Would you like to inspect the original subtitles? These are the user uploaded subtitles that are being translated:
1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:04,162
WWW.MY-SUBS.CO
1
00:00:02,434 --> 00:00:06,304
Vincent:
This is where the wealthyand the powerful rule.
2
00:00:06,371 --> 00:00:08,806
It is her world,
3
00:00:08,874 --> 00:00:12,277
A world apart from mine.
4
00:00:12,344 --> 00:00:16,047
Her name... Is catherine.
5
00:00:18,951 --> 00:00:22,020
From the moment I saw her,she captured my heart
6
00:00:22,087 --> 00:00:24,656
With her beauty,
7
00:00:24,723 --> 00:00:29,193
Her warmth and her courage.
8
00:00:29,261 --> 00:00:32,063
I knew then, as I know now,
9
00:00:32,131 --> 00:00:35,099
She would change my life...
10
00:00:35,167 --> 00:00:37,969
Forever.
11
00:00:41,140 --> 00:00:45,810
Catherine:
He comes from a secret place,far below the city streets,
12
00:00:45,878 --> 00:00:49,313
Hiding his face from strangers,
13
00:00:49,381 --> 00:00:52,184
Safe from hate and harm.
14
00:00:52,251 --> 00:00:55,787
He brought me thereto save my life.
15
00:00:55,855 --> 00:01:00,858
And now, wherever I go,he is with me in spirit.
16
00:01:00,926 --> 00:01:04,863
For we have a bond strongerthan friendship or love.
17
00:01:04,931 --> 00:01:07,532
And althoughwe cannot be together,
18
00:01:07,600 --> 00:01:11,036
We will never, ever be apart.
19
00:01:41,233 --> 00:01:44,769
♪ ♪
20
00:02:13,232 --> 00:02:15,099
♪ ♪
21
00:02:41,693 --> 00:02:43,828
(knocking)
22
00:02:51,470 --> 00:02:53,404
What is it, catherine?
23
00:02:53,472 --> 00:02:55,640
What makes you so sad?
24
00:03:01,681 --> 00:03:05,083
Sometimes I see things...
25
00:03:05,151 --> 00:03:06,851
And I can't help but wonder
26
00:03:06,919 --> 00:03:09,320
If there's any hope
left for any of us.
27
00:03:15,093 --> 00:03:17,361
I have known
that feeling.
28
00:03:21,066 --> 00:03:23,902
A father...
29
00:03:23,969 --> 00:03:26,237
Beats his child to death.
30
00:03:29,875 --> 00:03:32,744
What does that say
about us?
31
00:03:32,811 --> 00:03:35,780
About our world and the way
we treat each other?
32
00:03:41,286 --> 00:03:43,654
Evil exists, it's real.
33
00:03:43,722 --> 00:03:46,724
We know that.
34
00:03:46,792 --> 00:03:48,927
But when it touches
little children...
35
00:03:51,396 --> 00:03:54,933
...It tells us that no one
anywhere is safe.
36
00:04:00,806 --> 00:04:02,574
We have children
living with us below
37
00:04:02,574 --> 00:04:04,876
Who have suffered more
in their young years
38
00:04:04,943 --> 00:04:07,845
Than anyone should be
allowed in 100 lifetimes.
39
00:04:10,182 --> 00:04:12,583
Where's the hope?
40
00:04:12,651 --> 00:04:15,353
Within you.
41
00:04:18,190 --> 00:04:19,290
Within us.
42
00:04:19,358 --> 00:04:20,525
We must not
let it die.
43
00:04:20,593 --> 00:04:22,961
We must protect it...
44
00:04:23,029 --> 00:04:25,196
For each other.
45
00:04:28,366 --> 00:04:30,334
(car horns honking)
46
00:04:35,241 --> 00:04:37,308
She's inside
with her lawyer.
47
00:04:37,376 --> 00:04:40,111
I'll be here, but I don't
think you'll need me.
48
00:04:46,084 --> 00:04:48,353
I'm peter rundler,
mrs. Nolan's lawyer.
49
00:04:48,421 --> 00:04:50,321
Catherine chandler.
50
00:04:52,491 --> 00:04:54,425
Mrs. Nolan...
51
00:04:56,194 --> 00:04:58,763
You understand the da's office
is considering
52
00:04:58,864 --> 00:05:02,533
A grant of immunity for you
to testify against your husband.
53
00:05:02,635 --> 00:05:05,002
Before I decide whether
to recommend that course,
54
00:05:05,071 --> 00:05:06,604
I'll need to ask you
a few questions.
55
00:05:06,671 --> 00:05:08,739
My client doesn't
want to answer
any questions
56
00:05:08,807 --> 00:05:10,041
Until she
has immunity.
57
00:05:10,109 --> 00:05:12,209
She doesn't want to
incriminate herself.
58
00:05:12,277 --> 00:05:13,978
Mr. Rundler, I already have
your client's
59
00:05:14,045 --> 00:05:16,347
Latest statements
to the police.
60
00:05:16,415 --> 00:05:18,383
I'm only asking her
to illuminate some points
61
00:05:18,450 --> 00:05:20,484
Which are likely
to be raised in court.
62
00:05:20,552 --> 00:05:23,254
There are very sensitive
issues with mrs. Nolan.
63
00:05:23,322 --> 00:05:25,189
It was so quiet.
64
00:05:28,027 --> 00:05:32,130
That's how I knew it was bad.
65
00:05:32,197 --> 00:05:34,899
Usually, there was screaming
or yelling.
66
00:05:40,773 --> 00:05:42,407
(sighs)
67
00:05:42,475 --> 00:05:44,609
Mrs. Nolan,
68
00:05:44,676 --> 00:05:48,245
In what condition
was jonathan when
you found him?
69
00:05:48,314 --> 00:05:51,282
No.
70
00:05:51,349 --> 00:05:53,951
No.
71
00:05:54,019 --> 00:05:55,920
I'm sorry,
mrs. Nolan,
72
00:05:56,088 --> 00:05:57,522
But we're
preparing a case
73
00:05:57,590 --> 00:05:59,223
For your husband's
grand jury hearing.
74
00:05:59,290 --> 00:06:01,125
We need to know
what your testimony
75
00:06:01,192 --> 00:06:02,927
Will be.
76
00:06:08,167 --> 00:06:09,533
Joe:
Don't you get it?
77
00:06:09,601 --> 00:06:11,936
Prosecute her,
and we lose her testimony.
78
00:06:12,004 --> 00:06:13,905
Then all we have against nolan
is circumstantial.
79
00:06:13,906 --> 00:06:16,540
She is an accessory
to her own child's murder.
80
00:06:16,608 --> 00:06:18,142
She should pay for that!
81
00:06:18,277 --> 00:06:20,978
Maybe. Maybe she'll be paying
for it for the rest of her life.
82
00:06:21,147 --> 00:06:22,814
(scoffs)
that is not what I meant.
83
00:06:22,848 --> 00:06:24,348
Cathy, you're thinking
with your heart.
84
00:06:24,416 --> 00:06:25,883
So will the jury.
85
00:06:25,985 --> 00:06:27,618
Look, I am not going
to debate the ethics
86
00:06:27,686 --> 00:06:29,187
Of granting
molly nolan immunity,
87
00:06:29,254 --> 00:06:30,822
Because she is the key
to this thing.
88
00:06:30,889 --> 00:06:33,858
That's what moreno thinks,
that's what I think,
89
00:06:33,859 --> 00:06:35,026
And that's all
there is to it.
90
00:06:35,093 --> 00:06:36,594
How can you be
so reductive, joe?
91
00:06:36,662 --> 00:06:38,128
It's not that simple.
92
00:06:38,197 --> 00:06:40,097
In a court of law,
and for our purposes,
93
00:06:40,265 --> 00:06:41,332
It is that simple.
94
00:06:41,399 --> 00:06:43,434
As simple as the fact
that you and I both know
95
00:06:43,535 --> 00:06:45,169
Richard nolan is guilty.
96
00:06:45,171 --> 00:06:47,471
(sighs)
97
00:06:47,539 --> 00:06:51,242
So, I'm just supposed
to put aside my feelings?
98
00:06:51,243 --> 00:06:53,744
If it interferes
with your work, absolutely.
99
00:06:55,514 --> 00:06:58,650
Tell me now-- are you going
to work with me on this or not?
100
00:06:58,717 --> 00:07:00,551
Do you want me
to get somebody else?
