1 00:00:05,491 --> 00:00:07,527 (narrator): In Toronto's war on crime, 2 00:00:07,593 --> 00:00:10,129 the worst offenders are pursued by the detectives 3 00:00:10,196 --> 00:00:13,066 of the Specialized Criminal Investigations Unit. 4 00:00:13,132 --> 00:00:14,434 These are their stories. (echoing gavel) 5 00:00:15,968 --> 00:00:17,370 (women singing) ♪ stay, wanna go 6 00:00:17,437 --> 00:00:19,739 ♪ Wanna stay, wanna go 7 00:00:19,806 --> 00:00:24,077 ♪ I don't know what to say, I wanna throw it all away ♪ 8 00:00:24,811 --> 00:00:26,679 ♪ I feel like a zombie 9 00:00:26,746 --> 00:00:29,115 ♪ I'll die at the party 10 00:00:29,182 --> 00:00:31,784 ♪ Yeah, you'll find my body (phone ringing) 11 00:00:31,851 --> 00:00:33,386 ♪ fully covered in confetti 12 00:00:33,453 --> 00:00:35,021 ♪ I tried calling... ♪ (cheering) 13 00:00:35,088 --> 00:00:36,622 - Come on, Ivy. Stay for one more song. 14 00:00:36,689 --> 00:00:37,990 (pop song playing on speakers) - No, Amy. 15 00:00:38,057 --> 00:00:39,892 Uh, seriously, I have to go. 16 00:00:39,959 --> 00:00:41,327 I have class tomorrow at nine. 17 00:00:41,394 --> 00:00:42,829 - You're literally acing every course, 18 00:00:42,895 --> 00:00:44,530 you can take a morning off. 19 00:00:44,597 --> 00:00:46,599 What? Is something wrong? 20 00:00:46,666 --> 00:00:48,868 Is-is it Rob? - No. I'm fine. 21 00:00:48,935 --> 00:00:50,503 Go sing, I'll see you at home. 22 00:00:50,570 --> 00:00:52,205 Go! (chuckling) 23 00:00:52,271 --> 00:00:53,673 Go. (scoffing): Okay. 24 00:00:53,739 --> 00:00:55,875 - Uh, can I close my tab? - Sure. 25 00:00:57,510 --> 00:00:59,278 No whole lotta love tonight? 26 00:00:59,912 --> 00:01:01,214 - What? 27 00:01:01,280 --> 00:01:02,448 - Nothing. 28 00:01:04,150 --> 00:01:05,318 (phone ringing) 29 00:01:05,384 --> 00:01:07,086 Here. 30 00:01:07,153 --> 00:01:09,555 - Rob, stop calling. I'm not at Tempo. 31 00:01:09,622 --> 00:01:11,724 (suspenseful music) 32 00:01:11,791 --> 00:01:14,293 - Ivy, if you're still feeling this way, 33 00:01:14,360 --> 00:01:15,895 maybe you should take a break. 34 00:01:15,962 --> 00:01:17,530 Go see your parents. 35 00:01:17,597 --> 00:01:20,700 - So you think I should just run away from my problems? 36 00:01:20,766 --> 00:01:23,569 - No. I think you need to manage your stress. 37 00:01:23,636 --> 00:01:26,139 - But you don't think this is real, do you? 38 00:01:27,039 --> 00:01:29,375 Like, I'm not living in some fantasy world, Dr. Nielson! 39 00:01:29,442 --> 00:01:31,043 - I didn't say that, Ivy. 40 00:01:31,744 --> 00:01:33,513 Come. Sit. 41 00:01:33,579 --> 00:01:34,447 Please. 42 00:01:37,183 --> 00:01:38,117 (sighing) 43 00:01:38,184 --> 00:01:39,552 I think you should consider 44 00:01:39,619 --> 00:01:41,921 doing what's best for you in this situation. 45 00:01:41,988 --> 00:01:43,723 - I know what's best for me. 46 00:01:44,857 --> 00:01:46,592 And I'm not going anywhere. 47 00:01:47,660 --> 00:01:49,829 - Everyone's looking at this all wrong. 48 00:01:49,896 --> 00:01:51,464 I've done the test. 49 00:01:51,531 --> 00:01:53,966 These wounds were made by something easily accessible. 50 00:01:54,033 --> 00:01:56,769 Um, a steak knife. A pairing knife. 51 00:01:56,836 --> 00:01:59,906 - So, you think the killer was in the house with her. 52 00:01:59,972 --> 00:02:00,907 Followed her out? 53 00:02:00,973 --> 00:02:02,875 - Why? Is that what you think? 54 00:02:02,942 --> 00:02:03,910 Come on. 55 00:02:03,976 --> 00:02:06,279 Please, Ivy. Help me out. 56 00:02:06,345 --> 00:02:09,415 Why would someone stab this woman seven times? 57 00:02:09,482 --> 00:02:11,817 (suspenseful music) - Passion makes people do 58 00:02:11,884 --> 00:02:14,954 irrational things, Morris. And you'd know that 59 00:02:15,021 --> 00:02:17,023 if you didn't spend all your time playing with knives. 60 00:02:20,393 --> 00:02:22,828 - Okay, so what is it then? I wanna possess you, 61 00:02:22,895 --> 00:02:24,697 be you, so... I'm gonna kill you? 62 00:02:24,764 --> 00:02:27,433 (phone ringing) 63 00:02:27,500 --> 00:02:28,634 - Hello? 64 00:02:28,701 --> 00:02:31,204 Uh, yes, yes. Thank you for calling back. 65 00:02:31,270 --> 00:02:34,106 Uh, yeah, I can be there. 66 00:02:37,543 --> 00:02:39,412 - Is that your, uh, mystery lead? 67 00:02:39,478 --> 00:02:41,113 (chuckling) 68 00:02:42,515 --> 00:02:44,083 (door opening) 69 00:02:44,917 --> 00:02:47,019 - Uh, you're sure that's what you heard? 70 00:02:47,086 --> 00:02:49,555 - Yes. I'm certain. 71 00:02:49,622 --> 00:02:51,490 - Who else have you told about this? 72 00:02:51,557 --> 00:02:53,192 - You're the first. 73 00:02:53,259 --> 00:02:56,596 (intriguing music) (restaurant din) 74 00:02:57,530 --> 00:02:59,832 (typing on keyboard) 75 00:02:59,899 --> 00:03:01,467 (email sent feedback) 76 00:03:04,337 --> 00:03:05,605 (gasping) 77 00:03:05,671 --> 00:03:06,973 - Rob, what the hell are you doing? 78 00:03:07,039 --> 00:03:08,808 (stammering): I just... wanna talk. 79 00:03:08,874 --> 00:03:10,676 Been avoiding me. (incredulous chuckling) 80 00:03:10,743 --> 00:03:12,478 - We've talked for months. You don't listen. 81 00:03:12,545 --> 00:03:14,180 We broke up. 82 00:03:14,247 --> 00:03:16,616 - Okay, but... what if I didn't want to? 83 00:03:20,086 --> 00:03:21,554 - Hey, it's me. 84 00:03:21,621 --> 00:03:24,490 Great work. I just think that maybe... 85 00:03:24,557 --> 00:03:26,759 our last chapter needs a bit more muscle. 86 00:03:26,826 --> 00:03:28,894 I mean, I know you're all about the subtlety and that's awesome, 87 00:03:28,961 --> 00:03:30,730 but I think that if we're gonna make waves, 88 00:03:30,796 --> 00:03:32,531 we need to hit it harder. 89 00:03:32,598 --> 00:03:34,367 That's my thought. Anyway, I'll see you soon. 90 00:03:37,036 --> 00:03:38,638 (phone dinging) 91 00:03:40,273 --> 00:03:42,575 (intriguing music swelling) 92 00:03:48,948 --> 00:03:51,484 - Amy? Are you home? I need to talk to you. 93 00:03:52,918 --> 00:03:54,120 Amy? 94 00:03:54,987 --> 00:03:56,822 (crickets chirping) (sighing) 95 00:04:00,593 --> 00:04:05,831 (suspenseful music) 96 00:04:23,549 --> 00:04:25,951 Amy, I'm on my way to campus to find you. 97 00:04:26,018 --> 00:04:27,453 Call me as soon as you-- (line disconnecting) 98 00:04:27,520 --> 00:04:29,155 (groaning) 99 00:04:29,221 --> 00:04:31,557 (dramatic music) 100 00:04:31,624 --> 00:04:33,659 (keys jingling softly) 101 00:04:40,533 --> 00:04:42,201 (gasping) 102 00:04:42,268 --> 00:04:44,804 (staticky voice over phone): Hello? Campus Services. 103 00:04:44,870 --> 00:04:47,239 What's your emergency? Hello? 104 00:04:49,842 --> 00:04:50,043 (theme song) 105 00:05:25,811 --> 00:05:28,881 - Campus Security got a call from this phone at 11:22, 106 00:05:28,948 --> 00:05:30,549 but there was nobody on the line. 107 00:05:30,616 --> 00:05:32,351 (police sirens chiming) They sent somebody at 11:30, 108 00:05:32,418 --> 00:05:34,553 thinking it was a prank. 109 00:05:34,620 --> 00:05:36,355 - No such luck. - Yeah. 110 00:05:36,422 --> 00:05:38,190 - Ivy Abbott, 20 years old. 111 00:05:38,257 --> 00:05:40,025 (somber music) Dean says she's a third-year 112 00:05:40,092 --> 00:05:41,427 Criminology Major. 113 00:05:41,494 --> 00:05:43,195 She's got a 4.0 GPA. 114 00:05:43,262 --> 00:05:44,897 - Smart kid. 115 00:05:44,964 --> 00:05:46,565 - You talked to the parents yet? 116 00:05:46,632 --> 00:05:48,300 - Yeah. They're both academics. 117 00:05:48,367 --> 00:05:51,003 They're in Edinburg for a year, they're flying back today. 118 00:05:51,070 --> 00:05:52,938 Ivy was their only kid. 119 00:05:53,005 --> 00:05:54,440 - So... (sighing) 120 00:05:54,507 --> 00:05:56,809 what sent Ivy Abbott to an emergency phone 121 00:05:56,876 --> 00:05:58,344 in the middle of the night? 122 00:05:58,411 --> 00:05:59,745 - Well, her cell phone died. 123 00:05:59,812 --> 00:06:02,748 - Uh... here. 124 00:06:02,815 --> 00:06:04,917 See if it'll charge. 125 00:06:04,984 --> 00:06:05,885 - Oh, great. Thanks. 126 00:06:05,951 --> 00:06:08,454 (police sirens chiming) 127 00:06:08,521 --> 00:06:11,056 - I wonder if someone was following her. 128 00:06:11,123 --> 00:06:13,893 - Well, these indentations between her fingers. 129 00:06:13,959 --> 00:06:16,395 Could be she tried to arm herself? 130 00:06:16,462 --> 00:06:18,764 - Maybe with her keys for protection. 131 00:06:18,831 --> 00:06:21,667 Okay, so, she runs to the phone to call for help, 132 00:06:21,734 --> 00:06:23,335 but the killer 133 00:06:23,402 --> 00:06:26,272 stabs her in the neck and then drags her 134 00:06:26,338 --> 00:06:28,040 and flips her over. 135 00:06:28,107 --> 00:06:30,109 - Keeps stabbing. (sighing) 136 00:06:30,176 --> 00:06:32,678 The wound to her neck would've been fatal. 137 00:06:32,745 --> 00:06:35,014 The six stabs on her back, that was anger. 138 00:06:35,080 --> 00:06:36,816 This was personal. 139 00:06:36,882 --> 00:06:38,651 (loudly): You found a weapon? 