35:50,811 --> 00:35:52,568
We are here to defend our colleagues.

707
00:35:53,188 --> 00:35:54,868
We are all tired of criticism of the police.

708
00:35:55,374 --> 00:35:57,478
With and your inquiries

709
00:35:57,622 --> 00:35:59,542
cast suspicion on all the work of the Police

710
00:35:59,543 --> 00:36:02,828
I believe exactly the opposite, but still.

711
00:36:06,958 --> 00:36:07,318
Steph it's your turn.

712
00:36:08,038 --> 00:36:09,218
All right.

713
00:36:25,078 --> 00:36:27,208
This is the second time for two
months since you summoned me here.

714
00:36:27,388 --> 00:36:29,875
for an issue that I doubt concerns the BIS.

715
00:36:30,448 --> 00:36:31,941
You're wasting your time,
.

716
00:36:31,942 --> 00:36:33,808
and you make me lose it too

717
00:36:34,078 --> 00:36:36,518
while we have much more important missions to do.

718
00:36:36,958 --> 00:36:39,188
Nobody wants to waste time, Commissioner.

719
00:36:39,358 --> 00:36:41,528
If he cooperates, it will be very fast.

720
00:36:45,508 --> 00:36:49,017
I show you some screenshots taken from a
video shot by a journalist

721
00:36:49,018 --> 00:36:51,338
on the evening of December 8, 2018.

722
00:36:52,138 --> 00:36:54,548
Could these men be part of the BIS?

723
00:36:56,848 --> 00:36:57,358
I do not know.

724
00:36:57,868 --> 00:36:59,488
There is one whose face is easily recognisable.

725
00:37:00,028 --> 00:37:01,598
But I don't know who he is.

726
00:37:02,338 --> 00:37:04,018
What do you think of the helmets these men are wearing?

727
00:37:04,378 --> 00:37:05,798
I don't think anything.

728
00:37:06,208 --> 00:37:08,938
Three of these helmets are BIS Wendy helmets.

729
00:37:09,148 --> 00:37:11,193
- Unlike the other two
- I'm not a helmet specialist.

730
00:37:11,194 --> 00:37:14,458
Can non-approved personal helmets be worn?

731
00:37:14,518 --> 00:37:18,458
So you're interrogating people to find out
whether the helmets are regulation or not?

732
00:37:20,668 --> 00:37:23,818
During your last hearing you stated,
and I quote verbatim:

733
00:37:23,938 --> 00:37:25,787
We were asked to intervene in a state

734
00:37:25,788 --> 00:37:27,867
of total improvisation, some
of my men had to

735
00:37:27,868 --> 00:37:29,768
Buy equipment from Decathlon.

736
00:37:30,598 --> 00:37:31,948
Do you confirm this statement?

737
00:37:32,278 --> 00:37:33,638
I don't remember.

738
00:37:35,938 --> 00:37:37,692
I will show you the product sheet of the helmet.

739
00:37:37,693 --> 00:37:40,268
Oxelo skateboard set
sold by Decathlon.

740
00:37:40,558 --> 00:37:44,738
What do you think of the helmet shown
in these two screens?

741
00:37:45,538 --> 00:37:46,108
I do not know.

742
00:37:46,828 --> 00:37:48,115
There might be some similarities, but...

743
00:37:48,116 --> 00:37:50,738
This does not authorize us to affirm
that they are equal.

744
00:37:50,848 --> 00:37:52,978
My men are not alone
to use their own helmets.

745
00:37:53,548 --> 00:37:56,198
or buy them from Decathlon.

746
00:37:58,738 --> 00:38:01,558
We have made requests to Decathlon
in the Île-de-France region.

747
00:38:01,798 --> 00:38:03,197
to find out who bought the helmets.

748
00:38:03,358 --> 00:38:05,528
Oxelo in the days preceding the event.

749
00:38:08,608 --> 00:38:11,127
We could both save time
if you provided us with the names of the agents.

750
00:38:11,128 --> 00:38:13,268
shown in these images.

751
00:38:16,228 --> 00:38:18,957
I can summon each member of the BIS
one by one until…

752
00:38:18,958 --> 00:38:21,578
we identify who is shown in the video.

753
00:38:22,528 --> 00:38:24,818
But this will hinder your missions.

754
00:38:28,738 --> 00:38:30,488
Can I expect your response?

755
00:38:31,918 --> 00:38:35,397
Note that the names of the members of the BIS
were provided by the commissioner.

756
00:38:35,398 --> 00:38:37,768
Division commander Frédéric Picard
is the following:

757
00:38:38,188 --> 00:38:39,118
Clement Garcia.

758
00:38:39,328 --> 00:38:40,498
Michel Brzezinski.

759
00:38:40,768 --> 00:38:42,898
Arnaud Lavallée, Sébastien Jacquet.

760
00:38:43,048 --> 00:38:44,588
Michael Fague.

761
00:38:46,498 --> 00:38:49,388
Mr. Garcia, do you recognize yourself in this photo?

762
00:38:50,698 --> 00:38:51,698
YES.

763
00:38:55,168 --> 00:38:57,875
You can confirm that you are pictured here in the company of

764
00:38:57,876 --> 00:39:01,328
Michel Fage, Sébastien Jacquet in the valley and Michel Brzezinski?

765
00:39:02,434 --> 00:39:04,058
I don't really recognize them.

766
00:39:05,038 --> 00:39:07,808
I recognize Clément Garcia and Arnaud Lavallée.

767
00:39:08,038 --> 00:39:09,698
I'm less sure about others.

768
00:39:10,528 --> 00:39:12,938
Were you together on the evening of December 8th?

769
00:39:13,643 --> 00:39:14,534
Yes.

770
00:39:14,578 --> 00:39:16,208
A memorable moment for the BAC.

771
00:39:16,678 --> 00:39:18,058
We can see that you are moving
in un piccolo gruppo.

772
00:39:18,418 --> 00:39:20,798
It's not a risk in one context
so conflicted?

773
00:39:20,998 --> 00:39:21,898
That's pretty unusual, isn't it?

774
00:39:22,528 --> 00:39:25,718
We had separated from the main group
to use the bathrooms of a bar.

775
00:39:25,768 --> 00:39:26,218
Then.

776
00:39:26,338 --> 00:39:27,538
It took some time to do this.

777
00:39:27,718 --> 00:39:28,258
to re-establish the connection.

778
00:39:28,948 --> 00:39:30,158
Which bar?

779
00:39:30,208 --> 00:39:31,388
I don't remember.

780
00:39:31,648 --> 00:39:33,800
Where was the reunion location
with the main group?

781
00:39:32,038 --> 00:39:33,508


782
00:39:33,808 --> 00:39:35,108
On the Champs-Élysées.

783
00:39:35,248 --> 00:39:36,518
At what height?

784
00:39:37,438 --> 00:39:38,128
Rather high.

785
00:39:38,848 --> 00:39:41,558
You remember the roads you've traveled
to get to the Champs-Élysées?

786
00:39:42,238 --> 00:39:43,108
Mostly narrow streets.

787
00:39:43,468 --> 00:39:44,368
I couldn't say which one.

788
00:39:44,728 --> 00:39:47,657
It is possible to see you in the recordings
on Avenue Pierre 1er.

789
00:39:47,717 --> 00:39:51,128
rue Georges Bizet, avenue Marceau and rue Vernet.

790
00:39:51,328 --> 00:39:52,508
What do you think?

791
00:39:53,128 --> 00:39:55,468
I don't know this area well, but I can
pay attention to the street names.

792
00:39:56,278 --> 00:39:58,628
But it's really your group
what do we see in these videos?

793
00:39:59,338 --> 00:40:00,338
Yes

794
00:40:00,838 --> 00:40:02,198
It seems so.

795
00:40:03,148 --> 00:40:06,888
Monsieur Brzezenski, confirms that he has
with an LBD 40?

796
00:40:07,408 --> 00:40:09,518
Who among you was equipped with an LBD 40?

797
00:40:10,018 --> 00:40:10,648
Lavalle.

798
00:40:11,038 --> 00:40:11,548
And Fage.

799
00:40:11,878 --> 00:40:14,978
He used it during the trip
towards the Champs-Élysées?

800
00:40:16,128 --> 00:40:17,218
It's possible.

801
00:40:17,718 --> 00:40:19,337
I remember we had to do it.

802
00:40:19,338 --> 00:40:21,228
to keep hostile individuals at a distance.

803
00:40:21,498 --> 00:40:22,938
some individuals were very violent and

804
00:40:23,688 --> 00:40:24,378
They wanted to beat us.

805
00:40:24,528 --> 00:40:27,228
Your shots caused injuries
among the protesters?

806
00:40:27,258 --> 00:40:27,678


807
00:40:27,298 --> 00:40:29,208
Yes, some protesters have
had some bruises.

808
00:40:29,478 --> 00:40:32,488
I am referring to injured people who have requested
the intervention of the firefighters.

809
00:40:32,898 --> 00:40:34,258
Not that I remember.

810
00:40:35,628 --> 00:40:37,048
I do not believe.

811
00:40:37,308 --> 00:40:38,895
Around 6.30pm, a young man of twenty.

812
00:40:38,896 --> 00:40:42,088
He was wounded in the head by a
Flash ball on Magellan Street.

813
00:40:42,198 --> 00:40:43,348
What do you think?

814
00:40:44,178 --> 00:40:45,508
It doesn't tell me anything.

815
00:40:46,428 --> 00:40:48,148
I don't know, it doesn't tell me anything.

816
00:40:48,588 --> 00:40:51,317
You don't remember if two protesters were there
incited shooting with the LBD 40…

817
00:40:51,318 --> 00:40:53,488
and one of your colleagues shot with
the LBD?

818
00:40:53,568 --> 00:40:53,838
No.

819
00:40:54,438 --> 00:40:56,118
Yet you were there at that moment.

820
00:40:56,478 --> 00:40:58,308
It's possible, but I don't remember such an episode.

821
00:40:58,878 --> 00:41:01,033
It was an eventful day;
I don't remember everything in detail.

822
00:41:01,308 --> 00:41:03,418
You didn't see any injured protesters.?

823
00:41:04,158 --> 00:41:05,158
No.

824
00:41:05,478 --> 00:41:06,478
No.

825
00:41:08,088 --> 00:41:09,088
No.

826
00:41:09,648 --> 00:41:11,848
No, I don't remember any protestors
was injured.

827
00:41:12,048 --> 00:41:15,888
It is said that there have been situations of
conflict and maybe even gunshots, but

828
00:41:15,918 --> 00:41:18,598
without being able to locate them
or describe them precisely.

829
00:41:18,768 --> 00:41:22,738
and none of them said they remembered a
protester injured by a Flash ball.

830
00:41:22,848 --> 00:41:26,978
Chances are one of them
shot Mr. Girard

831
00:41:24,378 --> 00:41:27,088


832
00:41:27,348 --> 00:41:29,178
Yes, but we know nothing about the circumstances.

833
00:41:29,448 --> 00:41:31,738
You were able to hear
Guillaume Gérard?

834
00:41:31,878 --> 00:41:32,808
Only in writing.

835
00:41:33,048 --> 00:41:35,988
It's just starting to come back
the ability to speak.

836
00:41:36,048 --> 00:41:38,497
His version coincides with
that of Rémi Cordier,

837
00:41:38,498 --> 00:41:41,928
It all happened very quickly and he didn't
showed no hostile attitude.

838
00:41:42,498 --> 00:41:44,088
What is your personal opinion?

839
00:41:44,483 --> 00:41:46,318
I don't have an opinion.

840
00:41:46,938 --> 00:41:50,178
Colleagues at the BRI are clearly not
very collaborative

841
00:41:50,359 --> 00:41:53,528
but there are no elements that have
acted outside the rules.

842
00:41:53,538 --> 00:41:55,948
At present, it is impossible
know the truth.

843
00:42:07,273 --> 00:42:08,968
How many days are we staying
in Saint-Dizier?

844
00:42:09,048 --> 00:42:10,378
All week.

845
00:42:11,178 --> 00:42:13,378
But there's nothing to do there,
it is absolute zero.

846
00:42:15,378 --> 00:42:16,968
There are gusts.

847
00:42:17,658 --> 00:42:19,138
Super.

848
00:42:20,688 --> 00:42:22,168
Grandma will spoil you.

849
00:42:22,848 --> 00:42:26,038
I bet he made it tonight
the macaroni au gratin for us.

850
00:42:28,878 --> 00:42:30,358
What is Yogurt doing?

851
00:42:35,388 --> 00:42:37,018
He's tired of being cooped up.

852
00:42:48,318 --> 00:42:50,258
You can wear the yellow vest
on the dashboard.

853
00:42:50,308 --> 00:42:51,988
and it must be in the glove compartment.

854
00:44:07,758 --> 00:44:08,628
Victor, can you help us?

855
00:44:09,408 --> 00:44:11,788
Let him play with the cat.

856
00:44:13,548 --> 00:44:14,868
You should make videos.

857
00:44:15,018 --> 00:44:16,738
There are tons of them on the internet.

858
00:44:16,848 --> 00:44:19,318
I'm sure Yogurt would have
a great success.

859
00:44:28,638 --> 00:44:30,978
Dad, why don't you buy a dishwasher?