101
00:07:02,821 --> 00:07:04,288
I want to do this.
102
00:07:04,356 --> 00:07:05,590
I just...
103
00:07:05,657 --> 00:07:07,257
(sighs)
104
00:07:07,325 --> 00:07:10,728
It's hard for me
to separate myself like that.
105
00:07:10,830 --> 00:07:12,830
(sighs)
106
00:07:12,898 --> 00:07:14,832
I know.
107
00:07:34,452 --> 00:07:36,888
(subway car chugging)
108
00:07:45,965 --> 00:07:47,899
(subway car clanging)
109
00:07:56,808 --> 00:07:58,643
(groans softly)
110
00:08:04,884 --> 00:08:07,084
(groaning softly)
111
00:08:12,858 --> 00:08:13,958
Man:
Did the grand
jury indict?
112
00:08:14,026 --> 00:08:15,126
Is the case
going to trial?
113
00:08:15,194 --> 00:08:16,727
Man #2:
Excuse me, sir.
Yes, it is.
114
00:08:16,862 --> 00:08:18,796
Is it true mrs. Nolan lied
to the police several times
115
00:08:18,864 --> 00:08:20,331
Before blaming
her husband?
116
00:08:20,398 --> 00:08:21,666
I'm afraid I can't comment
on substantive details
117
00:08:21,733 --> 00:08:22,866
Of the prosecution,
gentlemen.
118
00:08:22,934 --> 00:08:24,402
Why was nolan the
only one accused?
119
00:08:24,169 --> 00:08:25,436
What about
his wife?
120
00:08:25,538 --> 00:08:27,238
Come on, fellas,
you know how it works.
121
00:08:27,305 --> 00:08:28,572
All I can tell you is
122
00:08:28,640 --> 00:08:29,640
The grand jury found
probable cause
123
00:08:29,708 --> 00:08:32,242
To believe a felony
was committed by the defendant.
124
00:08:32,310 --> 00:08:34,945
Richard nolan will be tried
by a jury of his peers.
125
00:08:35,013 --> 00:08:37,181
Isn't this just
a political ploy
126
00:08:37,249 --> 00:08:39,817
By the d.A., grabbing
after headlines
127
00:08:39,885 --> 00:08:41,586
By going after a
wall street celebrity?
128
00:08:41,653 --> 00:08:43,487
The district attorney works
for the people.
129
00:08:43,522 --> 00:08:45,556
You, me, and everyone else
in this city.
130
00:08:45,624 --> 00:08:47,291
He believes richard nolan
committed a crime
131
00:08:47,359 --> 00:08:48,726
Against the people.
132
00:08:48,793 --> 00:08:51,495
If the man is guilty,
we intend to make him pay.
133
00:08:51,530 --> 00:08:52,796
That's our job.
134
00:08:52,864 --> 00:08:54,631
What about the culpability
of his wife?
135
00:08:54,566 --> 00:08:56,300
What about
his alibi...?
136
00:08:56,368 --> 00:08:58,669
(sighs)
wow.
137
00:08:58,737 --> 00:08:59,970
Do I know you?
138
00:09:00,039 --> 00:09:01,072
I don't know.
139
00:09:01,140 --> 00:09:02,607
(both laughing)
140
00:09:02,675 --> 00:09:04,509
Joe:
So what do you think
about them letting cameras
141
00:09:04,576 --> 00:09:06,611
Into the courtroom?
142
00:09:06,678 --> 00:09:08,246
The truth?
143
00:09:09,381 --> 00:09:10,981
Yeah.
144
00:09:11,150 --> 00:09:12,950
I think it's intrusive,
voyeuristic,
145
00:09:13,017 --> 00:09:14,552
And completely unnecessary.
146
00:09:14,887 --> 00:09:16,020
I'm sorry you feel that way.
147
00:09:16,155 --> 00:09:17,922
Can I bother you two
a minute?
148
00:09:17,990 --> 00:09:19,356
Sure, boss.
Come on in.
149
00:09:19,424 --> 00:09:21,225
Why don't you have
a seat.
150
00:09:21,292 --> 00:09:22,827
No. I'll just
be a minute.
151
00:09:22,895 --> 00:09:24,862
By the way, you did a great job
with the grand jury.
152
00:09:24,930 --> 00:09:26,264
Thanks.
153
00:09:26,231 --> 00:09:28,633
Uh, I just got word that, uh,
154
00:09:28,700 --> 00:09:30,634
Virginia sheets
is defending nolan.
155
00:09:30,702 --> 00:09:33,070
From boggs and macmillan?
156
00:09:33,138 --> 00:09:34,672
Who's virginia sheets?
157
00:09:34,707 --> 00:09:36,707
One of macmillan's
pit bull protégés.
158
00:09:36,775 --> 00:09:39,744
She's out of yale,
an incredible string of wins.
159
00:09:39,812 --> 00:09:41,712
Oh.
160
00:09:41,780 --> 00:09:43,614
Yeah, between sheets
and this whole media thing,
161
00:09:43,682 --> 00:09:45,983
This case is becoming
very emotional.
162
00:09:46,050 --> 00:09:48,318
(sighs)
163
00:09:48,354 --> 00:09:49,787
This was a tough call for me.
164
00:09:49,855 --> 00:09:51,755
Really a tough
one, but, uh,
165
00:09:51,857 --> 00:09:55,826
I have decided I want catherine
to head up the prosecution.
166
00:09:55,894 --> 00:09:57,528
What?!
167
00:09:57,596 --> 00:09:58,629
Sorry, joe.
168
00:09:58,697 --> 00:10:01,398
Sir, I-I'm very flattered,
169
00:10:01,466 --> 00:10:04,602
But... Do you think
that's such a good idea?
170
00:10:04,670 --> 00:10:07,738
I mean, joe's has all
the trial experience...
171
00:10:07,806 --> 00:10:09,006
I know that.
172
00:10:09,074 --> 00:10:10,808
He's been after me for months
to give you more.
173
00:10:10,876 --> 00:10:13,177
Look, you're
going to have
174
00:10:13,245 --> 00:10:14,411
To trust me on this one.
175
00:10:14,479 --> 00:10:15,612
I've been in this game longer
176
00:10:15,781 --> 00:10:17,147
Than both of you.
177
00:10:17,149 --> 00:10:18,750
It doesn't hurt matters at all
178
00:10:18,817 --> 00:10:21,218
That the people still identify
with catherine chandler.
179
00:10:21,286 --> 00:10:23,454
Because I was a victim?
180
00:10:23,522 --> 00:10:25,323
Well, maybe you don't like
to see that exploited,
181
00:10:25,390 --> 00:10:26,957
But that is strong stuff
to a jury,
182
00:10:27,025 --> 00:10:28,959
And it may be
the one advantage we need
183
00:10:29,027 --> 00:10:30,494
If we really want
to put this guy away.
184
00:10:32,931 --> 00:10:35,799
Which is the bottom line.
185
00:10:36,768 --> 00:10:39,069
Anyway, we got to speak.
186
00:10:45,077 --> 00:10:46,711
Joe, I'm...
187
00:10:46,778 --> 00:10:49,446
(sighs)
188
00:10:49,514 --> 00:10:50,581
I'm really sorry.
189
00:10:50,648 --> 00:10:52,116
I know how much
you wanted this case.
190
00:10:52,151 --> 00:10:54,218
Hey, come on, radcliffe.
191
00:10:54,286 --> 00:10:57,355
I'm a team player.
192
00:10:57,422 --> 00:11:00,324
But I got to tell you,
I think moreno's logic stinks.
193
00:11:00,392 --> 00:11:02,160
So do I.
I'm not blaming you.
194
00:11:02,227 --> 00:11:04,495
I'm just wondering what the hell
I've been doing around here
195
00:11:04,563 --> 00:11:05,763
For the past
seven years.
196
00:11:05,830 --> 00:11:08,332
Joe!
197
00:11:14,405 --> 00:11:16,807
(indistinct, overlapping voices)
198
00:11:19,278 --> 00:11:21,445
Child's voice:
Please, please.
199
00:11:21,513 --> 00:11:23,648
Daddy?!
200
00:11:23,715 --> 00:11:25,849
(distant crying)
201
00:11:25,917 --> 00:11:29,520
Child's voice:
Help me.
202
00:11:29,588 --> 00:11:32,790
(child crying)
203
00:11:37,996 --> 00:11:41,732
(child crying)
204
00:11:41,800 --> 00:11:44,568
Child's voice:
Help me.