140 00:06:38,717 --> 00:06:39,985 - Uh, no. Nothing yet. 141 00:06:40,052 --> 00:06:41,520 (intriguing music) 142 00:06:41,587 --> 00:06:44,423 - Anything on her person that could account for this? 143 00:06:44,490 --> 00:06:46,091 Looks like rope burn. 144 00:06:46,158 --> 00:06:48,427 - No, we just found her wallet, keys, and her phone. 145 00:06:48,494 --> 00:06:50,162 (phone beeping) Oh, it's charged. 146 00:06:50,229 --> 00:06:51,397 (sighing): Thanks. 147 00:06:54,066 --> 00:06:55,267 Hey. 148 00:06:56,368 --> 00:06:59,905 "What do you mean you're too scared to stay home. Call me." 149 00:07:03,976 --> 00:07:06,145 (echoing gavel) 150 00:07:07,279 --> 00:07:09,648 (shakily): Ivy said she was coming back to our apartment. 151 00:07:09,715 --> 00:07:11,951 I was studying on campus till midnight. 152 00:07:12,017 --> 00:07:14,186 My phone was on Do Not Disturb. 153 00:07:14,253 --> 00:07:17,223 And when I got Ivy's voicemail... 154 00:07:17,289 --> 00:07:19,124 ...I texted her and she didn't respond. 155 00:07:19,191 --> 00:07:21,827 I ran home, then I found this. 156 00:07:21,894 --> 00:07:24,663 I tried to blow them all out, but there are so many. 157 00:07:25,631 --> 00:07:27,166 - Amy, is there anyone we can call? 158 00:07:27,233 --> 00:07:28,834 (door opens) - Can I text my mom? 159 00:07:28,901 --> 00:07:30,236 - Of course. 160 00:07:30,302 --> 00:07:32,404 (shaky breathing) 161 00:07:32,471 --> 00:07:33,706 (sniffling) 162 00:07:39,745 --> 00:07:42,481 Amy, has anything like this happened before? 163 00:07:42,548 --> 00:07:44,917 - The first time there were just a couple of candles. 164 00:07:44,984 --> 00:07:45,818 Then a few more. 165 00:07:45,885 --> 00:07:47,086 It's the third time. 166 00:07:47,152 --> 00:07:49,655 (shakily): I've never been so scared. 167 00:07:52,124 --> 00:07:54,894 - Do you have any idea who might have done this? 168 00:07:54,960 --> 00:07:57,196 - Yeah, I figured it was Rob. Ivy's ex. 169 00:07:57,263 --> 00:08:00,366 I-it started a couple months ago when they broke up. 170 00:08:00,432 --> 00:08:01,800 - Did Ivy ever inform the police? 171 00:08:01,867 --> 00:08:04,303 - Yeah, she tried. The cop at the station 172 00:08:04,370 --> 00:08:05,738 said that it's not a crime 173 00:08:05,804 --> 00:08:07,640 to leave something outside of someone's house. 174 00:08:08,774 --> 00:08:10,843 - Yeah... Sweetheart, I'm so sorry to hear that. 175 00:08:12,111 --> 00:08:16,015 Do you think this was some grand gesture to try to get Ivy back? 176 00:08:16,081 --> 00:08:17,583 - We tried every other way. 177 00:08:17,650 --> 00:08:20,786 Constant calling, texting. Guy's unhinged. 178 00:08:22,788 --> 00:08:24,490 - What, you think I did something to Ivy? 179 00:08:25,457 --> 00:08:27,159 No, no. I would never hurt her. 180 00:08:27,226 --> 00:08:28,994 - Well, what do you know about this, huh? 181 00:08:29,061 --> 00:08:31,297 It's got quite the distinctive scent. 182 00:08:31,363 --> 00:08:32,464 (sniffs) 183 00:08:32,531 --> 00:08:35,234 Cedar, cannabis, Canadian wildflowers. 184 00:08:35,301 --> 00:08:36,902 And a hundred of these were left on 185 00:08:36,969 --> 00:08:39,672 Ivy's patio last night. - That's crazy. 186 00:08:39,738 --> 00:08:41,040 - Where were you last night, Rob? 187 00:08:41,907 --> 00:08:43,108 - I was at the Madison. 188 00:08:43,175 --> 00:08:45,744 Got there at, like, 10 PM with a few buddies. 189 00:08:45,811 --> 00:08:47,279 We stayed until, I don't know, 1:30? 190 00:08:47,346 --> 00:08:48,681 Get back here with Kailey. 191 00:08:48,747 --> 00:08:50,849 She just left. - Kailey? 192 00:08:52,084 --> 00:08:54,653 - I'm trying to see new people. Get over Ivy. 193 00:08:55,521 --> 00:08:57,122 Best six months of my life were with her. 194 00:08:57,189 --> 00:08:58,324 - So why did you break up? 195 00:08:58,390 --> 00:09:00,059 - I don't know, I... (inhaling deeply) 196 00:09:00,125 --> 00:09:01,927 She just pulled away. She broke up with me. 197 00:09:01,994 --> 00:09:02,995 She wouldn't tell me why. She... 198 00:09:03,062 --> 00:09:04,563 (intriguing music) (exhaling deeply) 199 00:09:04,630 --> 00:09:06,432 She shut down her social media, started to go to therapy, 200 00:09:06,498 --> 00:09:07,967 which I thought was weird. 201 00:09:08,033 --> 00:09:10,436 I mean, she never wanted to talk about her feelings before. 202 00:09:10,502 --> 00:09:12,438 - Who's her therapist? 203 00:09:12,504 --> 00:09:14,206 - Someone on campus. 204 00:09:15,407 --> 00:09:17,643 Sarah something. 205 00:09:17,710 --> 00:09:19,878 (echoing gavel) 206 00:09:20,546 --> 00:09:23,182 - Ivy and I met four times in the last few months. 207 00:09:24,183 --> 00:09:26,018 She was a great student. 208 00:09:26,085 --> 00:09:27,720 Good kid. 209 00:09:27,786 --> 00:09:30,022 - Yeah, she needed someone to talk to. 210 00:09:30,089 --> 00:09:32,725 - Yes. She was stressed. Anxious. 211 00:09:32,791 --> 00:09:36,629 - Did this anxiety have anything to do with, uh, 212 00:09:36,695 --> 00:09:37,830 unwanted attention? 213 00:09:37,896 --> 00:09:40,232 - A lot of female students seek out guidance 214 00:09:40,299 --> 00:09:42,534 regarding harassment, Detective, and unfortunately 215 00:09:42,601 --> 00:09:44,203 Ivy was no different. 216 00:09:44,269 --> 00:09:47,573 Look, I... I wouldn't normally do this, but, um. 217 00:09:51,643 --> 00:09:53,178 You can have my notes. 218 00:09:53,245 --> 00:09:55,347 They might help. - Thank you. 219 00:09:55,414 --> 00:09:58,017 - Ivy was convinced that someone was following her. 220 00:09:58,083 --> 00:09:59,652 She said that they left things outside of her apartment, 221 00:09:59,718 --> 00:10:01,120 lurked near her place. 222 00:10:01,186 --> 00:10:02,955 To be honest, I couldn't tell whether this was real 223 00:10:03,022 --> 00:10:04,523 or whether it was some delusion 224 00:10:04,590 --> 00:10:05,858 brought on by some underlying issue. 225 00:10:05,924 --> 00:10:07,993 - It says here, "Possible BPD" 226 00:10:08,060 --> 00:10:10,029 I'm assuming that's Borderline Personality Disorder? 227 00:10:10,095 --> 00:10:12,665 Disordered sense of self, intense emotions... 228 00:10:12,731 --> 00:10:14,967 - Relationship instability. Yes. 229 00:10:15,034 --> 00:10:17,036 All motivated by a fear of abandonment. 230 00:10:17,102 --> 00:10:19,738 But I wasn't sure because Ivy also exhibited traits 231 00:10:19,805 --> 00:10:21,807 of Paranoid Personality Disorder. 232 00:10:21,874 --> 00:10:24,209 Delusions, distrust. 233 00:10:24,276 --> 00:10:26,311 - And you never made an official diagnosis? 234 00:10:26,378 --> 00:10:28,313 - No, no, and... 235 00:10:29,248 --> 00:10:31,083 Considering what happened to her, I suppose I... 236 00:10:31,150 --> 00:10:33,018 I got that all wrong. 237 00:10:33,085 --> 00:10:35,020 (sighing) 238 00:10:35,087 --> 00:10:36,922 Regardless, it would take me more than 239 00:10:36,989 --> 00:10:38,590 four sessions to be sure. You know, 240 00:10:38,657 --> 00:10:41,493 some folks go after this stuff with a hammer. 241 00:10:42,161 --> 00:10:43,862 I paint in watercolour. 242 00:10:43,929 --> 00:10:45,464 You know, it takes time. 243 00:10:45,531 --> 00:10:47,199 Patience. 244 00:10:47,266 --> 00:10:49,601 (sighing): I wanted to help Ivy, I really did, 245 00:10:49,668 --> 00:10:52,871 but I couldn't report the harassment for her. 246 00:10:52,938 --> 00:10:56,575 - Did Ivy ever describe this person? 247 00:10:56,642 --> 00:10:58,444 - The only thing that I remember her saying 248 00:10:58,510 --> 00:11:00,879 is that he wore an army jacket. 249 00:11:00,946 --> 00:11:03,882 (suspenseful music) 250 00:11:03,949 --> 00:11:06,118 (indistinct chatter) 251 00:11:11,290 --> 00:11:12,925 - It's so sad, isn't it? 252 00:11:12,991 --> 00:11:14,693 Did you know her? 253 00:11:15,761 --> 00:11:17,529 (emotionally): She was my girlfriend. 254 00:11:17,596 --> 00:11:18,931 - Oh, my God... 255 00:11:18,997 --> 00:11:20,866 I'm so sorry. 256 00:11:20,933 --> 00:11:22,768 - Apparently, she tried to report it, 257 00:11:22,835 --> 00:11:24,570 but the description of the guy was vague 258 00:11:24,636 --> 00:11:26,638 and you know what they say about stalking. 259 00:11:26,705 --> 00:11:28,273 - Yes, homicide in slow motion. (sighing) 260 00:11:28,340 --> 00:11:30,442 (indistinct chatter) - Finished Ivy Abbott's autopsy. 261 00:11:30,509 --> 00:11:32,678 The killer twisted the knife inside her neck 262 00:11:32,745 --> 00:11:34,446 almost 180 degrees. 263 00:11:34,513 --> 00:11:36,682 - He sliced her carotid and her jugular? 264 00:11:36,749 --> 00:11:38,684 - Yeah. She bled out quickly. (sighing) 265 00:11:38,751 --> 00:11:41,120 I looked into those abrasions on her left hand, 266 00:11:41,186 --> 00:11:43,422 there's thin fibres embedded. I sent them for testing. 267 00:11:43,489 --> 00:11:46,425 - Possibly clutching onto an object as a weapon 268 00:11:46,492 --> 00:11:48,160 when the keys failed? - Maybe. 