1 00:01:53,251 --> 00:01:55,876 To acquire green wood, 2 00:01:56,084 --> 00:02:00,501 you have to force it away from him separate organic connection. 3 00:02:00,709 --> 00:02:04,709 However, when it comes to raffia wood nothing is separated from property. 4 00:02:04,918 --> 00:02:09,209 Only what is already separated from property is taken from property. 5 00:02:15,584 --> 00:02:20,376 And despite this essential The difference is that you both call theft 6 00:02:20,584 --> 00:02:23,251 and punished both as theft. 7 00:02:45,751 --> 00:02:49,293 There are two kinds of depravity, says Montesquieu. 8 00:02:49,959 --> 00:02:52,418 Forward! Faster! 9 00:02:53,209 --> 00:02:56,418 The one when the people not obeying the laws. 10 00:02:57,209 --> 00:03:00,543 The other if it corrupted by the laws. 11 00:03:28,459 --> 00:03:29,959 Running! 12 00:03:41,751 --> 00:03:46,168 You have the difference between Theft and collecting blurred. 13 00:03:46,376 --> 00:03:50,001 But you are wrong; if you believe; it is in your interest. 14 00:03:51,001 --> 00:03:55,209 The people feel the punishment but it does not see the crime. 15 00:04:00,418 --> 00:04:02,876 And because it sees no crime, 16 00:04:03,543 --> 00:04:07,126 where it is punished, you should fear it. 17 00:04:08,001 --> 00:04:09,543 Because it will take revenge. 18 00:04:11,001 --> 00:04:12,834 And, satisfied, Karl? 19 00:04:15,543 --> 00:04:17,501 Am I satisfied, Stirner? 20 00:04:19,876 --> 00:04:23,543 I don't know it. - Also because of you it has come to this. 21 00:04:23,751 --> 00:04:27,501 I am happy with two things. My article had an impact. 22 00:04:27,709 --> 00:04:32,001 And we can the Prussian despot finally look in the face. 23 00:04:32,209 --> 00:04:36,334 Should be banned, Newspapers and cutting us off? 24 00:04:36,543 --> 00:04:38,418 That we go to prison? 25 00:04:38,626 --> 00:04:42,418 I should have kept my mouth shut and should I be censored? 26 00:04:42,626 --> 00:04:45,543 Make do with innuendos like you? 27 00:04:45,751 --> 00:04:48,459 What are we the victims of? Of our success. 28 00:04:48,668 --> 00:04:51,293 We owe it to Karl's texts, admit it. 29 00:04:51,501 --> 00:04:56,126 And the result? We are dead. Nice success. Hats off. Bravo, Karl. 30 00:04:59,001 --> 00:05:02,709 We don't give up! Don't open! - They're massacring us! 31 00:05:04,834 --> 00:05:07,168 Shut up! Ending! 32 00:05:08,418 --> 00:05:10,418 Why are we afraid? 33 00:05:10,626 --> 00:05:14,834 You can kill the Rheinische Zeitung and shut our mouths. 34 00:05:15,043 --> 00:05:17,501 But they cannot kill thinking. 35 00:05:17,709 --> 00:05:19,209 We won't give in. 36 00:05:19,418 --> 00:05:21,876 We establish - a new newspaper. 37 00:05:22,084 --> 00:05:26,959 - Full of the same asses. - The Rheinische Zeitung full of idiots? 38 00:05:27,168 --> 00:05:31,876 A bunch of scrawls all over them World revolution without idea or concept. 39 00:05:34,876 --> 00:05:39,334 And what are you doing? You always want say everything through the flower. 40 00:05:39,543 --> 00:05:43,168 You write vague literary reviews, vague conclusions 41 00:05:43,376 --> 00:05:47,834 You take that back immediately! We've all had enough of your arrogance! 42 00:05:51,293 --> 00:05:52,793 Yes. 43 00:05:53,001 --> 00:05:55,168 I've had enough of you too, farmer. 44 00:05:55,376 --> 00:05:59,668 And from you “Young Hegelians” and “free spirits”. 45 00:05:59,876 --> 00:06:01,376 You clowns! 46 00:06:01,584 --> 00:06:04,459 - Karl... - Enough of the needle pricks. 47 00:06:04,668 --> 00:06:07,126 I want to fight with club blows! 48 00:06:07,334 --> 00:06:10,543 Enough of the hypocrisy, stupidity and brutal authority. 49 00:06:10,751 --> 00:06:13,918 - We are banned? Good this way. - What are you doing? 50 00:06:14,126 --> 00:06:17,293 A few nights behind bars will be good for us. 51 00:06:17,501 --> 00:06:20,209 Gentlemen, I'm ready. 52 00:06:20,418 --> 00:06:26,334 I didn't do anything! Let me go! 53 00:06:26,543 --> 00:06:28,043 Faster! 54 00:06:34,043 --> 00:06:36,793 Karl? I have an offer for you. 55 00:06:37,001 --> 00:06:39,334 Quiet! 56 00:06:44,876 --> 00:06:48,209 I want one found a new magazine. 57 00:06:48,418 --> 00:06:51,793 Different. Suitor. More modern. Braver. 58 00:06:54,376 --> 00:06:56,001 Paris. Would that be something for you? 59 00:07:16,251 --> 00:07:19,209 Two people have each other scalded on the steam loom. 60 00:07:19,418 --> 00:07:21,543 This has to stop! It's unbearable! 61 00:07:25,834 --> 00:07:28,001 Hey, you! Get out of the queue! 62 00:07:39,626 --> 00:07:41,334 Who cut that? 63 00:07:43,584 --> 00:07:48,043 Definitely the Irish bastards. 64 00:07:48,251 --> 00:07:50,501 What about Róisín? 65 00:07:50,709 --> 00:07:55,001 She fell asleep at the loom and suddenly her fingers were gone. 66 00:07:55,209 --> 00:07:57,334 Who will give her back her fingers? 67 00:07:57,543 --> 00:07:59,209 Do you allow? - Be quiet. 68 00:07:59,418 --> 00:08:01,501 You better watch out. 69 00:08:01,709 --> 00:08:05,209 You get paid to work not for sleeping! 70 00:08:05,834 --> 00:08:08,793 - Caution. They incite them. - Paid? 71 00:08:09,001 --> 00:08:11,584 With what? She hadn't slept for three days! 72 00:08:11,793 --> 00:08:15,043 And now you're letting them die. Do you call that work? 73 00:08:15,251 --> 00:08:17,043 Quiet! 74 00:08:17,709 --> 00:08:21,876 The repair will be paid for by you deducted. This is what you get now. 75 00:08:22,084 --> 00:08:25,709 Consider yourself lucky, that I don't dismiss you all. 76 00:08:26,334 --> 00:08:30,793 Repairs are expensive. Workers in Manchester are not. 77 00:08:32,418 --> 00:08:35,209 Ten fingers, We are not worth more. 78 00:08:35,418 --> 00:08:38,959 And without them we land in the junkyard, right? 79 00:08:39,626 --> 00:08:42,293 She is the one, who asked about Róisín. 80 00:08:42,501 --> 00:08:45,376 She is the leader. - What's her name again? 81 00:08:45,584 --> 00:08:48,584 Just ask me, boss. I have a mouth. 82 00:08:48,793 --> 00:08:51,501 And a cheeky mouth, it seems to me. 83 00:08:51,918 --> 00:08:54,459 My name is Mary Burns. 84 00:08:54,668 --> 00:08:56,584 Mary! 85 00:08:57,543 --> 00:08:59,168 Born in Tipperary. 86 00:08:59,376 --> 00:09:00,918 And now a slave 87 00:09:01,126 --> 00:09:04,793 in the Ermen and Engels spinning mill in Manchester, England. 88 00:09:09,501 --> 00:09:14,293 Throw them out. She can look for another bread provider. 89 00:09:14,501 --> 00:09:16,709 Have you heard? Out! 90 00:09:16,918 --> 00:09:20,376 Anyone else with big ideas, can go right away. 91 00:09:44,584 --> 00:09:46,084 No! 92 00:09:51,251 --> 00:09:53,584 You have to weed out the bad apples. 93 00:09:53,793 --> 00:09:58,751 I want a list with all troublemakers and rioters. 94 00:09:58,959 --> 00:10:00,959 Father, isn't it enough now? 95 00:10:04,126 --> 00:10:07,168 Do you want to explain to me how to run a factory? 96 00:10:07,376 --> 00:10:08,834 No, father. 97 00:10:09,043 --> 00:10:11,459 That's not part of my intentions. 98 00:11:23,001 --> 00:11:26,001 Excuse me, what's in there? - In there? 99 00:11:26,209 --> 00:11:28,626 The Irish. - Okay, thank you. 100 00:11:28,834 --> 00:11:31,876 In your place I would stay away. 101 00:11:34,126 --> 00:11:37,751 ♪ I found my lovely maiden 102 00:11:38,251 --> 00:11:42,168 ♪ One early summer morning 103 00:11:42,626 --> 00:11:45,918 ♪ Now I milk my cows 104 00:11:47,043 --> 00:11:50,793 ♪ And I'm off to Tipperary... 105 00:11:58,126 --> 00:12:00,834 May I introduce myself? - We know you. 106 00:12:01,043 --> 00:12:03,709 Be quiet. Why are you talking to him? 107 00:12:04,626 --> 00:12:07,876 - He's the factory owner's son. - Which manufacturer? 108 00:12:08,084 --> 00:12:12,543 Engels' son from the spinning mill Ermen and Engels in Bridgewater. 109 00:12:12,751 --> 00:12:17,543 Where we have worn ourselves out, until we got fired today. 110 00:12:17,751 --> 00:12:20,251 Yes, I am the angel son. 111 00:12:21,001 --> 00:12:25,043 My first name is Friedrich, but calls me Fred or Freddy. 112 00:12:25,251 --> 00:12:27,918 What do you want? You don't belong here. 113 00:12:28,126 --> 00:12:32,168 On the other side of the river there are enough pubs for gentlemen like you. 114 00:12:32,376 --> 00:12:34,959 gentlemen, who throw us out like dogs... 115 00:12:35,793 --> 00:12:38,501 Like the Irish dogs we are... 116 00:12:40,209 --> 00:12:43,418 All Irish dogs, right, Paddy? - Yes. 117 00:12:43,626 --> 00:12:48,418 One of them spits out chewing tobacco over the gentleman's shiny boots. 118 00:12:49,834 --> 00:12:54,001 I could handle that. And please don't call me gentleman. 119 00:12:54,209 --> 00:12:58,168 I am neither English nor gentleman. - What you don't say! 120 00:12:58,751 --> 00:13:00,959 I deeply despise gentlemen. 121 00:13:01,793 --> 00:13:05,668 They are pigs who are fattened by the sweat of the workers. 122 00:13:07,126 --> 00:13:09,084 He makes fun of us. 123 00:13:10,501 --> 00:13:14,334 Do you know what I believe? He's here to laugh at us. 124 00:13:15,418 --> 00:13:19,959 I have come to you to ask for your help. 125 00:13:20,168 --> 00:13:22,584 Our help? - How to help? 126 00:13:22,793 --> 00:13:26,293 I need it for my book First hand reports. 127 00:13:26,501 --> 00:13:27,918 He's writing a book? 128 00:13:28,751 --> 00:13:32,626 About the situation of the working class in Manchester and Leeds... 129 00:13:41,709 --> 00:13:44,126 Is that a gold watch? that you have there? 130 00:13:46,209 --> 00:13:50,876 - Whose sweat paid for it? - Leave it alone, Paddy. 131 00:13:51,084 --> 00:13:53,876 reports first hand do you want? 132 00:13:54,709 --> 00:13:57,251 This is a working man's hand, see? 133 00:13:57,876 --> 00:14:00,418 And it lands on your gentlemanly nose, 134 00:14:00,626 --> 00:14:04,334 if you don't leave immediately. So go. 135 00:14:13,251 --> 00:14:15,209 And if I prefer to stay? 136 00:14:27,918 --> 00:14:30,001 Are you okay, sir? 137 00:14:31,001 --> 00:14:32,876 Are you injured? 138 00:14:37,418 --> 00:14:38,501 Yes. 139 00:14:40,251 --> 00:14:42,209 In a wonderful way. 140 00:14:57,334 --> 00:14:58,834 What's wrong with her, Alphonsine? 141 00:14:59,043 --> 00:15:01,918 Nothing, Madam Jenny, she just woke up. 142 00:15:03,043 --> 00:15:04,543 Shhh... 143 00:15:06,043 --> 00:15:07,543 I'll take it. 144 00:15:14,376 --> 00:15:18,126 I don't trust Alphonsine. She steals from us. 145 00:15:18,876 --> 00:15:21,209 She's snooping around and she's fake. 146 00:15:21,418 --> 00:15:23,376 She can steal! 147 00:15:23,584 --> 00:15:26,001 We owe her two months. 148 00:15:27,918 --> 00:15:31,751 Lenchen, my Lenchen. 149 00:15:33,001 --> 00:15:35,168 If Lenchen could come to us. 150 00:15:48,209 --> 00:15:50,084 You long for Trier. 151 00:15:52,084 --> 00:15:53,584 No. 152 00:15:54,834 --> 00:15:56,334 To Lenchen. 153 00:15:59,251 --> 00:16:02,043 She was in Metz for three years, she gets along here. 154 00:16:02,251 --> 00:16:06,459 Your devoted servant, your big house, your big park, 155 00:16:06,668 --> 00:16:09,918 your family why did I rip you out of there? 156 00:16:10,126 --> 00:16:12,918 I can't even do it to be paid by Ruge. 157 00:16:13,126 --> 00:16:14,626 Karl! 158 00:16:15,334 --> 00:16:18,376 Do you know what your biggest mistake is? - What? 159 00:16:18,959 --> 00:16:20,626 You are unfair. - Oh yes? 160 00:16:20,834 --> 00:16:26,251 Yes, unfair to the others, with me, with Ruge. 161 00:16:26,459 --> 00:16:29,459 Ruge pays badly, but he makes Paris possible for us. 162 00:16:29,668 --> 00:16:34,668 And he gave you to me. Without him we wouldn't be married yet. 163 00:16:34,876 --> 00:16:36,751 And you think without Paris... 