860
00:44:29,598 --> 00:44:30,928


861
00:44:31,008 --> 00:44:32,159
I like washing dishes.

862
00:44:40,308 --> 00:44:41,698
They're cute.

863
00:44:44,868 --> 00:44:46,288
While jumping.

864
00:44:46,578 --> 00:44:47,438
That is

865
00:44:47,448 --> 00:44:48,448
funny.

866
00:44:52,968 --> 00:44:54,845
You know your mother is passing by
more time watching.

867
00:44:54,846 --> 00:44:56,568
video of kittens talking to me?

868
00:44:56,718 --> 00:44:57,898
But then...

869
00:44:58,248 --> 00:45:01,078
It's better than the horrors that are
they see on television.

870
00:45:01,653 --> 00:45:04,408
If everyone did like me
the world would be better.

871
00:45:04,474 --> 00:45:05,668
At least it wouldn't be violent.

872
00:45:05,835 --> 00:45:07,848
These videos get billions of views and...

873
00:45:08,208 --> 00:45:11,358
the world is still so violent, rather

874
00:45:11,748 --> 00:45:13,458
they prevent people from thinking.

875
00:45:13,668 --> 00:45:14,918
Of course not.

876
00:45:14,958 --> 00:45:17,098
let's make him think about something else.

877
00:45:17,718 --> 00:45:20,293
When no one will have brains or democracy anymore

878
00:45:20,294 --> 00:45:23,188
you'll wonder if you looked too carefully.

879
00:45:23,568 --> 00:45:24,078
the kittens

880
00:45:24,678 --> 00:45:26,328
However, you are heartless.

881
00:45:26,898 --> 00:45:30,118
The other day He killed a mole with his spade.
So, without thinking twice...

882
00:45:30,198 --> 00:45:30,708
Really?

883
00:45:31,338 --> 00:45:33,388
With the spade, like this.

884
00:45:34,068 --> 00:45:35,668
He destroyed my flowerbed.

885
00:45:35,758 --> 00:45:36,788
Your flowerbed?

886
00:45:36,888 --> 00:45:37,698
You are violent.

887
00:45:38,088 --> 00:45:40,828
You are a violent Gérard, closed.

888
00:45:47,928 --> 00:45:48,928
OH.

889
00:46:08,298 --> 00:46:10,798
All that's left to do is get something to eat
and cat litter

890
00:46:10,998 --> 00:46:11,998


891
00:46:12,558 --> 00:46:14,598
To mineral water for
I'll take care of grandma

892
00:46:14,603 --> 00:46:16,968
look for the croquettes and
Yogurt litter.

893
00:46:17,568 --> 00:46:18,868
Bottom left.

894
00:47:40,278 --> 00:47:41,278
Excuse me.

895
00:47:42,558 --> 00:47:43,558
Excuse me.

896
00:47:46,278 --> 00:47:47,428
I know you

897
00:47:48,528 --> 00:47:50,012
What is he doing here?

898
00:47:50,538 --> 00:47:51,718
You're following us.

899
00:47:52,008 --> 00:47:53,398
No. Absolutely not.

900
00:47:52,608 --> 00:47:53,178


901
00:47:53,898 --> 00:47:55,768
So, what are you doing here?

902
00:47:56,388 --> 00:47:57,228
I'm doing the shopping.

903
00:47:57,618 --> 00:47:59,248
Here. In Saint-Dizier.

904
00:47:58,158 --> 00:47:59,248


905
00:47:59,568 --> 00:48:00,568
YES.

906
00:48:01,098 --> 00:48:03,958
Don't take us for fools, we have
since you were watching.

907
00:48:04,428 --> 00:48:05,848
Why should I look at you?

908
00:48:06,738 --> 00:48:09,188
I do not know. To spy on us.

909
00:48:07,878 --> 00:48:09,148


910
00:48:09,498 --> 00:48:11,058
I have no reason to spy on you.

911
00:48:11,388 --> 00:48:12,538
Oh yes.

912
00:48:12,768 --> 00:48:15,988
You didn't lead the investigation
about Guillaume's background?

913
00:48:16,758 --> 00:48:19,888
All the filth that was
posted on social media.

914
00:48:19,968 --> 00:48:22,588
As if he deserved that
what happened to him

915
00:48:22,638 --> 00:48:24,278
Also to make him look like a criminal.

916
00:48:24,288 --> 00:48:25,957
I have nothing to do with it, I'm not here for you.

917
00:48:25,958 --> 00:48:28,648
I came to visit my parents.

918
00:48:28,818 --> 00:48:29,808
But what are you saying?

919
00:48:30,138 --> 00:48:31,288
The truth.

920
00:48:32,148 --> 00:48:33,898
I was born here in Saint-Dizier.

921
00:48:35,058 --> 00:48:37,588
You're making this all up, right?

922
00:48:37,968 --> 00:48:39,478
I grew up here.

923
00:48:39,918 --> 00:48:41,938
I'm with my son, we're doing the shopping.

924
00:48:43,128 --> 00:48:44,668
Show me your documents.

925
00:48:44,718 --> 00:48:45,078
What?

926
00:48:45,318 --> 00:48:46,798
Your identity document.

927
00:48:58,998 --> 00:49:01,138
I don't have glasses, look at you.

928
00:49:04,788 --> 00:49:05,788
Saint-Dizier.

929
00:49:09,858 --> 00:49:11,368
Who are your parents?

930
00:49:11,538 --> 00:49:13,558
Sylvie and Gérard Bertrand.

931
00:49:13,758 --> 00:49:15,298
Sylvie Bertrand.

932
00:49:16,008 --> 00:49:16,278
YES.

933
00:49:16,518 --> 00:49:17,208
Of Marnaval?.

934
00:49:17,838 --> 00:49:18,078
YES.

935
00:49:18,648 --> 00:49:19,068
I know her.

936
00:49:19,878 --> 00:49:23,562
Ah yes, two years ago it broke
her wrist, I helped her.

937
00:49:20,962 --> 00:49:23,578


938
00:49:26,448 --> 00:49:27,989
You see, I'm not lying.

939
00:49:30,528 --> 00:49:32,338
Can you tell us what stage the investigation is at?

940
00:49:33,468 --> 00:49:34,978
Nobody tells us anything.

941
00:49:36,078 --> 00:49:37,378
It's ongoing.

942
00:49:38,418 --> 00:49:40,308
This is a preliminary investigation;
it's a long process.

943
00:49:40,548 --> 00:49:43,548
Excuse me, but I shouldn't be communicating with
her outside of the hearings.

944
00:49:43,638 --> 00:49:46,667
Why does it take so long when to condemn
Rémi, it only took ten minutes?

945
00:49:46,668 --> 00:49:48,548
He was sentenced to three months in prison.

946
00:49:48,768 --> 00:49:50,188
He lost his job.

947
00:49:50,538 --> 00:49:52,188
With a criminal record that
he will never find anything again.

948
00:49:52,698 --> 00:49:54,722
He doesn't care.

949
00:49:55,578 --> 00:49:57,828
Is this all he can do?

950
00:49:58,568 --> 00:50:01,438
It's long, but it's not true that we don't care.

951
00:50:01,518 --> 00:50:02,598
You have to have patience.

952
00:50:02,958 --> 00:50:04,578
But we have been patient for months.

953
00:50:05,118 --> 00:50:07,018
At least tell us the progress of the investigation.

954
00:50:08,838 --> 00:50:10,618
I'm sorry, I can't tell you anything.

955
00:50:13,098 --> 00:50:14,278
Obviously.

956
00:50:15,118 --> 00:50:16,658
Well, Sonia let's go.

957
00:50:16,788 --> 00:50:17,788
It disgusts me.

958
00:50:19,036 --> 00:50:21,386
If I were you, I wouldn't be able to
to look at myself in the mirror.

959
00:50:21,566 --> 00:50:23,286
It's not worth it, let's go.

960
00:50:26,336 --> 00:50:27,936
What happened?

961
00:50:29,726 --> 00:50:30,506
They are yellow vests.

962
00:50:31,136 --> 00:50:32,136
No.

963
00:50:32,396 --> 00:50:34,596
You see they don't have yellow vests.

964
00:50:35,516 --> 00:50:37,506
They could be vests
yellows in plain clothes.

965
00:50:40,766 --> 00:50:42,906
I asked you if you knew her.

966
00:50:43,000 --> 00:50:43,906
I understand.

967
00:50:43,926 --> 00:50:45,356
So you know her?

968
00:50:45,566 --> 00:50:46,046
Yes, certainly.

969
00:50:46,376 --> 00:50:48,936
I don't remember his last name anymore.

970
00:50:49,376 --> 00:50:51,876
Maybe you never told me.

971
00:50:52,496 --> 00:50:54,116
I only remember his name.

972
00:50:54,656 --> 00:50:56,076
Is it Giselle?

973
00:50:55,316 --> 00:50:56,036


974
00:50:56,336 --> 00:50:57,536
No it's Joelle.

975
00:50:57,596 --> 00:50:59,646
See, I don't even remember.

976
00:51:00,836 --> 00:51:04,746
His son was seriously injured
during a demonstration.

977
00:51:04,466 --> 00:51:04,796


978
00:51:04,946 --> 00:51:06,956
Mom, are you doing this on purpose or what?

979
00:51:07,256 --> 00:51:09,486
You don't see the link
with my job?

980
00:51:09,536 --> 00:51:12,326
- Are you the one investigating?
- And who else could it be?

981
00:51:12,536 --> 00:51:13,166
I do not know.

982
00:51:13,286 --> 00:51:14,197
Why are you getting angry?

983
00:51:14,366 --> 00:51:15,949
I don't get angry, but I
it seems absurd that you…

984
00:51:15,950 --> 00:51:17,786
you don't pay attention anymore
to what I say.

985
00:51:17,936 --> 00:51:20,236
Of course I pay attention.

986
00:51:21,236 --> 00:51:23,646
In any case, I hope they don't search
to cover up the matter.

987
00:51:23,696 --> 00:51:25,164
Don't get involved too.

988
00:51:25,165 --> 00:51:28,357
Do you realize? You're talking
of my work.

989
00:51:30,986 --> 00:51:34,916
I'm not in that office to cover things up.
No, it's exactly the opposite.

990
00:51:35,876 --> 00:51:37,762
There are interrogations.

991
00:51:37,763 --> 00:51:40,206
the requisitions, the minutes to be drawn up,
not for fun

992
00:51:40,291 --> 00:51:42,576
We have dozens of investigations like that.

993
00:51:43,136 --> 00:51:46,407
- I didn't tell you anything
- You always say everything that comes into your head.

994
00:51:46,427 --> 00:51:48,456
You don't even think about it, it's unbearable.

995
00:51:49,706 --> 00:51:52,765
Do you have any idea what work they do
the police officers

996
00:51:52,766 --> 00:51:55,026
to try to maintain order?

997
00:51:55,496 --> 00:51:58,266
Do you know how many agents are left
injured during the demonstrations?

998
00:51:59,126 --> 00:52:00,356
This is not a reason to cripple

999
00:52:00,457 --> 00:52:01,436
people who did nothing.

1000
00:52:01,706 --> 00:52:02,911
Were you there?

1001
00:52:03,001 --> 00:52:05,976
- They didn't do anything... did you see anything?
- No.

1002
00:52:06,806 --> 00:52:09,356
So if you don't know anything, shut up.

1003
00:52:09,866 --> 00:52:11,196
Then I'm silent.

1004
00:52:12,476 --> 00:52:14,796
But I have the right to feel compassion
for this boy.

1005
00:52:20,306 --> 00:52:22,726
I would like to go to the national directorate.

1006
00:52:20,876 --> 00:52:22,356


1007
00:52:24,056 --> 00:52:25,226
There they deal with serious issues.

1008
00:52:25,436 --> 00:52:26,936
Not a thankless job like ours.

1009
00:52:27,056 --> 00:52:29,166
Under Decroly's orders?

1010
00:52:29,276 --> 00:52:30,826
You couldn't stand it

1011
00:52:29,648 --> 00:52:30,648


1012
00:52:30,850 --> 00:52:32,766
I'm at IGPN to expose the cops
corrupt,

1013
00:52:33,146 --> 00:52:34,636
certainly not colleagues

1014
00:52:34,711 --> 00:52:36,816
At every demonstration there are complaints.

1015
00:52:36,926 --> 00:52:39,126
At this moment we do nothing else

1016
00:52:39,356 --> 00:52:42,106
Initially, I was quite
I agree with the yellow vests.

1017
00:52:42,116 --> 00:52:42,986
I think they are basically right.

1018
00:52:43,766 --> 00:52:45,742
Then they really lost control.

1019
00:52:45,300 --> 00:52:45,836


1020
00:52:46,256 --> 00:52:49,015
Colleagues have balls,
I'm on the front line

1021
00:52:49,016 --> 00:52:50,454
in restoring order

1022
00:52:50,455 --> 00:52:52,376
but at the slightest false step.

1023
00:52:52,706 --> 00:52:53,930
they are being targeted.

1024
00:52:53,936 --> 00:52:57,926
The problem is that we treat them like children and they
we talk to them as if they were children.