269 00:11:48,227 --> 00:11:51,196 I once tried to fend off a subway perv using a debit card. 270 00:11:51,263 --> 00:11:53,999 - Yeah, I pretended ChapStick was pepper-spray. 271 00:11:54,066 --> 00:11:55,501 It actually worked. 272 00:11:55,567 --> 00:11:57,336 Her killer wasn't a stranger. 273 00:11:57,402 --> 00:11:59,037 He had a personal connection with her. 274 00:11:59,104 --> 00:12:01,106 - Yeah, he either hated her or desired her. 275 00:12:01,173 --> 00:12:04,443 - Maybe he even felt a whole lotta love. 276 00:12:04,510 --> 00:12:06,745 It's the name of the candle. Forensics just came back, 277 00:12:06,812 --> 00:12:08,847 pinpointed a proprietary blend 278 00:12:08,914 --> 00:12:11,850 of cedar, cannabis, and Canadian wildflowers. 279 00:12:11,917 --> 00:12:14,353 Created by a Canadian company, Shy Wolf. 280 00:12:14,419 --> 00:12:17,756 I called them and guess who bought 150 candles 281 00:12:17,823 --> 00:12:19,825 using their credit card online? 282 00:12:19,892 --> 00:12:21,293 (soft music playing) - Hope you have a reservation 283 00:12:21,360 --> 00:12:22,828 'cause we're totally booked tonight. 284 00:12:22,895 --> 00:12:26,165 - Oh, I'm sure you can squeeze us in for, I don't know, 285 00:12:26,231 --> 00:12:28,634 five minutes and 33 seconds? 286 00:12:28,700 --> 00:12:30,702 - Well, that's just enough time to do a hearty rendition 287 00:12:30,769 --> 00:12:32,704 of Whole Lotta Love. 288 00:12:32,771 --> 00:12:34,239 - Carter Harold, right? 289 00:12:34,306 --> 00:12:35,874 That's you? - Yeah. 290 00:12:35,941 --> 00:12:37,242 - Well, seems recently you bought 291 00:12:37,309 --> 00:12:39,044 a whole lotta these candles. 292 00:12:39,111 --> 00:12:40,546 (glass thudding) 293 00:12:40,612 --> 00:12:43,081 - It's very expensive to just leave them all 294 00:12:43,148 --> 00:12:46,318 in Ivy Abbott's backyard. 295 00:12:46,385 --> 00:12:48,420 (dramatic music) 296 00:12:48,487 --> 00:12:50,355 (glass clanking) 297 00:12:50,422 --> 00:12:52,157 (grunting) 298 00:12:53,458 --> 00:12:55,093 - Come on, Carter. That's enough. 299 00:12:55,160 --> 00:12:56,862 - I didn't kill Ivy, I swear. 300 00:12:59,665 --> 00:13:00,766 - You sure? 301 00:13:00,833 --> 00:13:02,367 'Cause you were stalking her. 302 00:13:03,936 --> 00:13:06,238 - Okay. I left the candles on the night she died. 303 00:13:06,305 --> 00:13:07,339 On all those nights. 304 00:13:07,406 --> 00:13:09,141 But I just wanted... - Wanted what? 305 00:13:09,208 --> 00:13:10,909 Be her own personal boogeyman? 306 00:13:10,976 --> 00:13:13,679 - No. I wanted her to know that I cared about her. 307 00:13:13,745 --> 00:13:15,881 The candles. They were a message. 308 00:13:15,948 --> 00:13:17,482 They were named after a song we sang together. 309 00:13:17,549 --> 00:13:18,684 - You're telling me a 20-year-old 310 00:13:18,750 --> 00:13:20,886 sang Led Zeppelin at karaoke? 311 00:13:20,953 --> 00:13:23,021 - Not exactly. Um... 312 00:13:23,088 --> 00:13:24,823 I was in a room on my own one night. 313 00:13:24,890 --> 00:13:27,192 But then I heard a voice in the hall joining in. 314 00:13:27,259 --> 00:13:30,362 I logged out and saw... 315 00:13:30,429 --> 00:13:31,263 ...her. 316 00:13:31,330 --> 00:13:32,965 - Then you got hooked. 317 00:13:33,832 --> 00:13:36,535 Pulled her address off her ID, went to her house, 318 00:13:36,602 --> 00:13:38,704 started taking photos, lighting candles. 319 00:13:38,770 --> 00:13:39,972 - She needed to know how I felt. 320 00:13:40,038 --> 00:13:41,807 (intriguing music) - What about how she felt? 321 00:13:41,874 --> 00:13:44,409 'Cause I'm pretty sure you terrified her. 322 00:13:44,476 --> 00:13:46,445 Every. Single. Time. 323 00:13:46,511 --> 00:13:49,948 - See, I-I'm, uh, pretty new to this, so forgive me, 324 00:13:50,015 --> 00:13:54,419 but you want us to believe you trespassed onto her property, 325 00:13:54,486 --> 00:13:55,988 peaked through her windows 326 00:13:56,054 --> 00:13:58,757 and took some pretty intrusive photos of her, 327 00:13:58,824 --> 00:14:02,628 but then you didn't follow her to a deserted area, 328 00:14:02,694 --> 00:14:04,630 stab her in the neck and in the back? 329 00:14:04,696 --> 00:14:08,834 Carter, what did Ivy do when she saw the candles? 330 00:14:12,771 --> 00:14:14,439 Answer the question. 331 00:14:14,506 --> 00:14:17,242 - She ran away. Okay? 332 00:14:17,309 --> 00:14:19,144 She obviously didn't like them. - Shocker. 333 00:14:19,211 --> 00:14:22,014 - So I left and I went to work a late shift at the bar. 334 00:14:22,981 --> 00:14:24,883 Check the cameras, I was there by 11:15. 335 00:14:24,950 --> 00:14:25,951 - We will. 336 00:14:26,018 --> 00:14:27,552 - Honestly, I wished I followed her. 337 00:14:27,619 --> 00:14:28,654 I could've helped her. 338 00:14:29,554 --> 00:14:31,657 - Well, maybe it's not too late to help. 339 00:14:31,723 --> 00:14:33,926 I mean, you followed her around, right? 340 00:14:33,992 --> 00:14:34,993 - Yeah. 341 00:14:35,060 --> 00:14:36,662 - What was she up to? 342 00:14:37,062 --> 00:14:38,864 - She was spending way too much time 343 00:14:38,931 --> 00:14:40,198 at that Criminology building. 344 00:14:40,265 --> 00:14:41,466 - She had classes there. 345 00:14:41,533 --> 00:14:43,535 - No, it's not just class. It's... 346 00:14:43,602 --> 00:14:44,836 ...something else. 347 00:14:44,903 --> 00:14:46,805 Every day, she goes to some weird locked room 348 00:14:46,872 --> 00:14:48,640 that only a few people had a key to. 349 00:14:49,741 --> 00:14:50,043 - What's inside? 350 00:14:52,443 --> 00:14:54,579 - I don't know, but I think it's bad for her. 351 00:14:56,415 --> 00:14:58,350 Very bad. 352 00:14:58,417 --> 00:15:00,819 (echoing gavel) 353 00:15:01,520 --> 00:15:02,754 - Let me know when you're done. 354 00:15:07,192 --> 00:15:11,096 - That looks like a bunch of true crime nerds made a nest. 355 00:15:11,163 --> 00:15:14,366 - Or the Cold Case Club. 356 00:15:14,433 --> 00:15:17,936 They do seminars supervised by Professor Garrett Poole. 357 00:15:18,003 --> 00:15:19,705 - What's the case? 358 00:15:19,771 --> 00:15:24,609 - The victim was Kat Berman, murdered in 2019. 359 00:15:24,676 --> 00:15:26,311 Student at Queens University. 360 00:15:26,378 --> 00:15:28,313 (sighing): She was stabbed once in the neck. 361 00:15:28,380 --> 00:15:29,514 (suspenseful music) 362 00:15:29,581 --> 00:15:32,451 - And six times... in the back. 363 00:15:33,885 --> 00:15:35,921 Exactly like Ivy. 364 00:15:41,927 --> 00:15:45,764 - So Ivy Abbott was studying Kat Berman's murder 365 00:15:45,831 --> 00:15:48,900 and ends up getting killed in exactly the same way? 366 00:15:48,967 --> 00:15:51,269 - Yeah, down to the twist of the knife. 367 00:15:51,336 --> 00:15:53,372 (office phones ringing) Uh, take a look at Ivy's autopsy 368 00:15:53,438 --> 00:15:56,041 and Kat's autopsy from six years ago. 369 00:15:56,108 --> 00:15:57,609 Their fatal neck wounds were caused 370 00:15:57,676 --> 00:15:59,544 by the exact same maneuver. 371 00:15:59,611 --> 00:16:01,580 - Followed by six stabs to the back. 372 00:16:01,646 --> 00:16:04,416 The only difference was the marks on the hand. 373 00:16:04,483 --> 00:16:06,218 Ivy had them, Kat did not. 374 00:16:06,284 --> 00:16:07,686 - You talk to Kingston PD? (distant door buzzing) 375 00:16:07,753 --> 00:16:10,422 - Yeah, they gave us access to Kat's file, 376 00:16:10,489 --> 00:16:12,457 but they haven't had a new lead in forever. 377 00:16:12,524 --> 00:16:14,760 - So, now we have two dead students, 378 00:16:14,826 --> 00:16:16,628 similar ages, same wound. 379 00:16:16,695 --> 00:16:19,231 (sighing): Yeah. We might be looking at a serial murderer. 380 00:16:19,297 --> 00:16:23,201 - Or a copycat who knew the wound pattern well. 381 00:16:23,268 --> 00:16:26,738 Maybe because they studied it at Cold Case Club. 382 00:16:26,805 --> 00:16:28,907 (echoing gavel) 383 00:16:30,108 --> 00:16:31,710 - Ivy was an excellent student. 384 00:16:31,777 --> 00:16:33,612 - I'm sorry for your loss, Professor Poole. 385 00:16:33,678 --> 00:16:35,814 Uh, profile told us she was in your Cold Case Club? 386 00:16:35,881 --> 00:16:39,017 - Yeah, one of only 10 kids selected. 387 00:16:39,084 --> 00:16:41,153 - Yes, it was an invitation only 388 00:16:41,219 --> 00:16:43,255 criminology seminar for third-year students 389 00:16:43,321 --> 00:16:46,024 and Ivy was, yeah, she was doing incredibly well. 390 00:16:46,091 --> 00:16:47,292 They all were. 391 00:16:47,359 --> 00:16:48,994 - So you thought your best and brightest 392 00:16:49,061 --> 00:16:51,663 could solve Kat Berman's murder? 393 00:16:51,730 --> 00:16:53,865 Uh, stump the Kingston PD? 394 00:16:55,200 --> 00:16:57,636 - No, it's more of a teaching exercise. 395 00:16:57,702 --> 00:17:00,005 - Hmm. - So you take an unsolvable case 396 00:17:00,072 --> 00:17:01,640 and give it to a bunch 397 00:17:01,706 --> 00:17:03,708 of smart kids. - And see what they do with it. 398 00:17:05,710 --> 00:17:08,013 Each bring their own expertise, their own point of view. 399 00:17:08,080 --> 00:17:09,648 It's fascinating. - Hmm. 400 00:17:09,714 --> 00:17:12,284 - And what was, uh, Ivy's angle? 