164 00:16:40,293 --> 00:16:42,626 I'm happy, Karl. 165 00:17:30,459 --> 00:17:33,793 ♪ If '5 don't want the people' 166 00:17:34,001 --> 00:17:37,459 ♪ that we should love each other 167 00:17:37,668 --> 00:17:40,334 ♪ then good night! 168 00:17:41,751 --> 00:17:45,001 ♪ If '5 also annoys people' 169 00:17:45,209 --> 00:17:48,459 ♪ If '5 also annoys people' 170 00:17:49,376 --> 00:17:52,543 ♪ I love you! 171 00:18:16,251 --> 00:18:21,043 At some point you will become your mother Yes, she has to introduce her granddaughter. 172 00:18:23,168 --> 00:18:26,168 Should I go back to Trier? - Just for a while. 173 00:18:28,043 --> 00:18:33,043 And take the opportunity to get some money from mom. 174 00:18:33,959 --> 00:18:35,459 Yes, that would be an idea. 175 00:18:38,043 --> 00:18:39,543 Charles 176 00:18:40,168 --> 00:18:43,084 if we are too much for you and become a burden to you 177 00:18:43,293 --> 00:18:45,209 Now you are being unfair. - No. 178 00:18:45,834 --> 00:18:51,584 Wonderful idea! My reactionary brother will be happy if I come begging. 179 00:18:52,584 --> 00:18:56,376 - Come on, I didn't say anything. - I'm already listening to his sermon 180 00:18:56,584 --> 00:19:02,251 about his sister's misalliance with the atheist Jewish socialist, 181 00:19:02,459 --> 00:19:07,251 the one with his subversive writing can't even provide for the family. 182 00:19:07,459 --> 00:19:11,584 I'll tell you all that, you must drink the bitter cup. 183 00:19:11,793 --> 00:19:14,376 Enough. You won. 184 00:19:18,168 --> 00:19:20,126 I have two books in the works. 185 00:19:21,043 --> 00:19:22,834 And there are the articles. 186 00:19:25,001 --> 00:19:27,168 You should tidy things up. 187 00:19:31,168 --> 00:19:32,668 Here. 188 00:19:34,668 --> 00:19:37,793 And Ruge with Ruge you are too accommodating! 189 00:19:38,876 --> 00:19:44,459 He's not poor. He has shares in on the Cologne - Antwerp railway line. 190 00:19:45,084 --> 00:19:46,584 The Ruge? 191 00:19:47,543 --> 00:19:51,126 Yes, the whole world knows that. - I don't know that. 192 00:20:02,126 --> 00:20:04,459 Try my cigars! 193 00:20:04,668 --> 00:20:06,834 London! Coronas! 194 00:20:07,959 --> 00:20:09,168 Cigars! 195 00:20:13,959 --> 00:20:15,251 Cigars. 196 00:20:15,459 --> 00:20:18,918 Whatever you want. Robusta, Corona, London... 197 00:20:19,126 --> 00:20:21,001 Not that expensive... 198 00:20:22,209 --> 00:20:23,376 This one. 199 00:20:24,168 --> 00:20:26,668 Three sous if you can manage it. 200 00:20:28,834 --> 00:20:31,168 - Two for five? - Citizens! 201 00:20:31,376 --> 00:20:33,084 I hand over to our guest, 202 00:20:33,293 --> 00:20:35,751 the one in our honor arrived from Lyon: 203 00:20:35,959 --> 00:20:38,584 Our dear, great Proudhon! 204 00:20:44,334 --> 00:20:46,793 Dear friends, comrades, citizens! 205 00:20:47,584 --> 00:20:51,876 I am happy to take part in yours Republican banquet. 206 00:20:52,084 --> 00:20:53,959 Long live Proudhon! 207 00:20:54,168 --> 00:20:57,251 you want ban these banquets, 208 00:20:57,459 --> 00:21:00,709 because they fear your anger. Rightly so! 209 00:21:00,918 --> 00:21:04,168 Because the people will always be stronger than the police 210 00:21:04,376 --> 00:21:07,418 and the thirst for freedom stronger than repression! 211 00:21:07,626 --> 00:21:10,709 Down with Guizot! - Long live the craftsmen! 212 00:21:10,918 --> 00:21:15,793 It's you, the craftsmen, the weavers, the shoemakers, 213 00:21:16,001 --> 00:21:20,459 the tailors, the carpenters, who make this country rich! 214 00:21:20,668 --> 00:21:24,918 What about the workers? The road workers, mechanics, casters! 215 00:21:25,126 --> 00:21:29,543 I won't forget her! These men, women and children, 216 00:21:29,751 --> 00:21:33,709 those of these novel ones Hell machines are chained 217 00:21:34,168 --> 00:21:38,543 and who sometimes even lack bread, to stay strong. 218 00:21:38,751 --> 00:21:41,459 You have to say it loud and clear! 219 00:21:41,668 --> 00:21:44,459 Kill them! 220 00:21:44,668 --> 00:21:46,959 With that I am on my topic... 221 00:21:47,168 --> 00:21:48,793 What is slavery? 222 00:21:49,793 --> 00:21:54,001 If I answer she's murder, you will agree with me immediately. 223 00:21:54,209 --> 00:21:58,751 So why do I have to when I ask "What is the property?" 224 00:21:58,959 --> 00:22:02,876 and to that I answer "It's theft", explain again every time? 225 00:22:03,084 --> 00:22:05,126 Property? But what property? 226 00:22:05,334 --> 00:22:07,459 Private, civil property? 227 00:22:07,668 --> 00:22:10,668 I know the man it is Karl Marx. 228 00:22:10,876 --> 00:22:13,709 I mean property in general, 229 00:22:13,918 --> 00:22:17,709 a natural right like freedom, Equality or security. 230 00:22:17,918 --> 00:22:19,418 These are abstractions. 231 00:22:19,626 --> 00:22:22,793 They are rights! Natural rights! 232 00:22:23,376 --> 00:22:27,376 Freedom, equality and security each individual, 233 00:22:27,584 --> 00:22:32,001 does not restrict everyone, on the contrary, it reinforces it! 234 00:22:32,209 --> 00:22:35,084 They are social natural rights! 235 00:22:35,959 --> 00:22:39,168 The property, on the other hand necessarily hinders 236 00:22:39,376 --> 00:22:42,626 freedom, equality and safety of others. 237 00:22:42,834 --> 00:22:46,334 It is an antisocial natural law! 238 00:22:48,209 --> 00:22:52,334 Therefore I do not demand its extension to all, 239 00:22:52,751 --> 00:22:55,793 but simply its abolition! 240 00:22:56,001 --> 00:22:57,376 Bravo! Viva! 241 00:22:57,918 --> 00:23:01,376 Down with property, the king, the state! 242 00:23:01,584 --> 00:23:03,168 Long live anarchy! 243 00:23:05,626 --> 00:23:07,876 Mikhail, I agree with you. 244 00:23:08,084 --> 00:23:11,001 But be careful, the enemy's ears are listening. 245 00:23:21,876 --> 00:23:24,543 Mikhail Alexandrovich Bakunin. 246 00:23:25,293 --> 00:23:30,209 They sought a quarrel with the master. The others call him master. 247 00:23:30,418 --> 00:23:33,418 For me there is no master, God or king. 248 00:23:33,626 --> 00:23:36,251 Karl Marx. I'm not an anarchist. 249 00:23:36,459 --> 00:23:41,459 I thought to myself. I know the German French yearbooks. Hit it. 250 00:23:42,293 --> 00:23:45,001 I recognize blood, that boils in the veins. 251 00:23:45,209 --> 00:23:47,751 And it boils in your veins of your writings. 252 00:23:48,876 --> 00:23:52,209 Do you read the yearbooks? Why don't you write them? 253 00:23:54,751 --> 00:23:59,584 Proudhon, that's Marx from them German-French yearbooks. 254 00:23:59,793 --> 00:24:01,251 Good day. -Marx! 255 00:24:01,459 --> 00:24:04,084 Very pleased. My wife, Jenny. 256 00:24:04,959 --> 00:24:06,584 - Very pleased. - Good day. 257 00:24:06,793 --> 00:24:09,251 Grün translated the yearbooks for me. 258 00:24:09,459 --> 00:24:11,709 Then he will definitely falsify it. 259 00:24:12,293 --> 00:24:16,168 They seem to like brawls. - Rather the contradiction. 260 00:24:16,376 --> 00:24:19,834 That's right, you're a Hegelian. - Above all, materialist. 261 00:24:20,918 --> 00:24:25,668 You didn't answer my question. - I have defined property, I think. 262 00:24:25,876 --> 00:24:30,751 And theft? How do you define that? - Do you have to? 263 00:24:30,959 --> 00:24:33,918 Everyone knows it is the violation of someone else's good. 264 00:24:34,126 --> 00:24:36,959 I guess I don't understand you. - Yes, you do. 265 00:24:37,168 --> 00:24:38,876 If you say that... 266 00:24:39,084 --> 00:24:41,793 are ownership and possession the same thing? 267 00:24:42,001 --> 00:24:44,501 They say property is theft. 268 00:24:44,709 --> 00:24:49,834 So if I steal someone's property, then what do I steal? The theft? 269 00:24:50,043 --> 00:24:52,876 They just pretend to be obtuse. 270 00:24:53,084 --> 00:24:55,043 Karl never pretends anything. 271 00:24:55,251 --> 00:24:59,001 What he wants to say is: Your wording is an image. 272 00:24:59,209 --> 00:25:01,543 A beautiful picture, but as they say here, 273 00:25:01,918 --> 00:25:04,043 one that is itself bites the tail. 274 00:25:06,918 --> 00:25:10,918 I have to say, Your wife knows a lot about idioms. 275 00:25:11,126 --> 00:25:12,918 Right, green? 276 00:25:20,501 --> 00:25:24,543 Friends! Great news! The Faubourg St. Antoine is burning! 277 00:25:24,751 --> 00:25:26,376 What happened? 278 00:25:27,793 --> 00:25:30,168 It started with a cobbler. 279 00:25:30,376 --> 00:25:33,751 He brings shoes to the master for three francs. 280 00:25:33,959 --> 00:25:37,918 The master finds them poorly done and wants to pay him 50 sous. 281 00:25:38,126 --> 00:25:42,001 The boy doesn't agree. The bastard throws him out. 282 00:25:42,209 --> 00:25:45,876 The shoemaker and his buddies beat everything short and small. 283 00:25:46,084 --> 00:25:50,126 The police and the federal government are already there and the National Guard alerted! 284 00:25:50,334 --> 00:25:53,584 A riot. - Weitling, always take it easy. 285 00:25:53,793 --> 00:25:57,584 There are riots every day in the Faubourg. It's not a revolution. 286 00:25:57,793 --> 00:26:00,043 No, but things are getting hot. 287 00:26:01,126 --> 00:26:03,334 I'm looking for Arnold Ruge... 288 00:26:11,793 --> 00:26:14,168 He lives next door. Through this door. 289 00:26:15,084 --> 00:26:17,293 By the way, there is a spy outside. 290 00:26:17,501 --> 00:26:19,501 With a dirty scarf? - Yes. 291 00:26:19,709 --> 00:26:21,543 He's hard to miss. 292 00:26:27,626 --> 00:26:29,126 A countryman? 293 00:26:30,209 --> 00:26:32,168 Do you know the young man? 294 00:26:32,959 --> 00:26:34,084 No. 295 00:26:36,584 --> 00:26:40,251 What do you think? to take action against this spy? 296 00:26:40,459 --> 00:26:44,084 He just notes who goes in and out. What should you do? 297 00:26:44,293 --> 00:26:48,168 You could give him a slap in the mouth. I wouldn't have a problem with that. 298 00:26:48,376 --> 00:26:52,626 Don't! We are just tolerated here, That's what they're just waiting for! 299 00:26:56,876 --> 00:26:59,209 Should I pour you a drink too? 300 00:26:59,418 --> 00:27:01,751 Just an inch, my love. 301 00:27:06,293 --> 00:27:08,876 Excellent, absolutely excellent. 302 00:27:10,001 --> 00:27:13,293 Listen, unfortunately I can't don't pay immediately. 303 00:27:13,501 --> 00:27:15,084 I'll get by for now. 304 00:27:15,293 --> 00:27:16,793 That's nice. 305 00:27:17,001 --> 00:27:18,543 Do you allow? - Secure. 306 00:27:18,751 --> 00:27:22,418 I enjoy working with you, not with others. 307 00:27:22,626 --> 00:27:24,876 Who are you thinking of? Feuerbach? 308 00:27:25,084 --> 00:27:30,418 Feuerbach? I'm still waiting to a text from him. No, to Marx... 309 00:27:31,876 --> 00:27:33,584 Oh yes, that one. 310 00:27:34,376 --> 00:27:35,876 Do you know him? 311 00:27:36,751 --> 00:27:40,918 We met once. - Making a newspaper with the man... 312 00:27:41,126 --> 00:27:44,126 - An impossible guy. - That's right, impossible! 313 00:27:44,334 --> 00:27:49,293 His texts are never finished on time, he always finds an excuse. 314 00:27:49,501 --> 00:27:51,376 He is a dirty person. 315 00:27:51,584 --> 00:27:56,126 Like me only with him and his wife Could share roof and table 316 00:27:56,334 --> 00:27:57,834 My God, his wife. 317 00:27:58,043 --> 00:28:00,501 A fury? Or a fishwife? 318 00:28:00,709 --> 00:28:02,334 Who are we talking about? 319 00:28:06,709 --> 00:28:10,251 By the way, there's a spy down there. - Seems so. 320 00:28:10,459 --> 00:28:13,543 Karl, let me introduce you Friedrich Engels. 