1025
00:52:58,106 --> 00:53:01,966
And then, no one talks like that to their children anymore,
how bosses talk to officers.

1026
00:52:58,706 --> 00:53:01,956


1027
00:53:02,336 --> 00:53:05,376
And so, once on a mission,
they let off steam.

1028
00:53:05,546 --> 00:53:07,271
I heard a police commissioner say, laughing, that…

1029
00:53:07,272 --> 00:53:09,206
these guys let themselves go
like in front of a video game.

1030
00:53:09,566 --> 00:53:10,964
You've seen the pictures of the BAC
who shoots

1031
00:53:10,965 --> 00:53:14,000
They shoot with the LBD saying:
"He voted, he voted."

1032
00:53:13,676 --> 00:53:14,156


1033
00:53:14,100 --> 00:53:16,176
With every roll: "He voted."

1034
00:53:27,686 --> 00:53:29,436
Victor, turn it off!

1035
00:53:46,676 --> 00:53:47,676
Victor!

1036
00:53:53,426 --> 00:53:54,576
I'll try.

1037
00:53:58,106 --> 00:53:59,766
Victor, turn it off!

1038
00:54:00,086 --> 00:54:01,656
Yes, I'm finishing the chapter.

1039
00:54:01,976 --> 00:54:03,306
Then turn off.

1040
00:54:03,806 --> 00:54:05,256
All right, goodnight.

1041
00:54:07,316 --> 00:54:08,316
Mom.

1042
00:54:08,546 --> 00:54:09,546
YES.

1043
00:54:11,876 --> 00:54:13,496
Why does everyone hate the police?

1044
00:54:13,976 --> 00:54:14,976
Who?.

1045
00:54:17,246 --> 00:54:18,666
Hand.

1046
00:54:20,126 --> 00:54:20,666


1047
00:54:21,296 --> 00:54:23,316
It's not true that everyone hates her,
but what are you saying?

1048
00:54:23,546 --> 00:54:24,546
Well, yes.

1049
00:54:24,986 --> 00:54:28,206
You and dad don't realize why
you know nothing but policemen.

1050
00:54:28,976 --> 00:54:30,666
But nobody likes the police.

1051
00:54:31,826 --> 00:54:33,886
It's... it's stupid

1052
00:54:32,576 --> 00:54:33,876


1053
00:54:35,756 --> 00:54:39,366
When the attacks occurred in France,
people applauded us in the street.

1054
00:54:39,446 --> 00:54:40,866
It happened a long time ago.

1055
00:54:41,096 --> 00:54:42,096
Not

1056
00:54:42,956 --> 00:54:43,956
Well, yes.

1057
00:54:44,336 --> 00:54:46,686
Your friends tell you that
doesn't like the police?

1058
00:54:46,736 --> 00:54:48,916
Not just my teammates.
There are also TAGS.

1059
00:54:47,966 --> 00:54:48,596


1060
00:54:49,196 --> 00:54:50,816
- What TAG?
- ACAB.

1061
00:54:50,186 --> 00:54:50,726


1062
00:54:50,846 --> 00:54:53,046
All cops are bastards.

1063
00:54:53,576 --> 00:54:55,356
I know what it means.

1064
00:54:56,756 --> 00:54:59,976
Whoever writes these things is an idiot,
what do you want me to say?

1065
00:55:03,176 --> 00:55:04,806
Well… OK…

1066
00:55:03,716 --> 00:55:04,716


1067
00:55:05,816 --> 00:55:06,566
You're right

1068
00:55:06,686 --> 00:55:09,726
There are quite a few people who say
that he doesn't appreciate the police.

1069
00:55:10,256 --> 00:55:12,735
But I can assure you that
it's not the majority.

1070
00:55:12,736 --> 00:55:15,956
and even they are basically
glad it's there.

1071
00:55:16,016 --> 00:55:16,256


1072
00:55:16,376 --> 00:55:17,126
That's not the problem.

1073
00:55:17,576 --> 00:55:18,356
What is it about, then?

1074
00:55:18,956 --> 00:55:19,526
Eh

1075
00:55:19,796 --> 00:55:22,666
I already told you. To no one
I like the police

1076
00:55:21,026 --> 00:55:22,596


1077
00:55:24,746 --> 00:55:27,416
The issue is not whether the police
whether appreciated or not.

1078
00:55:27,547 --> 00:55:29,466
It's not a particularly pleasant job.

1079
00:55:29,554 --> 00:55:31,206
If you enforce the law.

1080
00:55:31,224 --> 00:55:33,008
You don't always make friends

1081
00:55:32,156 --> 00:55:33,156


1082
00:55:33,956 --> 00:55:36,103
The question is whether the
people trust

1083
00:55:36,446 --> 00:55:39,246
of policemen and their work.

1084
00:55:40,976 --> 00:55:41,976
Well.

1085
00:55:42,686 --> 00:55:44,986
Finish that chapter and then turn off.

1086
00:56:03,326 --> 00:56:04,326


1087
00:56:29,036 --> 00:56:30,976
- Is that the one over there?
- Yes

1088
00:57:14,576 --> 00:57:16,356
- Good morning.
- Good morning.

1089
00:57:15,746 --> 00:57:16,350


1090
00:57:16,376 --> 00:57:19,166
Police inspectors, we would like to speak with
someone from the management.

1091
00:57:19,556 --> 00:57:21,916
Sure ma'am, wait a moment please

1092
00:57:20,317 --> 00:57:21,636


1093
00:57:22,196 --> 00:57:24,976
Two of your colleagues have already come to
meet us some time ago.

1094
00:57:25,016 --> 00:57:26,865
They had the recordings
of our cameras

1095
00:57:26,866 --> 00:57:28,526
and spoke to several customers.

1096
00:57:29,066 --> 00:57:30,786
Yes, we have the minutes.

1097
00:57:30,886 --> 00:57:31,726
Mr. Santoni?

1098
00:57:31,736 --> 00:57:32,736
YES.

1099
00:57:32,906 --> 00:57:34,166
The gentlemen are police officers.

1100
00:57:34,736 --> 00:57:37,796
They are interested in events
of December 8th

1101
00:57:38,336 --> 00:57:40,086
He is our security manager.

1102
00:57:40,466 --> 00:57:43,926
We have a question regarding a window
which overlooks Quentin Bauchart.

1103
00:57:44,096 --> 00:57:45,096
That one right there.

1104
00:57:46,646 --> 00:57:47,846
It's on the 3rd floor.

1105
00:57:48,111 --> 00:57:49,656
Must be 316.

1106
00:57:48,956 --> 00:57:49,556


1107
00:57:50,276 --> 00:57:52,042
- Yes it's 316
- A junior suite

1108
00:57:51,296 --> 00:57:52,016


1109
00:57:52,076 --> 00:57:54,071
We believe there was a witness
at that window.

1110
00:57:54,072 --> 00:57:57,496
Can you tell us who was occupying the suite that day?

1111
00:57:57,536 --> 00:57:58,936
I can check.

1112
00:57:59,936 --> 00:58:01,456
- Mrs. Gaziorek?
- Yes

1113
00:58:00,836 --> 00:58:01,076


1114
00:58:01,556 --> 00:58:03,101
We can check if the 316 was

1115
00:58:03,102 --> 00:58:04,526
occupied on the evening of December 8th.

1116
00:58:05,246 --> 00:58:06,366
Certain.

1117
00:58:10,576 --> 00:58:11,316
YES.

1118
00:58:11,336 --> 00:58:13,316
It was occupied by a couple
coming from Munich.

1119
00:58:13,676 --> 00:58:15,426
left the next day.

1120
00:58:15,536 --> 00:58:18,236
- Were they in the room around 6.30pm?
- Yes.

1121
00:58:18,596 --> 00:58:19,835
When a customer

1122
00:58:19,836 --> 00:58:21,666
swipe your card to enter.

1123
00:58:21,716 --> 00:58:22,346
is recorded.

1124
00:58:22,556 --> 00:58:24,656
So yes, we have several entrances.

1125
00:58:24,776 --> 00:58:28,736
Some customers arrive in the early part of the
morning, the last ones at 10.30am.

1126
00:58:29,036 --> 00:58:30,594
They went away

1127
00:58:30,595 --> 00:58:32,156
They returned at 9.32pm during the day.

1128
00:58:32,576 --> 00:58:35,526
For staff there is an entrance at 1.44pm.

1129
00:58:35,636 --> 00:58:39,056
She must be the floor maid for
the reorganization… so at 3.07pm.

1130
00:58:39,266 --> 00:58:39,446


1131
00:58:39,776 --> 00:58:41,156
one last entry at 6.19pm.

1132
00:58:41,276 --> 00:58:42,756
Blanket service.

1133
00:58:42,896 --> 00:58:43,346
Would be?.

1134
00:58:43,946 --> 00:58:47,676
The second shift waitresses who
they prepare the room for the night.

1135
00:58:47,966 --> 00:58:49,546
They fold up the blankets…

1136
00:58:49,556 --> 00:58:52,906
they put their slippers on the carpet next to them
to the bed, the chocolate on the pillow.

1137
00:58:49,586 --> 00:58:52,476


1138
00:58:53,156 --> 00:58:55,316
Do you know who the waitress was?

1139
00:58:55,556 --> 00:58:56,425
YES.

1140
00:58:56,426 --> 00:58:58,536
Each badge has its own personal code.

1141
00:58:59,216 --> 00:59:01,366
- Madame Gaziorek?
- Sure

1142
00:59:01,496 --> 00:59:02,706
Alicia Mady

1143
00:59:02,186 --> 00:59:02,606


1144
00:59:02,936 --> 00:59:04,536
Is it on duty today?

1145
00:59:05,216 --> 00:59:05,986
YES. YES.

1146
00:59:05,752 --> 00:59:05,946


1147
00:59:06,206 --> 00:59:09,026
- Yes, second shift from 12pm to 7pm
- We'd like to talk to you

1148
00:59:09,566 --> 00:59:11,556
and see the 316, is it possible?

1149
00:59:11,906 --> 00:59:13,716
Yes, the suite is free..

1150
00:59:31,556 --> 00:59:32,556
Service?

1151
00:59:34,406 --> 00:59:36,436
- Please.
- Thank you.

1152
01:00:14,336 --> 01:00:16,176
Madame Mady will be here soon.

1153
01:00:38,628 --> 01:00:39,798
Without being indiscreet

1154
01:00:39,828 --> 01:00:41,358
How much does a suite like this cost?

1155
01:00:42,198 --> 01:00:46,298
Prices vary depending on the period, but
a junior suite costs around 2000 euros.

1156
01:00:46,428 --> 01:00:47,428
2000 euros?

1157
01:00:48,008 --> 01:00:48,887
Service.

1158
01:00:48,888 --> 01:00:49,888
Excuse me.

1159
01:00:50,328 --> 01:00:52,358
2000 pippoli… fuck…

1160
01:00:50,898 --> 01:00:51,898


1161
01:00:52,488 --> 01:00:55,918
Good morning. I'm Mr. Santoni, the
safety manager.

1162
01:00:53,508 --> 01:00:55,908


1163
01:00:56,328 --> 01:00:58,138
I don't know if we've met before.

1164
01:00:58,308 --> 01:01:01,948
- They are police officers, they are conducting an investigation.
- Good morning, ma'am.

1165
01:01:02,418 --> 01:01:03,648
Do I leave it up to you to ask the questions?

1166
01:01:03,768 --> 01:01:06,928
Yes, please, if it doesn't bother you, it would
even better if he left us alone.

1167
01:01:07,068 --> 01:01:08,398
OK, very good.

1168
01:01:08,418 --> 01:01:11,518
- If you need something, don't hesitate to ask.
- Thank you.

1169
01:01:11,628 --> 01:01:12,628
Go ahead.

1170
01:01:19,728 --> 01:01:22,098
We are IGPN investigators,
the police police.

1171
01:01:22,398 --> 01:01:23,118
Do you know what it is?

1172
01:01:23,748 --> 01:01:24,438
Not exactly.

1173
01:01:24,738 --> 01:01:27,598
We are investigating possible wrongdoing
committed by police officers.

1174
01:01:27,608 --> 01:01:29,138
To be clearer, not
we are investigating you.

1175
01:01:29,178 --> 01:01:30,658
you have nothing to fear.

1176
01:01:30,828 --> 01:01:34,037
We are investigating an incident that occurred
in this street on December 8th

1177
01:01:34,038 --> 01:01:35,998
during the event.

1178
01:01:36,378 --> 01:01:37,788
Around 6.30pm.

1179
01:01:38,328 --> 01:01:39,914
Management told us that

1180
01:01:39,915 --> 01:01:42,658
she was in this suite
for the blanket service.

1181
01:01:42,948 --> 01:01:44,068
He confirms?

1182
01:01:45,978 --> 01:01:48,628
I don't remember, but they say it
them, it must be true.

1183
01:01:48,678 --> 01:01:50,278
Following this accident there was a

1184
01:01:50,358 --> 01:01:51,508
boy seriously injured

1185
01:01:51,558 --> 01:01:53,638
a complaint was filed

1186
01:01:54,078 --> 01:01:57,238
We're trying to figure out exactly
what happened, do you understand?

1187
01:01:58,158 --> 01:01:59,668
I understand perfectly.