401 00:17:12,350 --> 00:17:13,952 - Interpreting witness testimony. 402 00:17:14,019 --> 00:17:15,253 - Hmm. 403 00:17:15,320 --> 00:17:16,922 And what if, uh, a student 404 00:17:16,988 --> 00:17:18,957 discovers a lead? (intriguing music) 405 00:17:19,024 --> 00:17:21,126 - Well, then I would take it to the cold case unit, 406 00:17:21,193 --> 00:17:24,262 but I've been using this one for a couple years now 407 00:17:24,329 --> 00:17:25,764 and so far there are no new leads. 408 00:17:25,831 --> 00:17:26,932 - Hmm. 409 00:17:26,998 --> 00:17:29,601 But, uh, Ivy wanted to find one. Yeah. 410 00:17:29,668 --> 00:17:31,536 Uh, we heard she spent quite a lot of time 411 00:17:31,603 --> 00:17:34,206 in the seminar room after hours. 412 00:17:34,272 --> 00:17:35,807 - Yes, they all did. 413 00:17:35,874 --> 00:17:37,676 I told them they'd get top marks if they solved it 414 00:17:37,742 --> 00:17:39,077 and they couldn't take the files home. 415 00:17:39,144 --> 00:17:42,581 - Did those files include, uh, 416 00:17:42,647 --> 00:17:45,484 Kat Berman's autopsy? 417 00:17:46,751 --> 00:17:48,320 - Yes. Why? 418 00:17:48,386 --> 00:17:50,655 - Oh, we were wondering if any of the students were, uh, 419 00:17:50,722 --> 00:17:52,324 taking the pathology angle? 420 00:17:52,390 --> 00:17:54,359 - Cause of death. Injuries. 421 00:17:55,927 --> 00:17:58,163 - Yes, Morris Lemay. 422 00:17:58,230 --> 00:18:00,732 He's an aspiring forensic pathologist. 423 00:18:00,799 --> 00:18:02,868 He was trying to recreate Kat Berman's wounds 424 00:18:02,934 --> 00:18:06,438 using various unique methods. 425 00:18:07,506 --> 00:18:08,740 - Many body pathologists 426 00:18:08,807 --> 00:18:11,009 practise replicating knife wounds. 427 00:18:11,076 --> 00:18:12,410 It's not weird. 428 00:18:14,579 --> 00:18:16,915 - So, does everyone work on Miss Piggy? 429 00:18:16,982 --> 00:18:19,084 - Well, they should. The consistency of pig flesh 430 00:18:19,151 --> 00:18:20,719 is very close to human. 431 00:18:20,785 --> 00:18:22,020 - Well, funny. That's why we're here. 432 00:18:22,087 --> 00:18:23,755 Morris, where were you the night Ivy died? 433 00:18:23,822 --> 00:18:26,324 - I didn't kill Ivy. I was with my parents. Here. 434 00:18:26,391 --> 00:18:27,592 All night. 435 00:18:27,659 --> 00:18:28,693 You can ask them. 436 00:18:28,760 --> 00:18:29,861 (distant children chattering) 437 00:18:29,928 --> 00:18:31,530 - What's on your mind? 438 00:18:31,596 --> 00:18:32,898 - If only I'd move faster. 439 00:18:32,964 --> 00:18:34,266 (intriguing music) Done better. 440 00:18:34,332 --> 00:18:35,867 Could've found out who really did this and... 441 00:18:35,934 --> 00:18:37,435 Ivy would still be alive. 442 00:18:37,502 --> 00:18:39,271 - Do you think Kat's killer murdered Ivy? 443 00:18:39,337 --> 00:18:40,372 - Isn't it obvious? 444 00:18:40,438 --> 00:18:42,941 Ivy probably figured out who did it. 445 00:18:43,008 --> 00:18:45,210 (lowly): You call yourself a detective... 446 00:18:46,545 --> 00:18:49,881 - Professor Poole says that there were no new leads. 447 00:18:49,948 --> 00:18:51,616 - Yeah, well, Professor Poole doesn't know everything. 448 00:18:51,683 --> 00:18:53,585 Ivy finished reviewing witness testimony 449 00:18:53,652 --> 00:18:55,921 and moved on to something that wasn't even assigned to her. 450 00:18:55,987 --> 00:18:57,889 Something that no one was allowed to do. 451 00:18:57,956 --> 00:18:59,791 - Interviewing real witnesses. 452 00:18:59,858 --> 00:19:01,326 - How'd you know? 453 00:19:01,393 --> 00:19:03,061 - Oh, well, that's exactly what he would've done. 454 00:19:03,128 --> 00:19:05,263 So, what was Ivy's strategy? 455 00:19:05,330 --> 00:19:07,999 - Ivy was really into victimology. 456 00:19:08,066 --> 00:19:09,734 In particular, victim facilitation. 457 00:19:09,801 --> 00:19:12,103 You know, the theory of what makes someone a target. 458 00:19:12,170 --> 00:19:13,905 But nothing of the witness testimony 459 00:19:13,972 --> 00:19:15,640 made it seem like Kat was a high-risk victim. 460 00:19:15,707 --> 00:19:17,309 Just went to work and to school. 461 00:19:17,375 --> 00:19:20,779 - So Ivy wanted to know how the killer came into Kat's orbit. 462 00:19:20,845 --> 00:19:22,914 - Yeah. Ivy figured the perp was either an unassuming random, 463 00:19:22,981 --> 00:19:24,416 a stalker-- 464 00:19:24,482 --> 00:19:27,319 - Or someone Kat didn't want anyone else to know about. 465 00:19:27,385 --> 00:19:29,955 Did Ivy find any new leads? 466 00:19:30,021 --> 00:19:33,158 - She went to meet a witness the day she died. 467 00:19:33,225 --> 00:19:36,828 I saw the address she wrote down before she left. 468 00:19:36,895 --> 00:19:39,664 (echoing gavel) 469 00:19:39,731 --> 00:19:43,101 - Yes. Ivy Abbott came by here at 6 PM. 470 00:19:43,168 --> 00:19:44,102 We chatted, she left. 471 00:19:44,169 --> 00:19:45,637 I was here till 12. 472 00:19:45,704 --> 00:19:47,105 I didn't even know her. 473 00:19:47,172 --> 00:19:50,043 - But Ivy thought that you might know Kat Berman. 474 00:19:53,243 --> 00:19:54,179 - And where was this? 475 00:19:54,246 --> 00:19:55,680 - Six years ago, I was living 476 00:19:55,747 --> 00:19:57,649 in Kingston with my aunt and on the weekend I delivered 477 00:19:57,716 --> 00:19:59,517 pizzas for a place called Max Dough. 478 00:19:59,584 --> 00:20:02,287 - And Ivy knew you were delivering pizzas to Kat? 479 00:20:02,354 --> 00:20:04,522 - She saw a photo of our pizza box in Kat's recycling. 480 00:20:04,589 --> 00:20:06,324 Part of the case files, I guess. 481 00:20:06,391 --> 00:20:07,692 - And Ivy wanted to know 482 00:20:07,759 --> 00:20:10,061 if you ever saw anyone with Kat on the weekends? 483 00:20:10,128 --> 00:20:13,098 - Yes. And there was a guy there with her sometimes. 484 00:20:13,164 --> 00:20:15,000 Definitely a boyfriend. - So Damien, 485 00:20:15,066 --> 00:20:17,836 did you ever, uh, see a face, get a name? 486 00:20:17,902 --> 00:20:19,271 (intriguing music) - No, but I heard his voice. 487 00:20:19,337 --> 00:20:20,805 He was annoying. 488 00:20:20,872 --> 00:20:22,340 Told the same story over and over. 489 00:20:22,407 --> 00:20:24,276 So our pizza box was red, right? 490 00:20:24,342 --> 00:20:26,344 Every time Kat took it inside, 491 00:20:26,411 --> 00:20:28,346 he would make a comment on how it was 492 00:20:28,413 --> 00:20:31,650 the exact same colour of his fancy cottage in Newfoundland. 493 00:20:31,716 --> 00:20:34,719 So when I told Ivy about it, she got really tense. 494 00:20:34,786 --> 00:20:37,022 Said she needed to talk to her professor right away. 495 00:20:37,088 --> 00:20:38,890 - Hmm. Funny. 496 00:20:38,957 --> 00:20:42,160 He didn't tell us that. 497 00:20:44,329 --> 00:20:46,097 (indistinct chatter afar) 498 00:20:46,164 --> 00:20:47,832 - Morris. What are you doing here? 499 00:20:47,899 --> 00:20:50,602 - I, uh, came to grab some of my research. 500 00:20:50,669 --> 00:20:51,603 - Well, you won't need it. 501 00:20:51,670 --> 00:20:53,104 Out of respect for Ivy, 502 00:20:53,171 --> 00:20:54,706 I'm cancelling this seminar for good. 503 00:20:54,773 --> 00:20:57,375 (scoffing): But what about our grades? 504 00:20:57,442 --> 00:20:59,144 - Is that all you can think about? Your grades? 505 00:21:00,278 --> 00:21:02,747 (chuckling): What kind of question is that, man? 506 00:21:02,814 --> 00:21:04,616 What's wrong with you? 507 00:21:04,683 --> 00:21:06,851 - Uh... 508 00:21:06,918 --> 00:21:08,987 Uh, I'm sorry. You're right. 509 00:21:09,688 --> 00:21:10,422 - Hang on, hang on. 510 00:21:10,488 --> 00:21:13,024 I'm sorry. It's, um... 511 00:21:13,091 --> 00:21:14,426 Marks are gonna be determined 512 00:21:14,492 --> 00:21:16,227 based on the work that's already been submitted. 513 00:21:16,294 --> 00:21:18,596 You're okay. Don't worry. 514 00:21:20,632 --> 00:21:23,501 - So you've never heard of Damien Aku. 515 00:21:23,568 --> 00:21:25,704 - No, Ivy never mentioned meeting anyone named, 516 00:21:25,770 --> 00:21:28,440 Damien Aku and... 517 00:21:28,506 --> 00:21:30,575 I would never condone reaching out to a stranger 518 00:21:30,642 --> 00:21:33,244 about the cold case. - Really? 519 00:21:33,311 --> 00:21:36,681 'Cause Damien told us that Ivy's first priority 520 00:21:36,748 --> 00:21:39,951 was to report back to you about a new suspect. 521 00:21:40,018 --> 00:21:42,220 - Well, she may have sent an email. 522 00:21:42,287 --> 00:21:44,189 Maybe it ended up in my junk box. 523 00:21:44,255 --> 00:21:46,591 I don't know, my inbox is a mess. 524 00:21:46,658 --> 00:21:47,826 I haven't had time to go through-- 525 00:21:47,892 --> 00:21:49,794 - Sorry, this is the first new clue in years 526 00:21:49,861 --> 00:21:51,162 and you haven't had time? 527 00:21:51,229 --> 00:21:53,598 - I'm saying I didn't know there was a new clue. 528 00:21:53,665 --> 00:21:54,933 - Oh, okay. Well, that's all right. 