321 00:28:19,209 --> 00:28:21,084 Don't we know each other? 322 00:28:23,043 --> 00:28:24,834 I have to go back to the kitchen. 323 00:28:30,084 --> 00:28:34,043 Berlin. In Bettina von Arnim's salon! 324 00:28:34,918 --> 00:28:38,459 Exactly. - You were very arrogant. 325 00:28:39,418 --> 00:28:42,376 - Maybe. I was young. - And rich. 326 00:28:42,584 --> 00:28:45,376 You showed everyone that. - I don't know. 327 00:28:46,001 --> 00:28:50,376 Me, yes. They have about communism talked as if you had invented it, 328 00:28:50,584 --> 00:28:53,918 with your officer's epaulettes and gold buttons 329 00:28:54,376 --> 00:28:57,126 - That was ridiculous! - That's past. 330 00:28:57,334 --> 00:28:59,418 Let's look to the future... 331 00:28:59,626 --> 00:29:01,959 Exactly. You know why I'm here. 332 00:29:02,168 --> 00:29:06,418 My current situation - Don't tell me anything. 333 00:29:06,626 --> 00:29:11,168 My child is sick, I have to leave my family feed and you owe me money. 334 00:29:11,376 --> 00:29:13,543 You have stocks, everyone knows that. 335 00:29:13,751 --> 00:29:18,168 The stock has fallen! - Just sell at a loss! 336 00:29:18,376 --> 00:29:21,918 I have delivered you two items. You owe me one! 337 00:29:22,126 --> 00:29:24,918 Do you need a bond? - Have you been asked? 338 00:29:25,126 --> 00:29:26,334 I asked Ruge. 339 00:29:26,543 --> 00:29:30,251 - I don't take sous from a... - Yes? From one? 340 00:29:30,459 --> 00:29:36,209 From a gold-buttoned amateur who passing the time in the suburbs! 341 00:29:36,418 --> 00:29:38,543 Karl, please! 342 00:29:39,668 --> 00:29:44,543 Wait here, I'll take a look see if I can find anything, yes? 343 00:30:00,293 --> 00:30:04,459 You seem to know me well. Have you read my texts? 344 00:30:06,584 --> 00:30:08,084 I read yours. 345 00:30:08,293 --> 00:30:12,293 In particular the criticism of Hegel See legal philosophy. 346 00:30:12,501 --> 00:30:14,459 I don't care. - Oh yes? 347 00:30:32,168 --> 00:30:34,376 Chablis 1839... 348 00:30:34,584 --> 00:30:38,584 Ruge knows how to welcome guests. Even if he pays poorly. 349 00:30:39,501 --> 00:30:41,001 Or? 350 00:30:51,251 --> 00:30:56,251 I've never had anything so precise and engaging read. 351 00:30:59,334 --> 00:31:03,543 You have the Hegelian dialectic turned from head to feet. 352 00:31:03,751 --> 00:31:06,209 I'm 24, you can't be much older. 353 00:31:07,751 --> 00:31:11,543 You are the biggest materialist thinkers of our time. 354 00:31:11,751 --> 00:31:13,751 You are a genius, my dear. 355 00:31:15,709 --> 00:31:17,209 A genius. 356 00:31:22,709 --> 00:31:26,209 This study about the English proletariat? 357 00:31:27,209 --> 00:31:30,293 The situation of the workers Class in England? - Yes. 358 00:31:31,543 --> 00:31:33,043 This is from me. 359 00:31:33,626 --> 00:31:35,834 Will you forgive my frankness? 360 00:31:36,043 --> 00:31:38,168 Go ahead. I endure everything. 361 00:31:41,459 --> 00:31:43,626 This is first class work. 362 00:31:45,251 --> 00:31:47,543 No one before you has done this. 363 00:31:47,751 --> 00:31:51,126 There is only one expression for it: This is colossal. 364 00:31:56,959 --> 00:31:58,459 Charles 365 00:32:03,918 --> 00:32:06,001 This is better than your stuff, right? 366 00:32:07,251 --> 00:32:08,751 It's different. 367 00:32:11,251 --> 00:32:16,043 You have a knowledge of the working world, like I've never seen anywhere before. 368 00:32:16,251 --> 00:32:19,751 Manchester, the slums, the manufactories... 369 00:32:19,959 --> 00:32:25,918 They know the poorest and the bourgeoisie like the back of your hand. How do you do that? 370 00:32:28,584 --> 00:32:31,209 I feel uncomfortable telling you this. 371 00:32:32,751 --> 00:32:35,001 I am an authorized signatory for my father, 372 00:32:35,209 --> 00:32:38,501 him and a partner have three spinning mills there. 373 00:32:40,001 --> 00:32:42,334 All well and good. But the other side? 374 00:32:42,876 --> 00:32:44,584 The poorest of the poor? - Yes. 375 00:32:45,626 --> 00:32:47,126 That's something different. 376 00:32:48,501 --> 00:32:50,501 This is a love story. 377 00:32:51,751 --> 00:32:55,376 Are your papers in order? - I have my passport. 378 00:33:03,626 --> 00:33:05,709 Let's not take any risks. 379 00:33:05,918 --> 00:33:09,334 Currently they are Distrustful of Germans. 380 00:33:09,876 --> 00:33:11,876 Just follow me. 381 00:33:13,001 --> 00:33:18,001 Don't stand still. On mine Zeichen biegen wir in die Passage ab. 382 00:33:19,584 --> 00:33:22,959 - Now! - Stop! Two men with me! 383 00:33:23,168 --> 00:33:26,126 - Leave it! - Is an heirloom! 384 00:33:26,334 --> 00:33:29,501 Stand still! 385 00:33:51,918 --> 00:33:54,501 - Good day. - What comes to mind? 386 00:34:12,376 --> 00:34:15,376 Help! Help! The police! 387 00:34:15,584 --> 00:34:17,459 Out of the way! 388 00:34:57,959 --> 00:35:02,501 Um nochmal auf Ihre Texte zurückzukommen... Das Einzige, was Ihnen fehlt... 389 00:35:02,709 --> 00:35:04,459 Go ahead. 390 00:35:05,418 --> 00:35:09,459 Ihre Kritik an der Religion und am Idealismus sind maßgebend. 391 00:35:09,668 --> 00:35:14,126 Aber lesen Sie die englischen Ökonomen. Ricardo. Smith. Bentham. 392 00:35:16,334 --> 00:35:18,084 That is the basis for everything. 393 00:35:19,334 --> 00:35:21,626 Do you read English? - I learn quickly. 394 00:35:23,501 --> 00:35:24,793 Chess. 395 00:35:29,543 --> 00:35:31,626 Another one for me. - Another one? 396 00:35:32,251 --> 00:35:34,751 Waiter! Two more! 397 00:35:37,251 --> 00:35:40,543 Good I can only do that. 398 00:35:42,959 --> 00:35:44,459 And dull. 399 00:35:46,459 --> 00:35:50,001 On the heads, really think, and all free spirits! 400 00:35:54,001 --> 00:35:55,501 Cheers. 401 00:35:57,501 --> 00:35:59,001 I haven't seen it. 402 00:35:59,209 --> 00:36:01,043 Hey, Garcon! 403 00:36:05,543 --> 00:36:07,584 It's over with Ruge. 404 00:36:07,793 --> 00:36:10,418 I will give my texts to the forward. 405 00:36:12,543 --> 00:36:15,251 I'm completely stranded, I... 406 00:36:16,459 --> 00:36:17,959 Me too... Garçon! 407 00:36:18,168 --> 00:36:19,793 Seriously, I need money. 408 00:36:20,751 --> 00:36:23,543 Did I ever tell you told by my wife? 409 00:36:23,751 --> 00:36:28,043 Jenny? The most beautiful Aristocrat from all of Trier 410 00:36:28,751 --> 00:36:33,376 This is a Westphalen, one of the most respected families in the country... 411 00:36:34,334 --> 00:36:36,418 And who did she marry? Me! 412 00:36:40,334 --> 00:36:42,668 The son of a converted Jew. 413 00:36:48,293 --> 00:36:51,459 She makes me so happy. 414 00:36:54,876 --> 00:36:56,376 You're lucky. 415 00:36:59,209 --> 00:37:00,709 And you? 416 00:37:04,084 --> 00:37:05,584 What? 417 00:37:05,793 --> 00:37:09,543 Don't you have something? told about a great love? 418 00:37:09,751 --> 00:37:11,251 Complicated. 419 00:37:12,459 --> 00:37:13,959 On us. 420 00:37:15,543 --> 00:37:18,251 So, here’s to us! 421 00:37:28,793 --> 00:37:30,293 Are things better? 422 00:37:34,501 --> 00:37:36,001 Not particularly. 423 00:37:37,918 --> 00:37:42,459 I'm taking you home now. - No! I'll take you home. 424 00:37:44,168 --> 00:37:46,209 Here. - Thanks. 425 00:37:53,209 --> 00:37:54,709 Do you know... 426 00:37:57,793 --> 00:37:59,501 I understood something. 427 00:38:00,168 --> 00:38:01,668 Through you. 428 00:38:03,543 --> 00:38:06,334 I understood something. - Me too through you. 429 00:38:06,543 --> 00:38:08,293 No, I through you. 430 00:38:09,876 --> 00:38:11,376 Listen. 431 00:38:12,293 --> 00:38:15,251 Until now, all philosophers have - Oh 432 00:38:15,459 --> 00:38:17,293 Listen to me! - Come on. 433 00:38:17,501 --> 00:38:21,293 All philosophers Up until now we have only ever interpreted things. 434 00:38:23,001 --> 00:38:25,084 The whole world interprets... 435 00:38:29,459 --> 00:38:31,251 But you have to change them. 436 00:38:33,626 --> 00:38:36,293 But with what? With whom? 437 00:38:39,334 --> 00:38:41,584 Proudhon. He will help us. 438 00:38:42,709 --> 00:38:44,543 Come! 439 00:39:15,001 --> 00:39:16,793 Shhh 440 00:39:20,334 --> 00:39:22,793 Karl? Where are you? 441 00:39:30,626 --> 00:39:32,126 Oh. 442 00:39:48,584 --> 00:39:50,751 Oh God, my head! 443 00:40:17,084 --> 00:40:18,584 Are you leaving already? 444 00:40:21,959 --> 00:40:24,209 Thank you for your hospitality. 445 00:40:24,418 --> 00:40:26,876 Your generosity. 446 00:40:27,584 --> 00:40:33,376 - There are important matters. - Don't forget about our affairs. 447 00:40:33,584 --> 00:40:35,084 How could I? 448 00:40:37,293 --> 00:40:39,251 We didn't just drink. 449 00:40:39,459 --> 00:40:41,459 We took notes. 450 00:40:41,668 --> 00:40:44,376 The two of us are going to publish something. 451 00:40:45,209 --> 00:40:49,334 Criticize Stirner, Bauer, the whole sentimental clique. 452 00:40:49,543 --> 00:40:53,334 All from the "Critical Review", what they call their goo. 453 00:40:53,543 --> 00:40:57,084 This will hit like a powder keg. - Powder keg? 454 00:40:57,293 --> 00:40:58,793 Sir? 455 00:40:59,001 --> 00:41:00,501 And the title? 456 00:41:01,251 --> 00:41:03,543 We have barely laid the foundation. 457 00:41:03,751 --> 00:41:07,709 A title just comes to mind, when I look at you like that. 458 00:41:09,293 --> 00:41:12,459 The criticism of critical criticism. 459 00:41:23,293 --> 00:41:26,501 "The true price of everything. 460 00:41:27,084 --> 00:41:31,251 What everything really costs to the person who wants to acquire it, 461 00:41:32,751 --> 00:41:35,918 is the effort and effort, to acquire it..." 462 00:41:45,751 --> 00:41:50,084 “What everything really is, the one who acquired it 463 00:41:51,084 --> 00:41:56,209 and who wants to dispose of it or exchange it for something else 464 00:41:58,793 --> 00:42:03,459 It's the effort and effort that he can save for himself 465 00:42:04,251 --> 00:42:07,501 and that he other people can burden. ” 466 00:42:09,168 --> 00:42:13,001 "Work was the first prize, 467 00:42:16,584 --> 00:42:21,334 the original purchase price, who was paid for all things. ” 468 00:42:26,418 --> 00:42:31,459 You know, Karl likes you very much. He is difficult when it comes to friendship. 469 00:42:31,668 --> 00:42:34,751 He's never had anyone brought home. 470 00:42:34,959 --> 00:42:39,376 You are the first guest. - It probably wasn't so nice for you. 471 00:42:42,001 --> 00:42:43,876 I read your essay. 472 00:42:44,543 --> 00:42:46,543 And it fizzes like champagne. 473 00:42:46,751 --> 00:42:49,668 I judge what you contribute to Karl's work. 474 00:42:50,751 --> 00:42:54,668 Only there is Forgive me for my directness. 475 00:42:54,876 --> 00:42:56,668 He doesn't have your condition. 476 00:42:57,334 --> 00:43:03,084 After a night like this you are fresh and cheerful, but he needs two days of rest. 477 00:43:03,709 --> 00:43:08,876 Take him wherever you want. But try to moderate it. 478 00:43:10,543 --> 00:43:12,959 You are extraordinary, Ms. Marx. 479 00:43:14,459 --> 00:43:16,293 Jenny. - Jenny. 480 00:43:17,793 --> 00:43:19,418 You are admirable. 481 00:43:20,543 --> 00:43:23,876 They would have a rich and can lead an idle life, 482 00:43:24,084 --> 00:43:26,876 surrounded by luxury, Enjoyment and your class. 483 00:43:27,084 --> 00:43:29,793 Of deadly boredom I escaped. 484 00:43:30,543 --> 00:43:32,584 There is no happiness without rebellion 485 00:43:32,793 --> 00:43:36,501 against the prevailing order, against the old world. 486 00:43:36,709 --> 00:43:41,876 I believe that and I hope that I do I see this old world soon collapsing. 