1188
01:02:00,798 --> 01:02:04,238
- You saw something, right?
- No.

1189
01:02:03,708 --> 01:02:04,808
No?

1190
01:02:04,838 --> 01:02:08,368
When she was looking out the window,
what did you see on the street?

1191
01:02:08,658 --> 01:02:10,258
Who said I was at the window?

1192
01:02:10,578 --> 01:02:13,648
We have a video; where the
let's see at that window.

1193
01:02:15,048 --> 01:02:17,369
Just tell us what you saw.

1194
01:02:21,108 --> 01:02:22,468
I saw the firefighters.

1195
01:02:23,178 --> 01:02:24,358
But first?

1196
01:02:25,548 --> 01:02:28,258
- You were watching before the firefighters arrived, right?
- No

1197
01:02:30,516 --> 01:02:32,458
It's very important that you tell us.

1198
01:02:32,508 --> 01:02:34,377
We must rebuild
the truth of the facts.

1199
01:02:34,378 --> 01:02:37,228
His testimony can help us do this.

1200
01:02:39,438 --> 01:02:43,678
I saw the firefighters standing by
taking care of an injured person.

1201
01:02:45,378 --> 01:02:47,948
Did you see how she was hurt?

1202
01:02:46,398 --> 01:02:47,758


1203
01:02:50,178 --> 01:02:53,248
I looked out the window when
I heard the fire siren.

1204
01:02:53,598 --> 01:02:55,958
I understand that you are wary.

1205
01:02:56,118 --> 01:02:57,718
But we're not trying to screw her.

1206
01:03:02,268 --> 01:03:03,778
I don't know what to say.

1207
01:03:04,308 --> 01:03:06,908
I can't make something up
which I haven't seen.

1208
01:03:07,728 --> 01:03:08,728
All right.

1209
01:03:11,418 --> 01:03:15,538
I'll give you my business card
in case you remember anything.

1210
01:03:17,118 --> 01:03:18,868
There is also my personal number.

1211
01:03:19,668 --> 01:03:21,808
You can contact me at any time

1212
01:03:31,248 --> 01:03:32,848
He can go back to work.

1213
01:03:41,778 --> 01:03:43,228
We took the wrong approach.

1214
01:03:43,608 --> 01:03:44,878
I do not believe.

1215
01:03:45,258 --> 01:03:47,008
- And there's something you don't say.
- Oh yes?

1216
01:03:49,458 --> 01:03:51,198
Let's summon her, she always has a certain effect.

1217
01:03:51,948 --> 01:03:53,189
I do not know.

1218
01:03:53,238 --> 01:03:55,198
We risk it closing even more.

1219
01:04:01,578 --> 01:04:03,278
Here, look.

1220
01:04:03,498 --> 01:04:04,098
What is this?

1221
01:04:04,818 --> 01:04:05,908
Soap.

1222
01:04:05,988 --> 01:04:06,708
Did you steal it?

1223
01:04:07,278 --> 01:04:09,358
It's a bar of soap, I don't consider it stealing.

1224
01:04:10,318 --> 01:04:11,918
Feel how good it is, do you want it?

1225
01:04:11,598 --> 01:04:11,838


1226
01:04:11,988 --> 01:04:12,738
Oh no, thanks.

1227
01:04:12,918 --> 01:04:13,958
- Safe? I have two
- No.

1228
01:04:13,638 --> 01:04:13,878


1229
01:04:14,208 --> 01:04:14,298


1230
01:04:14,718 --> 01:04:15,718


1231
01:04:45,678 --> 01:04:46,678


1232
01:04:54,828 --> 01:04:55,828
It was.

1233
01:04:55,878 --> 01:04:56,878
Already.

1234
01:04:58,698 --> 01:04:59,878
That's right.

1235
01:06:02,028 --> 01:06:03,028
Yes Victor.

1236
01:06:03,168 --> 01:06:05,067
I'm home, where are you?

1237
01:06:05,068 --> 01:06:06,208
Are you coming?

1238
01:06:07,878 --> 01:06:10,918
I'm still at work, I'll be back
home a little later.

1239
01:06:11,018 --> 01:06:12,358
What? I don't hear.

1240
01:06:13,218 --> 01:06:14,998
I'll come back later.

1241
01:06:15,168 --> 01:06:16,768
Wait.

1242
01:06:24,288 --> 01:06:25,338
Victor are you still there?

1243
01:06:26,178 --> 01:06:26,808
Yes. What's happening?

1244
01:06:27,408 --> 01:06:29,368
Nothing, I'll come back later.

1245
01:06:29,778 --> 01:06:32,368
I cooked as you told me,
but it's getting cold.

1246
01:06:32,461 --> 01:06:33,228
Um, what did you do?

1247
01:06:33,498 --> 01:06:35,638
The quiche and nuggets.

1248
01:06:35,902 --> 01:06:37,558
You shouldn't have done both.

1249
01:06:38,328 --> 01:06:39,408
It's not a problem, they are excellent.

1250
01:06:40,128 --> 01:06:41,218
I am waiting for you.

1251
01:06:41,594 --> 01:06:43,398
I'll stay here a little longer,
start without me.

1252
01:06:43,668 --> 01:06:43,998
All right.

1253
01:06:44,000 --> 01:06:46,100
So, shall I eat the quiche or the nuggets?

1254
01:06:46,158 --> 01:06:48,598
You decide, what you want
like it more.

1255
01:06:49,968 --> 01:06:51,968
I'm leaving you, kisses. See you soon.

1256
01:07:25,938 --> 01:07:27,208
Mrs Mady?

1257
01:07:28,338 --> 01:07:29,743
Mrs Mady…

1258
01:07:30,258 --> 01:07:31,968
Can we talk?

1259
01:07:37,188 --> 01:07:38,508
We could go to a bar, maybe.

1260
01:07:39,108 --> 01:07:40,468
I don't have time.

1261
01:07:40,578 --> 01:07:42,240
I need your help.

1262
01:07:43,068 --> 01:07:44,670
I told you I didn't see anything.

1263
01:07:45,948 --> 01:07:47,758
I know, but I don't believe her.

1264
01:07:48,618 --> 01:07:49,948
I'm not a liar.

1265
01:07:50,538 --> 01:07:53,808
I don't think you're a liar,
but he didn't tell me everything.

1266
01:07:52,368 --> 01:07:53,668


1267
01:07:53,808 --> 01:07:55,678
Please, I would like to go home.

1268
01:09:17,958 --> 01:09:18,948
He will come to my house.

1269
01:09:19,068 --> 01:09:20,938
If necessary, why not?

1270
01:09:20,988 --> 01:09:21,998
Can you do it?.

1271
01:09:22,008 --> 01:09:22,438
No.

1272
01:09:22,488 --> 01:09:24,448
Not really, but it's important.

1273
01:09:25,878 --> 01:09:28,198
Tell me what you saw.

1274
01:09:30,048 --> 01:09:31,888
I understand that you are afraid.

1275
01:09:32,298 --> 01:09:34,282
May your word not count against it
that of a policeman.

1276
01:09:34,283 --> 01:09:35,898
Don't let the police believe you.

1277
01:09:36,078 --> 01:09:37,488
No, I don't want to have problems with the police.

1278
01:09:37,968 --> 01:09:39,898
So did you see anything?

1279
01:09:41,718 --> 01:09:42,588
You won't have any problems.

1280
01:09:42,708 --> 01:09:44,158
What do you know?

1281
01:09:44,778 --> 01:09:46,648
There will never be retaliation against him.

1282
01:09:47,418 --> 01:09:49,938
You managed to find me, right?
They will do the same.

1283
01:09:50,178 --> 01:09:51,303
My job is to ensure that...

1284
01:09:51,304 --> 01:09:54,268
the cops who crossed the line
don't do it again.

1285
01:09:54,348 --> 01:09:57,058
Do you agree that these
policemen should be punished?

1286
01:09:57,858 --> 01:09:58,548
This never happens.

1287
01:09:58,908 --> 01:10:01,258
- Why do you say this?
- Because it's the truth.

1288
01:10:01,498 --> 01:10:03,048
I see it every day

1289
01:10:03,648 --> 01:10:05,328
The BAC monitors the kids

1290
01:10:05,778 --> 01:10:07,068
they provoke them until they get angry.

1291
01:10:07,338 --> 01:10:10,008
and then they make them get on the vehicle,
they offend them and beat them.

1292
01:10:08,448 --> 01:10:10,078


1293
01:10:10,048 --> 01:10:12,208
They always write false reports

1294
01:10:11,418 --> 01:10:11,838


1295
01:10:12,618 --> 01:10:14,068
They are never punished.

1296
01:10:20,568 --> 01:10:22,198
I filmed everything.

1297
01:10:25,586 --> 01:10:26,886
Did you film it?

1298
01:10:27,056 --> 01:10:28,056
Yes.

1299
01:10:29,366 --> 01:10:30,966
There was noise on the street.

1300
01:10:32,486 --> 01:10:35,286
I saw some guys around
to a burning scooter.

1301
01:10:35,966 --> 01:10:37,536
I filmed it with my phone.

1302
01:10:37,916 --> 01:10:39,306
Just out of curiosity.

1303
01:10:40,736 --> 01:10:42,456
and the police arrived.

1304
01:10:42,656 --> 01:10:44,906
- Do you still have that video?
- Yes

1305
01:10:45,326 --> 01:10:48,396
I wanted to publish it online,
but then I changed my mind.

1306
01:10:49,426 --> 01:10:51,426
Of people of color and of
Arabs being beaten.

1307
01:10:51,446 --> 01:10:53,066
Nobody cares.

1308
01:10:53,156 --> 01:10:54,326
And now that's happening to white people.

1309
01:10:54,716 --> 01:10:57,546
Suddenly it's interesting and
so why should I do anything?

1310
01:10:59,966 --> 01:11:00,791
She would have come, if it had happened to a
white in my neighborhood?

1311
01:11:00,792 --> 01:11:02,976
Certain.

1312
01:11:03,446 --> 01:11:04,446
YES?!?

1313
01:11:04,796 --> 01:11:04,916


1314
01:11:05,096 --> 01:11:07,596
The IGPN is also investigating the officers
of police in the suburbs.

1315
01:11:07,641 --> 01:11:08,641
YES.

1316
01:11:09,116 --> 01:11:10,596
But how many were convicted?

1317
01:11:11,126 --> 01:11:11,306


1318
01:11:11,696 --> 01:11:14,503
The IGPN doesn't decide, but they are there
states of the convicted policemen

1319
01:11:14,576 --> 01:11:15,346
Condemned?

1320
01:11:15,406 --> 01:11:17,306
At worst they got it
a suspension of sentence.

1321
01:11:17,366 --> 01:11:19,356
Nobody wants to go against the police.

1322
01:11:20,036 --> 01:11:21,946
How many were fired?

1323
01:11:23,066 --> 01:11:24,066
How many?

1324
01:11:30,296 --> 01:11:33,477
Fired…no one.

1325
01:11:33,506 --> 01:11:34,906
Nobody

1326
01:11:37,886 --> 01:11:39,886
See? Nobody.

1327
01:11:45,266 --> 01:11:47,946
Trust me and give me that video.

1328
01:11:48,956 --> 01:11:50,856
I don't have it with me. It's at my house.

1329
01:11:51,146 --> 01:11:52,596
I can accompany you.

1330
01:11:52,766 --> 01:11:55,176
He asks me for trust, but doesn't he trust?

1331
01:11:56,996 --> 01:11:57,996
All right.

1332
01:11:59,936 --> 01:12:01,416
Do you still have my ticket?

1333
01:12:01,586 --> 01:12:02,586
YES.

1334
01:12:08,186 --> 01:12:10,536
And this won't change anything anyway

1335
01:12:37,616 --> 01:12:39,776
Hey you… no no no

1336
01:12:40,556 --> 01:12:42,186
this is not for you.

1337
01:13:40,826 --> 01:13:41,826
HI.

1338
01:13:49,316 --> 01:13:50,646
Bye bye.

1339
01:13:55,226 --> 01:13:56,226
Benoît.

1340
01:13:56,426 --> 01:13:58,386
Come here, I have something to show you.

1341
01:14:27,266 --> 01:14:28,266


1342
01:15:20,186 --> 01:15:21,906
Can you go back to the beginning?

1343
01:15:26,246 --> 01:15:28,206
Where are Girard and Cordier?

1344
01:15:28,256 --> 01:15:30,916
They're coming, look.

1345
01:15:29,366 --> 01:15:30,366


1346
01:15:31,946 --> 01:15:32,906
So I'm not with the others.

1347
01:15:33,476 --> 01:15:35,706
They are walking calmly
along the way, see?

1348
01:15:46,286 --> 01:15:48,306
There, they find themselves in front of the BIS.

1349
01:15:49,586 --> 01:15:51,786
Rémi is on the left, Guillaume on the right.

1350
01:15:52,916 --> 01:15:55,086
He has the phone in his hand.

1351
01:15:58,366 --> 01:16:01,056
There are two of them shooting

1352
01:15:58,796 --> 01:15:59,216


1353
01:16:01,466 --> 01:16:03,456
Look at the LDB 40

1354
01:16:01,976 --> 01:16:02,976


1355
01:16:04,016 --> 01:16:05,556
They fire at the same time.