529 00:21:54,999 --> 00:21:56,334 You know what, we can fill you in. 530 00:21:56,401 --> 00:22:00,939 Uh, so Ivy found out that Kat had a secret boyfriend. 531 00:22:01,005 --> 00:22:03,141 (suspenseful music) Now, we don't know his name. 532 00:22:03,208 --> 00:22:05,510 - Oh, but we do know that he owns some 533 00:22:05,577 --> 00:22:07,278 pretty stunning property. 534 00:22:07,345 --> 00:22:08,913 - Yeah, a red cottage in Newfoundland. 535 00:22:08,980 --> 00:22:11,282 - Kinda like this one. 536 00:22:11,349 --> 00:22:15,186 (sighing) (suspenseful music continues) 537 00:22:15,253 --> 00:22:19,157 - Were you dating Kat Berman, Professor Poole? 538 00:22:19,224 --> 00:22:21,760 - And what did you do when Ivy found out? 539 00:22:23,895 --> 00:22:27,732 We know he took a sabbatical from Osler in 2019, 540 00:22:27,799 --> 00:22:29,634 moved to Kingston to write a book on the penitentiary. 541 00:22:29,701 --> 00:22:31,469 (suspenseful music) Same year Kat was killed. 542 00:22:31,536 --> 00:22:32,804 - Yeah, Kat worked in a library 543 00:22:32,871 --> 00:22:34,639 that housed some of the penitentiary archives. 544 00:22:34,706 --> 00:22:36,274 They might have met there. 545 00:22:36,341 --> 00:22:38,977 We haven't confirmed it, but after Kat was killed, 546 00:22:39,043 --> 00:22:41,112 Garrett Poole went back home 547 00:22:41,179 --> 00:22:42,747 and eventually started the Cold Case Club. 548 00:22:42,814 --> 00:22:45,150 - It's possible he was simply interested in the case. 549 00:22:45,216 --> 00:22:46,351 They lived in the same city. 550 00:22:46,418 --> 00:22:47,952 Maybe he read about it in the newspaper-- 551 00:22:48,019 --> 00:22:49,988 - Yes, but now we're thinking that he was sleeping with Kat. 552 00:22:50,054 --> 00:22:53,358 So, he's either obsessed with the woman he loved... 553 00:22:53,425 --> 00:22:57,629 - Or he's a, uh, murdering narcissist who's 554 00:22:57,695 --> 00:23:00,365 spent the last three years daring his students 555 00:23:00,432 --> 00:23:01,966 to catch him. 556 00:23:02,033 --> 00:23:04,035 - Who the hell are we dealing with? 557 00:23:04,102 --> 00:23:06,070 - We're about to find out. 558 00:23:10,875 --> 00:23:14,546 - Yes, I was sleeping with Kat Berman in 2019. 559 00:23:14,612 --> 00:23:16,848 Our relationship has nothing to do with her murder. 560 00:23:16,915 --> 00:23:18,917 I didn't kill her. I loved her. 561 00:23:18,983 --> 00:23:22,720 - You used her murder as fodder for a university class. 562 00:23:22,787 --> 00:23:25,023 - I wanna solve the case. - So did Ivy. 563 00:23:25,089 --> 00:23:26,724 And from the looks of it, 564 00:23:26,791 --> 00:23:29,360 she got dangerously close to the truth. 565 00:23:29,427 --> 00:23:31,930 Uh, we got a warrant to search your communication 566 00:23:31,996 --> 00:23:35,733 and, oh, you weren't lying about your inbox being a mess. 567 00:23:35,800 --> 00:23:39,370 But, uh, we found this in your trash. 568 00:23:39,437 --> 00:23:41,940 - What is this, uh, Ivy's email? 569 00:23:42,006 --> 00:23:44,275 The one that, uh, you couldn't find. 570 00:23:44,342 --> 00:23:45,443 - Hmm. - It was sent 571 00:23:45,510 --> 00:23:46,711 the night she was killed, but forgive me, 572 00:23:46,778 --> 00:23:50,381 I-I left my glasses on my desk. 573 00:23:50,448 --> 00:23:53,284 Perhaps you could read it out to us. 574 00:23:53,351 --> 00:23:56,821 (soft electrical buzzing) 575 00:23:58,623 --> 00:24:00,692 - "I know you were dating Kat." 576 00:24:02,160 --> 00:24:04,329 (suspenseful music) 577 00:24:04,395 --> 00:24:06,965 This isn't what this looks like. Come on. 578 00:24:07,031 --> 00:24:10,602 - No? Because you deleted a very clear message from Ivy 579 00:24:10,668 --> 00:24:13,505 that would give you a very clear motive for murder. 580 00:24:13,571 --> 00:24:15,940 - And let's face it, it might be easier just to get rid of her 581 00:24:16,007 --> 00:24:18,643 than to, uh, have to track down and destroy 582 00:24:18,710 --> 00:24:22,580 2,000 copies of a book with a very damning detail on it. 583 00:24:22,647 --> 00:24:24,082 (chuckling) 584 00:24:24,148 --> 00:24:27,151 - I did not kill Ivy out of some kind of self-preservation 585 00:24:27,218 --> 00:24:29,487 because I did not kill Kat. 586 00:24:29,554 --> 00:24:30,588 Do you understand? 587 00:24:30,655 --> 00:24:32,390 - Then why would you lie to us? 588 00:24:32,457 --> 00:24:34,092 - Do you have any idea how hard it is 589 00:24:34,158 --> 00:24:35,460 to be a male professor these days? 590 00:24:35,527 --> 00:24:37,729 (chuckling) 591 00:24:40,698 --> 00:24:43,968 I did not want the fact that I slept with Kat to get out. 592 00:24:44,035 --> 00:24:45,770 Okay? It's not because I killed her, 593 00:24:45,837 --> 00:24:48,206 it's because I would be ruined. I'd be cancelled. 594 00:24:48,273 --> 00:24:49,307 I would lose everything. 595 00:24:49,374 --> 00:24:50,043 (lowly): Yeah, but Ivy still knew. 596 00:24:55,179 --> 00:24:55,980 Go after her? 597 00:24:56,047 --> 00:24:57,615 - Yeah, your office is very, 598 00:24:57,682 --> 00:24:58,816 very close to where she was killed. 599 00:24:58,883 --> 00:25:00,184 - Yeah, but I wasn't at my office. 600 00:25:00,251 --> 00:25:01,486 - Where were you? 601 00:25:01,553 --> 00:25:03,187 - I was with a colleague at her office. 602 00:25:03,254 --> 00:25:04,856 - Who? - Sarah Nielson. 603 00:25:04,923 --> 00:25:06,658 I'm working with her on my new book. 604 00:25:06,724 --> 00:25:09,561 I was with her from 9:30 to midnight. 605 00:25:10,128 --> 00:25:11,696 - Sarah Nielson the campus therapist? 606 00:25:11,763 --> 00:25:15,934 - Did you know that, um, Sarah was treating Ivy? 607 00:25:17,735 --> 00:25:20,772 - I mean... (suspenseful music continues) 608 00:25:22,340 --> 00:25:23,508 Yes. 609 00:25:23,575 --> 00:25:24,876 - How? 610 00:25:26,778 --> 00:25:28,279 - 'Cause I introduced them. 611 00:25:28,346 --> 00:25:30,548 (scoffing) 612 00:25:30,615 --> 00:25:33,985 - Do you hand pick all your students' therapists? 613 00:25:34,052 --> 00:25:35,553 (chuckling) 614 00:25:36,688 --> 00:25:39,624 - Maybe you got your pal to talk to Ivy 615 00:25:39,691 --> 00:25:41,826 for the same reason you trashed that email. 616 00:25:41,893 --> 00:25:44,462 Because you didn't want the world to know 617 00:25:44,529 --> 00:25:48,466 that you and Ivy were also in a sexual relationship. 618 00:25:48,533 --> 00:25:49,901 - Yeah, that would make you two for two. 619 00:25:49,968 --> 00:25:53,037 That's two relationships, two students. 620 00:25:53,104 --> 00:25:54,505 Both dead. 621 00:25:55,273 --> 00:25:56,741 - Ivy never told me 622 00:25:56,808 --> 00:25:58,509 that she and Garrett Poole were sleeping together. 623 00:25:58,576 --> 00:25:59,444 I'd have to report that. 624 00:25:59,510 --> 00:26:01,179 - Even though you're friends? 625 00:26:01,245 --> 00:26:02,847 - I think that outweighs friendships, Detective. 626 00:26:02,914 --> 00:26:04,215 So do morals. 627 00:26:04,282 --> 00:26:06,584 - And the night Ivy was killed? 628 00:26:06,651 --> 00:26:08,252 - Well, Garrett was with me in my office 629 00:26:08,319 --> 00:26:09,687 till well after midnight. 630 00:26:09,754 --> 00:26:11,389 We were working on his new book. 631 00:26:11,456 --> 00:26:13,458 Whatever was happening with Ivy, 632 00:26:13,524 --> 00:26:16,127 Garrett's telling the truth about that night. 633 00:26:16,194 --> 00:26:18,463 - That's helpful, Sarah. Thank you. 634 00:26:18,529 --> 00:26:21,899 - Did forensics come back on those fibres in Ivy's hand? 635 00:26:21,966 --> 00:26:23,334 - I was just about to call you. 636 00:26:23,401 --> 00:26:27,572 They're from a cord used in retractable key card fobs. 637 00:26:27,639 --> 00:26:30,508 - What, like the one Poole used to let us into his office? 638 00:26:30,575 --> 00:26:32,910 - It looked long enough to wrap around Ivy's hand, 639 00:26:32,977 --> 00:26:34,112 cause rope burn. 640 00:26:34,178 --> 00:26:35,780 I knew we shouldn't have let him go. 641 00:26:35,847 --> 00:26:38,349 - No, the man had an alibi, it was verified. 642 00:26:38,416 --> 00:26:42,186 - But if you find the cord, I can test it for Ivy's DNA. 643 00:26:42,253 --> 00:26:43,655 - Thanks, Lucy. Standby. 644 00:26:45,590 --> 00:26:49,394 Okay, you two. We need to be very strategic here 645 00:26:49,460 --> 00:26:51,562 because whether or not there's DNA on that cord... 646 00:26:51,629 --> 00:26:53,731 - Poole's alibi still stands. 647 00:26:53,798 --> 00:26:55,266 - However, in my experience, even the most 648 00:26:55,333 --> 00:26:57,468 bulletproof of alibis will weaken 649 00:26:57,535 --> 00:27:00,338 when faced with a fear of obstructing justice. 