487 00:43:42,751 --> 00:43:44,251 Both of us! 488 00:43:44,459 --> 00:43:45,959 No 489 00:43:46,501 --> 00:43:48,418 The three of us, Jenny. 490 00:43:50,251 --> 00:43:52,043 We unhinge them. 491 00:43:53,209 --> 00:43:54,709 This old world. 492 00:43:57,334 --> 00:44:00,959 Maybe we should be a little more than three, right? 493 00:44:08,793 --> 00:44:11,334 You know, my dear Marx, 494 00:44:11,543 --> 00:44:15,501 as a dirty little farm worker's child I raked potatoes 495 00:44:15,709 --> 00:44:17,918 Threshing wheat, tending cows... 496 00:44:19,084 --> 00:44:21,293 Sitting is torture for me. 497 00:44:22,418 --> 00:44:26,293 - I'm doing it for you, Courbet. - It's an honor, Master. 498 00:44:26,501 --> 00:44:29,459 Not master! They paint for the people. 499 00:44:29,668 --> 00:44:33,084 I recognize such artists others I detest. 500 00:44:33,293 --> 00:44:36,209 And what about Raphael, Da Vinci, Michelangelo? 501 00:44:36,418 --> 00:44:41,376 I reject her. The art the future will be for the collective. 502 00:44:42,751 --> 00:44:45,918 Conversion of runners? Very risky. 503 00:44:46,126 --> 00:44:47,584 Go ahead, replace it! 504 00:44:48,501 --> 00:44:50,084 My knight is tied up. 505 00:44:52,501 --> 00:44:55,543 We'll play again immediately. - This move is infallible. 506 00:44:55,751 --> 00:45:00,084 There are no infallible moves. You are too confident. 507 00:45:00,293 --> 00:45:03,126 I can not anymore! I'm sorry. 508 00:45:04,168 --> 00:45:06,709 You know my friend Friedrich Engels. 509 00:45:08,584 --> 00:45:11,376 We're writing about you right now. - Oh, really? 510 00:45:11,584 --> 00:45:15,334 We defend you against the supporters of critical criticism. 511 00:45:15,543 --> 00:45:19,084 - Including your friend Green. - They're attacking me? 512 00:45:19,293 --> 00:45:21,876 Most violently. - And you defend me? 513 00:45:22,084 --> 00:45:23,918 Are you defending someone? 514 00:45:24,126 --> 00:45:28,626 It was below the belt. Two hearts beat in your chest. 515 00:45:28,834 --> 00:45:32,501 The critical Proudhon, who thinks in abstract categories, 516 00:45:32,709 --> 00:45:35,876 and the real Proudhon, who sees the real misery. 517 00:45:36,501 --> 00:45:39,334 We defend the second one. - Against the first? 518 00:45:39,543 --> 00:45:43,834 No. For those who are critical critics "to own or not to own", 519 00:45:44,043 --> 00:45:47,459 also "to have or not to have", abstract ideas. 520 00:45:47,668 --> 00:45:51,293 For you and us "having nothing" is not an abstract idea, 521 00:45:51,501 --> 00:45:55,584 but a devastating fact. 522 00:45:55,793 --> 00:46:01,209 Nowadays a person who has nothing is worth nothing. Money determines its value. 523 00:46:01,418 --> 00:46:05,543 Therefore you are right the economic system is analyzed. 524 00:46:05,751 --> 00:46:09,501 No socialist author before has ever done that. 525 00:46:09,709 --> 00:46:15,168 Your book is the first scientific one Manifesto of the French Proletariat. 526 00:46:16,501 --> 00:46:19,876 Thanks. Let us drink to your work. 527 00:46:21,293 --> 00:46:22,959 And the title? 528 00:46:23,168 --> 00:46:24,751 The title? 529 00:46:26,918 --> 00:46:28,668 Criticism of critical criticism. 530 00:46:31,334 --> 00:46:32,501 Very amusing. 531 00:46:33,293 --> 00:46:37,334 Seems very dialectical to me, very Hegelian. 532 00:47:25,709 --> 00:47:27,418 Assassination attempt! 533 00:47:27,626 --> 00:47:32,334 Three shots were fired. Assassination attempt on Friedrich Wilhelm I 534 00:47:32,543 --> 00:47:35,584 Assassination attempt carried out to the King of Prussia! 535 00:47:49,584 --> 00:47:51,043 The most important point... 536 00:47:51,918 --> 00:47:53,418 is the goods. 537 00:47:54,751 --> 00:47:57,209 work, your work, 538 00:47:57,418 --> 00:47:59,334 is also a commodity in its own way. 539 00:48:00,043 --> 00:48:05,084 You sell your labor to your employer like a commodity. 540 00:48:05,293 --> 00:48:08,043 Only you are not free. 541 00:48:08,626 --> 00:48:10,959 You sell them to survive. 542 00:48:11,168 --> 00:48:13,959 We're dying! - And at the lowest price. 543 00:48:14,168 --> 00:48:17,501 There are always manufacturers and workers. - Nothing is forever. 544 00:48:17,709 --> 00:48:21,668 The expression "there will always be" comes from the bourgeoisie. 545 00:48:21,876 --> 00:48:24,209 This is what capital wants us to believe. 546 00:48:24,418 --> 00:48:26,334 But everything is moving. 547 00:48:26,959 --> 00:48:30,293 Everything is subject to change. Nothing lasts. 548 00:48:30,501 --> 00:48:35,793 All social relationships, slavery, serfdom, wage labor, 549 00:48:36,001 --> 00:48:38,168 are historical and transitory. 550 00:48:38,376 --> 00:48:41,709 In reality they have to change the current conditions. 551 00:48:41,918 --> 00:48:45,751 The bourgeois is always free, to hire workers, 552 00:48:45,959 --> 00:48:47,876 and they have to sell. 553 00:48:48,084 --> 00:48:50,709 The bourgeoisie speaks gladly of freedom. 554 00:48:50,918 --> 00:48:54,584 But it's just theirs, not yours, and you know that. 555 00:48:54,793 --> 00:48:56,751 You feel it firsthand. 556 00:48:56,959 --> 00:48:59,084 Every single day! 557 00:49:02,001 --> 00:49:05,126 So it's not a fair game. 558 00:49:06,584 --> 00:49:08,084 That is clear. 559 00:49:08,626 --> 00:49:10,168 The cards are marked. 560 00:49:10,793 --> 00:49:14,084 What mistake to make reformists like Proudhon, 561 00:49:14,918 --> 00:49:19,709 equal pay as the goal the social revolution? 562 00:49:19,918 --> 00:49:24,418 You want to improve a system which inherently creates misery. 563 00:49:25,126 --> 00:49:26,876 Not about turning it inside out. 564 00:49:27,084 --> 00:49:29,043 Proudhon is a great man! 565 00:49:29,251 --> 00:49:31,501 No question. He is a big man. 566 00:49:32,293 --> 00:49:35,126 But not a great economist. 567 00:49:35,334 --> 00:49:39,209 He has his place in the movement, which is getting strong - in New York. 568 00:49:39,418 --> 00:49:43,001 I greet the representative from there, Hermann Kriege... 569 00:49:46,168 --> 00:49:48,668 In Brussels, London, Geneva, 570 00:49:48,876 --> 00:49:51,751 even in Russia and especially in Germany, 571 00:49:51,959 --> 00:49:54,918 where our famous friend comes from Weitling is coming! 572 00:49:58,751 --> 00:50:04,293 And where our unfortunate Friedrich Wilhelm As we know, he was the victim of an assassination attempt. 573 00:50:04,876 --> 00:50:07,168 Unfortunately without success. 574 00:50:07,376 --> 00:50:11,001 And also in England, where my friend Engels comes from... 575 00:50:14,668 --> 00:50:17,834 Now I'm happy to hand over to Weitling. 576 00:50:23,043 --> 00:50:25,126 You were very bold. 577 00:50:25,334 --> 00:50:28,043 Friends, this meeting... 578 00:50:28,251 --> 00:50:32,126 - Regarding the assassination attempt? - Excuse me please. 579 00:50:32,334 --> 00:50:36,543 I don't think it's bad. But the Prussians won't like it. 580 00:50:36,751 --> 00:50:40,793 They are not my target group. - Please be careful. 581 00:50:41,001 --> 00:50:45,501 They will deal harshly with the French. I can't help you then. 582 00:50:45,709 --> 00:50:49,543 Other words, to communicate this feeling. 583 00:50:49,751 --> 00:50:52,001 So your suitcases are already packed? 584 00:50:52,709 --> 00:50:53,834 Yes. 585 00:50:54,584 --> 00:50:57,501 Tonight I'm in London, tomorrow in Manchester. 586 00:50:57,709 --> 00:50:59,209 We will miss you. 587 00:51:01,251 --> 00:51:05,501 I will suffer. - And what about “great love”? 588 00:51:05,709 --> 00:51:07,584 If only there were her. 589 00:51:09,209 --> 00:51:11,918 Come back soon. We have a lot to do. 590 00:51:12,126 --> 00:51:16,543 Our hearts beat as one! 591 00:51:16,751 --> 00:51:19,293 In the bright sunlight full of love! 592 00:51:20,043 --> 00:51:22,751 In the bright sunlight of the revolution! 593 00:51:23,376 --> 00:51:25,126 Vive la liberté! 594 00:51:25,334 --> 00:51:27,834 Brothers, friends... 595 00:51:28,043 --> 00:51:30,251 We are one! 596 00:51:30,876 --> 00:51:34,751 We are invincible! 597 00:52:01,543 --> 00:52:03,334 On the first floor. 598 00:52:37,793 --> 00:52:39,293 Come! 599 00:52:48,793 --> 00:52:51,376 Fast. 600 00:52:57,584 --> 00:53:00,668 - Monsieur Karl Marx? - Yes that's me. 601 00:53:00,876 --> 00:53:04,001 By order the Prime Minister Guizot, 602 00:53:04,209 --> 00:53:07,293 in the name of the king, they will be expelled from the country. 603 00:53:07,501 --> 00:53:10,876 The King of France or of Prussia? - Very funny. 604 00:53:11,084 --> 00:53:13,459 Departure within 24 hours. 605 00:53:13,668 --> 00:53:16,293 You're kidding! - Do you think so? 606 00:53:19,376 --> 00:53:20,751 Your passports! 607 00:53:40,084 --> 00:53:41,584 Hmm. 608 00:53:58,918 --> 00:54:03,084 In 24 hours to go where? 609 00:54:08,084 --> 00:54:09,584 Where? 610 00:54:24,834 --> 00:54:27,543 We have to sell everything we have. 611 00:54:28,126 --> 00:54:30,376 In a day. - We have no choice. 612 00:54:35,918 --> 00:54:40,626 They have already expelled everyone from the country. Bakunin, Hess, even Ruge. 613 00:54:55,626 --> 00:54:58,626 Dear? Are you sick? 614 00:55:11,501 --> 00:55:13,001 I 615 00:55:13,834 --> 00:55:15,459 I'm expecting another child. 616 00:56:13,001 --> 00:56:14,501 Yes, father? 617 00:56:15,334 --> 00:56:16,834 How are you doing? 618 00:56:17,501 --> 00:56:19,001 How are you doing? 619 00:56:19,876 --> 00:56:22,751 I survive. - I call it "being useful." 620 00:56:22,959 --> 00:56:25,293 But I'll pay you pretty well for it. 621 00:56:25,501 --> 00:56:29,001 Are you here because you are mine maybe want to say something? 622 00:56:33,126 --> 00:56:36,126 In my London club people ask about you. 623 00:56:36,334 --> 00:56:39,876 My friend Naylor keeps asking what Freddy is up to. 624 00:56:40,418 --> 00:56:43,043 I can't lie. What should I say to him? 625 00:56:43,543 --> 00:56:45,043 Whatever you want, father. 626 00:56:46,293 --> 00:56:51,876 Say I'm going fox hunting, play cards and work hard for you. 627 00:56:52,709 --> 00:56:54,543 What if he shows me this? 628 00:56:56,084 --> 00:57:00,001 What should I say to him? That it is a religious text? 629 00:57:02,876 --> 00:57:05,834 It's not like that. - Don't play with me. 630 00:57:06,043 --> 00:57:11,043 It's not a satire against religion, it is directed against the Young Hegelians. 631 00:57:11,584 --> 00:57:15,751 You have no respect for anything, anyone or me. 632 00:57:15,959 --> 00:57:20,126 But I'm not an idiot. You have nothing against subversive groups. 633 00:57:20,334 --> 00:57:23,251 There should be criticism of critical criticism be called. 634 00:57:23,459 --> 00:57:26,876 Marx added The Holy Family without asking me. 635 00:57:27,084 --> 00:57:29,584 Your name in connection with Marx! 636 00:57:32,918 --> 00:57:35,876 Please leave us alone for a moment? 637 00:57:41,584 --> 00:57:45,543 You have lovely friends there. - I don't have anyone better. 638 00:57:46,418 --> 00:57:48,084 You have no idea. 639 00:57:48,293 --> 00:57:49,793 Don't provoke me. 640 00:57:52,501 --> 00:57:55,793 I ask you with respect, not to judge me. 641 00:57:56,001 --> 00:58:01,168 Let’s stick with our employment relationship. You pay me as an authorized representative. 642 00:58:02,209 --> 00:58:05,418 To do you a service, don't forget that. 643 00:58:05,626 --> 00:58:07,584 My patience has its limits. 644 00:58:10,126 --> 00:58:13,459 I haven't been here a day yet and now you're threatening me. 645 00:58:15,834 --> 00:58:19,126 I'm not threatening you I'm warning you. 646 00:58:26,334 --> 00:58:30,668 Next week will be your brother and your sister confirmed. 