205
00:11:44,636 --> 00:11:45,903
Pascal:
Vincent?
206
00:11:45,971 --> 00:11:48,339
Here.
207
00:11:56,814 --> 00:11:58,615
What is it?
208
00:11:58,683 --> 00:12:00,484
Can't you hear it?
A child crying.
209
00:12:00,551 --> 00:12:02,652
Listen.
210
00:12:08,260 --> 00:12:11,028
I must find this child.
211
00:12:11,096 --> 00:12:13,230
I'm sorry, vincent.
212
00:12:13,298 --> 00:12:15,799
No one knows where
these voices come from.
213
00:12:17,869 --> 00:12:20,204
Where are you?
214
00:12:20,272 --> 00:12:22,773
Where are you?!
215
00:12:50,135 --> 00:12:52,069
(paper crinkling)
216
00:12:56,741 --> 00:12:58,809
(clears throat)
217
00:12:58,877 --> 00:13:00,178
By his own admission,
218
00:13:00,245 --> 00:13:03,647
We know that richard nolan has,
on a number of occasions,
219
00:13:03,715 --> 00:13:06,083
Physically abused
his wife, molly.
220
00:13:06,151 --> 00:13:10,153
Ladies and gentlemen,
the state will show
221
00:13:10,221 --> 00:13:13,791
That mr. Nolan also abused
his son jonathan.
222
00:13:13,858 --> 00:13:15,960
On February the 6th,
223
00:13:16,028 --> 00:13:20,397
Richard nolan carried
his pattern of abuse too far.
224
00:13:20,465 --> 00:13:24,302
On that night, he beat
his five-year-old son jonathan
225
00:13:24,369 --> 00:13:26,904
To death.
226
00:13:33,845 --> 00:13:37,748
What makes mr. Nolan's crime
so reprehensible
227
00:13:37,816 --> 00:13:41,652
Is that it was not just
a single act of violence
228
00:13:41,720 --> 00:13:44,088
But rather a sequence of acts,
229
00:13:44,222 --> 00:13:45,957
All of which display
230
00:13:46,024 --> 00:13:49,026
A cold and complete disregard
for human life.
231
00:13:49,094 --> 00:13:51,628
The sequence began
232
00:13:51,696 --> 00:13:54,731
When mr. Nolan
savagely beat his son
233
00:13:54,799 --> 00:13:59,403
For interrupting
a telephone conversation.
234
00:13:59,471 --> 00:14:01,539
The coroner will testify
235
00:14:01,606 --> 00:14:03,941
That just one
of the many blows
236
00:14:04,109 --> 00:14:08,145
Was powerful enough
to snap the child's neck.
237
00:14:08,212 --> 00:14:11,681
Mr. Nolan then ordered his wife
238
00:14:11,749 --> 00:14:15,252
To call for help only after
he'd left the apartment
239
00:14:15,320 --> 00:14:17,554
To establish an alibi.
240
00:14:17,622 --> 00:14:20,358
She was expected to lie,
241
00:14:20,392 --> 00:14:23,828
To claim that
the child had fallen.
242
00:14:23,895 --> 00:14:26,330
But when the police arrived,
243
00:14:26,397 --> 00:14:30,334
Molly nolan was so distraught
over the death of her son
244
00:14:30,401 --> 00:14:34,071
That she couldn't
keep the story straight.
245
00:14:34,139 --> 00:14:36,841
And when the police
became suspicious,
246
00:14:36,908 --> 00:14:40,110
Mr. Nolan had no choice
247
00:14:40,178 --> 00:14:43,613
But to blame his wife.
248
00:14:43,681 --> 00:14:49,052
Mr. Nolan expects you
to set him free.
249
00:14:49,120 --> 00:14:51,589
He expects you
to recognize him as a man
250
00:14:51,656 --> 00:14:54,592
Of prominence
and respectability,
251
00:14:54,659 --> 00:14:57,595
A man who could never
commit a crime like this.
252
00:14:59,764 --> 00:15:02,833
Ladies and gentlemen,
the state will show
253
00:15:02,900 --> 00:15:05,269
That on February the 6th,
254
00:15:05,337 --> 00:15:08,872
Mr. Nolan brutally beat
his five-year-old son to death
255
00:15:08,940 --> 00:15:12,643
Then coerced his wife
into lying to the police.
256
00:15:12,711 --> 00:15:17,214
And then, mr. Nolan
met his daughter, amy
257
00:15:17,282 --> 00:15:19,550
For a pleasant dinner.
258
00:15:21,986 --> 00:15:24,020
Phillips:
The great irony in this trial
259
00:15:24,088 --> 00:15:27,257
Is that my client arrives
here today after having spent
260
00:15:27,325 --> 00:15:28,992
The last five years of his life
261
00:15:29,060 --> 00:15:33,063
Helping his desperately
sick wife, molly.
262
00:15:33,131 --> 00:15:35,866
Mrs. Nolan is a highly
unstable woman
263
00:15:35,934 --> 00:15:37,801
And an admitted alcoholic.
264
00:15:37,869 --> 00:15:41,705
Now... If there were any sense
265
00:15:41,773 --> 00:15:43,340
In these proceedings,
266
00:15:43,407 --> 00:15:46,810
In my opinion, we wouldn't be
trying richard nolan
267
00:15:46,878 --> 00:15:49,179
At all for this crime.
268
00:15:49,247 --> 00:15:52,416
But since richard nolan is the
one on trial, we must consider
269
00:15:52,483 --> 00:15:55,152
The merits of the prosecution's
case against him.
270
00:15:55,220 --> 00:15:58,823
And our defense is very simple.
271
00:15:58,890 --> 00:16:01,225
Mr. Nolan cannot have
committed this crime,
272
00:16:01,292 --> 00:16:04,762
Because he was not there
when it happened.
273
00:16:04,830 --> 00:16:07,297
He was with his teenage daughter
274
00:16:07,365 --> 00:16:09,767
From a previous marriage,
amy nolan,
275
00:16:09,834 --> 00:16:12,035
As she will testify.
276
00:16:12,103 --> 00:16:13,870
Look at the facts.
277
00:16:13,938 --> 00:16:17,674
And the facts will indicate...
278
00:16:17,742 --> 00:16:19,143
Mr. Nolan
279
00:16:19,210 --> 00:16:21,145
Is an innocent man.
280
00:16:23,281 --> 00:16:25,382
Anchor (on tv):
Now we join our
live at 5:00 news team
281
00:16:25,450 --> 00:16:27,518
With the latest
on the nolan case.
282
00:16:27,586 --> 00:16:29,153
Reporter:
So how do you think mr. Nolan
283
00:16:29,221 --> 00:16:30,454
Is taking the pressure?
284
00:16:30,522 --> 00:16:31,955
Think you have him on the run?
285
00:16:32,023 --> 00:16:34,057
Catherine:
Nobody is chasing mr. Nolan.
286
00:16:34,126 --> 00:16:36,860
All we're after
is the truth here.
287
00:16:36,928 --> 00:16:39,362
And another thing,
it would be nice
288
00:16:39,430 --> 00:16:41,164
If you people would stop
treating this case
289
00:16:41,232 --> 00:16:42,566
Like a celebrity divorce.
290
00:16:42,634 --> 00:16:46,136
This trial is not about
wall street or high society,
291
00:16:46,204 --> 00:16:48,372
It is about the victims--
292
00:16:48,440 --> 00:16:51,808
Victims of a crime too many
of us pretend isn't there.
293
00:16:51,876 --> 00:16:53,143
(reporters clamoring)
294
00:16:53,211 --> 00:16:56,213
Man:
What message is this
sending to the city?
295
00:16:56,280 --> 00:16:58,215
(reporters continue clamoring)
296
00:17:04,089 --> 00:17:06,690
Coroner:
Well, in addition,he had numerous contusions
297
00:17:06,758 --> 00:17:08,191
On his face and chest,
298
00:17:08,259 --> 00:17:11,428
As well as a cut on his scalp
above the temple.
299
00:17:11,495 --> 00:17:13,063
And the cause
of death?
300
00:17:13,131 --> 00:17:14,899
Fractured spinal column.
301
00:17:14,966 --> 00:17:17,735
It would take
a great deal of force
302
00:17:17,802 --> 00:17:19,436
To break bone like that,
303
00:17:19,504 --> 00:17:20,437
Wouldn't it, doctor?