1356
01:16:07,826 --> 01:16:09,236
Two shots, but only one impact.

1357
01:16:09,386 --> 01:16:10,345
Exact.

1358
01:16:10,346 --> 01:16:12,356
So they shoot a guy who's standing
running away and doing nothing.

1359
01:16:10,706 --> 01:16:12,026


1360
01:16:12,386 --> 01:16:14,276
It will be difficult for them to invoke self-defense.

1361
01:16:14,486 --> 01:16:16,676
They threw a can of beer at him,
but that was before.

1362
01:16:17,276 --> 01:16:18,026
Nobody threatens them.

1363
01:16:18,566 --> 01:16:20,826
Guillaume turns around as he runs.

1364
01:16:21,956 --> 01:16:23,106
Yes? Are you sure?

1365
01:16:25,256 --> 01:16:26,256
Let me see

1366
01:16:28,286 --> 01:16:29,793
Okay, it goes round and round for
see what they are doing

1367
01:16:29,794 --> 01:16:32,196
Does this justify them shooting?
He's running, he's not a threat.

1368
01:16:31,376 --> 01:16:31,496


1369
01:16:31,736 --> 01:16:32,336


1370
01:16:32,636 --> 01:16:35,826
- He's running away, he's not threatening
- I didn't say that.

1371
01:16:36,176 --> 01:16:37,476
They will be able to use it.

1372
01:16:37,706 --> 01:16:38,726
For me, it's a retaliatory strike.

1373
01:16:38,906 --> 01:16:40,856
an idiot provokes them, throws them
a can and...

1374
01:16:40,976 --> 01:16:43,556
they shoot the first one who comes along.

1375
01:16:43,616 --> 01:16:45,566
There is also football.

1376
01:16:49,496 --> 01:16:51,486
Honestly, what the hell is that guy doing?

1377
01:16:52,136 --> 01:16:53,736
I agree, it's a rant.

1378
01:16:57,506 --> 01:16:58,686
And they leave.

1379
01:16:59,396 --> 01:17:00,396
Calmly.

1380
01:17:01,286 --> 01:17:02,496
How disgusting.

1381
01:17:03,716 --> 01:17:05,646
Can you figure out who does what?

1382
01:17:06,116 --> 01:17:07,116
YES.

1383
01:17:08,606 --> 01:17:09,626
Football is Fage's.

1384
01:17:10,046 --> 01:17:12,696
Lavallé is nearby, downstairs
there are Jacquet and Garcia.

1385
01:17:11,846 --> 01:17:12,846


1386
01:17:13,106 --> 01:17:15,096
Brzezenski is further down the road.

1387
01:17:16,946 --> 01:17:19,836
So who shot
they are Fage and Lavallée.

1388
01:17:27,956 --> 01:17:29,186
Is the video on social media?

1389
01:17:29,516 --> 01:17:31,596
No, the witness didn't post it online.

1390
01:17:32,216 --> 01:17:34,326
We will be able to work more calmly.

1391
01:17:32,287 --> 01:17:32,363


1392
01:17:34,796 --> 01:17:37,186
Did you summon them again?

1393
01:17:35,366 --> 01:17:37,026


1394
01:17:37,496 --> 01:17:38,756
I wanted to talk to her about it first.

1395
01:17:38,866 --> 01:17:41,666
Three of the five are currently missing
in mainland France.

1396
01:17:41,707 --> 01:17:44,476
- Where are they?
- They were sent to Mayotte.

1397
01:17:42,956 --> 01:17:44,096


1398
01:17:44,516 --> 01:17:46,566
Brzezinski, Jacquet and Garcia.

1399
01:17:47,606 --> 01:17:48,776
We will not wait for their return.

1400
01:17:49,286 --> 01:17:52,376
Listen to Lavallée and Fages,
the main defendants.

1401
01:17:52,676 --> 01:17:54,366
Do I put them in protective custody?

1402
01:17:54,956 --> 01:17:56,826
This wasn't what I had in mind.

1403
01:17:57,048 --> 01:17:58,986
They blatantly lied.

1404
01:17:59,026 --> 01:18:01,696
If we lose the element of surprise,
they will come to an agreement.

1405
01:18:01,766 --> 01:18:04,486
What's wrong? Mrs Bertrand,
why is he reversing roles?

1406
01:18:04,526 --> 01:18:07,526
Usually, the prosecutor's office requests precautionary custody,
while the investigators oppose it.

1407
01:18:08,126 --> 01:18:09,694
For now, they don't know the video exists.

1408
01:18:09,695 --> 01:18:11,886
I can confront them with their contradictions.

1409
01:18:13,016 --> 01:18:17,783
If you hear them at the same time, not
they will be able to come to an agreement

1410
01:18:14,783 --> 01:18:17,166


1411
01:18:17,786 --> 01:18:19,686
Please coordinate with your investigators.

1412
01:18:21,356 --> 01:18:22,356
Understood.

1413
01:18:23,171 --> 01:18:24,026
- Goodbye, Mrs. Bertrand.
- Until we meet again.

1414
01:18:24,296 --> 01:18:29,796
Lavallée is located at the reception
on the ground floor.

1415
01:18:28,016 --> 01:18:28,556


1416
01:18:28,676 --> 01:18:29,306


1417
01:18:29,936 --> 01:18:30,936
And Fage?

1418
01:18:31,616 --> 01:18:32,893
He won't come.

1419
01:18:33,806 --> 01:18:34,136
What?

1420
01:18:34,736 --> 01:18:37,936
Medical certificate. He is on sick leave.

1421
01:18:36,176 --> 01:18:37,596


1422
01:18:38,996 --> 01:18:41,546
- Are you kidding us?
- What should we do?

1423
01:18:40,346 --> 01:18:40,886


1424
01:18:41,666 --> 01:18:42,951
You want me to summon them again
both?

1425
01:18:42,952 --> 01:18:45,456
- When will Fage be there?
- Shit.

1426
01:18:48,566 --> 01:18:49,716
Go get it.

1427
01:18:53,576 --> 01:18:56,785
Mr. Lavallée, during your premiere
hearing she stated

1428
01:18:56,786 --> 01:19:00,036
not to remember a protester
wounded by a blow from LBD.

1429
01:19:00,176 --> 01:19:01,806
Do you confirm this statement?

1430
01:19:02,096 --> 01:19:03,096
YES.

1431
01:19:03,746 --> 01:19:05,569
You didn't fire any shots that
it could have hurt

1432
01:19:05,570 --> 01:19:08,196
a protester around 6.30pm?

1433
01:19:08,636 --> 01:19:08,906
No.

1434
01:19:09,596 --> 01:19:10,526
Not even another of his colleagues.

1435
01:19:11,006 --> 01:19:12,276
As far as I know, no.

1436
01:19:14,696 --> 01:19:16,206
I'll show you a video.

1437
01:19:37,166 --> 01:19:38,166


1438
01:19:43,016 --> 01:19:45,756
These images help you
remember this episode?

1439
01:19:46,556 --> 01:19:48,036
Not in every detail.

1440
01:19:48,476 --> 01:19:50,826
Can you describe what we see in the video?

1441
01:19:52,226 --> 01:19:53,966
We see rioters hurling insults

1442
01:19:54,146 --> 01:19:55,136
and throw objects.

1443
01:19:55,526 --> 01:19:57,996
They run away when they see us.

1444
01:19:56,839 --> 01:19:57,966


1445
01:19:59,576 --> 01:20:01,926
Our group arrives at the corner
of the road and we find ourselves

1446
01:20:02,096 --> 01:20:04,266
faced with two hostile individuals.

1447
01:20:05,786 --> 01:20:07,206
Fages and I fire a shot

1448
01:20:07,266 --> 01:20:09,036
to protect our colleagues.

1449
01:20:09,326 --> 01:20:12,756
What makes you think that the two do
are they behaving in a hostile manner?

1450
01:20:12,926 --> 01:20:15,336
All the protesters we have
encountered were hostile.

1451
01:20:15,806 --> 01:20:18,696
Obviously if you question them,
they will say the opposite.

1452
01:20:16,407 --> 01:20:18,666


1453
01:20:18,986 --> 01:20:21,416
The question is who committed acts of
violence against the police?

1454
01:20:21,596 --> 01:20:22,856
Who looted the shops?

1455
01:20:23,156 --> 01:20:24,844
Who vandalized the streets?

1456
01:20:25,072 --> 01:20:28,962
I am only telling you about these two individuals.

1457
01:20:29,042 --> 01:20:33,132
How their behavior represents a
threat enough to justify a shot?

1458
01:20:34,232 --> 01:20:36,942
I remind you that your intervention must
be necessary and proportionate.

1459
01:20:38,132 --> 01:20:39,582
They run away.

1460
01:20:39,632 --> 01:20:41,922
This clearly indicates that they have
things to answer for.

1461
01:20:43,142 --> 01:20:45,612
One of them turns to throw an object at us.

1462
01:20:46,232 --> 01:20:47,522
Where can we see what weapon his hand is holding?

1463
01:20:47,672 --> 01:20:48,972
In his turning.

1464
01:20:49,292 --> 01:20:52,982
You don't notice it in the video, but I don't
I had the same perspective.

1465
01:20:53,102 --> 01:20:55,572
From my point of view, his
gesture was unmistakable.

1466
01:20:55,622 --> 01:20:56,892
He was behaving in a threatening manner.

1467
01:20:57,152 --> 01:20:58,106
I didn't want to take any chances

1468
01:20:58,107 --> 01:21:01,372
to take a bolt in the face,
me or my colleagues.

1469
01:21:01,382 --> 01:21:03,552
When you find yourself in a situation
of self-defense.

1470
01:21:03,820 --> 01:21:05,132
We have to react in a fraction of a second.

1471
01:21:05,642 --> 01:21:06,642
Certainly.

1472
01:21:07,682 --> 01:21:09,783
You are not here to stop terrorists.

1473
01:21:09,784 --> 01:21:12,392
armed to the teeth, but from the front
to unarmed demonstrators.

1474
01:21:12,812 --> 01:21:13,502
This is what she says.

1475
01:21:13,652 --> 01:21:15,432
No, that's what the pictures show.

1476
01:21:16,142 --> 01:21:18,792
Many protesters transformed
into wild beasts.

1477
01:21:19,232 --> 01:21:21,142
One bolt can kill.

1478
01:21:21,212 --> 01:21:23,481
It seems like an exaggeration to describe
Mr. Girard's attitude

1479
01:21:23,482 --> 01:21:26,161
in this way, he describes it as
that of a wild beast.

1480
01:21:26,162 --> 01:21:28,422
He runs away with his back to her.

1481
01:21:31,622 --> 01:21:32,942
What did you do after the shooting?

1482
01:21:33,182 --> 01:21:35,172
once Mr
Gérard was on the ground.

1483
01:21:38,252 --> 01:21:40,242
I don't remember, we have...

1484
01:21:40,382 --> 01:21:43,402
We probably continued
our patrol.

1485
01:21:43,772 --> 01:21:46,362
He knows that Mr. Gérard has
suffered a head injury?

1486
01:21:46,532 --> 01:21:48,252
And he was seriously injured.

1487
01:21:48,512 --> 01:21:50,232
That's not the impression I got.

1488
01:21:50,372 --> 01:21:51,691
Especially why not
I aimed for the head.

1489
01:21:52,232 --> 01:21:54,982
Then it was Mr. Fages' shot
to hit Mr. Girard?

1490
01:21:55,082 --> 01:21:57,909
I didn't say that. I just know
that I didn't aim for the head.

1491
01:21:56,209 --> 01:21:57,572


1492
01:21:58,022 --> 01:22:00,222
And as far as I know, neither does my colleague.

1493
01:22:00,662 --> 01:22:00,962
OK.

1494
01:22:01,352 --> 01:22:04,662
So you're stating that after
the shot went away.

1495
01:22:05,192 --> 01:22:06,192
YES.

1496
01:22:06,932 --> 01:22:09,192
Mr. Lavallée, I will show you
the rest of the video.

1497
01:22:22,982 --> 01:22:24,162
What does he see?

1498
01:22:26,252 --> 01:22:27,672
It's not very clear.

1499
01:22:29,222 --> 01:22:30,999
Pictures can give
the impression that

1500
01:22:31,052 --> 01:22:32,772
my colleague remove him
with the foot.

1501
01:22:36,212 --> 01:22:36,962
It's good football.

1502
01:22:37,472 --> 01:22:37,892
I do not know.

1503
01:22:38,312 --> 01:22:41,812
Perhaps. I don't remember that gesture.

1504
01:22:40,172 --> 01:22:41,832


1505
01:22:42,932 --> 01:22:45,552
Looking at Mr. Fage's gesture in the video.

1506
01:22:46,412 --> 01:22:47,922
Does this seem justified to you?

1507
01:22:49,412 --> 01:22:51,942
At that moment, Mr. Gérard
Does it pose a threat?

1508
01:22:52,202 --> 01:22:53,202
I don't know.

1509
01:22:53,282 --> 01:22:55,620
Maybe my colleague believed that

1510
01:22:55,622 --> 01:22:59,682
the individual was about to pick up an object
off the ground and didn't want to take any risks.