647 00:58:30,876 --> 00:58:34,751 I assume you won't take part in this evening meal. 648 00:58:35,626 --> 00:58:40,293 Father, why are you asking me questions if you already know the answers? 649 00:58:42,334 --> 00:58:44,959 How could this devil just drive into you? 650 00:58:46,709 --> 00:58:49,918 We go to church, we go to work. 651 00:58:50,126 --> 00:58:54,293 And you're lounging in the den of evil with communists and concubines. 652 00:58:54,501 --> 00:58:57,209 I'm not done yet! Where do you want to go? 653 00:59:04,668 --> 00:59:06,209 Get some fresh air. 654 00:59:07,668 --> 00:59:09,168 I'm suffocating. 655 00:59:10,334 --> 00:59:12,751 And what do I say to your mother? 656 00:59:24,501 --> 00:59:26,959 Do you want a mouthpiece for cigars? 657 00:59:27,168 --> 00:59:28,626 Cigars? 658 00:59:29,918 --> 00:59:33,501 Nicely done. How old are you? - I don't know. 659 00:59:33,709 --> 00:59:36,043 Some say ten, others eight. 660 00:59:36,834 --> 00:59:40,126 I would say six at most. Thanks. 661 00:59:45,876 --> 00:59:47,668 Where are they? 662 00:59:47,876 --> 00:59:49,543 Hey, wait! 663 01:00:06,293 --> 01:00:07,793 It's you... 664 01:00:08,751 --> 01:00:10,418 God! 665 01:00:10,626 --> 01:00:12,126 It's you. - It's me. 666 01:00:20,834 --> 01:00:24,043 Shorty, this is Friedrich. He is not a usurer. 667 01:00:24,251 --> 01:00:25,751 Who is he? 668 01:00:26,543 --> 01:00:31,084 Well, if he doesn't run around and gives money to little brats 669 01:00:31,793 --> 01:00:33,293 is he my husband. 670 01:00:33,959 --> 01:00:37,293 Lizzy, Friedrich is back. - Hello, Frederick. 671 01:00:40,959 --> 01:00:43,084 Did you just arrive? 672 01:00:43,293 --> 01:00:45,126 I've been there for three days. 673 01:00:45,959 --> 01:00:49,293 Three days? And you're just coming now? 674 01:00:50,626 --> 01:00:53,251 You scoundrel. - You don't know my father... 675 01:00:54,418 --> 01:00:56,876 Oh, of course you know him. 676 01:00:57,084 --> 01:00:59,168 He is a walking prison. 677 01:01:00,251 --> 01:01:02,251 I was just able to break out. 678 01:01:02,459 --> 01:01:05,251 We don't have any good beer in the house to celebrate. 679 01:01:06,918 --> 01:01:10,334 Give Shorty another guinea. He earned it. 680 01:01:16,293 --> 01:01:19,001 Damn it! - Now off with you. 681 01:01:19,209 --> 01:01:20,834 I want my husband for myself. 682 01:01:21,043 --> 01:01:22,959 Thank you. - Please. 683 01:01:54,501 --> 01:01:56,084 How are things going here? 684 01:01:57,209 --> 01:01:58,709 Is something moving? 685 01:01:59,626 --> 01:02:01,584 It's not just moving, my love... 686 01:02:02,584 --> 01:02:05,543 I organized the meeting for you. 687 01:02:08,209 --> 01:02:10,459 Does the covenant of the righteous mean something to you? 688 01:02:12,084 --> 01:02:13,584 Tell. 689 01:02:58,251 --> 01:03:02,168 You have any political activity prohibited here. 690 01:03:02,376 --> 01:03:04,459 I signed that, yes. 691 01:03:10,126 --> 01:03:11,376 Please. 692 01:03:21,501 --> 01:03:23,751 Can you read this? 693 01:03:24,584 --> 01:03:28,001 I have a family to support. I need work. 694 01:03:28,209 --> 01:03:31,543 There is one for the post office legible handwriting required. 695 01:03:51,376 --> 01:03:52,876 I do everything. 696 01:03:53,709 --> 01:03:55,209 No matter what. 697 01:04:18,543 --> 01:04:20,084 How is she, Lenchen? 698 01:04:23,709 --> 01:04:25,959 No, not yet, Mr. Marx! 699 01:04:37,584 --> 01:04:41,126 Now push! 700 01:05:02,834 --> 01:05:05,584 What are you waiting for? You can go to her. 701 01:05:09,501 --> 01:05:11,168 Jenny? 702 01:05:22,668 --> 01:05:26,209 It's a girl. - Again? 703 01:05:26,418 --> 01:05:28,626 Is that all you say? 704 01:05:47,959 --> 01:05:50,126 Shhh 705 01:06:05,084 --> 01:06:06,793 Hello, Laura. 706 01:06:10,584 --> 01:06:12,376 Can we call her Laura? 707 01:06:12,834 --> 01:06:15,668 If Lenchen agrees to it. - Yes, of couse. 708 01:06:17,126 --> 01:06:18,626 Lenchen? 709 01:06:20,834 --> 01:06:23,126 Luckily she's there, Karl. 710 01:06:24,376 --> 01:06:26,876 What would I have done without her? 711 01:06:28,293 --> 01:06:32,001 Lenchen, this is Laura. Do you like this, "Laura"? 712 01:06:33,168 --> 01:06:35,709 That's a very pretty name. 713 01:06:36,418 --> 01:06:38,418 So we'll call you Laura. 714 01:06:55,584 --> 01:06:57,126 My dear Karl, 715 01:06:57,959 --> 01:07:01,418 it is particularly horrible not just a bourgeois, 716 01:07:01,626 --> 01:07:03,959 but also to be a manufacturer. 717 01:07:04,501 --> 01:07:08,126 A bourgeois who is active acts against the proletariat 718 01:07:09,543 --> 01:07:14,251 A few days with my father showed me this horror. 719 01:07:15,084 --> 01:07:20,709 Communist propaganda and at the same time to engage in chess and industry - 720 01:07:20,918 --> 01:07:22,418 that doesn't work. 721 01:07:24,334 --> 01:07:25,959 I can't stand this. 722 01:07:44,459 --> 01:07:46,709 My dear Friedrich, 723 01:07:47,501 --> 01:07:49,751 I share your dilemma. 724 01:07:49,959 --> 01:07:52,043 And I miss your presence. 725 01:07:54,168 --> 01:07:57,126 Here is the material life materially hard. 726 01:07:59,834 --> 01:08:02,418 I became a father again. 727 01:08:04,709 --> 01:08:07,709 Jenny gave me a wonderful Laura as a gift. 728 01:08:09,668 --> 01:08:13,709 Because I have no other option see feeding my family, 729 01:08:13,918 --> 01:08:16,251 I'm thinking about a new book. 730 01:08:16,459 --> 01:08:21,543 It is important to recognize that the... Materialism as we understand it 731 01:08:21,751 --> 01:08:26,126 from bourgeois materialism differs in this respect; 732 01:08:26,334 --> 01:08:29,793 as he a humanization society strives for. 733 01:08:32,043 --> 01:08:34,418 Two days! We don't ask for anything more... 734 01:08:34,626 --> 01:08:37,126 You always say that. - You're tiring, Madame! 735 01:08:37,334 --> 01:08:40,668 - Then the bailiff. - Out! 736 01:08:40,876 --> 01:08:42,376 What do you want? 737 01:08:43,376 --> 01:08:45,043 We want our money. 738 01:08:45,251 --> 01:08:47,501 They're bleeding us dry! 739 01:08:48,584 --> 01:08:50,209 Excuse me. 740 01:08:56,876 --> 01:08:59,626 Here. In order? 741 01:09:02,084 --> 01:09:03,501 Nice day. 742 01:09:04,334 --> 01:09:06,001 Now get out of here. 743 01:09:08,376 --> 01:09:11,543 By what miracle...? Where do you come from? 744 01:09:11,751 --> 01:09:14,251 From the post office. - Have you found work? 745 01:09:14,459 --> 01:09:18,293 Money order. From Frederick. - What's new? 746 01:09:18,501 --> 01:09:20,001 Even living ones! 747 01:09:28,834 --> 01:09:30,418 Jenny. 748 01:09:30,626 --> 01:09:32,126 Lenchen. 749 01:09:36,668 --> 01:09:38,209 I wanted to tell you 750 01:09:40,209 --> 01:09:42,543 Oh, it's not that easy to say. 751 01:09:44,334 --> 01:09:48,876 You know, the Friedrich in London struck the covenant of the righteous. 752 01:09:49,084 --> 01:09:51,418 Yes and? - You know Weitling. 753 01:09:52,543 --> 01:09:55,834 The enlightened tailor. - Don't make fun of me. 754 01:09:56,043 --> 01:10:01,251 He is a leader. He has these Organization built and made strong. 755 01:10:01,459 --> 01:10:04,251 I know. - And these people believe in something. 756 01:10:04,459 --> 01:10:06,709 But they lack solid ideas. 757 01:10:07,126 --> 01:10:08,918 That you can deliver to them. 758 01:10:11,501 --> 01:10:13,876 And what did Friedrich say? 759 01:10:20,793 --> 01:10:25,876 He asks me to come to London, to meet the members of the league. 760 01:10:30,209 --> 01:10:31,709 Understand. 761 01:10:32,209 --> 01:10:35,376 And I should go with Lenchen take care of the children. 762 01:10:35,584 --> 01:10:39,668 That doesn't matter. We get by with Mr. Engel's money. 763 01:10:43,584 --> 01:10:45,084 Oh well. 764 01:10:46,126 --> 01:10:49,751 No. Friedrich doesn't need me. He knows what to do. 765 01:10:49,959 --> 01:10:51,918 Charles - I'll stay. 766 01:10:52,126 --> 01:10:53,918 Now sit back down! 767 01:10:56,543 --> 01:10:58,293 You're crazy. 768 01:10:58,501 --> 01:11:02,668 A chance like this will never come again and you let it slip away? 769 01:11:03,043 --> 01:11:07,626 It's a very strong movement, which is represented in many countries. 770 01:11:07,834 --> 01:11:10,001 In Switzerland, in Germany 771 01:11:10,209 --> 01:11:14,334 If you become a delegate let this federal government nominate, 772 01:11:15,293 --> 01:11:17,168 you are no longer isolated. 773 01:11:17,376 --> 01:11:20,168 Together you can raise an army, 774 01:11:20,376 --> 01:11:23,251 which get bigger over time and becomes invincible. 775 01:11:27,793 --> 01:11:29,459 You have to go there. 776 01:11:35,459 --> 01:11:37,543 The covenant of the righteous 777 01:11:38,751 --> 01:11:40,084 You fool. 778 01:11:41,459 --> 01:11:43,293 Lenchen, are you coming? 779 01:11:47,584 --> 01:11:50,751 Oh, the tailor Weitling! 780 01:11:59,084 --> 01:12:00,751 It's over there! 781 01:12:04,543 --> 01:12:06,043 There she is. 782 01:12:07,209 --> 01:12:09,876 Fast. You're late. 783 01:12:12,918 --> 01:12:15,918 My friend, Karl. My wife, Mary. 784 01:12:16,626 --> 01:12:18,334 Your wife? 785 01:12:19,751 --> 01:12:22,626 You are such a great man for Frederick. 786 01:12:22,834 --> 01:12:26,501 I imagined you would be bigger. - I'm only human. 787 01:12:26,709 --> 01:12:30,293 I didn't expect... - Save yourself the compliments. 788 01:12:30,501 --> 01:12:32,001 Come on, this way. 789 01:12:48,293 --> 01:12:50,418 Don't be too sure. 790 01:12:50,626 --> 01:12:52,168 They are tough men. 791 01:12:52,376 --> 01:12:56,043 They took a lot of hits and trust no one. 792 01:12:56,251 --> 01:12:58,334 But have you read... - That too. 793 01:12:58,543 --> 01:13:01,251 Be careful with your "critical" thingy. 794 01:13:01,459 --> 01:13:03,626 She doesn't care about that. 795 01:13:05,043 --> 01:13:06,834 Very promising... 796 01:13:10,001 --> 01:13:11,376 Here are the men. 797 01:13:11,584 --> 01:13:15,084 You already know Friedrich. And this is Karl. 798 01:13:15,751 --> 01:13:17,168 Karl Marx. 799 01:13:22,918 --> 01:13:24,418 Sit down. 800 01:13:33,251 --> 01:13:36,959 The federal government differentiates between two types of people. 801 01:13:37,168 --> 01:13:41,084 Those through manual labor were steeled and formed, 802 01:13:41,293 --> 01:13:45,043 and those who benefit from it, the bourgeoisie. 803 01:13:46,668 --> 01:13:50,168 They don't seem to to belong to the first group. 804 01:13:51,168 --> 01:13:53,751 I wrote in my book 805 01:13:53,959 --> 01:13:56,084 You are an outsider. 806 01:13:56,293 --> 01:14:00,043 Have you ever experienced poverty? Prison or persecution? 807 01:14:00,251 --> 01:14:04,959 Excuse me, but if you reject us, before we have said a sound, 808 01:14:05,793 --> 01:14:09,251 then what's the motto? "All men are brothers"? 809 01:14:09,459 --> 01:14:11,001 It is our ideal... 810 01:14:11,209 --> 01:14:14,626 That's what we're fighting for. - It is our new Jerusalem. 811 01:14:14,834 --> 01:14:16,709 What are we doing here? 812 01:14:16,918 --> 01:14:22,334 The federal government needs real men, no eggheads patronizing him. 813 01:14:22,543 --> 01:14:25,876 But you want to spread your ideas, or not? 814 01:14:26,084 --> 01:14:30,293 Check us out. If we are not of any use are, reject us. 815 01:14:30,501 --> 01:14:33,126 Was there just mention of benefit? 816 01:14:33,501 --> 01:14:34,543 Marx. 817 01:14:36,043 --> 01:14:40,543 You too were from France reported. So this is where you're stuck. 818 01:14:40,751 --> 01:14:43,293 Transitional. In Brussels. - Brussels. 819 01:14:43,793 --> 01:14:46,751 I'll be staying there this fall some lectures. 