304
00:17:20,505 --> 00:17:21,472
Oh, yes.
305
00:17:21,539 --> 00:17:24,508
Would a woman of
my size and strength,
306
00:17:24,576 --> 00:17:27,177
Let's say,
have trouble doing it?
307
00:17:27,245 --> 00:17:30,847
In my opinion, it would be
very difficult, yes.
308
00:17:30,915 --> 00:17:33,450
Phillips:
Be honest with me, doctor.
309
00:17:33,518 --> 00:17:36,687
There is no way that you can
estimate with certainty
310
00:17:36,755 --> 00:17:39,489
Whether one individual
can or cannot inflict
311
00:17:39,557 --> 00:17:41,892
A certain degree of
bodily injury to another.
312
00:17:41,960 --> 00:17:43,027
Am I right?
313
00:17:43,094 --> 00:17:44,728
Oh, in many cases,
one could possibly say...
314
00:17:44,796 --> 00:17:47,164
But in this case,
315
00:17:47,232 --> 00:17:49,633
Can you determine such a thing
with any certainty?
316
00:17:49,700 --> 00:17:53,337
Well... Not with
absolute certainty.
317
00:17:53,471 --> 00:17:56,006
No further questions.
318
00:17:56,074 --> 00:17:57,775
Catherine:
When mrs. Nolanshowed you her son,
319
00:17:57,842 --> 00:17:59,676
Was he still alive?
320
00:17:59,744 --> 00:18:01,845
Not as far as I could tell.
321
00:18:01,913 --> 00:18:03,547
I couldn't find a pulse.
322
00:18:03,615 --> 00:18:05,416
And what did you do?
323
00:18:05,483 --> 00:18:07,284
I gave him cpr.
324
00:18:07,352 --> 00:18:09,253
Was no good.
325
00:18:09,320 --> 00:18:12,456
I decided to wait
for the ambulance guys.
326
00:18:12,590 --> 00:18:15,325
And this is when you
questioned mrs. Nolan?
327
00:18:15,393 --> 00:18:17,160
Right.
328
00:18:17,228 --> 00:18:20,096
Officer alburg, you have stated
329
00:18:20,164 --> 00:18:22,599
That it was when you
questioned mrs. Nolan
330
00:18:22,667 --> 00:18:25,703
That you first became
suspicious of her husband.
331
00:18:25,770 --> 00:18:27,705
Was he there at the time?
332
00:18:27,872 --> 00:18:28,972
Not in the beginning.
333
00:18:29,040 --> 00:18:31,341
Then why did you
become suspicious?
334
00:18:31,409 --> 00:18:34,211
All I did was ask her
where he was,
335
00:18:34,279 --> 00:18:35,345
And she got all crazy.
336
00:18:35,413 --> 00:18:36,880
What did she say?
337
00:18:36,948 --> 00:18:39,549
First, she said
she didn't know where he was.
338
00:18:39,618 --> 00:18:41,752
Then, she said
he'd be back soon.
339
00:18:41,820 --> 00:18:44,588
Then, she got all confused,
and finally, she said
340
00:18:44,656 --> 00:18:47,557
I should just
ask him what happened.
341
00:18:47,626 --> 00:18:49,093
Phillips:
You said you found it
342
00:18:49,160 --> 00:18:51,862
Suspicious when mr. Nolan
reacted calmly
343
00:18:51,930 --> 00:18:53,496
When he found out
about his son's death.
344
00:18:53,565 --> 00:18:55,832
It didn't seem to come
as a surprise to him.
345
00:18:55,900 --> 00:18:58,302
If you were responsible for
your child's death, officer,
346
00:18:58,370 --> 00:18:59,503
Would you be calm?
347
00:18:59,570 --> 00:19:01,838
Or would you,
perhaps more likely, be upset,
348
00:19:01,906 --> 00:19:02,840
Like mrs. Nolan?
349
00:19:02,907 --> 00:19:04,741
Objection! Hypothetical.
350
00:19:04,809 --> 00:19:06,477
The witness is
not an expert.
351
00:19:06,544 --> 00:19:07,878
Sustained.
352
00:19:08,012 --> 00:19:10,447
Withdraw the question.
353
00:19:12,550 --> 00:19:15,018
(spectators whispering)
354
00:19:18,689 --> 00:19:21,091
Mrs. Nolan, I
understand it's...
355
00:19:21,158 --> 00:19:23,160
I...
356
00:19:23,227 --> 00:19:26,997
I don't think
I can stand it...
357
00:19:27,065 --> 00:19:29,399
Talking about it.
358
00:19:29,467 --> 00:19:31,869
I know.
359
00:19:31,936 --> 00:19:35,572
But we have to get these
details clear in your mind.
360
00:19:35,640 --> 00:19:37,541
Tomorrow, your husband's
attorneys will do
361
00:19:37,608 --> 00:19:39,543
Everything they can to make
you contradict yourself.
362
00:19:39,610 --> 00:19:40,978
Do I have to go up there?
363
00:19:41,046 --> 00:19:42,746
There's no other way?
364
00:19:42,814 --> 00:19:45,282
I'm afraid not.
365
00:19:45,349 --> 00:19:48,285
Their best defense is to
make you appear guilty.
366
00:19:50,722 --> 00:19:53,190
Make me appear guilty, hmm?
367
00:19:56,094 --> 00:19:58,628
What if I am guilty?
368
00:20:02,767 --> 00:20:04,768
You're just like everybody else.
369
00:20:04,836 --> 00:20:07,638
You think I should be
up on the stand there with him.
370
00:20:07,705 --> 00:20:09,039
No.
371
00:20:09,106 --> 00:20:11,508
No, of course not.
372
00:20:13,177 --> 00:20:16,980
I should just get used to it.
373
00:20:17,048 --> 00:20:19,116
Nobody will ever understand.
374
00:20:19,184 --> 00:20:21,118
Molly...
375
00:20:24,122 --> 00:20:26,723
I want to understand.
376
00:20:26,790 --> 00:20:28,825
You know how he did it?
377
00:20:30,528 --> 00:20:34,230
He told me he loved me.
378
00:20:37,335 --> 00:20:39,069
When he hit me,
379
00:20:39,137 --> 00:20:41,638
He used to tell me
that it was for my own good
380
00:20:41,706 --> 00:20:43,640
And he did it
because he loved me.
381
00:20:47,411 --> 00:20:50,613
Just to hear him say it
was worth the pain.
382
00:20:53,284 --> 00:20:55,652
So I let him.
383
00:20:55,720 --> 00:20:57,988
And it kept getting worse.
384
00:20:58,056 --> 00:21:00,124
And I just...
385
00:21:00,191 --> 00:21:02,792
Kept letting him.
386
00:21:02,860 --> 00:21:04,495
You never fought back?
387
00:21:04,562 --> 00:21:06,397
I couldn't.
388
00:21:06,464 --> 00:21:08,465
You never...
389
00:21:08,533 --> 00:21:10,634
Thought you deserved better?
390
00:21:12,736 --> 00:21:14,671
(voice breaking):
No.
391
00:21:17,575 --> 00:21:19,910
Oh, my...
392
00:21:19,978 --> 00:21:21,912
(sobbing)
393
00:21:24,415 --> 00:21:27,517
You do, molly.
394
00:21:27,585 --> 00:21:30,520
(sobbing):
Oh, I don't think so.
395
00:21:33,524 --> 00:21:36,026
I don't think so, cathy.
396
00:21:36,094 --> 00:21:38,228
It wasn't you.
397
00:21:38,296 --> 00:21:39,863
You didn't hurt him.
You never touched him.
398
00:21:39,931 --> 00:21:43,800
I didn't help him.
I didn't help him.
399
00:21:43,868 --> 00:21:45,903
You were afraid for your life.
400
00:21:45,970 --> 00:21:47,070
Everyone knows that.
401
00:21:47,138 --> 00:21:49,439
Do they?
402
00:21:51,542 --> 00:21:54,778
They will.
403
00:21:54,846 --> 00:21:56,880
I promise.
404
00:21:56,947 --> 00:21:59,783
Molly...
405
00:21:59,851 --> 00:22:02,486
Make your husband pay
for what he did.
406
00:22:04,722 --> 00:22:08,057
You can do that tomorrow
when you speak in court.