650 00:27:00,405 --> 00:27:03,908 - So if we tell ethical, moral Sarah 651 00:27:03,975 --> 00:27:05,309 that we've got some evidence against Poole, 652 00:27:05,376 --> 00:27:07,078 she might bend. 653 00:27:07,145 --> 00:27:10,615 - And if you gild the lily by showing her a little more 654 00:27:10,682 --> 00:27:12,750 of the horror of the crime she's covering up... 655 00:27:12,817 --> 00:27:14,819 - Hmm, she might break. 656 00:27:14,886 --> 00:27:18,022 Can you, uh, put a SPIN team on Poole? 657 00:27:18,089 --> 00:27:19,257 - Nothing I'd rather do. 658 00:27:19,323 --> 00:27:20,591 Go break that alibi. 659 00:27:23,394 --> 00:27:24,762 (whispering): Garrett. 660 00:27:25,797 --> 00:27:27,799 Thank God they released you. You okay? 661 00:27:27,865 --> 00:27:29,801 - Yeah, I'm fine. I'm fine. 662 00:27:29,867 --> 00:27:32,503 Thanks for talking to the cops. You're a lifesaver. 663 00:27:33,905 --> 00:27:35,573 - Um... 664 00:27:36,340 --> 00:27:37,241 Garrett. 665 00:27:37,308 --> 00:27:38,643 - Yeah? 666 00:27:38,710 --> 00:27:41,279 - Is there anything that you wanna tell me? 667 00:27:41,345 --> 00:27:42,280 - About what? 668 00:27:42,346 --> 00:27:43,748 - About Ivy? 669 00:27:45,216 --> 00:27:46,284 Garrett. 670 00:27:46,350 --> 00:27:47,318 (whispering): I just lied for you. 671 00:27:47,385 --> 00:27:48,352 - Hey. 672 00:27:48,419 --> 00:27:50,455 (suspenseful music) 673 00:27:50,521 --> 00:27:52,323 You know I didn't hurt her. 674 00:27:52,390 --> 00:27:53,524 Right? 675 00:27:53,591 --> 00:27:54,726 You know that. 676 00:27:54,792 --> 00:27:56,494 (whispering): Of course you didn't! 677 00:27:56,561 --> 00:27:58,196 But... I-- - But nothing. 678 00:27:58,262 --> 00:28:00,498 Why should we give some myopic cop 679 00:28:00,565 --> 00:28:03,067 anyone who have opportunity to pin this on me? 680 00:28:03,134 --> 00:28:06,404 I left your office, I was out walking around the campus. 681 00:28:06,471 --> 00:28:09,807 Ju-just processing all these great ideas that you had 682 00:28:09,874 --> 00:28:12,643 for the last chapter, you know? 683 00:28:12,710 --> 00:28:14,746 You're amazing, you know that, right? 684 00:28:14,812 --> 00:28:16,647 - Oh, stop. 685 00:28:16,714 --> 00:28:18,483 - God, I'm so lucky to have you. 686 00:28:18,549 --> 00:28:19,984 - What do you mean? 687 00:28:20,051 --> 00:28:25,356 (chuckling): I mean... you're loyal and you're... 688 00:28:25,423 --> 00:28:28,726 You're faithful and you're... 689 00:28:28,793 --> 00:28:30,528 you're so smart. 690 00:28:30,595 --> 00:28:32,630 It's just pure. 691 00:28:32,697 --> 00:28:33,998 There's no silliness. 692 00:28:34,065 --> 00:28:36,934 There's no messy feelings getting in the way. 693 00:28:42,640 --> 00:28:44,308 - Why are you showing me these? 694 00:28:44,375 --> 00:28:46,811 - Because we believe your friend Garrett Poole 695 00:28:46,878 --> 00:28:48,513 did that to Ivy Abbott. 696 00:28:48,579 --> 00:28:50,047 - That's-that's impossible. 697 00:28:50,114 --> 00:28:51,649 I told you that we were together. 698 00:28:51,716 --> 00:28:55,119 - It's amazing what people will do to protect a friend. 699 00:28:57,155 --> 00:28:59,290 (suspenseful music) (glasses clicking) 700 00:28:59,357 --> 00:29:00,892 What do you have in your pocket? 701 00:29:00,958 --> 00:29:01,993 Come on, show me. 702 00:29:05,163 --> 00:29:06,964 (objects clinking softly) 703 00:29:07,031 --> 00:29:09,433 Okay, so you're by yourself. 704 00:29:09,500 --> 00:29:10,902 It's nighttime. 705 00:29:10,968 --> 00:29:12,436 Someone's following you. 706 00:29:12,503 --> 00:29:15,506 Out of all of this, what do you use to defend yourself? 707 00:29:17,508 --> 00:29:19,544 So they have a knife. 708 00:29:20,945 --> 00:29:22,079 You have a pen. 709 00:29:22,146 --> 00:29:24,549 - I mean, compared to you right now, 710 00:29:24,615 --> 00:29:26,651 Ivy was lucky. She had her keys on her. 711 00:29:26,717 --> 00:29:29,086 Intertwined them between her fingers 712 00:29:29,153 --> 00:29:31,722 in the hope that she could take a swing and then run. 713 00:29:31,789 --> 00:29:33,191 But she didn't. 714 00:29:33,257 --> 00:29:35,259 'Cause someone stabbed her in the side of the neck 715 00:29:35,326 --> 00:29:37,562 before she got the chance. 716 00:29:37,628 --> 00:29:39,197 (shakily): Why would Garrett do this? 717 00:29:39,263 --> 00:29:41,766 - Well, Ivy learned that there was another student 718 00:29:41,833 --> 00:29:44,902 he was involved with who also wound up dead. 719 00:29:44,969 --> 00:29:46,470 Kat Berman, six years ago. 720 00:29:46,537 --> 00:29:47,738 - There were more? 721 00:29:47,805 --> 00:29:49,907 I knew about Ivy. 722 00:29:49,974 --> 00:29:50,043 - Wait. You knew that Poole was sleeping with Ivy? 723 00:29:54,843 --> 00:29:54,912 Why are you wasting our time? 724 00:29:56,180 --> 00:29:57,215 - Okay. 725 00:29:58,883 --> 00:30:00,418 Ivy told me. 726 00:30:00,484 --> 00:30:04,355 I was horrified, but I couldn't always trust what she said. 727 00:30:04,422 --> 00:30:06,924 I told her it wasn't appropriate 728 00:30:06,991 --> 00:30:09,527 and she told me that she was too scared to break up with him. 729 00:30:09,594 --> 00:30:12,196 Now I could never imagine Garrett threatening a woman. 730 00:30:12,263 --> 00:30:15,066 - Well, this looks more than a threat, doesn't it? 731 00:30:16,434 --> 00:30:17,969 - Garrett wouldn't-- - Hurt anyone? 732 00:30:18,035 --> 00:30:19,370 Come on, Sarah. 733 00:30:19,437 --> 00:30:22,340 Predators don't just hide in the shadows. 734 00:30:22,406 --> 00:30:25,009 They're in nice offices in nice homes, 735 00:30:25,076 --> 00:30:26,811 in positions of power. 736 00:30:26,878 --> 00:30:29,547 - And you are enabling him. 737 00:30:31,482 --> 00:30:32,383 Why? 738 00:30:33,818 --> 00:30:35,887 - I didn't want Garrett to be ruined. 739 00:30:36,554 --> 00:30:40,024 What if Garrett was telling the truth? What if Ivy was lying? 740 00:30:41,392 --> 00:30:42,426 - But she wasn't. 741 00:30:42,493 --> 00:30:45,296 So don't lie for him. 742 00:30:46,063 --> 00:30:47,131 (exhaling deeply) 743 00:30:47,198 --> 00:30:48,532 (inhaling sharply) 744 00:30:51,502 --> 00:30:54,839 - Garrett was in my office with my until 11 PM. 745 00:30:54,906 --> 00:30:57,041 (dramatic music) 746 00:30:57,108 --> 00:30:59,443 I'm sorry. 747 00:30:59,510 --> 00:31:01,412 I never thought that he could do something like this, 748 00:31:01,479 --> 00:31:04,649 so when he asked me to say that we were together until midnight, 749 00:31:05,816 --> 00:31:07,585 I said okay. (knocking at door) 750 00:31:09,220 --> 00:31:10,254 - Detectives, a word. 751 00:31:10,321 --> 00:31:12,757 (office phones ringing) 752 00:31:12,823 --> 00:31:14,926 SPIN team just called. Poole is on the move, 753 00:31:14,992 --> 00:31:17,194 he's got a suitcase with him. 754 00:31:17,261 --> 00:31:18,763 I'll deal with Sarah, you go. 755 00:31:18,829 --> 00:31:20,598 (dramatic music) 756 00:31:24,936 --> 00:31:27,104 - There he is. We need his key fob. 757 00:31:28,572 --> 00:31:30,675 - Doctor Poole. 758 00:31:30,741 --> 00:31:33,678 - Garrett Poole. Police. Stop! 759 00:31:33,744 --> 00:31:34,845 (grunting) 760 00:31:37,281 --> 00:31:38,849 - What the hell is going on here? 761 00:31:38,916 --> 00:31:40,418 I didn't do anything. (handcuffs clinking) 762 00:31:40,484 --> 00:31:41,919 - We'll see about that. 763 00:31:41,986 --> 00:31:43,254 - Garrett Poole, you're under arrest 764 00:31:43,321 --> 00:31:45,489 for the murder of Ivy Abbott. 765 00:31:45,556 --> 00:31:48,659 (dramatic music) 766 00:31:53,798 --> 00:31:55,333 - I was headed to Union Station. 767 00:31:55,399 --> 00:31:58,769 I'm catching a train to go to Hudson Valley to see a friend. 768 00:31:58,836 --> 00:32:00,104 I'm not guilty of anything. 769 00:32:00,171 --> 00:32:01,739 - Well, the jury's out on that, 770 00:32:01,806 --> 00:32:03,274 but we'll have a clearer picture 771 00:32:03,341 --> 00:32:05,676 once forensics comes back with the key fob. 772 00:32:05,743 --> 00:32:08,245 You see, we believe it was the last thing that 773 00:32:08,312 --> 00:32:10,781 Ivy Abbott grabbed for before she died. 774 00:32:10,848 --> 00:32:13,184 - You knew it was only a matter of time 775 00:32:13,250 --> 00:32:15,419 before Ivy outed you as Kat's killer, 776 00:32:15,486 --> 00:32:18,022 so you got rid of her to save yourself! 777 00:32:18,089 --> 00:32:19,290 - I didn't kill Ivy! (knocking at door) 778 00:32:19,357 --> 00:32:22,026 I didn't kill Kat. I told you. I love them. 779 00:32:22,093 --> 00:32:23,394 Both of them! 780 00:32:23,461 --> 00:32:25,463 - You preyed on two young students 781 00:32:25,529 --> 00:32:27,031 and both have ended up dead. 782 00:32:27,098 --> 00:32:28,232 (door shutting) 783 00:32:28,299 --> 00:32:30,434 - Is that the results? The DNA test? 784 00:32:30,501 --> 00:32:31,535 What does it say? 785 00:32:32,436 --> 00:32:33,804 (insistently): What does it say? 786 00:32:35,573 --> 00:32:36,607 (sighing) 787 00:32:38,809 --> 00:32:40,778 - Negative for Ivy's DNA. 788 00:32:40,845 --> 00:32:42,413 - Yeah, I told you! 789 00:32:42,480 --> 00:32:44,582 I told you I didn't kill anyone! 