820 01:14:46,959 --> 01:14:50,834 A stage on the long journey to our only goal: 821 01:14:51,043 --> 01:14:52,834 The abolition of money. 822 01:14:53,043 --> 01:14:54,834 Let's take a look. 823 01:14:55,043 --> 01:14:56,543 They have become thin. 824 01:14:57,001 --> 01:14:58,501 They suffered. 825 01:14:58,709 --> 01:15:00,209 Me too. 826 01:15:00,418 --> 01:15:02,918 I had to endure chains and beatings. 827 01:15:03,126 --> 01:15:05,626 Look what they've done to me. 828 01:15:09,334 --> 01:15:11,668 But my soul remains unbroken. 829 01:15:11,876 --> 01:15:15,293 Weitling! This is not a rally. Sit down! 830 01:15:15,501 --> 01:15:19,043 So how could you be of use to us? 831 01:15:19,751 --> 01:15:22,543 Weitling has followers in France and Switzerland, 832 01:15:22,751 --> 01:15:25,918 and you have bandages in Germany and England. 833 01:15:26,126 --> 01:15:29,084 With us you have a bridgehead in Brussels... 834 01:15:30,251 --> 01:15:34,043 - Weitling is going there. - I'm talking about something constant. 835 01:15:34,251 --> 01:15:38,168 A permanent network to Paris, even to Lyon. 836 01:15:38,918 --> 01:15:41,584 Why Lyon? - Because of Proudhon. 837 01:15:43,543 --> 01:15:45,043 Do you know Proudhon? 838 01:15:45,251 --> 01:15:48,459 Yes, I know him personally. We are very close. 839 01:15:49,459 --> 01:15:53,001 We met regularly, until I was deported. 840 01:15:53,918 --> 01:15:56,626 And we have great respect for each other. 841 01:15:57,668 --> 01:15:59,626 One could even say, 842 01:15:59,834 --> 01:16:01,834 we are one heart and one soul. 843 01:16:04,834 --> 01:16:06,918 Heart and soul? 844 01:16:07,126 --> 01:16:09,918 - Heart and soul. - Yes. heart and soul 845 01:16:19,543 --> 01:16:24,501 The thing with Proudhon was daring. You immediately turn the pawn into a queen. 846 01:16:24,709 --> 01:16:25,959 James! 847 01:16:26,168 --> 01:16:29,334 I'm sorry, lady... - I know, no women. 848 01:16:29,543 --> 01:16:33,293 Please, get my wife outside... - Sir... 849 01:16:33,501 --> 01:16:38,959 I'll make such a fuss, that you will no longer find work anywhere. 850 01:16:39,168 --> 01:16:40,751 No, Frederick... 851 01:16:41,709 --> 01:16:44,043 - I don't belong here. - Let's go. 852 01:16:44,251 --> 01:16:47,876 We can our note compare in some pub. 853 01:16:51,751 --> 01:16:56,626 Look at young Engels! - Oh, Mr. Naylor. How are you doing? 854 01:16:56,834 --> 01:17:01,834 I often ask my good friend Engels, how the young Friedrich does. 855 01:17:02,043 --> 01:17:04,501 How is your father? - As best as possible. 856 01:17:04,709 --> 01:17:07,418 May I introduce you to my wife? 857 01:17:07,626 --> 01:17:11,834 - Very pleased. - And my good friend Marx. 858 01:17:12,043 --> 01:17:13,168 I'm pleased. 859 01:17:13,376 --> 01:17:18,543 Mister Naylor owns foundries in Leeds, with many workers, including children. 860 01:17:18,751 --> 01:17:20,251 Hard but necessary. 861 01:17:20,459 --> 01:17:24,793 My friend Marx is a journalist, he is researching something for us. 862 01:17:25,001 --> 01:17:27,126 About child labor in factories. 863 01:17:28,501 --> 01:17:30,293 How many do you have? 864 01:17:30,501 --> 01:17:33,418 In a factory about 20 children to 30 men. 865 01:17:34,001 --> 01:17:35,959 Day or night shift? - Both. 866 01:17:36,168 --> 01:17:38,459 Isn't that a bit tiring? 867 01:17:38,668 --> 01:17:42,501 Health doesn't matter day or night. - your health. 868 01:17:43,293 --> 01:17:45,168 I'm sorry, what? 869 01:17:45,376 --> 01:17:48,709 My wife says, that your health doesn't matter. 870 01:17:48,918 --> 01:17:50,959 But not the children's. 871 01:17:51,584 --> 01:17:53,084 We have no choice. 872 01:17:53,459 --> 01:17:58,209 You know only too well, without child labor we wouldn't be competitive. 873 01:17:58,418 --> 01:18:00,959 Because you have to pay fair wages? 874 01:18:02,793 --> 01:18:06,459 Not me, the market determines the price. - Naturally. 875 01:18:06,668 --> 01:18:11,293 I'm not the only one who can't have children quit and go bankrupt. 876 01:18:11,501 --> 01:18:14,126 That's how society is. - No, sir. 877 01:18:14,334 --> 01:18:17,876 These are the existing ones production relations, 878 01:18:18,084 --> 01:18:20,626 Society is not you. 879 01:18:23,126 --> 01:18:28,209 I don't know what you by “production relations” mean. 880 01:18:28,834 --> 01:18:31,251 That sounds Hebrew to me... 881 01:18:33,001 --> 01:18:34,376 Thanks, James. 882 01:18:35,959 --> 01:18:39,418 If work became more expensive, there would be no more profits. 883 01:18:39,626 --> 01:18:44,293 And therefore no economy and therefore no society. 884 01:18:45,459 --> 01:18:48,001 Maybe that's it, what you want... 885 01:18:48,209 --> 01:18:52,168 You're right, we don't speak the same language. 886 01:18:52,376 --> 01:18:55,334 What you call profits I call exploitation. 887 01:18:59,168 --> 01:19:04,168 Mister Engels, I am very patient been, as a friend of your father. 888 01:19:04,376 --> 01:19:07,918 Where would a society be? without exploitation people like you? 889 01:19:08,709 --> 01:19:12,168 You would also have to work. Wouldn't that be horrible? 890 01:19:18,626 --> 01:19:20,709 My recommendation to your father. 891 01:19:29,251 --> 01:19:31,126 My old man is killing me. 892 01:19:41,834 --> 01:19:47,084 We are pleased, important representatives to welcome the labor movement. 893 01:19:47,293 --> 01:19:50,751 You, Pavel Annenkov, welcome. 894 01:19:51,418 --> 01:19:55,251 You, Hermann Kriege, and last but not least 895 01:19:56,084 --> 01:19:59,084 our great, esteemed Weitling. 896 01:19:59,293 --> 01:20:01,043 It's nothing. 897 01:20:05,126 --> 01:20:07,543 You know the reason for this meeting. 898 01:20:07,751 --> 01:20:11,543 We want a simple, define common doctrine. 899 01:20:11,751 --> 01:20:14,543 In the interest of the uneducated workers. 900 01:20:14,751 --> 01:20:17,209 This won't be easy to do. 901 01:20:17,709 --> 01:20:21,251 It is a brotherly obligation. - You and brotherly? 902 01:20:21,459 --> 01:20:25,751 - Let's be constructive. - Otherwise I wouldn't be here. 903 01:20:25,959 --> 01:20:28,751 Unless you are because something else here. 904 01:20:28,959 --> 01:20:30,501 I'm sorry, what? - What do I know? 905 01:20:30,709 --> 01:20:32,293 Charles 906 01:20:32,501 --> 01:20:35,584 I like it the idea of simplicity. 907 01:20:35,793 --> 01:20:38,709 What unites us, comrades, is simple. 908 01:20:40,501 --> 01:20:43,959 - It is the happiness of the people. - The happiness of the people? 909 01:20:44,168 --> 01:20:47,918 You can view your activities cannot be justified in any other way? 910 01:20:48,126 --> 01:20:49,668 I beg your pardon? 911 01:20:49,876 --> 01:20:54,668 Forgiveness, love, happiness, the kingdom of Christ on earth. 912 01:20:55,501 --> 01:21:00,376 I ask you, Weitling, who you so much made noise with your sermons, 913 01:21:00,584 --> 01:21:04,459 on what real theoretical basis do you support yourself? 914 01:21:04,668 --> 01:21:07,293 And which ones will you rely on in the future? 915 01:21:13,251 --> 01:21:17,626 My goal, my intention is not to create new theories, 916 01:21:17,834 --> 01:21:19,793 economic or other. 917 01:21:20,001 --> 01:21:23,876 I am against this cult of the new at any price. 918 01:21:25,543 --> 01:21:29,501 Yesterday I said it again and the whole hall went wild. 919 01:21:30,084 --> 01:21:35,668 All power to the workers, to achieve universal harmony. 920 01:21:37,126 --> 01:21:40,668 100,000 armed proletarians are enough 921 01:21:40,876 --> 01:21:43,251 and the assistance of 40,000 criminals, 922 01:21:43,459 --> 01:21:48,084 about the tyranny of the bourgeoisie finish. - Wanting to uplift the workers, 923 01:21:48,293 --> 01:21:51,293 without them to offer a constructive doctrine, 924 01:21:51,501 --> 01:21:55,376 is a dishonest game with one inspired prophets 925 01:21:55,584 --> 01:21:57,834 and speechless idiots. 926 01:21:59,293 --> 01:22:03,793 - My listeners are idiots? - Outrageous. 927 01:22:04,001 --> 01:22:07,834 - Outrageous. - Look. A Russian, between us. 928 01:22:08,043 --> 01:22:09,543 Pavel. 929 01:22:09,751 --> 01:22:13,001 In his country, maybe play a role. 930 01:22:13,209 --> 01:22:16,168 This is the only place where such things grow strange connections 931 01:22:16,376 --> 01:22:19,834 between confused prophets and confused followers. 932 01:22:20,043 --> 01:22:23,959 But here, in Germany, France and England 933 01:22:24,168 --> 01:22:27,293 nothing happens without it a materialistic theory. 934 01:22:27,501 --> 01:22:32,209 This man has under the banner of Justice Hundreds Gathered! 935 01:22:32,418 --> 01:22:35,751 A double-faced person like you it would be better to remain silent. 936 01:22:35,959 --> 01:22:38,834 What do you call me? Shhh 937 01:22:39,043 --> 01:22:44,001 I have received thousands of letters prove that my humble work 938 01:22:44,209 --> 01:22:49,293 are more important than salon doctrines, far from the suffering people 939 01:22:49,501 --> 01:22:52,876 Ignorance still has never of any use to anyone! 940 01:22:53,084 --> 01:22:55,709 Take that back! Friedrich, say something! 941 01:22:55,918 --> 01:22:57,376 What's all this about? 942 01:22:57,584 --> 01:23:02,293 - I won't let that happen to me. - Be sensible, please. 943 01:23:16,501 --> 01:23:21,126 I will be the first victim of the guillotine then it's your turn, 944 01:23:21,334 --> 01:23:22,834 then your friends, 945 01:23:24,376 --> 01:23:27,709 and finally you cut cut your own neck off. 946 01:23:38,209 --> 01:23:42,626 Criticism devours everything, what exists. 947 01:23:44,043 --> 01:23:46,126 And when there's nothing left, 948 01:23:47,876 --> 01:23:49,834 she devours herself. 949 01:23:51,709 --> 01:23:53,209 Gentlemen, ladies. 950 01:24:08,251 --> 01:24:09,751 Thanks. 951 01:24:32,334 --> 01:24:34,043 What happened? 952 01:24:34,251 --> 01:24:35,751 Yes, what happened? 953 01:24:35,959 --> 01:24:39,668 Wasn't the goal to find a common doctrine? 954 01:24:39,876 --> 01:24:41,376 With such idiots? 955 01:24:42,626 --> 01:24:44,126 Karl, look at me. 956 01:24:44,709 --> 01:24:47,584 Was that intentional or just a bad mood? 957 01:24:47,793 --> 01:24:50,584 Whatever the case, we're done for. Broken. 958 01:24:51,418 --> 01:24:53,668 Green will report to Proudhon. 959 01:24:53,876 --> 01:24:57,584 Can we just stop to kowtow to Proudhon! 960 01:24:58,126 --> 01:25:00,876 Green would have bad-mouthed us anyway. 961 01:25:01,543 --> 01:25:04,501 Nice, but Proudhon was our joker, 962 01:25:04,709 --> 01:25:07,084 the king card in strategy. 963 01:25:07,293 --> 01:25:11,126 That was just a huge step for us. - And why? 964 01:25:11,334 --> 01:25:14,501 Someone enlighten me why are they idiots? 965 01:25:37,043 --> 01:25:41,126 I don't know what's stopping me, To crush them both. 966 01:25:41,334 --> 01:25:45,918 You have one of the most respectable men insulted to our movement, 967 01:25:46,126 --> 01:25:48,168 They are conceited hoodlums. 968 01:25:48,376 --> 01:25:50,376 Weitling is devastated. 969 01:25:50,918 --> 01:25:54,001 He says no one has it ever been so humiliated. 970 01:25:54,209 --> 01:25:57,376 He may have a little exaggerated. 971 01:25:58,084 --> 01:26:00,543 He has what? Would you repeat that? 972 01:26:01,668 --> 01:26:06,834 You have a man through the dirt drawn, a fighter, a leader 973 01:26:07,043 --> 01:26:10,251 Without regard his experience and maturity! 974 01:26:10,459 --> 01:26:15,709 Qualities that you completely miss! Your youth doesn't excuse everything. 