407
00:22:08,125 --> 00:22:10,927
(sniffles)
408
00:22:10,995 --> 00:22:12,929
(sighs)
409
00:22:15,533 --> 00:22:18,168
I'll try.
410
00:22:20,271 --> 00:22:21,638
(whispering):
Okay.
411
00:22:21,706 --> 00:22:23,506
Let's get back to what happened
when the police...
412
00:22:23,574 --> 00:22:25,309
Thank you, cathy.
413
00:22:28,012 --> 00:22:30,313
Thank you.
414
00:22:48,867 --> 00:22:51,001
(child groaning)
415
00:22:52,103 --> 00:22:53,236
(groaning)
416
00:23:14,058 --> 00:23:16,827
Boy:
Help me.
417
00:23:21,800 --> 00:23:24,067
Help me.
418
00:23:30,507 --> 00:23:33,010
Help me.
419
00:23:36,013 --> 00:23:38,081
Help me.
420
00:23:46,824 --> 00:23:47,691
Help me.
421
00:23:54,131 --> 00:23:57,000
Help me!
422
00:24:00,905 --> 00:24:02,139
Help me.
423
00:24:03,140 --> 00:24:04,808
(sobbing):
Help me.
424
00:24:04,876 --> 00:24:05,909
Help me.
425
00:24:07,078 --> 00:24:08,412
Help me.
426
00:24:09,380 --> 00:24:11,815
(sobbing):
Help me.
427
00:24:11,882 --> 00:24:13,983
(sobbing):
Help me.
Help me.
428
00:24:14,051 --> 00:24:16,186
Help me.
Help me.
429
00:24:16,253 --> 00:24:17,954
Help me.
Help me.
430
00:24:18,022 --> 00:24:19,790
(growling)
431
00:24:19,857 --> 00:24:21,325
(screaming)
432
00:24:23,428 --> 00:24:25,362
(panting)
433
00:24:25,430 --> 00:24:27,364
(subway train
passing in distance)
434
00:24:28,700 --> 00:24:32,068
(subway train passing
in distance)
435
00:24:38,343 --> 00:24:39,643
Catherine:
Mrs. Nolan,
436
00:24:39,711 --> 00:24:42,178
When you and your husbandwere first taken into custody,
437
00:24:42,246 --> 00:24:43,313
You told the police
438
00:24:43,381 --> 00:24:46,649
That your husband had been
away from the apartment
439
00:24:46,718 --> 00:24:49,586
When your son sustained
injuries in a fall.
440
00:24:49,654 --> 00:24:51,288
Was this true?
441
00:24:53,691 --> 00:24:56,359
Mrs. Nolan, I have
to ask you to speak up.
442
00:24:56,426 --> 00:24:57,593
What is your answer?
443
00:24:57,662 --> 00:24:59,162
(softly):
No.
444
00:24:59,230 --> 00:25:00,797
(clearing throat):
No.
445
00:25:00,865 --> 00:25:03,332
Why would you lie
to the police
446
00:25:03,400 --> 00:25:06,069
Like this, molly?
447
00:25:07,137 --> 00:25:09,372
I had already lost
my son jonathan,
448
00:25:09,440 --> 00:25:11,909
And I was afraid
of losing richard, too.
449
00:25:11,976 --> 00:25:16,313
You loved your husband
and you wanted to protect him?
450
00:25:16,381 --> 00:25:18,247
Yes.
451
00:25:18,315 --> 00:25:20,250
Was there another reason?
452
00:25:20,318 --> 00:25:22,552
Yes.
453
00:25:22,620 --> 00:25:23,853
And what was that?
454
00:25:23,921 --> 00:25:27,324
He told me that...
455
00:25:39,203 --> 00:25:41,404
He told you what, molly?
456
00:25:41,472 --> 00:25:44,841
He told me...
457
00:25:44,909 --> 00:25:47,844
That...
458
00:25:47,912 --> 00:25:49,246
(whimpers)
459
00:25:50,348 --> 00:25:52,349
Molly.
460
00:25:52,416 --> 00:25:55,452
You said
that the first story was a lie,
461
00:25:55,519 --> 00:25:58,821
But later you went on
to tell the truth.
462
00:25:58,889 --> 00:26:00,323
You did the right thing.
463
00:26:00,391 --> 00:26:02,859
Tell us the truth now.
464
00:26:02,994 --> 00:26:04,461
(crying):
I can't.
465
00:26:06,463 --> 00:26:09,299
Did your husband
hit jonathan that night?
466
00:26:09,366 --> 00:26:10,800
(sniffles)
467
00:26:10,868 --> 00:26:12,069
Did he?
468
00:26:12,203 --> 00:26:14,337
Your honor, she's harassing
her own witness.
469
00:26:14,404 --> 00:26:17,641
Ms. Nolan, do you intend
to answer the question?
470
00:26:17,709 --> 00:26:19,976
I can't, I can't.
471
00:26:20,044 --> 00:26:21,578
If you don't answer
the question,
472
00:26:21,645 --> 00:26:23,447
Then I'll have to ask you
to step down.
473
00:26:23,514 --> 00:26:25,048
Answer the question, molly.
474
00:26:25,116 --> 00:26:27,217
Answer
for jonathan.
475
00:26:28,286 --> 00:26:29,886
I'm sorry.
476
00:26:29,953 --> 00:26:31,588
The witness will have
to step down.
477
00:26:34,659 --> 00:26:36,292
Phillips:
Your honor, her testimony must
be disallowed.
478
00:26:36,361 --> 00:26:38,294
I can't cross-examine
if she can't speak.
479
00:26:38,363 --> 00:26:39,629
She can speak.
480
00:26:39,697 --> 00:26:41,765
She won't speak for
the same reason she kept quiet
481
00:26:41,833 --> 00:26:42,999
The night her son was killed.
482
00:26:43,067 --> 00:26:44,634
Because she is scared
to death of him!
483
00:26:44,702 --> 00:26:46,469
Your honor.
Ms. Chandler,
484
00:26:46,536 --> 00:26:48,538
Another word and
you'll be in contempt.
485
00:26:48,606 --> 00:26:50,606
Your honor, if the
witness won't testify,
486
00:26:50,674 --> 00:26:52,175
I move that this case
be dismissed
487
00:26:52,243 --> 00:26:54,044
On the grounds
of insufficient evidence.
488
00:26:54,112 --> 00:26:56,379
Ms. Chandler?
489
00:26:56,447 --> 00:26:57,647
I have to rule on this.
490
00:26:57,715 --> 00:26:59,815
Do you have other
witnesses to call?
491
00:27:03,654 --> 00:27:05,588
Your honor,
under the circumstances,
492
00:27:05,656 --> 00:27:08,691
I move that my witness be
allowed to testify on videotape.
493
00:27:08,759 --> 00:27:10,760
There have been other
precedents in abuse cases
494
00:27:10,827 --> 00:27:12,562
Where the victims
were allowed...
495
00:27:12,629 --> 00:27:14,664
Those precedents were
for testimony by children only.
496
00:27:14,731 --> 00:27:15,932
They don't apply here.
497
00:27:15,999 --> 00:27:18,435
My client deserves the right
to face his accuser.
498
00:27:18,502 --> 00:27:21,004
I'm sorry, ms. Chandler,
your motion is denied.
499
00:27:22,105 --> 00:27:25,475
Well, then, I... I'll need a...
500
00:27:25,543 --> 00:27:28,044
I-I would like
to request a continuance.
501
00:27:28,111 --> 00:27:31,080
Does defense counsel have
any objection?
502
00:27:31,148 --> 00:27:33,850
My client deserves the right
to a speedy trial.
503
00:27:36,487 --> 00:27:39,055
Motion for dismissal is denied.
504
00:27:39,123 --> 00:27:42,192
A continuation is
granted for 24 hours.
505
00:27:42,259 --> 00:27:43,660
(strikes gavel)
506
00:28:02,479 --> 00:28:04,714
Reporter (over tv):
The city council is
still at a stalemate
507
00:28:04,782 --> 00:28:07,583
On the battery park
low income housing development.
508
00:28:07,652 --> 00:28:09,653
Also coming up
on the news at 10:00,
509
00:28:09,720 --> 00:28:11,755
A setback for the prosecution
510
00:28:11,822 --> 00:28:15,158
In the nolan case as da's
prosecutor catherine chandler
511
00:28:15,226 --> 00:28:17,093
Loses control
of her star witness
512
00:28:17,161 --> 00:28:18,328
On the stand.