1511
01:23:00,645 --> 01:23:02,292
We should ask him.

1512
01:23:02,402 --> 01:23:04,122
I can't answer for him.

1513
01:23:11,852 --> 01:23:12,852
At that time?

1514
01:23:13,532 --> 01:23:15,282
He is rereading the minutes.

1515
01:23:15,332 --> 01:23:17,715
He says he acted in self-defense,
that he didn't aim for the head

1516
01:23:17,716 --> 01:23:19,922
and that he saw nothing but Guillaume
Girard was injured.

1517
01:23:20,492 --> 01:23:23,312
- And football?
- He said he didn't see anything.

1518
01:23:21,512 --> 01:23:23,052


1519
01:23:23,672 --> 01:23:24,956
But as soon as he leaves here,
he will call Fage to let him know

1520
01:23:25,046 --> 01:23:27,982
- about what's in the video.
- Certain.

1521
01:23:28,246 --> 01:23:31,032
He must be taken into custody and
Fages must be questioned immediately

1522
01:23:31,232 --> 01:23:32,622
I'll call the prosecutor's office.

1523
01:23:42,752 --> 01:23:45,222
Commander Bertrand, IGPN,
for Mr. Langlois.

1524
01:23:47,042 --> 01:23:48,042
Oh.

1525
01:23:48,842 --> 01:23:50,592
You need to call me back urgently.

1526
01:23:50,732 --> 01:23:52,248
I have a police officer I would like
place in preventive custody.

1527
01:23:52,249 --> 01:23:55,002
I need your permission.

1528
01:23:56,582 --> 01:23:59,072
Okay, I'll try on his cell phone.
Thank you.

1529
01:23:57,212 --> 01:23:57,932


1530
01:23:58,172 --> 01:23:59,172


1531
01:23:59,822 --> 01:24:01,202
He's not in the office.

1532
01:24:01,712 --> 01:24:03,072
He has a family emergency.

1533
01:24:06,212 --> 01:24:08,502
Shit, the answering machine.

1534
01:24:10,322 --> 01:24:13,901
Mr Deputy Prosecutor, I am the commander
Bertrand, IGPN, I ask you to call me back

1535
01:24:13,902 --> 01:24:16,332
Regarding Lavallée and Fages
of dossier 137.

1536
01:24:16,569 --> 01:24:17,252
Call the prosecutor's office.

1537
01:24:17,582 --> 01:24:18,782
let the magistrate on duty pass by.

1538
01:24:19,172 --> 01:24:20,862
And explain everything to him again?

1539
01:24:33,572 --> 01:24:34,532
- Can I go?
- No.

1540
01:24:34,292 --> 01:24:34,532


1541
01:24:35,072 --> 01:24:37,962
- Why?
- Because you're in custody.

1542
01:24:35,612 --> 01:24:37,572


1543
01:24:38,132 --> 01:24:38,432
What?

1544
01:24:38,882 --> 01:24:40,998
I order precautionary custody
for voluntary violence

1545
01:24:40,999 --> 01:24:43,182
committed by an authorized person
of public authority.

1546
01:24:43,442 --> 01:24:44,589
You have the right to be
assisted by a lawyer.

1547
01:24:44,590 --> 01:24:46,932
a lawyer of your choice
or one appointed by the court.

1548
01:24:47,192 --> 01:24:50,322
- He also has the right to submit
to a medical examination.
- Are you joking?

1549
01:24:52,322 --> 01:24:53,999
Do I look like I'm joking?

1550
01:24:54,512 --> 01:24:56,752
I, Stéphanie Bertrand, police commander.

1551
01:24:56,842 --> 01:24:58,952
to the department conducting the preliminary investigation.

1552
01:24:59,312 --> 01:25:02,462
Having seen the provisions of articles 75 et seq
of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

1553
01:25:02,822 --> 01:25:06,362
assisted by Major Benoît Guérini e
by Brigade Chief Carole de la Rue.

1554
01:25:06,782 --> 01:25:10,411
based on the mandatory request
to appear pursuant to art. 78.

1555
01:25:10,412 --> 01:25:12,720
2nd paragraph of the code
of criminal procedure.

1556
01:25:12,721 --> 01:25:15,422
We go to number 5 rue Pasteur.

1557
01:25:15,782 --> 01:25:18,312
94450 Limeil-Brévannes.

1558
01:25:18,632 --> 01:25:21,992
where at 1.15pm, we note that yes
it is a terraced house.

1559
01:25:22,352 --> 01:25:24,358
We ring the bell at the door
that is opened to us.

1560
01:25:24,381 --> 01:25:27,642
a corresponding male individual
to Monsieur Fage Mickael.

1561
01:25:28,142 --> 01:25:30,212
we qualify and

1562
01:25:30,512 --> 01:25:32,702
after ascertaining his identity.

1563
01:25:33,062 --> 01:25:35,612
Let's proceed with the arrest
at 1.30pm.

1564
01:25:36,092 --> 01:25:39,332
We inform Mr. Fage of your arrest
precautionary measure and its related rights

1565
01:25:39,602 --> 01:25:42,674
with separate notification coming
sent immediately.

1566
01:25:42,812 --> 01:25:45,082
For official duty.

1567
01:25:59,732 --> 01:26:01,152
Stephanie, Stephanie.

1568
01:26:04,712 --> 01:26:07,352
What's the point of this stop without it
the consent of the prosecutor?

1569
01:26:07,772 --> 01:26:09,102
I had to anticipate for Lavallé.

1570
01:26:08,102 --> 01:26:09,122


1571
01:26:09,242 --> 01:26:11,471
Langlois was unattainable,
he finally called me back

1572
01:26:11,472 --> 01:26:13,742
and gave authorization for the arrest.

1573
01:26:13,952 --> 01:26:16,092
- Okay, so everything is in order?
- Absolutely

1574
01:26:24,932 --> 01:26:29,262
Mr. Fage, confirm that it is you and Mr. Lavallée
that we see Mr. Girard being shot?

1575
01:26:30,392 --> 01:26:31,392
YES.

1576
01:26:31,502 --> 01:26:33,732
Did your shot hit Mr. Girard?

1577
01:26:33,872 --> 01:26:35,142
I do not know.

1578
01:26:35,522 --> 01:26:38,942
- In the video you can see that he is hit?
- Yes.

1579
01:26:39,752 --> 01:26:41,862
He suffered a serious head injury.

1580
01:26:44,132 --> 01:26:46,982
I didn't aim for the head.
It's not allowed

1581
01:26:45,422 --> 01:26:46,752


1582
01:26:47,582 --> 01:26:50,712
In your opinion what is the distance that
separates her from Mr. Girard?

1583
01:26:53,282 --> 01:26:54,362
I would say about 20 metres.

1584
01:26:54,992 --> 01:26:56,502
It's 14 metres.

1585
01:26:56,702 --> 01:26:59,982
At this distance, the margin of
error of LBD 40 is 4 cm.

1586
01:27:02,132 --> 01:27:04,242
So one of you must have
aimed at the head.

1587
01:27:04,322 --> 01:27:08,342
Maybe our LBD 40 not
they worked correctly.

1588
01:27:06,902 --> 01:27:08,382


1589
01:27:08,492 --> 01:27:10,542
This would explain a deviation
from the trajectory.

1590
01:27:11,462 --> 01:27:12,690
He made numerous shots,

1591
01:27:12,691 --> 01:27:15,556
he would have noticed it before,
in the day, right?

1592
01:27:16,771 --> 01:27:18,902
Maybe there was a
ammunition problem

1593
01:27:19,455 --> 01:27:21,192
I know I didn't aim for the head.

1594
01:27:21,992 --> 01:27:26,082
I would like to remind you that there is no evidence that this was the case
my client's shot to hit Mr. Gérard.

1595
01:27:29,552 --> 01:27:32,742
Mr. Fage, what did you do when the
protester fell to the ground?

1596
01:27:33,932 --> 01:27:35,442
I don't remember.

1597
01:27:36,572 --> 01:27:37,872
Make an effort.

1598
01:27:43,262 --> 01:27:46,222
Great, I'll show you
the rest of the video.

1599
01:27:44,402 --> 01:27:46,242


1600
01:28:09,302 --> 01:28:11,352
Can you describe what you see?

1601
01:28:14,762 --> 01:28:16,032
I'm listening to it.

1602
01:28:18,812 --> 01:28:19,812
Eh…

1603
01:28:22,622 --> 01:28:24,642
I make a movement to free myself.

1604
01:28:25,142 --> 01:28:27,462
Because that person is looking
to grab my leg.

1605
01:28:27,542 --> 01:28:29,382
Probably to make me fall.

1606
01:28:31,592 --> 01:28:34,842
He sees Mr. Girard looking
to grab her leg?

1607
01:28:35,740 --> 01:28:37,602
The pictures don't show this very well.

1608
01:28:37,322 --> 01:28:38,322


1609
01:28:38,792 --> 01:28:40,932
On the contrary, it seems to me that we succeed
to see everything very well.

1610
01:28:41,324 --> 01:28:42,512
It's easy to say now.

1611
01:28:42,692 --> 01:28:45,342
In that instant I had the clear sensation
that he was about to grab my leg.

1612
01:28:46,832 --> 01:28:48,882
Mr. Girard lies prostrate on the ground.

1613
01:28:49,472 --> 01:28:51,132
He doesn't make any moves.

1614
01:28:52,292 --> 01:28:54,452
She's the one who approaches and kicks him.

1615
01:28:55,172 --> 01:28:57,522
While he is on the ground and visibly injured.

1616
01:28:58,412 --> 01:29:00,332
In my opinion he was not injured.

1617
01:29:00,392 --> 01:29:01,712
Simply fell because

1618
01:29:02,462 --> 01:29:04,172
probably hit on the
chest from our blows.

1619
01:29:04,412 --> 01:29:07,062
He holds his head in his hands
and can't get up.

1620
01:29:09,482 --> 01:29:12,391
I remind you that after a shot it is necessary
check the person's condition

1621
01:29:12,392 --> 01:29:14,622
and that the bullet did not wound her.

1622
01:29:14,672 --> 01:29:16,602
I would like to reiterate that, in my opinion, he is not injured.

1623
01:29:17,612 --> 01:29:20,522
He didn't scream. I didn't see any blood.

1624
01:29:19,142 --> 01:29:20,532


1625
01:29:21,572 --> 01:29:23,952
If I had thought it was
wounded I would have helped him.

1626
01:30:02,102 --> 01:30:03,552
Has he already done it?

1627
01:30:03,782 --> 01:30:04,782
Not yet.

1628
01:30:19,952 --> 01:30:23,214
Tonio told me you arrested
BIS agents, is it true?

1629
01:30:23,227 --> 01:30:24,992
Do you want to talk about it now?

1630
01:30:25,112 --> 01:30:26,802
But yes, is it true or not?

1631
01:30:27,056 --> 01:30:29,016
It's a decision made
in agreement with the prosecutor's office.

1632
01:30:29,256 --> 01:30:31,557
- Are you playing with words is it your investigation or not?
- Yes.

1633
01:30:32,676 --> 01:30:33,916
Are you crazy?

1634
01:30:34,076 --> 01:30:35,636
The BIS? Did you see what he did at the Bataclan?

1635
01:30:35,656 --> 01:30:37,876
- Yes
- They are heroes.

1636
01:30:38,136 --> 01:30:39,537
They risk their lives while you investigate

1637
01:30:39,538 --> 01:30:42,016
behind your little desk
completely white

1638
01:30:40,776 --> 01:30:41,496


1639
01:30:42,156 --> 01:30:43,476
Frankly, it's shameful.

1640
01:30:43,626 --> 01:30:44,646
Change the disk

1641
01:30:45,006 --> 01:30:47,326
I hear the same refrain
every day.

1642
01:30:47,766 --> 01:30:50,696
- You need to ask yourself some questions.
- And they ask themselves?

1643
01:30:49,206 --> 01:30:50,626


1644
01:30:50,796 --> 01:30:52,718
No one gives the right to the BRI

1645
01:30:52,719 --> 01:30:54,816
to behave like cowboys.

1646
01:30:55,386 --> 01:30:56,375
- Like cowboy?

1647
01:30:56,466 --> 01:30:58,476
They invented it
the Wild West.

1648
01:30:58,836 --> 01:30:59,946
You all went crazy.

1649
01:31:00,336 --> 01:31:02,956
Give more credit to
thugs than at the BIS.

1650
01:31:02,106 --> 01:31:02,856


1651
01:31:03,186 --> 01:31:04,576
Do you know the case?

1652
01:31:05,136 --> 01:31:07,836
If I understand correctly, the main witness
Has he been convicted of violence?

1653
01:31:07,896 --> 01:31:10,756
I don't want to talk about this with you
and stop parroting.

1654
01:31:10,766 --> 01:31:13,325
Just because you're in bed with unions doesn't mean it
that you have to repeat everything they say.

1655
01:31:13,326 --> 01:31:15,226
Don't involve Noélie
in this matter.

1656
01:31:32,766 --> 01:31:34,996
Victor is ashamed to say
that we are police officers.

1657
01:31:37,086 --> 01:31:40,646
That's right, the father of a friend of his
he asked me where I taught.