975 01:26:32,293 --> 01:26:36,084 As far as you are concerned, the federal government has a decision is made. 976 01:26:36,293 --> 01:26:38,626 And I'm here to deliver it. 977 01:26:39,584 --> 01:26:44,459 You will join this community add to the decision made. 978 01:26:48,418 --> 01:26:50,584 "After careful consideration..." 979 01:26:53,001 --> 01:26:55,959 I repeat: "After careful consideration 980 01:26:56,168 --> 01:27:00,876 The London Committee asks you, firstly, to join the League of the Righteous. 981 01:27:05,334 --> 01:27:06,834 Secondly, 982 01:27:07,043 --> 01:27:09,293 to help reorganize it. 983 01:27:10,418 --> 01:27:14,876 And thirdly, to contribute to to develop a new program 984 01:27:15,084 --> 01:27:20,501 about this afterwards with all members will be discussed." understood? 985 01:27:22,501 --> 01:27:27,918 Of course you become ours invited to the next congress in autumn. 986 01:27:28,126 --> 01:27:32,418 We hope Joseph Proudhon of this to be able to convince people to take part. 987 01:27:32,626 --> 01:27:37,293 Your help with this would be valuable since you are friends with him. Not true? 988 01:27:37,501 --> 01:27:39,001 Do you have something to say? 989 01:27:40,209 --> 01:27:41,376 Nothing. 990 01:27:45,168 --> 01:27:46,334 Nothing. 991 01:27:52,168 --> 01:27:53,668 Gentlemen. 992 01:28:04,626 --> 01:28:08,418 I can do without this contract not return to Port-au-Prince. 993 01:28:08,626 --> 01:28:10,709 Of course, I understand that. 994 01:28:10,918 --> 01:28:14,459 - You have to - MARX: I know what I have to say. 995 01:28:17,459 --> 01:28:21,876 Either beats property brought the Republic to the ground 996 01:28:22,084 --> 01:28:25,168 or the Republic strikes the property to the ground. 997 01:28:36,209 --> 01:28:38,209 There he is. - Throw away the cigar. 998 01:28:39,084 --> 01:28:40,584 Proudhon! 999 01:28:40,959 --> 01:28:43,418 Dear doctor... 1000 01:28:44,418 --> 01:28:48,876 Do you remember Engels? - Naturally. Unfortunately I don't have much time. 1001 01:28:50,626 --> 01:28:54,209 I have your letter not fully understood. What is it about? 1002 01:28:54,418 --> 01:28:55,876 Yes, right away, green. 1003 01:28:57,459 --> 01:29:00,543 It was about the covenant of the righteous. A movement, 1004 01:29:00,751 --> 01:29:05,376 which extends into the New World. - Very briefly, what do you want from me? 1005 01:29:05,584 --> 01:29:08,626 To be his correspondent in France. 1006 01:29:09,251 --> 01:29:12,376 - Rapporteur? - Master, we have to go. 1007 01:29:12,584 --> 01:29:16,001 Don't call me master! Let me breathe. 1008 01:29:18,501 --> 01:29:21,709 A nice boy, but it hangs on the tail of my coat. 1009 01:29:21,918 --> 01:29:26,043 He tells everyone he has you taught German philosophy. 1010 01:29:26,251 --> 01:29:28,043 Pssst! 1011 01:29:28,251 --> 01:29:31,584 You know, he has a wife and two children to feed. 1012 01:29:31,793 --> 01:29:34,584 Understandable, that it puffs up a bit. 1013 01:29:35,709 --> 01:29:37,376 What did you want? 1014 01:29:38,418 --> 01:29:41,043 That I become a federal delegate? 1015 01:29:41,251 --> 01:29:42,918 I'll be honest with you. 1016 01:29:43,709 --> 01:29:49,376 I have too much work and I'm too lazy, to take on further obligations. 1017 01:29:49,584 --> 01:29:51,043 You are younger than me. 1018 01:29:51,251 --> 01:29:54,293 You don't have to respond immediately. 1019 01:29:54,501 --> 01:29:59,376 We will send you the documents. - No, really not. However 1020 01:29:59,584 --> 01:30:04,126 I would like to have our discussions continue as an exchange of letters. 1021 01:30:04,334 --> 01:30:06,209 But please, my dear Marx, 1022 01:30:06,418 --> 01:30:10,626 let's not slaughter each other or drag us through the mud! 1023 01:30:10,834 --> 01:30:15,418 Don't do it like Luther, who destroyed Catholic dogma 1024 01:30:15,626 --> 01:30:18,709 and one as well founded an intolerant religion. 1025 01:30:21,126 --> 01:30:22,668 Is this your final word? 1026 01:30:24,043 --> 01:30:27,751 Absolutely not, dear Marx. Certainly not. 1027 01:30:31,918 --> 01:30:34,793 The whole story is still ahead of us. 1028 01:30:38,876 --> 01:30:40,126 Moment. 1029 01:30:49,501 --> 01:30:51,459 My latest book. 1030 01:30:52,793 --> 01:30:54,293 Thanks. 1031 01:30:55,084 --> 01:30:57,793 I'm looking forward to your comment. 1032 01:31:00,168 --> 01:31:02,001 Greet your family. 1033 01:31:09,543 --> 01:31:12,668 The Philosophy of misery. 1034 01:31:19,709 --> 01:31:23,126 This congress must we decide for ourselves, yes? 1035 01:31:24,793 --> 01:31:26,293 Yes. 1036 01:31:27,626 --> 01:31:29,126 Secure. 1037 01:31:32,626 --> 01:31:35,543 But how? - Let that be my concern. 1038 01:31:41,209 --> 01:31:42,709 And Proudhon? 1039 01:31:46,626 --> 01:31:48,876 That will probably be my concern then. 1040 01:32:45,043 --> 01:32:47,126 The misery of philosophy! 1041 01:32:47,334 --> 01:32:50,793 Do you have Proudhons Read Philosophy of Misery? 1042 01:32:52,001 --> 01:32:57,334 Here is Marx's answer to that: The misery of philosophy. 1043 01:32:57,543 --> 01:33:01,751 Today at the first congress of the League of the Righteous in London: 1044 01:33:01,959 --> 01:33:04,751 our brothers from Leipzig and Berlin. 1045 01:33:04,959 --> 01:33:09,376 The emissaries are here from Sweden from Uppsala and Stockholm. 1046 01:33:10,043 --> 01:33:12,584 We expect news soon 1047 01:33:12,793 --> 01:33:15,626 from our friends from Philadelphia and New York. 1048 01:33:16,126 --> 01:33:21,793 Karl, may I introduce you to a few comrades imagine? Wilhelm, Hans, Walter. 1049 01:33:22,001 --> 01:33:26,334 - Nice, yes. Hermann! - But nothing new from Weitling. 1050 01:33:26,543 --> 01:33:28,709 Do you hear, Weitling? 1051 01:33:31,459 --> 01:33:34,459 How are you doing? - Good. You have to talk to him. 1052 01:33:36,251 --> 01:33:38,418 Lizzy! - That's nice. 1053 01:33:38,626 --> 01:33:40,126 Everything OK? 1054 01:33:40,668 --> 01:33:43,959 - Uh, Mister Engels? - Yes, that's me. 1055 01:33:44,168 --> 01:33:47,001 I'm Donald Murray. I'm pleased. 1056 01:33:47,209 --> 01:33:50,751 I'm sorry, but you're not standing on the speaker list. 1057 01:33:50,959 --> 01:33:53,251 They are not officially delegated. 1058 01:33:53,459 --> 01:33:57,543 What do you mean? We are members of the federal government, i.e. delegates. 1059 01:33:57,751 --> 01:34:01,334 It can only do one accredited delegates. 1060 01:34:01,543 --> 01:34:04,376 Accredited... But I am accredited. 1061 01:34:04,584 --> 01:34:07,334 You are invited, not accredited. 1062 01:34:07,543 --> 01:34:09,626 You can watch - No. 1063 01:34:09,834 --> 01:34:12,709 We don't come from that far to watch. 1064 01:34:13,751 --> 01:34:15,751 I demand a vote. 1065 01:34:15,959 --> 01:34:18,834 You will lose. You have too many opponents. 1066 01:34:19,043 --> 01:34:21,501 I have to be a delegate, period, out. 1067 01:34:29,251 --> 01:34:32,876 I was asked to for the delegation from Brussels... 1068 01:34:34,876 --> 01:34:38,834 - I call for a vote. - Why? Does it have to be that way? 1069 01:34:39,043 --> 01:34:43,418 Which of those present is against the accreditation of Friedrich Engels 1070 01:34:43,626 --> 01:34:46,626 as the only delegate for the Brussels region? 1071 01:34:46,834 --> 01:34:51,168 - We are for it! - Not us! Against it! 1072 01:34:51,376 --> 01:34:54,293 Who votes against? Raise your hand. 1073 01:34:59,834 --> 01:35:01,334 And who is for it? 1074 01:35:04,293 --> 01:35:06,751 Engels is with a simple majority 1075 01:35:06,959 --> 01:35:10,418 accepted as Brussels representative. 1076 01:35:15,084 --> 01:35:16,793 Come on, Friedrich, come on! 1077 01:35:22,959 --> 01:35:24,459 Thanks. 1078 01:35:25,376 --> 01:35:28,793 On behalf of my friends in France, 1079 01:35:29,876 --> 01:35:33,001 Germany, Switzerland and Belgium 1080 01:35:33,959 --> 01:35:37,084 am I here, to set out the principles 1081 01:35:37,668 --> 01:35:41,084 on whose basis we plan the future battle... 1082 01:35:42,001 --> 01:35:43,959 Because let’s not kid ourselves: 1083 01:35:44,168 --> 01:35:47,626 This fight is going to be extreme become violent 1084 01:35:47,834 --> 01:35:49,668 Enough, enough violence! 1085 01:35:50,459 --> 01:35:54,293 What we demand what humanity demands 1086 01:35:55,043 --> 01:35:58,668 is goodness! Fraternity! 1087 01:35:58,876 --> 01:36:00,459 What the world needs 1088 01:36:00,668 --> 01:36:04,543 more than our bodies water, is kindness. 1089 01:36:04,751 --> 01:36:10,418 - A deep brotherhood. - He's right! Let him talk! 1090 01:36:12,501 --> 01:36:17,376 There are probably people here for whom tears well up, 1091 01:36:17,584 --> 01:36:22,959 when they say the words kindness, Hear kindness and brotherhood. 1092 01:36:23,168 --> 01:36:26,793 But tears don't give power. 1093 01:36:27,001 --> 01:36:29,459 Power sheds no tears. 1094 01:36:29,668 --> 01:36:32,084 The bourgeoisie is not friendly 1095 01:36:32,293 --> 01:36:34,918 and you won't conquer with kindness. 1096 01:36:35,918 --> 01:36:39,293 Citizens, friends, comrades. 1097 01:36:40,459 --> 01:36:42,043 Why are we here? 1098 01:36:42,251 --> 01:36:44,793 Because we fight! 1099 01:36:46,043 --> 01:36:48,168 And what are we fighting for? 1100 01:36:48,376 --> 01:36:49,501 Freedom! - Equality! 1101 01:36:49,709 --> 01:36:51,293 All people are brothers! 1102 01:36:52,793 --> 01:36:55,043 All people are brothers? 1103 01:36:55,918 --> 01:36:57,626 All people are brothers? 1104 01:37:00,251 --> 01:37:03,043 Is that you? You? And you? 1105 01:37:03,251 --> 01:37:04,501 Yes, of course. 1106 01:37:04,709 --> 01:37:07,418 And what about you? Me? Everyone here today? 1107 01:37:09,668 --> 01:37:11,959 Are bourgeoisie and workers brothers? 1108 01:37:12,168 --> 01:37:14,751 No! No! 1109 01:37:14,959 --> 01:37:16,459 No, they're not. 1110 01:37:18,084 --> 01:37:19,584 They are enemies! 1111 01:37:21,459 --> 01:37:24,376 We have to know why we gather here. 1112 01:37:24,584 --> 01:37:28,834 Because of an abstract idea? A sentimental daydream? 1113 01:37:29,043 --> 01:37:31,168 How far do we get with this? 1114 01:37:31,376 --> 01:37:35,334 We have to know what the federal government wants, what he is fighting for! 1115 01:37:35,543 --> 01:37:38,709 And we have to decide that now. - Why now? 1116 01:37:38,918 --> 01:37:42,251 We know who you represent. Marx is there. 1117 01:37:42,459 --> 01:37:44,876 He's hiding now. 1118 01:37:45,084 --> 01:37:48,084 Long live Weitling! - Long live Proudhon! 1119 01:37:48,793 --> 01:37:51,543 No, I'm here. I'm not hiding. 1120 01:37:51,751 --> 01:37:56,084 You shout "Long live Proudhon" and “Long Live Weitling,” but to what end? 1121 01:37:56,293 --> 01:37:57,959 Quiet! - We already know that! 1122 01:37:58,168 --> 01:38:02,459 Proudhon does not leave France. And Weitling has given up. 1123 01:38:02,668 --> 01:38:05,251 You cheer for Shadow! All of you. 1124 01:38:05,459 --> 01:38:07,834 All of you! 1125 01:38:12,209 --> 01:38:16,293 I have the book here, that Marx speaks of. 1126 01:38:16,501 --> 01:38:18,459 His answer to Proudhon... 1127 01:38:18,668 --> 01:38:24,084 He asks the fundamental question and brings This brings our struggle to the point. 1128 01:38:24,293 --> 01:38:27,209 Charles. - Go on, you have the floor. 1129 01:38:31,751 --> 01:38:36,626 "The opposition between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie 1130 01:38:36,834 --> 01:38:40,043 can only go to one lead to total revolution..." 1131 01:38:40,251 --> 01:38:42,043 Shut him up! 1132 01:38:42,251 --> 01:38:45,043 "and as long as classes exist, 1133 01:38:45,251 --> 01:38:50,793 becomes the last word in social science always read...", as George Sand said: 1134 01:38:51,751 --> 01:38:53,251 "The Fight or Death." 