513
00:28:18,396 --> 00:28:19,695
We'll have more after this.
514
00:28:19,763 --> 00:28:20,863
(changes channel)
515
00:28:20,931 --> 00:28:23,466
No, I think miss chandler
is doing a fine job.
516
00:28:23,534 --> 00:28:25,001
If the prosecution
is having problems,
517
00:28:25,068 --> 00:28:26,903
It says more about the
strength of their case
518
00:28:26,970 --> 00:28:28,971
Than the strength
of their legal help.
519
00:28:35,980 --> 00:28:36,946
(knocks)
520
00:28:44,054 --> 00:28:46,489
(sighs)
521
00:28:46,556 --> 00:28:48,457
I'm glad to see you.
522
00:28:48,525 --> 00:28:50,260
Tell me.
523
00:28:50,328 --> 00:28:53,296
(sighs)
524
00:28:53,364 --> 00:28:55,565
It's not going well.
525
00:28:55,632 --> 00:28:57,500
The helpers bring
glowing reports.
526
00:28:57,568 --> 00:28:58,835
No, not anymore.
527
00:28:58,902 --> 00:29:00,003
We've had a setback.
528
00:29:00,071 --> 00:29:01,504
What happened?
529
00:29:01,572 --> 00:29:06,109
I underestimated the power
of the man we're prosecuting.
530
00:29:06,176 --> 00:29:08,677
I underestimated his control.
531
00:29:08,745 --> 00:29:10,080
He sits
in that courtroom
532
00:29:10,147 --> 00:29:12,715
With the best defense lawyers
money can buy,
533
00:29:12,783 --> 00:29:15,185
Listening to the atrocities
that he's committed
534
00:29:15,252 --> 00:29:17,887
With cold, dead eyes.
535
00:29:17,955 --> 00:29:21,691
He's making a mockery of this
trial and of a child's death,
536
00:29:21,759 --> 00:29:23,526
And I can't do anything.
537
00:29:26,897 --> 00:29:28,832
You must continue fighting.
538
00:29:28,899 --> 00:29:29,832
I know.
539
00:29:29,900 --> 00:29:31,968
Even if there is
nothing you can do.
540
00:29:32,035 --> 00:29:35,772
You must do it for the child,
541
00:29:35,840 --> 00:29:38,074
For his memory,
542
00:29:38,141 --> 00:29:41,377
And for all of us who refuse
to accept that child's death
543
00:29:41,379 --> 00:29:44,314
Alone in a room.
544
00:29:44,382 --> 00:29:47,250
That child's suffering
must not be forgotten.
545
00:29:47,318 --> 00:29:48,885
It won't, vincent.
546
00:29:48,953 --> 00:29:51,587
It must not be forgotten!
547
00:29:51,655 --> 00:29:52,989
(sighs)
548
00:29:53,057 --> 00:29:57,693
Because that child stands
in silent judgment of us all.
549
00:29:57,761 --> 00:29:59,996
(sighs)
550
00:30:17,815 --> 00:30:20,750
♪ ♪
551
00:30:33,864 --> 00:30:36,433
Got enough
there for two?
552
00:30:36,500 --> 00:30:38,701
(sighs)
553
00:30:38,769 --> 00:30:40,303
You scared me.
554
00:30:41,439 --> 00:30:43,573
Sorry.
555
00:30:49,313 --> 00:30:51,848
I really am
sorry, cathy.
556
00:30:51,916 --> 00:30:53,282
If you've come
to offer your help,
557
00:30:53,350 --> 00:30:54,617
I think it's a little late.
558
00:30:54,685 --> 00:30:56,553
You don't need my help.
559
00:30:56,620 --> 00:30:57,620
Never did.
560
00:30:57,688 --> 00:30:59,522
(scoffing):
Now you're being sarcastic.
561
00:30:59,590 --> 00:31:01,858
I've been watching
you, kiddo.
562
00:31:01,959 --> 00:31:03,426
Every move.
563
00:31:03,494 --> 00:31:05,428
I've been like every
other new yorker
564
00:31:05,496 --> 00:31:08,064
These past few weeks--
glued to the tube,
565
00:31:08,098 --> 00:31:10,366
And I got to tell you,
I've never felt so proud.
566
00:31:14,404 --> 00:31:16,539
Thank you, joe.
567
00:31:16,606 --> 00:31:18,541
I never expected that.
568
00:31:18,609 --> 00:31:21,911
So, tomorrow's
the big day.
569
00:31:21,979 --> 00:31:23,647
What's the
new game plan?
570
00:31:23,714 --> 00:31:26,048
The daughter, amy nolan.
571
00:31:26,116 --> 00:31:27,684
Sounds good to me.
572
00:31:27,752 --> 00:31:30,052
Go after the credibility
of nolan's alibi.
573
00:31:32,156 --> 00:31:34,290
What's this?
574
00:31:42,532 --> 00:31:45,368
I'm not sure
the judge will allow it.
575
00:31:48,939 --> 00:31:50,006
You've got to use this.
576
00:31:52,109 --> 00:31:54,043
Yeah, I guess so.
577
00:31:54,111 --> 00:31:55,578
Cathy, the verdict is going
to ride
578
00:31:55,645 --> 00:31:58,114
As much on emotions as facts.
579
00:31:58,182 --> 00:31:59,582
When the dust settles,
580
00:31:59,649 --> 00:32:03,018
You'll realize you did amy nolan
the greatest favor of her life.
581
00:32:05,689 --> 00:32:09,158
Phillips:
So just to clarify the factsone last time.
582
00:32:09,226 --> 00:32:11,594
You were with your father
constantly from the hours
583
00:32:11,662 --> 00:32:15,765
Of 7:30 to 9:00 p.M.
On the evening of February 6?
584
00:32:15,833 --> 00:32:17,299
Yes.
585
00:32:17,367 --> 00:32:19,802
And at no time did he
leave your company
for more than
586
00:32:19,870 --> 00:32:20,870
A few minutes, is that right?
587
00:32:20,938 --> 00:32:21,905
Yes.
588
00:32:22,039 --> 00:32:24,107
Thank you, amy.
589
00:32:24,174 --> 00:32:25,708
I have nothing more,
your honor.
590
00:32:25,776 --> 00:32:27,277
The defense... Rests.
591
00:32:29,313 --> 00:32:30,546
Ms. Chandler?
592
00:32:30,614 --> 00:32:32,181
Your witness.
593
00:32:32,249 --> 00:32:33,916
Thank you, your honor.
594
00:32:36,453 --> 00:32:40,290
Hello, amy.
595
00:32:40,358 --> 00:32:42,392
My name is catherine chandler,
596
00:32:42,460 --> 00:32:43,792
And my job
597
00:32:43,860 --> 00:32:46,162
Is to find
the truth.
598
00:32:46,230 --> 00:32:49,098
I just want you to know
that whatever happens,
599
00:32:49,166 --> 00:32:51,100
I don't mean
to hurt you.
600
00:32:53,003 --> 00:32:55,338
On the evening of February 6,
601
00:32:55,405 --> 00:32:57,406
Your father took you
out for dinner.
602
00:32:57,475 --> 00:32:59,042
Is this correct?
603
00:32:59,109 --> 00:33:00,810
Yes.
604
00:33:00,878 --> 00:33:01,945
What restaurant did your father
605
00:33:02,012 --> 00:33:04,314
Take you
to that night, amy?
606
00:33:04,381 --> 00:33:06,850
A little thai place
near my apartment.
607
00:33:06,917 --> 00:33:08,884
Do you go there often?
608
00:33:08,952 --> 00:33:10,486
I guess.
609
00:33:10,554 --> 00:33:14,490
So you would say it's one
of your favorites?
610
00:33:14,558 --> 00:33:16,825
Sure.
611
00:33:16,893 --> 00:33:19,595
How nice that your father
remembers
612
00:33:19,663 --> 00:33:23,366
Some of your favorite things.
613
00:33:23,433 --> 00:33:26,869
So you would say you and
your father are very close?
614
00:33:28,805 --> 00:33:31,174
Yes.
615
00:33:31,242 --> 00:33:32,609
Did you know your father
616
00:33:32,676 --> 00:33:34,277
Physically abused
your stepmother?
617
00:33:34,344 --> 00:33:36,278
Objection, your honor!
She's harassing the witness
618
00:33:36,346 --> 00:33:38,147
For irrelevant information!