1658
01:31:39,096 --> 01:31:40,551


1659
01:31:40,746 --> 01:31:42,376
I didn't understand at first.

1660
01:31:42,486 --> 01:31:45,096
Victor told me that you are a teacher
of physical education, I teach French…

1661
01:31:45,336 --> 01:31:48,876
I didn't even dare tell him
that he was wrong

1662
01:31:47,166 --> 01:31:48,166


1663
01:31:50,376 --> 01:31:52,246
He's ashamed to say that
I'm a policeman

1664
01:31:51,306 --> 01:31:51,966


1665
01:31:52,356 --> 01:31:53,836
What world do we live in?

1666
01:31:54,276 --> 01:31:57,455
- And you fuel hatred towards the police?
- I'm just doing my job

1667
01:31:57,456 --> 01:31:59,896
as I always have, it's a
sad detective work.

1668
01:32:00,000 --> 01:32:01,835
You weren't the same when you were
to the drug squad.

1669
01:32:01,836 --> 01:32:03,091
You know what? You should have
apply to the IGPN

1670
01:32:03,092 --> 01:32:06,196
in my place, this is how I would be
remained at the anti-drug station.

1671
01:32:06,366 --> 01:32:08,972
You were happy that one of us
took care of Victor.

1672
01:32:08,973 --> 01:32:11,896
There I could manage time and myself
they also liked drugs.

1673
01:32:12,036 --> 01:32:15,065
Well yes, the idea of investigating colleagues
It doesn't excite me at all

1674
01:32:15,066 --> 01:32:18,206
But if they do shit they have to
take responsibility for it.

1675
01:32:17,166 --> 01:32:18,066


1676
01:32:18,276 --> 01:32:19,416
- You just can't
put yourself in their shoes?

1677
01:32:20,016 --> 01:32:21,436
That's what I always do.

1678
01:32:22,506 --> 01:32:24,493
Constantly making excuses
for those who make mistakes

1679
01:32:24,494 --> 01:32:26,496
and bowing to the unions,

1680
01:32:26,586 --> 01:32:28,565
All the serious cops looking for
to do the right thing.

1681
01:32:28,566 --> 01:32:30,346
they would resign and quit
the police.

1682
01:32:30,389 --> 01:32:32,146
And only the assholes would remain.

1683
01:33:03,696 --> 01:33:05,236
It's been months now

1684
01:33:05,346 --> 01:33:08,446
that the government is asking the police
to risk their lives.

1685
01:33:06,966 --> 01:33:08,056


1686
01:33:08,466 --> 01:33:09,336
in front of some thugs.

1687
01:33:09,636 --> 01:33:11,626
that they would like to destroy
the Republic.

1688
01:33:10,176 --> 01:33:11,656


1689
01:33:12,156 --> 01:33:13,586
Our colleagues are faced with

1690
01:33:13,596 --> 01:33:14,926
situations that are close

1691
01:33:14,946 --> 01:33:16,516
to chaos and insurrection.

1692
01:33:16,776 --> 01:33:20,536
And today we learn that i
our colleagues at the BIS,

1693
01:33:18,126 --> 01:33:18,816


1694
01:33:18,966 --> 01:33:20,536


1695
01:33:20,736 --> 01:33:21,566
The BIS.

1696
01:33:21,516 --> 01:33:23,646
whose courage, in my opinion,
it's out of the question

1697
01:33:23,856 --> 01:33:25,355
they are arrested by the police.

1698
01:33:25,356 --> 01:33:28,776
like common criminals... useless
say this decision

1699
01:33:29,046 --> 01:33:30,246
will not contribute.

1700
01:33:30,396 --> 01:33:33,036
to appease the discontent that already exists
winds between us.

1701
01:33:33,426 --> 01:33:35,536
I'm telling you, the agents
they are disgusted.

1702
01:33:36,096 --> 01:33:38,356
The government must understand

1703
01:33:38,796 --> 01:33:40,996
that we are close to the breaking point

1704
01:33:41,736 --> 01:33:43,516
And when we are no longer here

1705
01:33:43,776 --> 01:33:46,156
There will be no one left to protect
the Republic.

1706
01:34:09,996 --> 01:34:13,656
- What's going on here?
- The custody period has just ended.

1707
01:34:22,386 --> 01:34:23,836
Can someone explain it to me?

1708
01:34:24,966 --> 01:34:26,506
The big bosses have arrived.

1709
01:34:26,766 --> 01:34:28,486
They are waiting for you in the meeting room.

1710
01:34:48,306 --> 01:34:50,166
I took the liberty of
call the prosecutor's office.

1711
01:34:50,167 --> 01:34:53,296
I suggested that the order be revoked
custody and followed my advice.

1712
01:34:53,706 --> 01:34:56,495
We must avoid causing discontent
of the unions at a time like this

1713
01:34:56,496 --> 01:34:59,435
where we ask a lot of our staff that
this is why he is constantly under pressure.

1714
01:34:59,436 --> 01:34:59,976
Mr. Fage and...

1715
01:35:00,216 --> 01:35:02,176
Mr. Lavallée have us
lied many times.

1716
01:35:02,496 --> 01:35:05,986
Mr. Fage attempted to avoid
the hearing with a delay tactic.

1717
01:35:06,336 --> 01:35:09,575
According to Article 78, it was completely
justified in forcing him to do so.

1718
01:35:09,576 --> 01:35:11,586
to appear with the use of
public force.

1719
01:35:11,256 --> 01:35:13,806
Thank you, Mrs Bertrand, I know
the criminal procedure code

1720
01:35:14,376 --> 01:35:16,866
I understood his desire to do
a custody order.

1721
01:35:17,086 --> 01:35:18,636
But nothing prevented it

1722
01:35:18,756 --> 01:35:19,926
call him back for a
voluntary interrogation.

1723
01:35:20,106 --> 01:35:21,219
This has nothing to do with it

1724
01:35:21,220 --> 01:35:24,136
so he could fix his
deposition and you know it very well.

1725
01:35:24,216 --> 01:35:27,485
These are serious issues; we have
a video that proves that

1726
01:35:27,486 --> 01:35:29,496
it was neither legitimate
defense or reaction

1727
01:35:29,826 --> 01:35:32,266
If the video is clear enough

1728
01:35:32,496 --> 01:35:35,256
It may not have been necessary
place them under custody.

1729
01:35:35,616 --> 01:35:38,616
It remains to be determined which of the two he has
caused Mr. Girard's injury.

1730
01:35:39,216 --> 01:35:40,523
We need to keep the pressure high.

1731
01:35:40,524 --> 01:35:43,426
- Extending the custody period
- Custody is revoked.

1732
01:35:45,666 --> 01:35:48,436
I hope you have other ways to
progress the investigation.

1733
01:35:48,996 --> 01:35:50,826
Have you consulted a ballistics expert?

1734
01:35:51,456 --> 01:35:53,795
Yes, an exercise is planned
simulation for next week.

1735
01:35:53,796 --> 01:35:54,216
Well.

1736
01:35:54,966 --> 01:35:56,866
This will definitely allow
to move forward.

1737
01:35:57,906 --> 01:35:59,386
I'll be very clear.

1738
01:35:59,736 --> 01:36:02,806
We can't afford to put ourselves
against the whole category.

1739
01:36:03,276 --> 01:36:05,195
This is also the point of
view of the head of the IGPN.

1740
01:36:05,196 --> 01:36:06,406
and the ministry.

1741
01:36:39,306 --> 01:36:43,415
His ballistics expert concluded, in agreement
with the medical examiner, who gives the builds

1742
01:36:43,416 --> 01:36:45,166
similar of the two officials.

1743
01:36:45,306 --> 01:36:49,086
given the very close and given shooting angles
Mr. Girard's rotational movement.

1744
01:36:49,506 --> 01:36:53,646
It is impossible to tell which of the two strokes he has
reached Mr. Girard at the head

1745
01:36:54,066 --> 01:36:55,497
and is the cause of the injuries

1746
01:36:55,498 --> 01:36:58,666
which resulted in a prognosis
of more than 60 days.

1747
01:38:42,756 --> 01:38:44,000
Mrs. Girard.

1748
01:38:44,946 --> 01:38:45,946
Good morning.

1749
01:38:46,416 --> 01:38:47,836
I wanted to talk to her.

1750
01:38:48,006 --> 01:38:50,086
Even though I shouldn't do it.

1751
01:38:51,636 --> 01:38:53,876
Can I come in?

1752
01:39:18,216 --> 01:39:20,146
The preliminary investigation is closed.

1753
01:39:21,276 --> 01:39:23,310
Your lawyer will inform you
of the conclusions of

1754
01:39:23,311 --> 01:39:25,476
prosecutor but I wanted to talk about it first
personally with her.

1755
01:39:25,866 --> 01:39:26,866
Why?

1756
01:39:27,696 --> 01:39:29,716
To be able to give you some explanations.

1757
01:39:31,716 --> 01:39:34,726
The investigation identified the officers
police officers who fired shots.

1758
01:39:35,346 --> 01:39:39,066
He also establishes that they fired without
respect the principle of necessity

1759
01:39:39,106 --> 01:39:42,226
and proportionality. I am
therefore responsible

1760
01:39:44,016 --> 01:39:46,044
The problem is that it was
impossible to determine.

1761
01:39:46,045 --> 01:39:48,976
Which of the two shots injured
his son at the head

1762
01:39:52,086 --> 01:39:55,246
It is definitely one of the two therefore
they will indict them both.

1763
01:39:56,016 --> 01:39:57,016
No

1764
01:39:58,476 --> 01:40:00,046
I don't understand.

1765
01:40:00,366 --> 01:40:02,256
There were two simultaneous shots.

1766
01:40:02,376 --> 01:40:04,486
but only one hit Guillaume.

1767
01:40:05,646 --> 01:40:07,345
Ballistic and medical tests.

1768
01:40:07,346 --> 01:40:11,216
They were unable to establish which one
hit him in the head.

1769
01:40:13,446 --> 01:40:16,156
They both shot,
both are responsible.

1770
01:40:17,886 --> 01:40:20,176
From a legal point of view,
the question is more complex.

1771
01:40:21,006 --> 01:40:24,706
So no one is punished because they don't know
Which of the two hurt Guillaume?

1772
01:40:27,546 --> 01:40:29,776
I understand this is difficult to understand.

1773
01:40:30,592 --> 01:40:33,142
But Guillaume will suffer the consequences
for the rest of his existence

1774
01:40:30,922 --> 01:40:32,312


1775
01:40:33,292 --> 01:40:35,552
They screwed up his life

1776
01:40:34,282 --> 01:40:35,372


1777
01:40:35,602 --> 01:40:37,382
And no one will be punished?

1778
01:40:38,002 --> 01:40:42,402
The police officer who kicked his
son will have to answer for the crime of violence.

1779
01:40:42,412 --> 01:40:45,632
Violence that will not lead to his own
suspension from service

1780
01:40:45,952 --> 01:40:48,452
No suspension?

1781
01:40:51,892 --> 01:40:53,192
And their leaders?

1782
01:40:53,332 --> 01:40:55,352
There are definitely gods
responsible, however

1783
01:40:56,662 --> 01:41:00,032
There were no orders that could
be considered illegitimate.

1784
01:41:02,692 --> 01:41:06,111
The prefecture asked the police
to contain violent protesters

1785
01:41:06,112 --> 01:41:10,442
- with the means at their disposal
- But Guillaume wasn't violent.

1786
01:41:11,752 --> 01:41:14,382
- I know
- And this doesn't change anything?

1787
01:41:14,572 --> 01:41:15,572
No.

1788
01:41:20,392 --> 01:41:22,682
Actually, I don't understand
why she came

1789
01:41:27,892 --> 01:41:30,122
I wanted to tell her what I did
my best.

1790
01:41:31,732 --> 01:41:33,512
To ascertain the truth.

1791
01:41:36,562 --> 01:41:38,432
She did her job
correctly

1792
01:41:38,782 --> 01:41:40,772
but what was the point?

1793
01:41:42,112 --> 01:41:43,502
What was it for?

1794
01:42:27,172 --> 01:42:28,252
He wanted to see me.

1795
01:42:28,262 --> 01:42:29,262
YES.

1796
01:42:29,272 --> 01:42:31,082
Please close the door.

1797
01:42:32,992 --> 01:42:33,992
THANK YOU.

1798
01:42:40,822 --> 01:42:42,032
I have a problem.

1799
01:42:42,952 --> 01:42:43,952
YES?

1800
01:42:44,002 --> 01:42:44,511
He should have told me he knew
the Girard family.

1801
01:42:44,512 --> 01:42:46,952


1802
01:42:47,412 --> 01:42:49,572
I don't know them.

1803
01:42:49,792 --> 01:42:51,842
Aren't they his relatives?

1804
01:42:51,922 --> 01:42:55,422
No. We are from the same place
city, that's all.

1805
01:42:53,182 --> 01:42:55,492


1806
01:42:55,783 --> 01:42:59,312
I didn't know them before I started
to work on this case.

1807
01:42:55,792 --> 01:42:55,953


1808
01:42:59,632 --> 01:43:00,262
Is it safe?