790 00:32:44,648 --> 00:32:46,050 - Then why did you ask a colleague 791 00:32:46,117 --> 00:32:48,252 to fabricate an alibi for you? 792 00:32:48,319 --> 00:32:50,254 - I didn't ask her to do that. 793 00:32:50,321 --> 00:32:51,956 It was her idea. 794 00:32:52,523 --> 00:32:56,060 - So, she just came up with this whole plan all by herself. 795 00:32:56,127 --> 00:32:57,395 Why? 796 00:32:57,461 --> 00:32:59,096 - Sarah is a friend. 797 00:32:59,163 --> 00:33:01,065 Okay? She's a close friend. 798 00:33:01,132 --> 00:33:03,167 She adores me. She'd do anything for me. 799 00:33:03,234 --> 00:33:06,103 So when we found out that Ivy was killed, 800 00:33:06,170 --> 00:33:07,738 a student we both knew, 801 00:33:07,805 --> 00:33:11,342 Sarah suggested that we just say we were together. 802 00:33:11,409 --> 00:33:12,843 You know? Just to keep things tidy. 803 00:33:14,011 --> 00:33:15,746 (inhaling sharply): So one more time. 804 00:33:16,647 --> 00:33:17,815 Where were you? 805 00:33:17,882 --> 00:33:20,584 - At 11 o'clock, I went out for a walk. 806 00:33:20,651 --> 00:33:23,254 And Sarah stayed behind and worked on my edits. 807 00:33:26,991 --> 00:33:28,459 (suspenseful music) - Leaving you both alone 808 00:33:28,526 --> 00:33:32,229 and unaccounted for at the time of Ivy Abbott's murder. 809 00:33:33,230 --> 00:33:34,999 Let's get Sarah's interview up. 810 00:33:35,066 --> 00:33:36,333 - Yeah, I'm on it. 811 00:33:36,400 --> 00:33:39,136 (typing on keyboard) 812 00:33:39,203 --> 00:33:41,138 (staticky): What do you have in your pockets? 813 00:33:41,205 --> 00:33:42,840 Come on, show me. 814 00:33:44,008 --> 00:33:46,143 Hmm, okay, so. 815 00:33:46,210 --> 00:33:49,680 You're alone. It's nighttime. 816 00:33:49,747 --> 00:33:52,450 (suspenseful music continues) 817 00:33:55,486 --> 00:33:57,121 - The white key card. 818 00:33:57,188 --> 00:33:59,623 It's not the official blue one the rest of the staff have. 819 00:33:59,690 --> 00:34:01,859 It's temporary. - And she tried to hide it. 820 00:34:01,926 --> 00:34:04,195 Which mean she got rid of her official card 821 00:34:04,261 --> 00:34:06,163 and the fob that went with it. 822 00:34:06,230 --> 00:34:08,299 - And as Poole said, 823 00:34:09,433 --> 00:34:11,836 "She adores him. She'd do anything to help him." 824 00:34:13,137 --> 00:34:15,706 - Sarah Nielson was inside Ivy's head. 825 00:34:15,773 --> 00:34:17,641 - Yeah, she knew she could kill Ivy 826 00:34:17,708 --> 00:34:20,377 and point the finger at any number of people in Ivy's life. 827 00:34:20,444 --> 00:34:22,046 - Even pointed you two toward a stalker. 828 00:34:22,113 --> 00:34:24,248 - And all the while, she was covering for Poole, 829 00:34:24,315 --> 00:34:25,483 which also gave herself an alibi. 830 00:34:25,549 --> 00:34:27,351 - That's some fancy footwork. 831 00:34:27,418 --> 00:34:28,986 - Hmm. - But then for some reason, 832 00:34:29,053 --> 00:34:31,655 she decided to throw Poole under the bus. Why? 833 00:34:31,722 --> 00:34:34,225 - Oh, 'cause we offered him up as a patsy. 834 00:34:34,291 --> 00:34:37,728 And if Sarah's smart, uh, the only piece of hard evidence 835 00:34:37,795 --> 00:34:40,030 that we hoped to test is long gone. 836 00:34:40,097 --> 00:34:41,632 - Finding that fob wouldn't help. 837 00:34:41,699 --> 00:34:43,033 (sighing) 838 00:34:43,100 --> 00:34:44,702 I'm Sarah's defence lawyer. 839 00:34:44,768 --> 00:34:46,904 First thing I'd say, 840 00:34:46,971 --> 00:34:49,173 everyone at Osler has that fob. 841 00:34:49,240 --> 00:34:50,043 30,000 people could be your killer. 842 00:34:55,643 --> 00:34:56,580 your client has no alibi. 843 00:34:56,647 --> 00:34:59,150 - She was in her office. Working. 844 00:34:59,216 --> 00:35:01,652 - The therapists' offices don't have cameras. I checked. 845 00:35:01,719 --> 00:35:04,088 - Thank you, Counselor, but I have the floor. 846 00:35:04,155 --> 00:35:06,524 - Oh. - Hmm. 847 00:35:06,590 --> 00:35:08,959 - You don't have my client's prints on the murder weapon 848 00:35:09,026 --> 00:35:10,728 because you don't have a murder weapon. 849 00:35:10,794 --> 00:35:12,630 No sign of her on CCTV. 850 00:35:12,696 --> 00:35:14,732 At least not a recognizable Sarah. 851 00:35:14,798 --> 00:35:17,468 - Okay, but what is a recognizable Sarah? 852 00:35:17,535 --> 00:35:20,304 The woman is a cypher. I-I don't think I've seen 853 00:35:20,371 --> 00:35:22,573 the real Sarah this entire time. 854 00:35:22,640 --> 00:35:25,209 - This... This could be the real Sarah. 855 00:35:25,276 --> 00:35:28,045 Uh, this is Poole's one big book, right? Got him tenure, 856 00:35:28,112 --> 00:35:31,048 but it doesn't read like his earlier papers. 857 00:35:31,115 --> 00:35:32,650 Listen to this language: 858 00:35:32,716 --> 00:35:34,518 (suspenseful music) "As Anna Freud posited in 1936, 859 00:35:34,585 --> 00:35:36,620 defence mechanisms operate unconsciously 860 00:35:36,687 --> 00:35:37,955 to protect the ego. 861 00:35:38,022 --> 00:35:40,291 Repression, rejection, sublimation, displacement. 862 00:35:40,357 --> 00:35:44,195 Sigmund Freud swung at these conditions with a hammer. 863 00:35:44,261 --> 00:35:47,097 But Anna Freud believed in time, layers, and patience. 864 00:35:47,164 --> 00:35:50,067 She unpacked these emotions with care 865 00:35:50,134 --> 00:35:52,536 and painted them with a watercolour brush." 866 00:35:52,603 --> 00:35:55,706 - That's exactly what Sarah said to us when we first met. 867 00:35:55,773 --> 00:35:58,075 You think that's her research? 868 00:35:58,142 --> 00:35:59,710 - And she gave it all to Poole? 869 00:35:59,777 --> 00:36:02,213 - Romantic isn't it? - Yeah, certainly is. 870 00:36:02,279 --> 00:36:03,747 And that's how we break her. 871 00:36:05,349 --> 00:36:08,018 Thanks for meeting me here, Sarah. 872 00:36:08,085 --> 00:36:09,553 How you feeling? 873 00:36:10,521 --> 00:36:12,256 - I-I'm a little stunned. 874 00:36:12,323 --> 00:36:14,124 I can't believe Garrett said it was my idea 875 00:36:14,191 --> 00:36:15,626 to lie about his alibi. 876 00:36:15,693 --> 00:36:17,194 (sighing): Yeah, well, we saw right through that. 877 00:36:17,261 --> 00:36:18,996 - Well, I'm just glad that you caught him. 878 00:36:19,063 --> 00:36:20,531 - Yeah. (chuckling) 879 00:36:20,598 --> 00:36:22,466 But it's not over yet. 880 00:36:22,533 --> 00:36:24,435 We still have to put him behind bars and... 881 00:36:24,501 --> 00:36:29,807 And there are aspects of both Ivy and Kat's cases 882 00:36:29,873 --> 00:36:32,476 that we just still don't understand, so 883 00:36:32,543 --> 00:36:33,877 hoping you can help. 884 00:36:33,944 --> 00:36:34,979 - Well, I don't know Kat. 885 00:36:35,045 --> 00:36:36,513 - Oh, that's okay. 886 00:36:36,580 --> 00:36:38,983 Kat's murder was almost exactly like Ivy's 887 00:36:39,049 --> 00:36:40,751 and you know Ivy, you know Garrett. 888 00:36:40,818 --> 00:36:43,520 You're the expert here, not me. (chuckling) 889 00:36:43,587 --> 00:36:45,789 I'm-I'm so curious about your perspective. 890 00:36:45,856 --> 00:36:48,959 - Hmm, I've already told you everything I know. 891 00:36:49,026 --> 00:36:52,630 - Facts, yeah. But I'm looking for feelings. 892 00:36:52,696 --> 00:36:55,466 And you were practically inside their heads. 893 00:36:55,532 --> 00:36:59,703 I mean, you were Ivy's therapist and Garrett's muse. 894 00:36:59,770 --> 00:37:01,805 - What do you mean Garrett's muse? 895 00:37:03,173 --> 00:37:05,876 - Oh, Sarah. I... I read his book. 896 00:37:05,943 --> 00:37:09,346 Those chapters on defence mechanisms, impulsivity, 897 00:37:09,413 --> 00:37:11,248 emotional dysregulation. (intriguing music) 898 00:37:11,315 --> 00:37:12,816 That was all you. 899 00:37:12,883 --> 00:37:14,985 - No, no, no, no, no. That wasn't all me. 900 00:37:15,052 --> 00:37:17,154 We worked-we worked together. - On your ideas? 901 00:37:17,221 --> 00:37:18,922 - Well, I wanted to help him. 902 00:37:18,989 --> 00:37:22,526 - Yeah, like you helped him with his alibi? 903 00:37:23,927 --> 00:37:27,364 It's okay. I know it's not your fault. 904 00:37:27,431 --> 00:37:30,668 I think that Garrett was able to get away with these murders 905 00:37:30,734 --> 00:37:34,672 because he manipulated his victims. You included. 906 00:37:34,738 --> 00:37:36,106 This guy was very careful. 907 00:37:36,173 --> 00:37:38,108 - No, no. There's careful and then there's controlling. 908 00:37:38,175 --> 00:37:40,010 - Oh, what do you mean? 909 00:37:40,077 --> 00:37:41,045 - Well, Ivy mentioned that 910 00:37:41,111 --> 00:37:42,813 Garrett asked to track her phone. 911 00:37:42,880 --> 00:37:45,049 That's why she was so scared. - Wow. 912 00:37:45,115 --> 00:37:46,350 - He liked to lead in relationships. 913 00:37:46,417 --> 00:37:47,551 To have the upper hand. 914 00:37:47,618 --> 00:37:49,019 - Well, was he like that with you too? 915 00:37:49,086 --> 00:37:51,255 In your relationship? 916 00:37:51,322 --> 00:37:53,624 - Well, Garrett and I... we're just friends. 