619
00:33:38,215 --> 00:33:41,350
Your honor, I am trying to
establish the credibility
620
00:33:41,418 --> 00:33:44,353
Of the most important
witness in this trial.
621
00:33:44,422 --> 00:33:45,555
Objection overruled.
622
00:33:45,623 --> 00:33:47,690
The witness may
answer the question.
623
00:33:51,194 --> 00:33:53,563
No, I didn't know.
624
00:33:53,630 --> 00:33:56,165
Do you know if your father
was physically abusive
625
00:33:56,233 --> 00:33:58,401
To your stepbrother,
jonathan?
626
00:34:00,204 --> 00:34:02,038
No.
627
00:34:02,105 --> 00:34:06,642
Do you think this kind of
physical abuse is wrong, amy?
628
00:34:06,710 --> 00:34:08,377
I don't know.
629
00:34:08,445 --> 00:34:10,479
I guess so.
630
00:34:10,547 --> 00:34:13,783
Did your father ever abuse you?
631
00:34:17,354 --> 00:34:18,521
No.
632
00:34:30,300 --> 00:34:33,970
Amy, I have here
your medical records
633
00:34:34,038 --> 00:34:35,605
For the past several years.
634
00:34:35,673 --> 00:34:37,072
Objection, irrelevant.
635
00:34:37,140 --> 00:34:38,141
Overruled.
636
00:34:40,678 --> 00:34:45,114
Two years ago, you were treated
for a fractured wrist.
637
00:34:45,182 --> 00:34:46,815
Do you remember
how that happened, amy?
638
00:34:46,883 --> 00:34:48,584
I'm not sure.
639
00:34:48,652 --> 00:34:49,685
It says here
640
00:34:49,753 --> 00:34:52,555
That you tripped and fell.
641
00:34:52,623 --> 00:34:54,357
Was that what happened?
642
00:34:54,425 --> 00:34:55,925
I guess.
643
00:34:55,992 --> 00:34:57,260
And one month later,
644
00:34:57,327 --> 00:34:59,095
You were at the hospital again.
645
00:34:59,163 --> 00:35:02,165
This time you needed stitches
in your ear.
646
00:35:02,232 --> 00:35:05,601
Do you remember
how this happened?
647
00:35:05,669 --> 00:35:09,272
I... I think I fell down again.
648
00:35:09,339 --> 00:35:10,706
Are you certain?
649
00:35:10,774 --> 00:35:13,309
Is that how
you recall it?
650
00:35:13,377 --> 00:35:14,844
I'm not positive.
651
00:35:14,912 --> 00:35:16,946
These are serious
accidents, amy.
652
00:35:17,014 --> 00:35:18,280
Don't you think it's strange
653
00:35:18,349 --> 00:35:20,282
That you don't remember
how they happened?
654
00:35:20,351 --> 00:35:21,817
I remember.
655
00:35:21,885 --> 00:35:26,322
Well, then... Can you explain
these injuries to us?
656
00:35:26,390 --> 00:35:29,025
No, I can't.
657
00:35:29,093 --> 00:35:31,394
This file goes on and on.
658
00:35:31,462 --> 00:35:33,596
Would you like me to
read it to the court?
659
00:35:33,664 --> 00:35:36,833
What about this fractured rib?
660
00:35:36,901 --> 00:35:40,970
And this infected bruise
over your right eye?
661
00:35:41,038 --> 00:35:43,138
And this broken finger?
662
00:35:43,206 --> 00:35:46,709
Can you explain
these injuries?
663
00:35:46,777 --> 00:35:48,177
No.
664
00:35:48,244 --> 00:35:52,882
Amy, your father did these
things to you, didn't he?
665
00:35:59,189 --> 00:36:00,890
Yes.
666
00:36:00,958 --> 00:36:03,393
And you also knew also knew
that he beat molly
667
00:36:03,460 --> 00:36:05,295
And your brother jonathan.
668
00:36:05,429 --> 00:36:07,963
Isn't that true?
669
00:36:10,701 --> 00:36:12,768
We have to hear
your answer, young lady.
670
00:36:12,836 --> 00:36:15,204
(sobbing):
Yes.
671
00:36:15,272 --> 00:36:19,175
Isn't that why you testified
672
00:36:19,242 --> 00:36:22,311
That you were with your father
at 7:30 that night--
673
00:36:22,379 --> 00:36:25,181
Because you were afraid
that he would hurt you
674
00:36:25,248 --> 00:36:26,482
If you didn't?
675
00:36:28,852 --> 00:36:29,885
No.
676
00:36:31,555 --> 00:36:34,723
Amy, are you saying that he was
with you that night?
677
00:36:34,791 --> 00:36:36,559
(sniffles)
678
00:36:36,626 --> 00:36:38,261
Yes.
679
00:36:38,328 --> 00:36:41,797
Your stepbrother
jonathan is dead.
680
00:36:41,865 --> 00:36:44,467
Are you certain
that this is your answer?!
681
00:36:49,373 --> 00:36:51,707
Yes.
682
00:36:54,979 --> 00:36:58,147
No more questions, your honor.
683
00:36:58,215 --> 00:37:00,082
You may step down.
684
00:37:10,026 --> 00:37:11,560
Sheets:
This case is as simple
685
00:37:11,628 --> 00:37:14,129
As the facts presented
in this courtroom:
686
00:37:14,197 --> 00:37:17,132
Mr. Nolan was not present
at the scene of the crime,
687
00:37:17,134 --> 00:37:19,402
So he must be innocent.
688
00:37:19,469 --> 00:37:22,771
Even if you doubt the testimony
that places him elsewhere,
689
00:37:22,839 --> 00:37:24,106
You must remember
690
00:37:24,174 --> 00:37:26,642
That the prosecution has given
no conclusive evidence
691
00:37:26,710 --> 00:37:28,010
To incriminate him:
692
00:37:28,077 --> 00:37:29,746
No means, no motive,
693
00:37:29,846 --> 00:37:32,080
And most important,
no witness to the crime.
694
00:37:32,148 --> 00:37:35,051
But since the issue
has been raised--
695
00:37:35,118 --> 00:37:37,186
And I'm sure it will be present
in your minds
696
00:37:37,254 --> 00:37:38,520
When you deliberate--
697
00:37:38,588 --> 00:37:44,393
Let me address the issue
of richard nolan's humanity.
698
00:37:44,461 --> 00:37:46,662
It is true that mr. Nolan
699
00:37:46,729 --> 00:37:48,730
Has abused members
of his family,
700
00:37:48,798 --> 00:37:52,468
And frankly, knowing that he is
a man of education
701
00:37:52,536 --> 00:37:56,038
And great accomplishment,
we must wonder why.
702
00:37:56,106 --> 00:37:58,141
The answer is--
703
00:37:58,208 --> 00:38:01,411
Like so many in our society
who abuse others--
704
00:38:01,545 --> 00:38:05,848
Richard nolan was as a child
abused himself.
705
00:38:05,916 --> 00:38:09,518
It's a tragic reality
706
00:38:09,586 --> 00:38:14,556
That people who are abused
often become abusers themselves.
707
00:38:14,624 --> 00:38:17,460
Whether this is because
they retain some vestige
708
00:38:17,528 --> 00:38:19,362
Of aggression
that needs to be vented,
709
00:38:19,429 --> 00:38:21,463
Or simply that
they become conditioned
710
00:38:21,531 --> 00:38:24,066
To communicating with violence
we don't know.
711
00:38:24,134 --> 00:38:26,735
All we know is
that these victims
712
00:38:26,803 --> 00:38:30,339
Become like carriers
of a deadly disease.
713
00:38:30,407 --> 00:38:34,243
But, ladies and gentlemen...
714
00:38:34,311 --> 00:38:37,546
My client did not kill his son.
715
00:38:37,614 --> 00:38:40,817
Whatever else you may think
of richard nolan,
716
00:38:40,884 --> 00:38:43,786
You be sure
when you deliberate this charge,
717
00:38:43,854 --> 00:38:45,822
You remember,
718
00:38:45,889 --> 00:38:48,791
There is far more
than a shadow of a doubt
719
00:38:48,858 --> 00:38:51,026
That he was even present.
720
00:38:51,094 --> 00:38:54,496
(spectators murmuring)
721
00:38:54,565 --> 00:38:56,566
Thank you.
722
00:39:15,018 --> 00:39:17,353
We've just heard
723
00:39:17,421 --> 00:39:22,524
That richard nolan is a man
suffering from a disease.