1809
01:43:00,952 --> 01:43:02,972
Saint-Dizier is a small city.

1810
01:43:03,322 --> 01:43:05,192
But it's not even a village.

1811
01:43:05,632 --> 01:43:07,922
Did you have no connection with them?

1812
01:43:08,782 --> 01:43:10,399
Guillaume Girard's mother as

1813
01:43:10,400 --> 01:43:12,782
health worker took care of it
from my mother three years ago.

1814
01:43:12,862 --> 01:43:14,972
But I didn't know that at first
of the investigation.

1815
01:43:15,922 --> 01:43:17,702
This is called "bonding".

1816
01:43:18,022 --> 01:43:19,492
If he believes it.

1817
01:43:19,542 --> 01:43:22,162
But this did not affect
my investigation.

1818
01:43:22,252 --> 01:43:24,092
Should I believe her?

1819
01:43:24,712 --> 01:43:27,032
I focused on the
search for evidence.

1820
01:43:27,352 --> 01:43:30,492
The mistakes made by these officials
of the BIS are objective and serious.

1821
01:43:30,502 --> 01:43:32,122
It doesn't matter.

1822
01:43:32,212 --> 01:43:35,371
You have a connection to the Girard family and
this created a prejudice

1823
01:43:35,372 --> 01:43:37,022
A prejudice?

1824
01:43:37,072 --> 01:43:38,072
YES.

1825
01:43:38,512 --> 01:43:41,672
Before the law, principles apply
of impartiality and equality.

1826
01:43:41,752 --> 01:43:43,892
If we don't respect them,
there is no justice.

1827
01:43:45,772 --> 01:43:48,752
Deontologically it is clear that
this represents a problem.

1828
01:43:49,862 --> 01:43:53,432
Even on an unconscious level, it can have
influenced his perception of the case.

1829
01:43:53,872 --> 01:43:55,012
It may have influenced
his choices.

1830
01:43:55,672 --> 01:43:58,862
Feel more empathy for the
plaintiff, understand it.

1831
01:43:59,392 --> 01:44:02,492
Even just the fact of coming from
same village has certainly had an influence.

1832
01:44:02,542 --> 01:44:03,722
He's human.

1833
01:44:10,072 --> 01:44:12,912
You're right, he's human

1834
01:44:13,612 --> 01:44:16,352
That definitely had an influence
my approach.

1835
01:44:18,322 --> 01:44:20,282
If I didn't come from the same town.

1836
01:44:21,512 --> 01:44:23,331
If there hadn't been this "bond"

1837
01:44:23,332 --> 01:44:24,632
as she says.

1838
01:44:25,462 --> 01:44:27,602
I probably would have quit
the investigation first

1839
01:44:29,572 --> 01:44:31,372
I probably wouldn't have been able to
find the incriminating video.

1840
01:44:31,612 --> 01:44:34,712
I probably would have settled for
have two contradictory versions.

1841
01:44:36,952 --> 01:44:39,732
I probably would have been less inclined
to believe the victim and his family.

1842
01:44:39,802 --> 01:44:41,902
and I would probably have more
easily accepted.

1843
01:44:42,082 --> 01:44:43,622
the policemen's version.

1844
01:44:47,662 --> 01:44:49,502
You're right, I was born
in Saint-Dizier

1845
01:44:50,632 --> 01:44:53,672
And Guillaume Girard's mother has
actually crossed my life.

1846
01:44:55,552 --> 01:44:57,752
But I'm an agent of
police for twenty years.

1847
01:44:57,962 --> 01:44:59,812
My son's father
he is a policeman.

1848
01:44:59,872 --> 01:45:01,502
My colleagues are
policemen.

1849
01:45:01,672 --> 01:45:03,332
I investigated some colleagues.

1850
01:45:04,252 --> 01:45:05,822
I know their lives.

1851
01:45:05,872 --> 01:45:09,281
the lack of consideration, if not the
real contempt they suffer

1852
01:45:09,282 --> 01:45:12,015
the difficulties in protecting
public order

1853
01:45:12,016 --> 01:45:15,592
the complexity and how much it is
this job is thankless.

1854
01:45:17,782 --> 01:45:19,352
But isn't this a prejudice?

1855
01:45:21,592 --> 01:45:23,372
It's a question of perspective.

1856
01:45:24,832 --> 01:45:26,139
Everyone thinks there is a
wrong point of view.

1857
01:45:26,140 --> 01:45:27,502
And if there are points of view
against it, what do we do?

1858
01:45:28,252 --> 01:45:30,762
How do we keep
all together?

1859
01:45:31,312 --> 01:45:33,582
I don't know what to think anymore.

1860
01:45:31,762 --> 01:45:32,762


1861
01:45:35,002 --> 01:45:37,712
I was born in Saint-Dizier,
like the Gérard family.

1862
01:45:38,422 --> 01:45:41,492
And I'm a cop, just like them
who shot their son.

1863
01:45:42,802 --> 01:45:44,192
I am both.

1864
01:45:47,842 --> 01:45:49,922
And I hope to be other things too.

1865
01:45:51,472 --> 01:45:53,072
A serious investigator.

1866
01:45:54,562 --> 01:45:55,952
A good friend.

1867
01:45:57,712 --> 01:45:59,402
A not too bad mother.

1868
01:46:00,472 --> 01:46:01,472
Here you are.

1869
01:46:06,742 --> 01:46:09,062
I understand, to a certain extent
sense is right.

1870
01:46:11,002 --> 01:46:14,592
But when you take things too much to heart,
mistakes are made.

1871
01:46:15,502 --> 01:46:17,942
At what point does it begin to take
things too close to your heart?

1872
01:46:19,702 --> 01:46:22,260
Listen to me, if there is a trial,
the defense could…

1873
01:46:22,261 --> 01:46:25,478
become aware of this "bond"
which seems light to you

1874
01:46:25,582 --> 01:46:27,592
but he could use it for
discredit the investigation.

1875
01:46:27,862 --> 01:46:30,812
and, moreover, the whole work
of the IGPN would be affected.

1876
01:46:32,092 --> 01:46:34,261
Even according to your logic,
it wasn't a good idea

1877
01:46:34,262 --> 01:46:35,781
You should have told me

1878
01:46:35,782 --> 01:46:38,232
- And thus entrust the investigation to someone else...
- Yes

1879
01:46:38,422 --> 01:46:40,892
who probably wouldn't have it
taken too much to heart?

1880
01:46:41,048 --> 01:46:43,172
Don't get her into this
way, it's useless.

1881
01:46:44,152 --> 01:46:47,832
I don't know if the victim will file a civil action
and whether the intervention of a judge will be necessary.

1882
01:46:47,872 --> 01:46:51,482
But in any case, if there is a sequel,
you won't be the one to deal with the matter.

1883
01:46:53,452 --> 01:46:56,252
We must be absolutely exemplary
in ethical terms.

1884
01:46:59,812 --> 01:47:03,242
Don't worry, I have arranged everything for you
does not have to undergo an administrative investigation.

1885
01:47:03,802 --> 01:47:06,462
You have nothing to fear
from this aspect.

1886
01:47:07,162 --> 01:47:09,642
- An administrative investigation?
- Yes

1887
01:47:10,252 --> 01:47:11,672
Could I be sanctioned?

1888
01:47:11,872 --> 01:47:13,742
You won't be, I guarantee it.

1889
01:47:15,772 --> 01:47:17,932
Are you serious?

1890
01:47:50,602 --> 01:47:52,112
Why are you laughing?

1891
01:47:52,342 --> 01:47:53,972
I'm watching some videos.

1892
01:47:55,072 --> 01:47:55,162


1893
01:47:55,462 --> 01:47:56,462


1894
01:48:07,552 --> 01:48:09,492
Mom how are you?

1895
01:48:10,222 --> 01:48:11,552
Everything OK.

1896
01:48:58,402 --> 01:48:59,402
Good morning.

1897
01:49:00,562 --> 01:49:03,372
My name is Guillaume Girard.

1898
01:49:01,582 --> 01:49:02,152


1899
01:49:02,332 --> 01:49:03,332


1900
01:49:04,492 --> 01:49:06,092
One year ago.

1901
01:49:06,112 --> 01:49:07,732
The police officers
they shot me.

1902
01:49:07,852 --> 01:49:10,302
with their LDB 40

1903
01:49:08,572 --> 01:49:10,202


1904
01:49:11,122 --> 01:49:14,222
One of their shots hit me
he took it into his head

1905
01:49:12,382 --> 01:49:14,222


1906
01:49:14,392 --> 01:49:17,692
and crushed my skull.

1907
01:49:15,952 --> 01:49:17,282


1908
01:49:19,162 --> 01:49:22,512
I stayed a long time
in hospital.

1909
01:49:20,962 --> 01:49:22,112


1910
01:49:23,542 --> 01:49:26,432
I couldn't speak
for several weeks.

1911
01:49:27,112 --> 01:49:29,382
I… I had to learn
everything again.

1912
01:49:28,102 --> 01:49:29,282


1913
01:49:29,392 --> 01:49:31,902
Follow orthophonic therapies.

1914
01:49:30,022 --> 01:49:31,262


1915
01:49:33,682 --> 01:49:36,512
Doctors say that

1916
01:49:35,122 --> 01:49:36,422


1917
01:49:36,532 --> 01:49:39,312
My brain will remain
damaged.

1918
01:49:37,612 --> 01:49:39,272


1919
01:49:41,902 --> 01:49:44,802
I can't take it anymore
to concentrate

1920
01:49:43,192 --> 01:49:44,432


1921
01:49:45,232 --> 01:49:48,042
I can't take it anymore
to reflect

1922
01:49:46,522 --> 01:49:47,672


1923
01:49:49,222 --> 01:49:51,702
I forget everything.

1924
01:49:54,952 --> 01:49:57,312
I suffer from migraines.

1925
01:50:00,022 --> 01:50:04,022
Sometimes my nerves
they falter and give way

1926
01:50:01,792 --> 01:50:02,962


1927
01:50:03,472 --> 01:50:04,472


1928
01:50:05,572 --> 01:50:07,292
I become aggressive.

1929
01:50:11,032 --> 01:50:13,982
I became a burden.

1930
01:50:12,592 --> 01:50:13,712


1931
01:50:14,302 --> 01:50:16,632
For my mother.

1932
01:50:21,202 --> 01:50:25,742
I do not understand. Why the
police shot me?

1933
01:50:22,792 --> 01:50:25,262


1934
01:50:26,872 --> 01:50:29,622
They say I meant it
to throw something.

1935
01:50:28,012 --> 01:50:29,422


1936
01:50:29,932 --> 01:50:31,412
But that's not true.

1937
01:50:33,054 --> 01:50:34,474
I didn't do anything.

1938
01:50:36,294 --> 01:50:38,344
I think about them all the time.

1939
01:50:41,214 --> 01:50:43,964
I'm trying not to hate them.

1940
01:50:45,804 --> 01:50:48,794
I'm trying to be positive

1941
01:50:46,914 --> 01:50:48,334


1942
01:50:55,164 --> 01:50:56,494
It's not easy.

1943
01:51:06,893 --> 01:51:10,663
She told me to go whistle
up there on the hill.

1944
01:51:11,375 --> 01:51:15,390
I waited for her with a little one
bouquet of wild roses.

1945
01:51:15,826 --> 01:51:19,628
I picked flowers and whistled
as much as I could.

1946
01:51:20,304 --> 01:51:23,911
I waited and waited,
but she never arrived.

1947
01:51:24,058 --> 01:51:25,457
Zaï-zaï-zaï-zaï.

1948
01:51:26,347 --> 01:51:27,656
Zaï-zaï-zaï-zaï.

1949
01:51:28,533 --> 01:51:29,842
Zaï-zaï-zaï-zaï.

1950
01:51:30,835 --> 01:51:32,144
Zaï-zaï-zaï-zaï.

1951
01:51:33,625 --> 01:51:34,432
Oh-oh.

1952
01:51:35,832 --> 01:51:36,832
Oh-oh.

1953
01:51:38,159 --> 01:51:39,159
Oh-oh.

1954
01:51:40,352 --> 01:51:41,352
Oh-oh.

1955
01:51:42,971 --> 01:51:46,856
She told me to go whistle
up there on the hill.

1956
01:51:47,503 --> 01:51:51,399
I waited for her with a small bouquet
of wild roses.

1957
01:51:51,860 --> 01:51:55,674
I picked flowers and whistled
as much as I could.

1958
01:51:56,480 --> 01:52:00,114
I waited and waited, but
she never arrived.

1959
01:52:00,181 --> 01:52:01,580
Zaï-zaï-zaï-zaï.

1960
01:52:02,470 --> 01:52:03,779
Zaï-zaï-zaï-zaï.

1961
01:52:04,656 --> 01:52:05,965
Zaï-zaï-zaï-zaï.

1962
01:52:06,958 --> 01:52:08,267
Zaï-zaï-zaï-zaï.

1963
01:52:09,741 --> 01:52:10,548
Oh-oh.

1964
01:52:11,948 --> 01:52:12,948
Oh-oh.

1965
01:52:14,275 --> 01:52:15,275
Oh-oh.

1966
01:52:16,468 --> 01:52:17,468
Oh-oh.