917 00:37:55,626 --> 00:37:56,660 - Really? (chuckling) 918 00:37:56,727 --> 00:37:58,195 Sarah, come on. 919 00:37:58,262 --> 00:38:00,364 I can tell when a woman is in love. 920 00:38:02,433 --> 00:38:05,502 And Garrett knew how you felt and he took advantage of that? 921 00:38:05,569 --> 00:38:07,671 - What are you suggesting? 922 00:38:07,738 --> 00:38:10,240 That I'm weak? (chuckling): No. God, no. 923 00:38:10,307 --> 00:38:12,976 No, I've, uh... 924 00:38:13,043 --> 00:38:14,812 I've been there myself. 925 00:38:14,878 --> 00:38:16,547 - Huh. 926 00:38:16,613 --> 00:38:19,783 - My rookie year, I fell absolutely head over heels 927 00:38:19,850 --> 00:38:21,885 with a guy that I worked with. 928 00:38:21,952 --> 00:38:24,788 (emotionally): I became obsessed. 929 00:38:24,855 --> 00:38:27,391 I memorized his schedule, I followed him around, 930 00:38:27,458 --> 00:38:29,593 I would make excuses to work together... 931 00:38:29,660 --> 00:38:31,428 - Did he like you back? 932 00:38:31,495 --> 00:38:33,564 - He liked my work. 933 00:38:33,630 --> 00:38:38,102 He liked it so much that sometimes he would claim it. 934 00:38:38,168 --> 00:38:39,937 (sighing): As his own. 935 00:38:40,003 --> 00:38:41,572 - Hmm. 936 00:38:41,638 --> 00:38:45,776 - Yeah, eventually he did. He did want more than just my work. 937 00:38:45,843 --> 00:38:47,077 - So he did like you back. 938 00:38:47,144 --> 00:38:49,313 (weakly): Mm-hmm. Yeah. 939 00:38:49,380 --> 00:38:52,649 But, uh, he didn't like me enough to get serious 940 00:38:52,716 --> 00:38:57,388 'cause, uh, turns out he was married the entire time. 941 00:38:57,454 --> 00:38:58,389 - Oh. 942 00:38:58,455 --> 00:39:00,824 - And I wanted a kid. 943 00:39:00,891 --> 00:39:02,292 I wanted a family. 944 00:39:02,359 --> 00:39:03,460 - That's terrible. 945 00:39:03,527 --> 00:39:05,662 At least Garrett isn't married. 946 00:39:05,729 --> 00:39:09,466 - Well, no. 947 00:39:09,533 --> 00:39:11,402 He is otherwise engaged. 948 00:39:11,468 --> 00:39:14,304 He spends his time on frivolous things, 949 00:39:14,371 --> 00:39:16,940 but gives you just enough to hang on. 950 00:39:17,007 --> 00:39:20,010 Kind words, empty promises, and all the while, 951 00:39:20,077 --> 00:39:21,945 your time marches on, your window is closing. 952 00:39:22,012 --> 00:39:25,449 - I have always had feelings for Garrett. 953 00:39:25,516 --> 00:39:26,850 - Hmm. 954 00:39:26,917 --> 00:39:29,953 - But he... He said that we shouldn't cross the line 955 00:39:30,020 --> 00:39:31,288 that we were colleagues. 956 00:39:31,355 --> 00:39:33,390 - But he crosses the line with his students. 957 00:39:33,457 --> 00:39:34,792 - But that's none of my business. 958 00:39:34,858 --> 00:39:37,194 And I have-I have accepted that we're just friends. 959 00:39:37,261 --> 00:39:39,129 - No, friends don't steal their friend's work. 960 00:39:39,196 --> 00:39:41,298 Friends don't use their friends 961 00:39:41,365 --> 00:39:44,468 to try to cover up their affairs with students. 962 00:39:44,535 --> 00:39:48,172 And friends don't blame their friends for their crimes. 963 00:39:48,238 --> 00:39:50,507 (suspenseful music) 964 00:39:50,574 --> 00:39:53,177 Or maybe they do. 965 00:39:53,243 --> 00:39:58,515 See, I think you might be doing exactly that to Garrett. 966 00:39:58,582 --> 00:40:00,517 - What are you talking about? 967 00:40:00,584 --> 00:40:04,955 - Sarah, how would you define projection? 968 00:40:05,022 --> 00:40:07,724 - It's when someone attributes their own undesirable feelings, 969 00:40:07,791 --> 00:40:09,626 thoughts, and behaviours to somebody else. 970 00:40:09,693 --> 00:40:12,996 - Okay, so when you suggested that Ivy was Borderline 971 00:40:13,063 --> 00:40:15,232 with a touch of Paranoid Personality Disorder 972 00:40:15,299 --> 00:40:18,068 and intense emotions, and fear of abandonment, 973 00:40:18,135 --> 00:40:19,736 impulsivity, delusions-- 974 00:40:19,803 --> 00:40:21,839 - I am not delusional, Detective. 975 00:40:21,905 --> 00:40:26,510 And I-I actually I've done nothing but try to help you. 976 00:40:26,577 --> 00:40:28,846 - Yeah. Well, you've been very helpful. 977 00:40:28,912 --> 00:40:32,182 Yeah, when you wanted me to trust you and like you, 978 00:40:32,249 --> 00:40:34,751 you told me everything I wanted to hear. 979 00:40:34,818 --> 00:40:37,521 But I've read your notes and I've made some of my own 980 00:40:37,588 --> 00:40:41,725 and I think all those things you were saying about Ivy... 981 00:40:42,826 --> 00:40:44,795 ...you were really talking about yourself. 982 00:40:44,862 --> 00:40:46,196 - Huh. 983 00:40:47,431 --> 00:40:48,499 - Sarah, stop. 984 00:40:48,565 --> 00:40:50,200 - No, no, no, no, no, no. I'm done here. 985 00:40:50,267 --> 00:40:51,768 From the moment that I walked into that office, 986 00:40:51,835 --> 00:40:53,036 you've been trying to manipulate me. 987 00:40:53,103 --> 00:40:55,339 - And now you are trying to turn the tables 988 00:40:55,405 --> 00:40:58,108 with anger and contempt and it's not gonna work. 989 00:40:58,175 --> 00:41:00,377 - Was that your attempt at empathizing in there? 990 00:41:00,444 --> 00:41:01,879 At relating? 991 00:41:01,945 --> 00:41:03,514 God, you are so out of your depth. 992 00:41:03,580 --> 00:41:04,448 You should be embarrassed. 993 00:41:04,515 --> 00:41:06,216 - See, you're projecting again. 994 00:41:06,283 --> 00:41:08,919 You've been carrying a torch for that man for 10 years. 995 00:41:08,986 --> 00:41:11,221 10 years of him stealing your work, 996 00:41:11,288 --> 00:41:15,058 tossing you scraps while he screws his students. 997 00:41:15,125 --> 00:41:17,794 And you know it's shameful and you still can't stop. 998 00:41:17,861 --> 00:41:19,162 - I don't need Garrett. 999 00:41:19,229 --> 00:41:21,231 - No, you don't, but you want him. 1000 00:41:21,298 --> 00:41:24,067 You want him fully and forever and you know he wants you too. 1001 00:41:24,134 --> 00:41:26,270 He just needed a little nudge. 1002 00:41:26,336 --> 00:41:29,139 You know that one day he's gonna wake up 1003 00:41:29,206 --> 00:41:31,642 and look at you and see what is right in front of him. 1004 00:41:31,708 --> 00:41:33,143 What's been here all along. 1005 00:41:33,210 --> 00:41:35,812 You just needed those girls to get out of the way. 1006 00:41:35,879 --> 00:41:37,447 They're baubles. 1007 00:41:37,514 --> 00:41:39,483 They're trinkets. 1008 00:41:39,550 --> 00:41:41,451 But you... You are the real thing. 1009 00:41:43,487 --> 00:41:46,857 So you stabbed Kat outside her house, 1010 00:41:46,924 --> 00:41:49,660 you tracked Ivy's phone and you killed her. 1011 00:41:49,726 --> 00:41:51,128 - No, no. You have no proof. 1012 00:41:51,194 --> 00:41:53,830 - I know that you threw away your key card. 1013 00:41:53,897 --> 00:41:57,568 And Ivy was smart. She grabbed it, didn't she? 1014 00:41:57,634 --> 00:42:00,304 As she was dying? 'Cause in her last moments, 1015 00:42:00,370 --> 00:42:02,439 she wanted to leave a trace. Someone, stop her, 1016 00:42:02,506 --> 00:42:04,308 please stop this monster-- 1017 00:42:04,374 --> 00:42:06,977 - Ivy-Ivy was a child, okay? An idiotic fool. 1018 00:42:07,044 --> 00:42:09,680 And she thought that Garrett was gonna, what? 1019 00:42:09,746 --> 00:42:11,348 Leave his job and marry her? 1020 00:42:11,415 --> 00:42:12,983 I tried to play nice. - How? 1021 00:42:13,050 --> 00:42:15,185 - I told her to leave. I said leave town, 1022 00:42:15,252 --> 00:42:17,354 but she-she stuck around. She didn't listen. 1023 00:42:17,421 --> 00:42:19,356 - Garrett didn't listen either? - No! He never does. 1024 00:42:19,423 --> 00:42:21,224 I-I-I don't know what I have to do! 1025 00:42:21,291 --> 00:42:22,893 - And that's why you threw him under the bus. 1026 00:42:22,960 --> 00:42:24,661 To make him listen, to make him yours. 1027 00:42:24,728 --> 00:42:26,129 (dramatic music) - Yes! 1028 00:42:26,196 --> 00:42:29,333 Yes because then, then it would finally be me and him 1029 00:42:29,399 --> 00:42:32,069 and I would stand by him and I would visit him 1030 00:42:32,135 --> 00:42:34,871 and-and when he got out of prison he would know who... 1031 00:42:34,938 --> 00:42:36,974 He would know who really loved him. 1032 00:42:37,040 --> 00:42:38,842 (shaky breathing) 1033 00:42:42,245 --> 00:42:44,181 - I wonder if he's gonna visit you. 1034 00:42:45,382 --> 00:42:46,683 (handcuffs clinking) 1035 00:42:46,750 --> 00:42:48,986 (somber music) 1036 00:42:59,963 --> 00:43:01,398 - You okay? 1037 00:43:01,465 --> 00:43:03,200 - Yeah. 1038 00:43:03,266 --> 00:43:07,170 Think I used more hammer than I did watercolour. 1039 00:43:07,237 --> 00:43:10,140 (chuckling): Well, whatever the tool, 1040 00:43:10,207 --> 00:43:12,976 we still painted our killer into a corner. 1041 00:43:14,745 --> 00:43:16,980 - It's never easy to corner another woman. 1042 00:43:21,084 --> 00:43:26,223 (somber music continues) 1043 00:43:28,091 --> 00:43:32,496 (theme music)