724
00:39:22,592 --> 00:39:26,462
He passed that disease
to his wife, we're told.
725
00:39:26,529 --> 00:39:29,332
She passed it to their son,
726
00:39:29,399 --> 00:39:32,235
And the boy died from it.
727
00:39:32,302 --> 00:39:33,903
Very simple.
728
00:39:33,971 --> 00:39:39,675
And the name that's been given
this disease, is abuse.
729
00:39:42,712 --> 00:39:45,181
Well...
730
00:39:45,248 --> 00:39:49,218
I will agree that
there is a disease here,
731
00:39:49,286 --> 00:39:50,552
And I'll agree
732
00:39:50,620 --> 00:39:52,789
That richard nolan
suffers from it.
733
00:39:52,856 --> 00:39:55,057
But I won't agree
that it's contagious,
734
00:39:55,125 --> 00:39:58,561
And I won't agree
that it's fatal,
735
00:39:58,629 --> 00:40:01,831
And I won't even agree
to its name.
736
00:40:06,003 --> 00:40:08,971
Ladies and gentlemen,
737
00:40:09,039 --> 00:40:12,808
I would like to tell you
about a place.
738
00:40:14,544 --> 00:40:17,012
It's a special place I know,
739
00:40:17,080 --> 00:40:20,015
Where this disease
does not exist.
740
00:40:21,651 --> 00:40:25,087
It is a place
that many people go to
741
00:40:25,154 --> 00:40:27,089
When they've been in pain,
742
00:40:27,157 --> 00:40:29,692
When they've been abused,
743
00:40:29,760 --> 00:40:32,761
So the disease does come
there...
744
00:40:32,829 --> 00:40:35,498
But it never stays.
745
00:40:39,736 --> 00:40:41,704
It is in our hearts,
746
00:40:41,772 --> 00:40:43,706
In that room
747
00:40:43,774 --> 00:40:47,677
Where hatred and cruelty
do not belong.
748
00:40:48,779 --> 00:40:50,880
I have told you
749
00:40:50,947 --> 00:40:55,484
That richard nolan's disease
needed a different name.
750
00:40:55,552 --> 00:41:00,155
The name that I would give it is
heartlessness.
751
00:41:01,425 --> 00:41:04,460
Only a man with an empty heart
752
00:41:04,528 --> 00:41:07,396
Could brutalize and terrorize
the ones
753
00:41:07,463 --> 00:41:08,731
That loved him.
754
00:41:08,799 --> 00:41:15,404
I believe that richard nolan
has no heart.
755
00:41:15,472 --> 00:41:19,608
And I believe
that the proof of that is
756
00:41:19,676 --> 00:41:22,645
On molly nolan's
lonely face.
757
00:41:22,713 --> 00:41:27,550
And we also know why that woman
could never have hurt her child.
758
00:41:28,918 --> 00:41:31,153
She sat on that stand,
759
00:41:31,221 --> 00:41:33,989
When all of us knew what
richard nolan had done to her,
760
00:41:34,057 --> 00:41:38,160
And still she could not speak
against him,
761
00:41:38,228 --> 00:41:41,330
Because she knew that to do so
would bring pain
762
00:41:41,398 --> 00:41:44,032
To someone that she loved.
763
00:41:44,101 --> 00:41:48,704
Molly nolan has a heart.
764
00:41:49,806 --> 00:41:51,741
(catherine sighs)
765
00:41:51,808 --> 00:41:54,343
I am asking you
766
00:41:54,478 --> 00:41:58,981
To go to that place
in your hearts...
767
00:41:59,048 --> 00:42:02,885
To find justice for a brutally
murdered little boy.
768
00:42:04,954 --> 00:42:10,426
That place is
where the truth lives.
769
00:42:10,494 --> 00:42:14,830
That place is where each of us
carries the cure
770
00:42:14,897 --> 00:42:18,334
To this terrible disease.
771
00:42:35,685 --> 00:42:38,187
(sighs)
772
00:42:50,433 --> 00:42:52,568
Have you reached
a verdict?
773
00:42:52,636 --> 00:42:54,570
Yes, we have, your honor.
774
00:43:13,023 --> 00:43:14,990
We find the
defendant guilty
775
00:43:15,058 --> 00:43:18,026
Of murder
in the second degree.
776
00:43:18,094 --> 00:43:21,063
(widespread murmuring)
777
00:43:22,966 --> 00:43:24,767
(sighs)
778
00:43:29,172 --> 00:43:32,007
(reporters clamoring)
779
00:43:36,246 --> 00:43:38,546
Catherine:
Let me just make
a brief statement.
780
00:43:38,614 --> 00:43:40,850
We are very happy
781
00:43:40,917 --> 00:43:43,886
That justice was done
in this courtroom today.
782
00:43:43,887 --> 00:43:46,422
A guilty man will pay
for his crime.
783
00:43:46,489 --> 00:43:51,093
But justice will not be served
in thousands of other places
784
00:43:51,160 --> 00:43:52,861
In this city
785
00:43:52,929 --> 00:43:55,564
Until we all confront the fact
of a crime
786
00:43:55,632 --> 00:43:59,568
That happens everywhere,
and every day.
787
00:43:59,636 --> 00:44:03,004
It's not just my job to stop it.
788
00:44:03,072 --> 00:44:05,006
It's our job.
789
00:44:05,074 --> 00:44:06,408
(reporters clamoring)
790
00:44:06,476 --> 00:44:07,743
Excuse me.
791
00:44:07,810 --> 00:44:09,111
Excuse us.
792
00:44:16,619 --> 00:44:19,021
It's over.
793
00:44:19,089 --> 00:44:21,023
We won.
794
00:44:21,091 --> 00:44:23,926
Good.
795
00:44:23,994 --> 00:44:26,962
It's a beginning.
796
00:44:34,037 --> 00:44:36,539
Where are the voices?
797
00:44:36,606 --> 00:44:39,909
It's all so quiet.
798
00:44:40,043 --> 00:44:42,811
Sometimes when the winds shift,
799
00:44:42,879 --> 00:44:45,781
The voices, the echoes are lost.
800
00:44:55,858 --> 00:44:58,293
Are you sad, vincent?
801
00:45:00,463 --> 00:45:03,332
More than once I've...
802
00:45:04,734 --> 00:45:07,670
...Heard a child's voice
crying out.
803
00:45:09,205 --> 00:45:12,807
There was no way I could reach
it, no way I could even find it.
804
00:45:12,875 --> 00:45:15,311
All I could do was
stand here
805
00:45:15,378 --> 00:45:18,380
And listen to it cry,
806
00:45:18,515 --> 00:45:21,650
And wonder...
807
00:45:21,718 --> 00:45:24,586
How can we begin to love life?
808
00:45:24,654 --> 00:45:27,723
How can we accept its gifts?
809
00:45:27,791 --> 00:45:29,992
How can we forget
even for a moment
810
00:45:30,060 --> 00:45:34,530
When children suffer
the way they do?
811
00:45:38,868 --> 00:45:40,802
(sighs)
812
00:45:40,870 --> 00:45:44,306
We can only start
with ourselves, I guess,
813
00:45:44,374 --> 00:45:47,876
With our own lives...
814
00:45:49,679 --> 00:45:52,214
...To try to touch the ones
815
00:45:52,282 --> 00:45:54,983
That cross our paths.
816
00:45:55,051 --> 00:45:57,386
That's what you did for me
817
00:45:57,453 --> 00:46:00,555
The night you
found me.
818
00:46:00,623 --> 00:46:04,292
It's everything you've given me
from that moment on.
819
00:46:09,799 --> 00:46:12,734
We won today
820
00:46:12,802 --> 00:46:14,937
Because we had the truth
821
00:46:15,004 --> 00:46:17,573
And it touched people.
822
00:46:17,640 --> 00:46:20,542
People recognize it
in their hearts.
823
00:46:20,610 --> 00:46:22,344
It can't be denied
824
00:46:22,412 --> 00:46:25,313
And there is a great power
in that.
825
00:46:27,250 --> 00:46:30,619
So we keep fighting.
826
00:46:32,722 --> 00:46:35,724
Yes.
827
00:46:35,725 --> 00:46:39,628
We keep fighting.
828
00:47:10,126 --> 00:47:13,795
♪ ♪
57731
Can't find what you're looking for?
Get subtitles in any language from opensubtitles.com, and translate them here.