1135 01:38:55,043 --> 01:38:56,543 "The bloody battle... 1136 01:38:57,334 --> 01:38:59,001 or nothingness." 1137 01:39:00,793 --> 01:39:03,668 - Long live George Sand! - Long live Marx! 1138 01:39:06,209 --> 01:39:09,959 Anyone who refuses to fight should stand up and say it! 1139 01:39:10,168 --> 01:39:15,209 The industrial revolution has produced the modern slave. 1140 01:39:15,418 --> 01:39:17,959 This slave is the proletariat. 1141 01:39:18,168 --> 01:39:22,293 When it frees itself, it liberates all of humanity! 1142 01:39:22,501 --> 01:39:24,876 And this freedom has a name! 1143 01:39:28,293 --> 01:39:29,793 Communism! 1144 01:39:33,251 --> 01:39:37,876 Therefore, I demand to abolish this motto! 1145 01:39:38,084 --> 01:39:41,001 Because it is misleading and weak! 1146 01:39:41,209 --> 01:39:42,709 This is a coup! 1147 01:39:43,418 --> 01:39:45,084 Here is our motto! 1148 01:39:46,043 --> 01:39:49,209 "Workers of all countries unite!" 1149 01:39:49,418 --> 01:39:52,459 I request that the covenant of the righteous 1150 01:39:52,668 --> 01:39:56,543 from today on will be renamed to "League of Communists"! 1151 01:39:56,751 --> 01:39:58,251 Who is for it? 1152 01:40:06,876 --> 01:40:08,876 And who is against it? 1153 01:40:12,918 --> 01:40:16,376 As of today, we are calling ourselves official 1154 01:40:17,501 --> 01:40:19,001 League of Communists! 1155 01:40:27,209 --> 01:40:28,834 The League of Communists! 1156 01:41:31,418 --> 01:41:33,834 You have two beautiful children, Jenny. 1157 01:41:38,168 --> 01:41:40,334 Would you like some too? 1158 01:41:40,543 --> 01:41:42,543 Fred? As a father? 1159 01:41:44,876 --> 01:41:47,584 No, he's tingling too much in the legs. 1160 01:41:49,001 --> 01:41:52,168 Besides, children mean a lot of sorrow for poor people. 1161 01:41:52,751 --> 01:41:54,959 But Fred... - I know. 1162 01:41:55,793 --> 01:41:59,251 He has money. Dirty money... 1163 01:42:00,668 --> 01:42:03,626 No. I want to be free. 1164 01:42:05,543 --> 01:42:08,334 I am free. I want to fight. 1165 01:42:08,918 --> 01:42:11,376 And to fight, I have to stay poor. 1166 01:42:12,251 --> 01:42:13,751 That's how I see it. 1167 01:42:15,876 --> 01:42:17,418 He understands me. 1168 01:42:32,626 --> 01:42:34,793 So no children with him? Ever? 1169 01:42:40,626 --> 01:42:42,751 Maybe with Lizzy, later. 1170 01:42:44,751 --> 01:42:46,251 Who is Lizzy? 1171 01:42:47,126 --> 01:42:49,543 My sister. She is 16. 1172 01:42:49,751 --> 01:42:53,501 She could give him some. She's practically begging for it. 1173 01:43:01,418 --> 01:43:03,334 Did I say something wrong? 1174 01:43:16,418 --> 01:43:21,251 No time? You have the program supposed to deliver a week ago. 1175 01:43:21,459 --> 01:43:25,251 I am behind on three items and I need the money. 1176 01:43:25,459 --> 01:43:26,959 The time is ripe! 1177 01:43:27,168 --> 01:43:30,584 I have a family to feed. Not you! 1178 01:43:34,043 --> 01:43:35,751 You are unfair. 1179 01:43:37,626 --> 01:43:39,584 Sorry. I want to say: 1180 01:43:39,793 --> 01:43:43,959 I can't stay away from others forever be dependent, not even on you. 1181 01:43:45,459 --> 01:43:48,376 I can too do nothing with your notes. 1182 01:43:48,584 --> 01:43:50,834 A Catechism of Communism? 1183 01:43:51,043 --> 01:43:54,084 That's what they asked us to do? - Why? It's idiotic! 1184 01:43:54,293 --> 01:43:57,251 So that the worker can do it himself can remember better. 1185 01:43:57,459 --> 01:43:59,751 I know, this is annoying crap. 1186 01:43:59,959 --> 01:44:02,043 I didn't say that. - But! 1187 01:44:03,209 --> 01:44:08,084 Charge it to me. Just tell the committee it's my fault. 1188 01:44:08,293 --> 01:44:09,793 Is that my style? 1189 01:44:10,001 --> 01:44:14,334 I don't know, but in London they slowly lose trust. 1190 01:44:15,918 --> 01:44:18,376 We have a final deadline. 1191 01:44:18,959 --> 01:44:20,459 February 1st. 1192 01:44:22,709 --> 01:44:24,209 That's soon. 1193 01:44:26,001 --> 01:44:28,001 What if we have nothing? 1194 01:44:28,209 --> 01:44:32,084 Then you all have to return borrowed documents and 1195 01:44:32,959 --> 01:44:35,793 there will be measures initiated against you. 1196 01:44:41,668 --> 01:44:43,668 Let them initiate it. 1197 01:44:49,709 --> 01:44:51,209 I'm tired. 1198 01:44:52,209 --> 01:44:53,918 Tired? 1199 01:44:54,126 --> 01:44:55,626 You? 1200 01:44:57,876 --> 01:45:01,543 Karl, the peoples are in turmoil! The price of bread is rising. 1201 01:45:02,209 --> 01:45:05,293 There are more in Ireland than 500,000 people starved to death. 1202 01:45:05,501 --> 01:45:07,501 Unemployment is increasing. 1203 01:45:07,709 --> 01:45:12,251 Austria and France are hanging on by a thread, Poland is ready! 1204 01:45:12,459 --> 01:45:14,876 We're winning, for God's sake! 1205 01:45:15,084 --> 01:45:17,918 Get up too, good heavens! Wake up! 1206 01:45:18,959 --> 01:45:20,459 I never stopped. 1207 01:45:22,126 --> 01:45:24,251 Never. Not for a second. 1208 01:45:25,751 --> 01:45:30,459 I'll be 30 soon, Friedrich. I have no money or energy left. 1209 01:45:30,668 --> 01:45:32,168 I want to write books. 1210 01:45:34,876 --> 01:45:37,334 That just takes a lot of patience. 1211 01:45:39,626 --> 01:45:42,626 I've had enough of leaflets and manifestos 1212 01:45:42,834 --> 01:45:44,334 It's okay. 1213 01:45:46,168 --> 01:45:47,709 You know, as do I, that... 1214 01:45:48,793 --> 01:45:51,334 all the work, this tremendous work, 1215 01:45:51,543 --> 01:45:54,501 the books, articles, lectures were free, 1216 01:45:54,709 --> 01:46:00,168 if we don't write a simple book, that summarizes everything that everyone can understand. 1217 01:46:00,751 --> 01:46:03,334 The misery of philosophy, good. 1218 01:46:03,543 --> 01:46:07,168 But we need a real one communist manifesto. 1219 01:46:07,376 --> 01:46:11,334 Proudhon will not recover from this. Weitling is at the end. 1220 01:46:13,668 --> 01:46:15,668 Do you want to stop this now? 1221 01:46:15,876 --> 01:46:17,376 Really? 1222 01:46:21,376 --> 01:46:25,376 You can rest afterwards. We both will rest. 1223 01:46:27,168 --> 01:46:28,709 We become good citizens 1224 01:46:28,918 --> 01:46:33,293 me in Barmen with mother and you in Trier with ten children. 1225 01:46:34,126 --> 01:46:35,626 Do you like that? 1226 01:46:42,084 --> 01:46:45,168 Now I believed for a moment you are serious. 1227 01:46:55,043 --> 01:46:57,043 Karl, what does that mean? 1228 01:46:58,126 --> 01:46:59,751 “Frightening figure”. 1229 01:47:00,501 --> 01:47:02,293 “Frightening figure”. 1230 01:47:02,501 --> 01:47:04,001 No, wait. 1231 01:47:08,751 --> 01:47:10,626 "A ghost 1232 01:47:11,626 --> 01:47:13,126 is going around in Europe." 1233 01:47:19,376 --> 01:47:23,918 "A ghost is haunting Europe, the specter of communism. 1234 01:47:24,126 --> 01:47:26,959 All the powers of old Europe 1235 01:47:28,709 --> 01:47:31,501 all the powers of the old 1236 01:47:32,626 --> 01:47:34,126 Europe..." 1237 01:47:36,376 --> 01:47:38,834 - Leave it. - Jenny, read it to him. 1238 01:47:41,084 --> 01:47:46,793 "A ghost is haunting Europe, the specter of communism. 1239 01:47:47,501 --> 01:47:52,001 All the powers of old Europe have each other for a holy hunt 1240 01:47:52,209 --> 01:47:57,584 allied against this ghost, the Pope and the Tsar, Metternich and Guizot, 1241 01:47:57,793 --> 01:48:03,584 French radicals and German ones Police officers of history... company..." 1242 01:48:06,168 --> 01:48:07,709 That doesn't make any sense. 1243 01:48:08,126 --> 01:48:10,001 What doesn't make sense? - Here. 1244 01:48:12,876 --> 01:48:17,043 You're right, the central one is missing paragraph. Friedrich, where is he? 1245 01:48:17,876 --> 01:48:20,876 - Where is he? Quick! - Don't push me. 1246 01:48:22,709 --> 01:48:24,209 Here. 1247 01:48:25,709 --> 01:48:30,668 "It is high time that the communists... their point of view, their purposes, 1248 01:48:30,876 --> 01:48:35,334 explain their tendencies and the fairy tale of the specter of communism 1249 01:48:35,543 --> 01:48:38,543 a manifesto of the party itself oppose. 1250 01:48:38,751 --> 01:48:40,251 Show me here. 1251 01:48:45,584 --> 01:48:48,834 So... I would write: 1252 01:48:49,959 --> 01:48:53,668 "their way of seeing things, their purposes, their tendencies 1253 01:48:53,876 --> 01:48:56,918 openly to the whole world..." 1254 01:49:03,709 --> 01:49:07,459 The story of all previous society' 1255 01:49:07,668 --> 01:49:10,209 is the story of class struggles. 1256 01:49:10,834 --> 01:49:15,168 Society is becoming more and more divided into two enemy camps. 1257 01:49:15,376 --> 01:49:19,376 In two large ones, diametrically opposed to each other opposite classes. 1258 01:49:21,126 --> 01:49:24,209 The bourgeoisie and the proletariat. 1259 01:49:28,376 --> 01:49:33,834 The bourgeoisie has personal dignity dissolved into a simple exchange value 1260 01:49:34,043 --> 01:49:38,709 And instead of countless securitized, she has pain/acquired freedoms 1261 01:49:38,918 --> 01:49:43,709 the only and pitiless freedom of trade and profit. 1262 01:49:43,918 --> 01:49:49,834 She has his family relationship touching, sentimental veil torn away 1263 01:49:50,043 --> 01:49:53,501 and it on a pure Money ratio returned. 1264 01:49:55,001 --> 01:50:00,418 She has the holy thrills of the pious Enthusiasm of bourgeois melancholy 1265 01:50:00,626 --> 01:50:04,251 in the ice cold water drowned by selfish calculation. 1266 01:50:10,793 --> 01:50:14,876 The trade crises are increasing in their periodic recurrence 1267 01:50:15,084 --> 01:50:19,084 again and again the existence of the whole civil society in question. 1268 01:50:19,293 --> 01:50:23,918 The need for one always expanded sales for their products 1269 01:50:24,126 --> 01:50:25,834 chases them across the globe. 1270 01:50:27,168 --> 01:50:31,043 A bourgeoisie is developing of general trade 1271 01:50:31,251 --> 01:50:35,501 and such an all-round dependency of the nations from each other: 1272 01:50:38,001 --> 01:50:41,334 The modern bourgeoisie resembles a magician, 1273 01:50:41,543 --> 01:50:45,251 who has the devilish powers, which he has conjured up, 1274 01:50:45,459 --> 01:50:47,709 no longer under control. 1275 01:50:48,543 --> 01:50:52,876 Die Waffen, womit die Bourgeoise den Feudalismus geschlagen hat, 1276 01:50:53,084 --> 01:50:56,251 richten sich jetzt gegen die Bourgeoisie selbst. 1277 01:51:53,376 --> 01:51:57,918 Song: Bob Dylan - Like a Rolling Stone ♪ Once upon a time you dressed so fine 1278 01:51:58,126 --> 01:52:01,126 ♪ Threw the bums a dime in your prime, didn't you? 1279 01:52:03,626 --> 01:52:06,876 ♪ Peaple call, say, ”Beware doll, you're bound to fall” 1280 01:52:07,084 --> 01:52:11,001 ♪ You thought they were all kiddin ' you 1281 01:52:14,376 --> 01:52:18,126 ♪ You used to laugh about 1282 01:52:19,543 --> 01:52:23,084 ♪ everybody that was hangin' out 1283 01:52:24,251 --> 01:52:27,209 ♪ Now you don't talk so loud 1284 01:52:28,626 --> 01:52:32,293 ♪ Now you don't seem so proud 1285 01:52:33,376 --> 01:52:40,334 ♪ About having to be scrounging your next meal 1286 01:52:42,043 --> 01:52:44,459 ♪ How does it feel 1287 01:52:47,459 --> 01:52:49,376 ♪ How does it feel 1288 01:52:51,668 --> 01:52:54,418 ♪ to be without a home 1289 01:52:56,626 --> 01:52:59,126 ♪ without a direction home 1290 01:53:01,709 --> 01:53:04,668 ♪ like a complete unknown 1291 01:53:06,668 --> 01:53:10,043 ♪ like a rolling stone?